Sola Scriptura and why do Protestants like it?

  • Thread starter Thread starter BornAgain2010
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Sir, I find it highly unlikely that the Apostles had no particular tradition relating to how clergy are ordained.
The only example we have is Paul sending Timothy to appoint them, but it’s clearl not given as a norm for the Church.
Paul wasn’t compelling anyone to live under Mosaic customs by what he did, because Paul wasn’t separating himself from eating with Gentiles for intimidation of the Jews who were keeping the dietary laws as Peter was. A Gentile who saw Peter doing that would think “Oh, I’m not worthy enough for Peter’s company as I am apparently, I must be just as he is doing to fellowship” and feel compelled to take on that lifestyle.
That’s not compelling. Peter is said to be actively compelling… that’s why the ESV uses “forcing.” It isn’t a matter of people noticed what Peter was doing. Peter is actively telling people to do as he is.
There is no element of force in play
I disagree. The word that is used reflects an active part on the person doing the compelling or forcing.
, so no, Peter was not ‘clearly instructing’ Gentiles to take the dietary laws upon themselves. There is no explicit statement that Peter verbally taught error in the guise of Christian doctrine. Isn’t this Sola Scriptura thing great?
At least we can have a discussion about. That’s what’s great about sola scriptura. If you were a priest and I a parishoner, you’d tell me what was what, and there’d be no discussion.
Of course Paul could not expect everyone who heard him to accept his message, but the Bereans did accept it with readiness of mind. They already accepted Paul’s message, so of course they are going to see it harmonizing with Scripture. You don’t receive the Church’s teachings with readiness of mind, so when you read the Scriptures you find contradictions (or so they appear to be, in your unready mind.)
Um… you don’t go search to see if what is preached is true, if you already accept it as truth.

To say that they embraced it, and then went home and looked to see if it was true is just silly.
 
It isn’t a matter of people noticed what Peter was doing. Peter is actively telling people to do as he is.
If Peter was doing exactly what he was preaching, how was he a hypocrite?
 
Well, Jesus says that they must believe in Him (v40,47), but that’s probably splitting hairs.

Correct, but, again, this isn’t John 6. John 6 isn’t taking place 18 hours before Jesus was to die.

Except that nowhere in John 6 does Jesus 9ro John) tie anything to the Last Supper. The bread analogy of His body is intended as a comparison to the bread Moses provided (well, the bread the Jews think Moses provided) in the desert. There is a clear confrontation between Old and New Covenants, a call by Christ to put their faith in Him, rather than Moses.

Except that John 6 is never tied to the Last Supper. One cannot simply pull out verses that sound like the go together and make doctrine.

My favorite counter example is this:

matt 27:5 And throwing down the pieces of silver into the temple, he departed, and he went and hanged himself.

Luke 3:11b … and whoever has food is to do likewise."

Now, these do pretty naturally fit together, but I doubt anyone is going to claim that it is doctrine.

Thus, we need a good exegetical basis for saying that John 6 is speaking of the Last Supper.
When Christ told the apostles this is my blood, this is my body they knew what Jesus meant cause He had already taught them what He meant, And what Jesus meant we find in St.John 6.We find no instruction from Jesus after He says these words at the last supper, cause the apostles knew already what was going on.
How in the world can you think these two verses in your example fit together? you need to lob a lot of St.Luke’s verse off in order to even come close to making any point, but you don’t have a point in the first place.
 
Muze,

Remember the Bereans didn’t have any new testament at that stage. The scriptures they were searching must have been the old testament. I imagine the apostles were referring to the foreshadowing and prophesies in the old testament to show them Jesus was the fulfillment of their scriptures.

They accepted the ORAL TEACHING of the apostles.
 
Chapter 2.

So do Catholics.

LOL… So, even if I can prove sola Scriptura to you from the bible, you still won’t accept it.

Have a nice day.
The point is Nestroianism can be proven from the Bible, when you take things out of context. Sola Scriptura ignores context.
 
Muze,

Remember the Bereans didn’t have any new testament at that stage. The scriptures they were searching must have been the old testament. I imagine the apostles were referring to the foreshadowing and prophesies in the old testament to show them Jesus was the fulfillment of their scriptures.

