Some help for our Protestant friends

  • Thread starter Thread starter cyberjacques
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Always For Him:
How is it that you think I have taken this out of context?
I don’t think you’ve taken the verse out of context, I know that you have.

You’re doing what your fellows call “cherry-picking.”

You need to back up at least one verse for the immediate context, and continue to v21, where the thought of the apostle begun in v19 is completed.
Always For Him:
Why is it that you believe in individual interpretation?
Again, no prohibition against interpreting scripture is given in scripture.

Historically, the Jews were commanded to know the law, to write it on their hearts, and to teach it to their children.

God didn’t change that command in the NT.

Furthermore, Augustine wrote a treatise giving instruction to the people on what he considered to be the appropriate way of interpreting the scripture, and perhaps learning even more by private study than one had learned from his teachers.

Why would Augustine offer instruction on how to interpret scripture, if God had issued a prohibition against it?
 
Sandusky,

Will you answer this question from AFH?

Is it too personal? I know I’m very curious as to what it is, ultimately that leads people away from the one church. Can you tell us what was the final straw for you?
I was an unsaved, unregenerate Christ rejector.
 
St. Vincent of Vincent of Lerins

Commonitory 450 AD

But here some one perhaps will ask, Since the canon of Scripture is complete, and sufficient of itself for everything, and more than sufficient, what need is there to join with it the authority of the Church’s interpretation? For this reason,— because, owing to the depth of Holy Scripture, all do not accept it in one and the same sense, but one understands its words in one way, another in another; so that it seems to be capable of as manyinterpretations as there are interpreters. For Novatian expounds it one way, Sabellius another, Donatus another, Arius, Eunomius, Macedonius, another, Photinus, Apollinaris, Priscillian, another, Iovinian, Pelagius, Celestius, another, lastly, Nestorius another. Therefore, it is very necessary, on account of so great intricacies of such various error, that the rule for the right understanding of the prophets and apostles should be framed in accordance with the standard of Ecclesiastical and Catholic interpretation.
 
St. Vincent of Vincent of Lerins

Commonitory 450 AD

But here some one perhaps will ask, Since the canon of Scripture is complete, and sufficient of itself for everything, and more than sufficient, what need is there to join with it the authority of the Church’s interpretation? For this reason,— because, owing to the depth of Holy Scripture, all do not accept it in one and the same sense, but one understands its words in one way, another in another; so that it seems to be capable of as manyinterpretations as there are interpreters. For Novatian expounds it one way, Sabellius another, Donatus another, Arius, Eunomius, Macedonius, another, Photinus, Apollinaris, Priscillian, another, Iovinian, Pelagius, Celestius, another, lastly, Nestorius another. Therefore, it is very necessary, on account of so great intricacies of such various error, that the rule for the right understanding of the prophets and apostles should be framed in accordance with the standard of Ecclesiastical and Catholic interpretation.
Surely you must be taking that out of context, since a mere 1,100 years later it was firmly established that all of those named had a right to their personal interpretation of Scripture and that so long as they agreed with Sandusky (who came along another 500 years later) they were correct.

You simply don’t understand The Atomic Church of Me and its theological prerequisites.
 
So you are in worse shape then we thought. You actaully had the truth in the palm of your hand and you chose to make shipreck of your faith and toss it away. How sad.
I don’t think we can make this assumption. It is clear from reading sandy’s posts that he never understood or grasped the truth until after he abandoned the Catholic faith. He has probably learned more about what Catholics believe since he joined this board than he ever did as a youngster. I don’t get the impression that he had much of a faith to shipwreck. On the contrary, it seems more like it was a form of godliness, without the power thereof.

Unfortunately, this is not an uncommon experience for cradle catholics, especially in that generation.
 
There is no prohibition against interpreting scripture found in scripture.
Oh, I agree! We are to write the words on our hearts, and have them on our lips, sing them in songs, and speak them to one another. However, it is not right to separate the Holy Writings from the Sacred tradition that produced them.
 
An even more interesting question is how the Gospel was interpreted in the 1st century when it hadn’t been written down yet.

Even after the Gospels were composed, there was a period of some centuries where the Bible was not widely available and the Church was underground. How was it to be interpreted then?

Good questions,
Sacred Tradition. The Sacred Scriptures are a written form of Sacred Tradition. They go together as the Sacred Deposit of Faith, given to the Apostles by Jesus Christ for HIS Catholic Church. Who has protected and taught them for 2,000 years. Under the Protection of the Holy Spirit. And will continue to do so till the "End of the World’. Anytime private interpretation doesn’t agree with the Church’s interpretation, guess who’s wrong!
 
