SPLIT: Confession to priest not necessary

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ginger2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
First, Jesus wasn’t just a man. He was God incarnate.
No question. However, the scriptures say that God gave the power to forgive sins to “men” - PLURAL. Since only one man, Jesus, had forgiven a sin at that point in the narrative, who is Matthew referring to if not all the other apostles whom he would have know were forgiving sins in the intervening years?
Second, salvation is not dependent on perfect understanding of every single Scripture. However, contradicting Scriptures in forbidden.
Agreed. What is your point?
Windgirl may correct me if I am wrong, but I believe we both agree, whatever God says is absolute truth and we accept it, even when we don’t fully understand. But we absolutely reject anything that contradicts what God has revealed to us in His Holy Scriptures, which are His inerrant Word to us.
Great. So, you will have no problem accepting the fact that Jesus said, “This is my body…this is my blood” and that is literally true of the Eucharist even if you don’t fully understand? Or the fact that He also said, “You are Peter (kepha) and upon this rock (kepha) I will build what I must call my church.”?

Or is it more accurate to say that what you accept is your fallible, human interpretation of what scripture says?
What you claim contradicts Scripture.

We reject it because our allegiance lies with God - alone.
Actually, that is exactly the position I would expect someone who is outside the fold (but unwilling to admit it) to take.

Look, I’m not saying that you’re not a Christian…the Church understands that you are. However, you are not in full communion with His Church which is a visible organization with a visible head (the Bishop of Rome).

I’ll quote this again in case you missed it the first time:
  1. Therefore, there exists a single Church of Christ, which subsists in the Catholic Church, governed by the Successor of Peter and by the Bishops in communion with him.58 The Churches which, while not existing in perfect communion with the Catholic Church, remain united to her by means of the closest bonds, that is, by apostolic succession and a valid Eucharist, are true particular Churches.59 Therefore, the Church of Christ is present and operative also in these Churches, even though they lack full communion with the Catholic Church, since they do not accept the Catholic doctrine of the Primacy, which, according to the will of God, the Bishop of Rome objectively has and exercises over the entire Church.60
On the other hand, the ecclesial communities which have not preserved the valid Episcopate and the genuine and integral substance of the Eucharistic mystery,61 are not Churches in the proper sense; however, those who are baptized in these communities are, by Baptism, incorporated in Christ and thus are in a certain communion, albeit imperfect, with the Church.62 Baptism in fact tends per se toward the full development of life in Christ, through the integral profession of faith, the Eucharist, and full communion in the Church.63

“The Christian faithful are therefore not permitted to imagine that the Church of Christ is nothing more than a collection — divided, yet in some way one — of Churches and ecclesial communities; nor are they free to hold that today the Church of Christ nowhere really exists, and must be considered only as a goal which all Churches and ecclesial communities must strive to reach”.64 In fact, “the elements of this already-given Church exist, joined together in their fullness in the Catholic Church and, without this fullness, in the other communities”.65 “Therefore, these separated Churches and communities as such, though we believe they suffer from defects, have by no means been deprived of significance and importance in the mystery of salvation. For the spirit of Christ has not refrained from using them as means of salvation which derive their efficacy from the very fullness of grace and truth entrusted to the Catholic Church”.66
 
Jesus also spoke of leaving the 99 in the fold and going in search of the lost sheep - His sheep - who was separated from the others.
Jesus didn’t say he was lost or separated.

ACTS 19:13-16
Then some itinerant Jewish exorcists tried to invoke the name of the Lord Jesus over those with evil spirits, saying, “I adjure you by the Jesus whom Paul preaches.”
When the seven sons of Sceva, a Jewish high priest, tried to do this,
the evil spirit said to them in reply, “Jesus I recognize, Paul I know, but who are you?”
The person with the evil spirit then sprang at them and subdued them all. He so overpowered them that they fled naked and wounded from that house.
 
Great. So, you will have no problem accepting the fact that Jesus said, “This is my body…this is my blood” and that is literally true of the Eucharist even if you don’t fully understand?
Not only do I accepted it, it makes perfect sense to me. But this is written clearly in Scriptures, compatible with other Scriptures, so it’s meaning is a given.
…you are not in full communion with His Church which is a visible organization with a visible head (the Bishop of Rome).
You are making a judgment to things you cannot know. You do not know everything the Lord is doing nor with whom.
 