They accepted the ORAL TEACHING of the apostles.
 
James seems to say otherwise:

14But each person is tempted when he is lured and enticed by his own desire. 15Then desire when it has conceived gives birth to sin, and sin when it is fully grown brings forth death.

And who is doing the tempting? God?

10 The brothers immediately sent Paul and Silas away by night to Berea, and when they arrived they went into the Jewish synagogue. 11Now these Jews were more noble than those in Thessalonica; they received the word with all eagerness, examining the Scriptures daily to see if these things were so. 12 Many of them therefore believed, with not a few Greek women of high standing as well as men.

These people heard the teaching, but went home and searched their bibles to see if what Paul taught was true…

Sounds like sola scriptura to me…

Were they prideful, sinful, or noble?

Sounds like lack of Faith to me.

So, we should believe what the Church says, even if it is wrong?
Sounds like lack of Faith to me and not Trusting in Christ and in the Church he started but trusting in our own understanding, our own feelings and our own interpretation. They even questioned the ones who were sent by Christ. Who do we think we are?
 
Hi, Muze,

Just let me add an item here for clairification… 🙂

We all teach - by word and by deed. No doubt about it. But, in the example given by Ivebeenshown, Peter’s behavior or even any remarks he may have made at the meal - were NOT OFFICIAL TEACHING. This is reserved for areas of doctrine determined by the Magisterium and the Pope to be infallible.

Yes, Peter gave bad example - even scandal - and was called down for it by Paul. Note, Peter apparently took it well (didn’t punch Paul in the nose, or roll around the floor or other such nonsense) and actually changed his behavior. Peter is actually recognized as the Apostle to the Jews while Paul is recognized as the Apostle to the Gentiles. I guess Paul’s admonishment was effective. 🙂

Every Pope is a sinner. Every Pope was born in sin - and is guilty of actual sin throughout their lives. This was true for Peter and it is true for his latest successor, Benedict XVI. I know this because every Pope since Peter has been a sinful human being - just like you and me! The Pope is not without faults - human failings not necessarily sinful. Now, that this has been announced to the world - the other consideration to keep in mind is that when an ‘ex cathedra’ statement is made - ONLY the Pope can make it - and, by definition it is totally true - it is infallible. And, that is something we can not do.

Hope this helps.

God bless
So, Paul is only commanding Titus to exercise the authority given to all Christians. Thus, this isn’t a matter of an apostle giving out authority, but rather of an apostle telling another to use what Christ have already given him.

How was Peter FORCING Gentiles to live like Jews, if he was not teaching them?

And then what did they do?

OK, but you mentioned the use of thse other two instances as a way to define this word. Are you now saying that these other two uses have no impact on the meaning of this one?
 
I dont know where this would go, but I guess it would best fit here.

My question is this:

Many Protestant denominations believe in and follow the mindset of Sola Scriptura. While having obvious drawbacks, what do protestants think is the practicality to Sola Scriptura?
Or IS there even any?

Me personally though, I prefer the 3-Legged Stool of Scripture, Tradition, and Magisterium. 👍
It is a good thing that we still have freedom of conscience. As a Protestant I’ll try to answer your question:

The Bible is all about Jesus. It is paramount for a “scripturist” to read the Bible every day as in “daily bread” because within the Bible we find the bread, doctrine, given to us by our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ, who is the way, the truth, and the life. In the Word of God, we get to know Jesus.