St. Vincent of Vincent of Lerins

Commonitory 450 AD

But here some one perhaps will ask, Since the canon of Scripture is complete, and sufficient of itself for everything, and more than sufficient, what need is there to join with it the authority of the Church’s interpretation? For this reason,— because, owing to the depth of Holy Scripture, all do not accept it in one and the same sense, but one understands its words in one way, another in another; so that it seems to be capable of as manyinterpretations as there are interpreters. For Novatian expounds it one way, Sabellius another, Donatus another, Arius, Eunomius, Macedonius, another, Photinus, Apollinaris, Priscillian, another, Iovinian, Pelagius, Celestius, another, lastly, Nestorius another. Therefore, it is very necessary, on account of so great intricacies of such various error, that the rule for the right understanding of the prophets and apostles should be framed in accordance with the standard of Ecclesiastical and Catholic interpretation.
As I said, there is no prohibition against private interpretation of scripture in scripture.
 
As I said, there is no prohibition against private interpretation of scripture in scripture.
As long as you stay inside the teachings of the church, or I guess for protestants, it would be considered inside the pale (pail ?) of orthodoxy, Though I am not sure what they consider orthodoxy, since they don’t meet in councils to counter heretical teachings anymore, hence Mormonism Jehovah Witness, Christian Scientist, oneness Pentecostals being able to thrive after springing up out of protestantism…
 
40.png
savedsinner:
As long as you stay inside the teachings of the church, or I guess for protestants, it would be considered inside the pale (pail ?) of orthodoxy, Though I am not sure what they consider orthodoxy, since they don’t meet in councils to counter heretical teachings anymore, hence Mormonism Jehovah Witness, Christian Scientist, oneness Pentecostals being able to thrive after springing up out of protestantism.
You can read the different confessions.

Start with The Westminster Confession of Faith if you’d like.
 
As long as you stay inside the teachings of the church, or I guess for protestants, it would be considered inside the pale (pail ?) of orthodoxy, Though I am not sure what they consider orthodoxy, since they don’t meet in councils to counter heretical teachings anymore, hence Mormonism Jehovah Witness, Christian Scientist, oneness Pentecostals being able to thrive after springing up out of protestantism…
They don’t meet in ecumenical councils between denominations, but some Protestant communities do meet with different groups within their own community, such as the United Methodists have recently done.

Lately, though, these get-togethers have been more about secular politics than religion, which has been the source of looming schisms.

It is a curious thing when one may believe whatever one likes about the nature of the Eucharist, but if you are opposed to gay marriage, you’re suspected of heresy!
 
Guanophore has written:

*However, it is not right to separate the Holy Writings from the Sacred tradition that produced them./I]

There are always problems of definition within Christianity. The ‘Holy Writings’ (define) for Catholics are clearly sometimes different from those of other denominations.

My biggest question here however is how we are to deal intelligently and spiritually with the huge explosion of Biblical translations, each of which differs in subtle ways from another.

There are numerous English-language Bibles for Western countries, the African Bible (and I assume same for other regions), and Bibles in every major (and sometimes not so major like Sotho or Pedi) language. Some translations are done by eminent commissions, some by local missionaries or pastors. I am not even sure which have received the Vatican’s imprimature.

I find major differences among the various English versions. Which does my Catholic Church use? We use the New Jerusalem or the Good News Bibles, but others are of course acceptable (NIV, KJV, NKJV).

Given the sometimes significant variations among translations, do we spend our time well by hunting down minutiae of scriptural meaning? Are there not larger issues to be addressed? I am confused here.

Martin Luther (the would-have-been Blessed, now apparently forgiven by CC) was, I believe, absolutely correct in making his vernacular translation from the Hebrew only. This of course caused great outcries when what are now called the Deuterocanonical books of the Bible (Apocrypha), having been written in Greek, were excluded from early vernacular translations. I believe they are now all included in modern Bibles.

Is nit-picking possible given the vast array of nits to pick?

How do we define Holy Writings and Sacred Tradition in a way that can perhaps clarify the subtle variations of any belief system?

Jabulani!

You are beautiful because I have clothed you in my splendour.*
 
Commonitory 450 AD
This is what you come up with when you read that quote from St. Vincent of of Lerins.
Well, all I can figure out is that you are either an idiot or a genius.

You know that it doesn’t say anywhere in scripture that everything a Christian believes is to only be found in scripture.
It says that written scripture and traditions being passed down by word of mouth are both to be followed.

Catholics can privately interpret scripute as long as they stay within the boundries of what the church has infallibly taught. An example of what I mean is that I can’t read scripture and then come to the conclusion that Jesus was not divine, but I could read Genesis and come to the conclusion that the world was created in 6 24 hour days, or that it took many millions of years, as long as I keep to what the church teaches about original sin and an actual Adam and Eve who fell into sin, and that it was God who created all things from nothing.
 