Mat 11:25 Jesus answered, I thank thee, O Father, Lord of heaven and earth, because thou hast hid these things from the wise and prudent, and hast revealed them unto babes.
The scriptures can be difficult to understand.

2 Peter 3:16
He writes the same way in all his letters, speaking in them of these matters. His letters contain some things that are hard to understand, which ignorant and unstable people distort, as they do the other Scriptures, to their own destruction.
1 Peter 2:5 you also, like living stones, are being built into a spiritual house to be a holy priesthood, offering spiritual sacrifices acceptable to God through Jesus Christ.
Amen! This is known as the universal priesthood of believers.
Eph 4:11 It was he who gave some to be apostles, some to be prophets, some to be evangelists, and some to be pastors and teachers,

No mention of specific individuals appointed priest here…
Surely you would admit that SOME specific individuals were appointed apostles and prophets, wouldn’t you?

But if what you are arguing is true then why does Paul exhort Timothy and Titus with the following directions:

2 Timothy 2:1-2

You then, my son, be strong in the grace that is in Christ Jesus. And the things you have heard me say in the presence of many witnesses entrust to reliable men who will also be qualified to teach others.

There are five generations of believers contained in this one passage: 1. Those who came before Paul and instructed him, 2. Paul himself, 3. Timothy, who was Paul’s disciple, 4. Those whom Timothy would disciple, and 5. Those to whom Timothy’s disciples would preach.

Titus 1:5

The reason I left you in Crete was that you might straighten out what was left unfinished and appoint elders in every town, as I directed you.

Apostolic Succession is illustrated here as Paul had appointed Titus and left him in charge of appointing elders in the Cretan church.

Clearly, Paul was giving his own disciples specific instructions about “appointing” others.
Hebrews 4:14 Therefore, since we have a great high priest who has gone to heaven, Jesus the Son of God, let us live our lives consistent with our confession of faith.

The OT was a mere shadow of the better things to come. We no longer need a substitute. We have the perfect Jesus.
Amen! We have a great high priest in heaven. However, He specifically appoints others to care for His flock here on earth (cf. John 21:15-18).

But look: in the Old Testament we see a three-fold priesthood. There is the common or universal priesthood of all Israelites at the bottom (cf. Ex. 19:6), a ministerial priesthood above them (cf. Ex. 19:22, 24; Lev. 1:5), and a high priest at the top (cf. Num. 35: 25). We thus should expect to find a similar three-fold priesthood under the New Covenant, and we do. There is the common or universal priesthood of all Christians (cf. 1 Pet. 2:5, 9), a ministerial priesthood above them (cf. Rom. 15:16), and a high priest at the top (cf. Heb. 3:1). Rather than varying from the biblical model of priesthood, the Catholic understanding copies it exactly.

It is the two-fold model you cling to that departs from what we see in the Bible.
 
Jesus didn’t say he was lost or separated.
Luke 15:3-7
3Then Jesus told them this parable: 4"Suppose one of you has a hundred sheep and loses one of them. Does he not leave the ninety-nine in the open country and go after the lost sheep until he finds it? 5And when he finds it, he joyfully puts it on his shoulders 6and goes home. Then he calls his friends and neighbors together and says, ‘Rejoice with me; I have found my lost sheep.’ 7I tell you that in the same way there will be more rejoicing in heaven over one sinner who repents than over ninety-nine righteous persons who do not need to repent.

Notice that the person has 100 sheep that are his. One of them gets separated from the others. He goes in search of it.

It is possible to belong to Christ and still be separated from the ONE FLOCK (cf. Jn 10:16)
 
Not only do I accepted it, it makes perfect sense to me. But this is written clearly in Scriptures, compatible with other Scriptures, so it’s meaning is a given.
Your profile says that you are a Protestant; therefore, let me ask: do you agree that Jesus is fully present, body, blood, soul and divinity, in the Eucharist after the consecration?
You are making a judgment to things you cannot know. You do not know everything the Lord is doing nor with whom.
I’m sorry if I made an assumption. so let me ask: do you agree that the Bishop of Rome is the Vicar of Christ here on earth?
 