In Genesis, Jesus is the seed of the woman. In Exodus, he is the passover lamb. In Leviticus, he is the high priest. In Numbers, he is the cloud and the fire. In Deuteronomy, he is the prophet like Moses. In Joshua, he is the captain of our salvation. In Judges, he is the judge and lawgiver. In Ruth, he is our kinsman and redeemer. In 1 & 2 Samuel, he is the prophet of the Lord, In 1 & 2 Kings, 1 & 2 Chronicles, he is the reigning king. In Ezra, he is the faithful scribe. In Nehemiah, he is the rebuilder of the broken walls. In Esther, he is Mordecai. In Job, he is the dayspring from on high. In Psalms, he is the lord who is our shepherd. In Proverbs & Ecclesiastes, he is the wisdom of God. In the Song of Solomon, he is the lover and the bridegroom. In Isaiah, he is the prince of peace. In Jeremiah & Lamentations, he is the weeping prophet. In Ezekiel, he is the wheel turning. In Daniel, he is the 4th man in the fiery furnace. In Hosea, he is the bridegroom. In Joel, he is the baptiser with the Holy Spirit. In Amos, he is our burden bearer. In Obadiah, he is our mighty saviour. In Jonah, he is our forgiving God. In Micah, he is the messenger with beautiful feet. In Nahum, he is the avenger of God’s elect. In Habakkuk, he is the great evangelist crying for revival. In Zephaniah, he is the restorer of God’s lost heritage. In Haggai, he is the cleansing fountain. In Zechariah, he is the pierced son. In Malachi, he is the son of righteousness.

In Matthew, he is the Messiah. In Mark, he is the wonder worker. In Luke, he is the son of man. In John, he is the Son of God. In Acts, he is the Ascended Lord. In Romans, he is the justifier. In 1 & 2 Corinthians, he is the gifts of the Spirit. In Galatians, he is the One who sets us Free. In Ephesians, he is the Christ of riches. In Philippans, he is the God who meets our every need. In Colossians, he is the fullness of the Godhead. In 1 & 2 Thessalonians, he is the Soon Coming King. In 1 & 2 Timothy, he is the Mediator between God and man. In Titus, he is the faithful pastor. In Philemon, he is our Friend, closer than a brother. In Hebrews, he is the blood that washes away my sins. In James, he is the great physician. In 1 & 2 Peter, he is the chief Shepherd. In 1 & 2 & 3 John, he is everlasting Love. In Jude, he is the Lord coming with 10.000 saints. In Revelation, he is the King of Kings and the Lord of Lords.

Hope this explains why the Bible is so important to us Protestant Christians.
 
The Bible is all about Jesus. It is paramount for a “scripturist” to read the Bible every day as in “daily bread” because within the Bible we find the bread, doctrine, given to us by our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ, who is the way, the truth, and the life. In the Word of God, we get to know Jesus.
That’s nice, but it doesn’t answer BA’s question. How can the doctrine of sola scriptura be practical when it has failed Protestantism so miserably?

Bible devotion nourishes, I won’t dispute that. But where in the Bible does Jesus give us a Bible?

Spot the fake verse!
51] I am the bible which came down from heaven; if any one reads this book, he will live for ever; and the bible which I shall give for the life of the world is my book."
51] I am the living bread which came down from heaven; if any one eats of this bread, he will live for ever; and the bread which I shall give for the life of the world is my flesh."
In Genesis, Jesus is the seed of the woman. (…message truncated…) In Revelation, he is the King of Kings and the Lord of Lords.
Hope this explains why the Bible is so important to us Protestant Christians.

That’s a beautiful dissertation. But it doesn’t explain how sola scriptura is practical when it has caused so much disunity. Personally, I don’t think that SS is Protestants main problem. SS spiritualizes real food and real drink into text. The Church is an extension of the Incarnation united by the Eucharist. SS redefines “Church” as something invisible, and spiritualized Jesus words of eternal life as if He meant all His words in the New Testament, and not in the context of Peter’s answer in John 6:68. What “words of eternal life” is Peter talking about? SS leans too heavily on a literal approach to scripture, but selectively spiritualizes one chapter in the Bible. John 6. That’s why a new denomination is being formed every 12 hours. It’s ONE BREAD, not a separate bread for each offering. It’s ONE BODY, not a broken home.

Acts 9:4-5; 22:8; 26:14-15 – Jesus asks Saul, “Why are you persecuting me?” when Saul was persecuting the Church. Jesus and the Church are one body (Bridegroom and Bride), and we are one with Jesus through His flesh and blood (the Eucharist).

We pray that God leads you home
 
Nikella,

You said: “Hope this explains why the Bible is so important to us Protestant Christians.”

The bible, Nikella (and Muze), is just as important to Catholics. After all, we preserved it so that it is available for use today. Without the Catholic Church, the bible would have never survived the first 1500 years from the death of Christ until the Protestant Revolt.