As long as you stay inside the teachings of the church, or I guess for protestants, it would be considered inside the pale (pail ?) of orthodoxy, Though I am not sure what they consider orthodoxy, since they don’t meet in councils to counter heretical teachings anymore, hence Mormonism Jehovah Witness, Christian Scientist, oneness Pentecostals being able to thrive after springing up out of protestantism…
Seems to me that harmful gross generalisations of this nature do not help any Protestant friends. Surely you can end the charicature which does you no favours either.

Most mainline Protestant denominations are members of the World Council of Churches based in Switzerland. The Catholic Church has been in association with WCC for over 40 years through the mechanism of a standing committee.

There are issues at hand that can use some thought.

Jabulani!

You are beautiful because I have clothed you in my splendour.
 
As I said, there is no prohibition against private interpretation of scripture in scripture.
And as I said, if your interpretation doesn’t agree with the Catholic Church’s interpretation, guess who is wrong. You have NO authority to decide who has the right interpretation.
 
guanophor, rightly corrected my assumption with:
I don’t think we can make this assumption. It is clear from reading sandy’s posts that he never understood or grasped the truth until after he abandoned the Catholic faith. He has probably learned more about what Catholics believe since he joined this board than he ever did as a youngster. I don’t get the impression that he had much of a faith to shipwreck. On the contrary, it seems more like it was a form of godliness, without the power thereof.
Unfortunately, this is not an uncommon experience for cradle catholics, especially in that generation.
As it turns out, this is true by sandusky’s own admission. I’m glad sandusky has chosen to hang around, as there is great insight into the truth of the one church on this thread.

I pray there will be found an open mind and heart to receive it. That, we have no control over and I find the hardness of heart and the closed mind to be the sadest circumstance one might find oneself in, on ones journey. It prohibits discovery.
 
Lisdogan posted:
There are always problems of definition within Christianity. The ‘Holy Writings’ (define) for Catholics are clearly sometimes different from those of other denominations.
There are only problems of definition, inasmuch as man began protesting the one truth and took it upon himself to change the “Holy Writings” to better suit his own personal wants.

You should be aware that the Catholic Church is not a denomination. It is incorrect to speak of the Catholic Church and then “other” denominations. The one, true Church is not a denomination, she is The Church which Christ established to teach all nations the one truth of His revelation. If one would keep to this plan, the plan orginated by God incarnate, then there would be no problem of definition with Christianity and there would be no denominations to differ from, and oppose other denominations because there would be no denominations. Christ did not establish denominations. He established, The Church. Man established denominations.
 
Lisdogan posted further this question:
My biggest question here however is how we are to deal intelligently and spiritually with the huge explosion of Biblical translations, each of which differs in subtle ways from another.
Intelligently we are to find and recognize the one church Christ established to teach (Which you have done as your profile says you are catholic. Welcome to the CAFs.), realize that the one church not only produced the NT and cannoized the Bible, but is also charged by God to protect the authenticity of the written text. So we are to intelligently look to her for the correct translation and charitably point out to those who use other translations the potential for error not only in following their own, private interpretation but also in the very words they privately interpret.

Spiritually, we are to pray unceasingly, and particularly for the intentions of Christ himself, which would of course be the will of God, that we will someday by united and of one mind as the Son is united and of one mind with the Father.
 
"St. Vincent of Vincent of Lerins:
Nestorius another. Therefore, it is very necessary, on account of so great intricacies of such various error, that the rule for the right understanding of the prophets and apostles should be framed in accordance with the standard of Ecclesiastical and Catholic interpretation.
As I said, there is no prohibition against private interpretation of scripture in scripture.
Do I gather from this that you are in disagreement with St. Vincent, who seems to say the opposite?

How do you understand the passage in Peter?

St. Vincent points out that the interpretation of the scripture used by the Apostolic Tradition was what was used to refute the heretics he listed in the above quote. On what basis, do you think, is it appropriate to abandon the Apostolic understanding of the Scriptures?
 
Excellent point Teflon:
It is a curious thing when one may believe whatever one likes about the nature of the Eucharist, but if you are opposed to gay marriage, you’re suspected of heresy!
When the Episcopal Church made a Bishop of an openly gay man, I thought all of Protestanism would see the fallacy of private interpretation and come flooding into Catholicism. I at least thought my siblings and other “fallen away Catholics” would take puase in great numbers and reconsider the unified and organized, Apostolic Church they left, in favor of this immoral chaos.

Didn’t happen.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top