Your profile says that you are a Protestant; therefore, let me ask: do you agree that Jesus is fully present, body, blood, soul and divinity, in the Eucharist after the consecration?
Absolutely “yes”
I’m sorry if I made an assumption. so let me ask: do you agree that the Bishop of Rome is the Vicar of Christ here on earth?
Positively “no”

Merry Christmas!
 
First, Jesus wasn’t just a man. He was God incarnate.

Second, salvation is not dependent on perfect understanding of every single Scripture. However, contradicting Scriptures in forbidden.

Windgirl may correct me if I am wrong, but I believe we both agree, whatever God says is absolute truth and we accept it, even when we don’t fully understand. But we absolutely reject anything that contradicts what God has revealed to us in His Holy Scriptures, which are His inerrant Word to us.

What you claim contradicts Scripture.

We reject it because our allegiance lies with God - alone.
No need to correct you, you got it right. 👍
 
“We are CHURCH to the degree we accept Church teaching.” - Fr. John Corapi
Everyone who is saved by faith in Christ together make up the church. The church/believers should accept God’s teaching in His word. Not accepting Catholic teaching doesn’t equal not being in Christ’s church in my view. Let’s just say I don’t like at things from the perspective of Mr. Corapi. No offense.
 
No, “we” (meaning we Catholics and you, a non-Catholic) are NOT His Church for you are not in full communion with His Church. You are a Christian, but you are separated from the fullness of His Body.
I’m going to have to disagree with that. Jesus knows who all His true sheep are and that is the church. I have no need of communion with Rome, I’m in communion with Christ.
Here are three articles by three famous authors who are all converts to the Catholic faith. They once believed exactly as you do.

Did Jesus Give Priests to the Church?
By Kenneth J. Howell
catholic.com/thisrock/2004/0404sbs.asp

Why We Have a Ministerial Priesthood
By Tim Staples
catholic.com/thisrock/2005/0503fea4.asp

The Office of New Testament Priest
by James Akin
cin.org/users/james/files/ntpriest.htm
No, offense but I could go and find you just as many testimonies from those who have left the Catholic Church, including priests.
 
I’m going to have to disagree with that. Jesus knows who all His true sheep are and that is the church. I have no need of communion with Rome, I’m in communion with Christ.
Sounds just like the Corinthian church to me.1st Corinthians 1:11-12
No, offense but I could go and find you just as many testimonies from those who have left the Catholic Church, including priests.
So what, that’s no proof of a lack of truth, only a human failure. This is consistent with the life of the Church since its beginning in the New Testament.

As to the question of the thread:
In my opinion the passages are clear as in this case.

John 20:21-23 is so important.
“21 He said therefore to them again: Peace be to you. As the Father hath sent me, I also send you. 22 When he had said this, he breathed on them; and he said to them: Receive ye the Holy Ghost. 23 Whose sins you shall forgive, they are forgiven them; and whose sins you shall retain, they are retained.”

My thinking is that if our Lord had not intended to make the Sacrament of Reconciliation a means of grace unto salvation, then why in the world would He have made this statement and given both this power and command to the presbyters of His church?

James 5:16 & 1st John 1:9 also offer us more insight into this doctrine.

James 5: 14 Is any man sick among you? Let him bring in the priests of the church, and let them pray over him, anointing him with oil in the name of the Lord. 15 And the prayer of faith shall save the sick man: and the Lord shall raise him up: and if he be in sins, they shall be forgiven him. 16 Confess therefore your sins one to another: and pray one for another, that you may be saved. For the continual prayer of a just man availeth much.

1st John 1:9 If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just, to forgive us our sins, and to cleanse us from all iniquity.

All these passages expressly speak of confession of sins and so I have to ask, then just how will those outside the Catholic Church explain the obvious link between these passages.

Here is a further outline for study on this sacrament courtesy of John Martignoni and his Bible Christian Society
Confession
A. Confess your sins to men
~ Leviticus 5:5-6 (“All scripture…”: 2 Tim 3:16)
(Law is a shadow: Hebrews 10:1)
~ 1 John 1:9
~ James 5:16
B. Can men forgive sins?
~ Only God has the power to forgive sins but He exercises this power through men.
~ Mark 2:7
~ Matthew 9:1-8
When the crowds saw it, they were afraid , and the glorified God, who had given such authority to men.
  • Matthew 9:8
To me, the scriptures are clear, and I can’t help but praise and thank God for His wisdom and mercy that (knowing the weaknesses of mankind) equipped His church with the means to help His children overcome our weaknesses and sins.