The problem with protestants and sola scriptura is that neither will EVER be able to authenticate the bible itself by using only the bible. To even THINK that one could do such a thing is ludicrous.

How can something authenticate itself?

Protestants always say, “the Jew determined the OT canon and Peter determined the NT canon”. Where in the world do such conclusions come from?

The Jews determined JUDAIC canon, but that wasn’t done until several centuries after Christ died.

Peter could not have determined the NT canon because he died in 67 AD, and the NT was not even finished being written yet, let alone compiled by the time of Peter’s death.

To show you the illogic of your position that the bible is self authenticating, please tell me where, in the entire bible, does it state which books should be in the bible. I will save you the trouble of looking and tell you that it is not there, but feel free to search yourself . . .

Do you not realize that the table of contents and an index are NOT inspired? Do you realize that the original manuscripts were NOT puctuated with periods, paragraph breaks, verse numbers, etc.? Where do you think these came from?

Suppose that one was to say, “well, the bible authenticates itself because we know who authored the books of the bible and (as Muze said), once we know that Paul wrote a book, then it is clearly part of the bible”.
  1. How do you know that Paul did not write anything other than what is in the bible? Are you suggesting that EVERY THING that Paul wrote was divinely inspired, and thus is in the bible? Where does the bible say that?
  2. What book in the bible specifically states that the OT has X number of books and the NT has Y number of books, and Z are the books that comprise the bible? Muze said that the Jews did this for the OT and Peter did this for the NT, but if you accept what Muze said, then you just violated your sacred principle of sola scriptura, because you are relying on something or someones (“Jews” and “Peter”) to tell you what is or is not inspired.
So much for relying ONLY on the bible to determine what should be IN the bible . . . :rolleyes:
 
Actually, I know this (NT) because Peter tells us that this is the case, for the writings of those who saw Christ’s glory…
Yes, but how do you know that letter is really from Peter?
Ah, but as the giant in “Princess Bride” says…“I don’t think that word means what you think it means.”

Paul is speaking of the instructions given to them when he was there teaching them. There is no implication that these traditions are to be kept for all cultures and all time.
Yes, he was speaking of the instructions he gave to them while he was there. This is the Sacred Tradition, the Kerygma.

Under what circumstances should we disregard the Aposotlic instructions?

Which part of the Apostolic instruction should we ignore?
Actually, this comes from 2 Peter 1. The Church simply applied these standards combined with the knowledge it had from early Church Fathers.

Ever read 2 Peter 1:16-21?
Yes, but again, how do you know those letters are really from Peter the Apostle? How do you know which of Paul’s writings he is referring? What if it is a reference to some of the lost letters of Paul?
From what I understand Luke is understood to be a disciple of Christ who saw his ascension. Furthermore, there is only one NT author in question, and that would be Hebrews, and at the time of the compiling of the canon, that was not in question.
How can you say this? How do you know that the Gospel and the Acts are not written by Barnabas, calling himself Luke? How do you know they are not just made up?

How do you know who wrote Matthew? How do you know Revelation is valid?
Code:
Or because it kinda destroys your point.
No, it is because it isn’t there.
Code:
Um... Read 2 Peter 1 again.  Peter knows he's about to die, and wants to leave the Church with something to hang on to in the days of false teachers to come.  So, he identifies those who saw Christ's glory, and then says that their writings are spoken from God, and they are born along by the Holy Spirit... What more do you need?
For you to recognize that there were 400+ writings floating around all claiming the same thing.

For you to realize that Peter is making reference to the Apostolic instruction about which he wanted to REMIND them.
No? You’re saying that no councils declaring the canon of Scripture ever happened?
Why should you trust them?
 
Hey, Muze,

“As I see it…” :D, there is a major misunderstanding going on involving Galations 2
LOL… SO, Peter was uncircumsized, but made sure that everyone in Galatia saw him getting circumsized, hoping they’d all feel compelled to follow? Or was he going around showing people that he was circumsized?

Seriously… whether forced or compelled, there is simply no way to objectively look at this passage and not see that Peter is verbally instructing Gentiles to live like Jews.
You can actually substitute Jew and Gentile for ‘circumcised’ and ‘uncircumcised’. Christ, a Jewish male, circumcised on the 8th day, chose Peter another Jewish male and eleven other Jewish males to be the Apostles. Later, Christ chose Saul of Tarsus, a Jewish male, circumcised on the 8th day - and a former Pharisee - to be an Apostle ‘out of time’. All of these men had been circumcised. Peter is going to preach to the Jews and Paul is going to preach to the Gentiles.

Here is the relevant Scripture… Gal 2:7-9

7
On the contrary, when they saw that I had been entrusted with the gospel to the uncircumcised, just as Peter to the circumcised,
8
for the one who worked in Peter for an apostolate to the circumcised worked also in me for the Gentiles,
9
and when they recognized the grace bestowed upon me, James and Cephas and John, 8 who were reputed to be pillars, gave me and Barnabas their right hands in partnership, that we should go to the Gentiles and they to the circumcised.

Now, Muze, it looks like you are going back to you ‘one-liners’ again. From the looks of things, you seem delighted that Peter made this hypocritical error. Yes, it really looks like he gave scandal - but, this is not an official teaching. if you are interested in seeing Peter with an official position, go to Acts 15 and see how Peter shuts down the Judiazers.

I am not aware of anyone arguing with on the personal short-comings and outright failures of Peter - the one chosen by the First Person of the Blessed Trinity to get the correct answer, and the one chosen by the Second Person of the Blessed Trinity (Matt 16:18) to lead the Chruch of Christ (and, that would be the Catholic Church). And, that means with all of this, Peter is still human, makes some poor choices, obviously learns from them and carries the Cathoic Church through until he is martyred. This really happened.

What didn’t happen is that there was NEVER an official teaching that Gentiles were somehow inferiior, or had to take additional steps to enter the newly forming Catholic Church.

Hope this clarifies the issue.

God bless
 
Well, to the Corinthians, he taught them to have wives wear a veil in Church, especially if they are prophesying. I don’t think the RCC requires women to wear a veil to mass… Or to even keep long hair. (Or requires men to have short hair.)

He also advises women to remain silent when in the church… Again, I don’t see such a requirement from the RCC…

Clearly at least SOME traditions are intended for local application, and given the culture and the issues going on in those churches, the intent IS for local context.
How do you know that?

What criteria do you use to decide which is which?
And I think this is Paul’s intent for most traditions that he teaches.
By what authority do you claim to know the Apostles’ intent?
Code:
Clearly there may be some timeless instruction that we might derive from them, but we'd also need to know that they were Pauline, and what Paul intended them to learn from it.
So you think all the “traditions” are from Paul, and none of them are from God?
The Greek word that is translated “interpretation” doesn’t fit. The word means something along the lines of “releasing” or “discharging.”
After some of the “interpretation” I have read, I can certainly vouch that they qualify as “releasing” and “discharging”. 😉
I’ve actually written a paper that makes the case that this word is better translated “revelation”, given the context of the passage.
Speaking of discharge…

Ok, so let’s go with “revelation”. The God given revelation of scripture does not come from one person’s private perception.
Well, sola scriptura isn’t a rejection of tradition entirely. Indeed, Luther and Calvin respected the traditions of the Church, but only in that they did not disagree with the bible itself.
The problem with this is that it boils down to what Luther, Calvin, or anyone with a belly button thinks scripture means. That is, what does scripture “reveal/discharge/release”. As we all know, there are as many different understandings of what God has “released” through the scriptures as there are individuals.
Code:
If people are twisting words in such a way that they disagree with what Paul is saying or says elsewhere, then this is a valid criticism, and has nothing to do with Sola Scriptura.
And who decides what “Paul’s words elsewhere” mean? You see, no matter which direction you come or go, it all gets back to one’s private interpretation.

In your example above, the early church believed Paul referred to the Sacred Traditions that were part of the Kerygma.

You think it is local customs. Who is right?

What did Jesus instruct us to do if we have a dispute about it?
 
Hi, Muze,

There really isn’t any way you can ‘prove’ SS is valid! Honest.
LOL… So, even if I can prove sola Scriptura to you from the bible, you still won’t accept it.
The two fundamental reasons for this is that:

1- the Bible itself makes no such claim that it AND IT ALONE is the source of God’s inspired Word, and

2- John states in two places (John 20:30-31 and John 21:25 ) that not everything has been written down.

St. John was totally knowledgeable in Apostolic Tradition - and by only accepting what is written you omit God inspired Apostolic Tradition. Recall, it was the Catholic Church who gave the world the Canon of Sacred Scriptures. There is nothing hidden here - but, Scripture can only take you so far. It is this limitation - as expressed by so many contradictory interpretations - that makes the limitation known. You must have an authorative souce to understand what is being said.

For a much better explaination than I can give you, please go to this link: catholic.com/thisrock/2004/0409fea3.asp Addressing these issues is really important mainly because SS is really leading people away from Christ! :eek: This happens when everyone claims they are lead by the Spirit and interpret Scripture as they see fit. Now, they are partially correct! They are being lead by a spirit - and the fact that 30,000+ groups ( philvaz.com/apologetics/a120.htm ) are all competing and arguing over Scripture should give you a good idea where that spirit comes from.

My suggestion would be to look at this link and see if you can refute it using logic and objective references. Go on, give it a try… 🙂

God bless
 
The issue is still “WHO has the final **authority **to interpret Christ’s teachings?”.

Who has the authority to interpret the Word of God (BOTH written and oral) in a definitive manner?

Interestingly some of the people arguing AGAINST Apostolic authority being protected by the Holy Spirit for the MAGISTERIUM seem to most aggressive in CLAIMING Apostolic authority being protected by the Holy Spirit for THEMSELVES. They wouldn’t put it that way, but re-read this thread a couple of times and see if you can perceive that.

We heard the charge that the Church was Arian. This was not substantiated at all. It was mere ipse dixit (It’s so because I say it’s so!”). I explained why it was the fallacy of ipse dixit earlier.

I pointed out that:
One thing’s for sure, if there are 11,000 (or 33,000) bible only groups or denominations all claiming to follow the bible ALONE as their ultimate authority, all claiming to follow the dictates of the Holy Spirit, and yet all coming to differing conclusions on various issues, you KNOW at least 10,999 (or 29,999) of them are going to be wrong somewhere. The Holy Spirit does NOT author chaos.
The number was insinuated as wrong. I think it’s right for reasons that I won’t get into here, but let’s assume it is wrong. Let’s say the denominational number is ONLY 11,000 as Protestants often lay claim to. The principle still holds true. You know at least 10,999 of them are not going to be protected by the Holy Spirit, and WILL be teaching “a different gospel” other than from what “you received from us” (c.f. Galatians 1:9).

We heard “tradition” “was man made, and (does) not carry any promise of
infallibility.”

I pointed out that Scripture refers to itself as “tradition” in 2nd Thessalonians 2:15. This was not addressed at all. I don’t see how it can be addressed in a compelling way short of admitting at least SOME tradition is NOT man-made and still affirm Sacred Scripture. As soon as you admit some tradition is NOT man-made you are showing your own self-contradiction.

We heard “magisterium” was man made. But the power of being given “the keys” and the power to “bind and loose” is “magisterium”.

You might say: “well it existed before but not now” (when those who saw His glory were here ONLY – this probably really alludes to the Transfiguration but certainly not sola Scriptura). But then you’d at least be admitting that “magisterium” isn’t “man-made” and contradicting your own points about it being man-made.

Either magisterium is man-made or it is God-made and doesn’t exist any more or neither. But to assert in practical terms (not literally but the practicality) that BOTH “Magisterium is man-made!” and “Magisterium is God-made but it doesn’t exist any more because I deny Apostolic succession!” is a self-contradiction. These assertions wouldn’t be put that way either but that is in effect what is going on here.

Actually the “magisterium” (or Divinely protected teaching office) is God-made and it DOES still exist through Apostolic Succession but I won’t address the Apostolic Succession issue on this thread.
**LUKE 10:16 **16 “He who hears you hears me,
and he who rejects you rejects me, and he who rejects me rejects him who sent me.”
Luke 10:16 IS an example of the Magisterium illustrated.
 
I asked where in Acts 15 the appeals to Genesis 17 were. You’d expect those appeals if the Church were practicing sola Scriptura. But they weren’t there (either the appeals or the response to my assertion).

We’ve been told James was the leader of the Church. But we’ve ALSO been told we ALL have authority and no one person leads the Church in terms of authority. Neither of these self-contradictions is true.

I asked where the Canon of Scripture was in Scripture. If it were there, I’d expect to see a verse such as . . . .
HYPOTHETICAL VERSE “The books, letters, etc. that belong in the Bible include: Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers, Deuteronomy, etc. etc. Matthew, Mark, Luke, John, etc. etc. Jude and Revelation.”
If the verse is NOT there (and of course it’s not) then you NEED an infallible authority to identify which books, etc. belong in Scripture and which ones are not inspired. This was not addressed in the context of God-given protected authority and sola Scriptura.

I asked:
Because the ancient Hebrew language was a “consonantal language” (it was all consonants). You NEEDED oral tradition to pass it on accurately from person to person then. Why?
Well think of an English analogy (of course the analogy is not inspired but I’m using the correlation merely to illustrate a point).
I’ll give you one word: “m****n”. This is an English word with no vowels. But what word is it?
Is it “man”? Is it “men”? Is it “amen”? Is it “many”? Is it “money”? Is it “omen”?
You don’t know do you?
You don’t know unless you have an oral interpretation to tell you what word it is.
I was basically disparaged for asking the question of how you’d KNOW what the word is without knowledge of what is being transmitted and that I am stepping out on a “ledge”.

I was told how I haven’t checked a Hebrew lexicon (note that I am to check a Scripture verse? No—to check a Hebrew lexicon because the answer to the language dilemma needs to be addressed outside of Scripture). But actually I HAVE checked a Hebrew lexicon and still don’t know the answer to this.

I’m not going to pretend here that I’m an expert on ancient Hebrew. I’m not. But the question is a common-sense one and it has not been answered yet and insulting me about “ledge”s isn’t going to answer the question.
“In Bible times, however the mechanics of learning required that the teacher listen to the student repeat the lesson back to him verbatim. The most important quality for being a good scholar was a trained and retentive memory.”—Our Father Abraham: Jewish roots of the Christian faith by Marvin R. Wilson p. 303
But WHY is such a well-trained memory integral to being a scholar in the ancient Hebrew culture? It isn’t today. I know Harvard-trained men today who have not had their memories held to this kind of scrutiny. It seems to me that you NEEDED to have a well-trained memory just to interpret the consonants/writings. I could be wrong and am open to a good-willed correction (not more insults though please) but I have not heard a good explanation yet here or anywhere else. There are other reasons to have such a well trained memory too but this one seems key to me and should be thought about.

I was told that Hebrew consonants were in groups of three and this makes it very readable in effect. “Thus, if you identify the three root consonants, you’ve identified the word.”

That raises other questions.

How does consonants in groups of three make it easier to read from generation to generation without being able to fill the consonants in?

Why is the “Tetragrammaton” (notice it’s not the TRIgrammaton) four Hebrew letters instead of three? It seems there is already at least one exception to the “three”-root consonants aspect that was stated. Are there other exceptions too? And perhaps that’s all it is—an exception—but I think the question is a reasonable one that was not answered adequately.

I was told (correctly):
"the Hebrew vowel system was added” (LONG after like 600AD).
But then WHY add a vowel system at all if the Hebrew consonant-only language was so self-evident as it was implied (and if it wasn’t self-evident you would be making my point not refuting it). Maybe it’s not as perspicuous as some seem to think. Just like interpreting Sacred Scripture is not as self-explaining as many would have you believe either.

None of the arguments sited for sola Scriptura here or anywhere else work. Any definition of what sola Scriptura is that I’ve seen so far (the definition itself) is not found in Scripture. Sola Scriptura is a tradition of men that makes void the commandments of God. Not ONE verse in all of Sacred Scripture teaches sola Scriptura. All of the self-contradictions shown to “support” sola Scriptura have been unpersuasive.
 
Hi, Salvatore123,

Excellent post! 👍

Between you and Guanophore it looks like Muze is getting a chace to see that just accepting what the Catholic Church has given to him - while still denying that the Catholic Church was founded by Christ, is bcoming more difficult… dare I say, impossible?

God bless
Nikella,

You said: “Hope this explains why the Bible is so important to us Protestant Christians.”

The bible, Nikella (and Muze), is just as important to Catholics. After all, we preserved it so that it is available for use today. Without the Catholic Church, the bible would have never survived the first 1500 years from the death of Christ until the Protestant Revolt.

The problem with protestants and sola scriptura is that neither will EVER be able to authenticate the bible itself by using only the bible. To even THINK that one could do such a thing is ludicrous.

How can something authenticate itself?

Protestants always say, “the Jew determined the OT canon and Peter determined the NT canon”. Where in the world do such conclusions come from?

The Jews determined JUDAIC canon, but that wasn’t done until several centuries after Christ died.

Peter could not have determined the NT canon because he died in 67 AD, and the NT was not even finished being written yet, let alone compiled by the time of Peter’s death.

To show you the illogic of your position that the bible is self authenticating, please tell me where, in the entire bible, does it state which books should be in the bible. I will save you the trouble of looking and tell you that it is not there, but feel free to search yourself . . .

Do you not realize that the table of contents and an index are NOT inspired? Do you realize that the original manuscripts were NOT puctuated with periods, paragraph breaks, verse numbers, etc.? Where do you think these came from?

Suppose that one was to say, “well, the bible authenticates itself because we know who authored the books of the bible and (as Muze said), once we know that Paul wrote a book, then it is clearly part of the bible”.
  1. How do you know that Paul did not write anything other than what is in the bible? Are you suggesting that EVERY THING that Paul wrote was divinely inspired, and thus is in the bible? Where does the bible say that?
  2. What book in the bible specifically states that the OT has X number of books and the NT has Y number of books, and Z are the books that comprise the bible? Muze said that the Jews did this for the OT and Peter did this for the NT, but if you accept what Muze said, then you just violated your sacred principle of sola scriptura, because you are relying on something or someones (“Jews” and “Peter”) to tell you what is or is not inspired.
So much for relying ONLY on the bible to determine what should be IN the bible . . . :rolleyes:
 
But Paul clearly identifies this as oral tradition, and its purpose is for a wife to honor her husband. Are you saying that a wife honoring her husband isn’t a moral issue?
Where is it “clearly identified” that this is an “oral tradition”?

So, “oral tradition” is about morals?
Code:
OK, does the RCC forbid women to speak, except when prophesying or praying?
If we did not, then by what authority would such a decision have been made?
But Paul isn’t talking about teaching and authority. He’s telling them to remain silent. If anything, the prophesying objection would seem to suggest otherwise.
What makes you say this is not part of the teaching and authority? How can “I do not permit a woman to speak in church” lack authority?
yes, the ECFs use it in this way, but I think they do so because they like how this verse works out when they do.
Ever consider that it is because the way they use it is consistent with what the Apostles believed and taught?
And those are questions that should be constantly asked and answered, especially for those things that aren’t fundamental to being a Christian.
Who decides what is “fundamental to being a Christian”?
Too often theologians (both protestant and catholic) are dealing with a crisis, and form theology for that task, and succeed, but then we codify exactly what they said as eternal doctrine, rather than going back and asking what aspects of their work stepped over a few lines for the purpose intended, and need to be returned to a biblical standard.
Maybe y’all do this, but this is not Catholic.
Calvin has these issues. So does Augustine. And Aquinas. And most theologians, including the ECFs. And even those things declared by the RCC.
No, we don’t Muse. There is no contradiction between the Scripture and the Church Teaching for Catholics, because they came from the same Source.
Not that we dont’ respect the work that these people did. But we should all have the ability to question it and study it. That’s the only way to prevent corruption of doctrine.
Oh, I see. Your ability to study and question the faith of the Apostles is what prevents the doctrine from being corrupted?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top