Here’s 100 references or so where the Bible speaks of sackcloth,
most of them are in direct relation to penance, which is a demonstration of sorrow for sin. A physical way in which people have shown their contrition for sin.

Being penitent and penance are inexorably linked in both the Old and New Testaments of the Bible. This is also what was meant when the people in the Gospels were told to bring forth fruit worthy of repentance. Penitence is the like a second step that follows repentance, and penance is a scriptural aspect of that.
 
I’m going to have to disagree with that. Jesus knows who all His true sheep are and that is the church. I have no need of communion with Rome, I’m in communion with Christ.
If you want to be in full communion with Christ, then you must be in full communion with the one true Church that He Himself established. The only Church founded by Jesus personally is the Catholic Church…almost all the rest were founded by (Protestant) men who hived off from the Church during the last few centuries.

Now, about this “church” that you claim to belong to…let me ask you a couple of questions if I may.

Infant baptism: Is it permissable for Christians or not? Baptists say “no”; Methodists say “yes”. What is your opinion, and what scripture verses specifically support your position?

How is it that two different groups within the body of Christ hold conflicting and contradictory views of such an important doctrine? Is doctrine important within the one body of Christ or are contradictory and conflicting doctrines acceptable?

Further, aren’t the Baptists and the Methodists both led by the Holy Spirit? Don’t both groups study to shew themselves approved workmen?

Again, which of these two camps are you in communion with? And is the other group in communion with you if they disagree with you?
No, offense but I could go and find you just as many testimonies from those who have left the Catholic Church, including priests.
It’s really not a numbers game; but feel free to find as many testimonies as you like. The question is not really how many (since Catholics outnumber all Protestants combined it’s no wonder that there are lots of ex-Catholics you can quote), but the quality of the converts. You see, if an ex-priest or a former nun has something to say against the Church that he or she has left, I take it with a grain of salt because I know that most of them left over some moral issue - celibacy usually. Okay. No problem from my perspective. They left because they would not or could not be obedient…they abandon the true Church in order to gain “personal freedom” or what have you. In the end, it is moral failure more times than not.

However, the disturbing trend of late is that many of the best and brightest of the Evangelical world seem to be crossing the Tiber.

The question is: what do these pastors and scholars have to gain from “poping”? Many of them lose their jobs (as pastors), their friends and family, and their standing in the community or the academic world, etc. Why do they do it?

Because they know that they must be obedient to Him.

And so must you.
 
The church is all Christians, not just an elite few.
All who are in Christ are part of the Church, that is not all that the Church is. For example, when Scripture says “if he still disagrees, take it to the Church” what does that mean? When 1Tim says “so that you shall know how to behave in the Church of the living God which is pillar and foundation of truth” what does that mean? Clearly there is more than “we are the Church”
No, it’s not a recent invention that I can confess my sins directly to God. 1 John 1: 9.
This passage does not address whether sins are confessed to God or a priest - it merely tells us that God will forgive us when we confess.
The veil in the temple guarding the holy of holies has been rent from top to bottom. .
And that is relevant because…?
By the way, what gives you authority to decide which parts of Scripture are aimed at whom?
The same authority you have…none! But what does the Scripture SAY
 
Oh wow. God rent the veil in the temple guarding the way into the holy of holies at the moment of Christ’s death and that has no relevance? Okay. 🤷
 
I’m going to have to disagree with that. Jesus knows who all His true sheep are and that is the church. I have no need of communion with Rome, I’m in communion with Christ.
The Necessity of Being Catholic (Condensed)
by James Akin
chnetwork.org/journals/nesschurch/ness_7.htm
  1. To be saved it is necessary to be a Christian.
  2. To be a Christian it is necessary to be a member of Christ’s Church.
  3. To be a member of Christ’s Church it is necessary to be a member of the Catholic Church.
  4. To be a member of the Catholic Church it is necessary to be subject to the Roman Pontiff.
  5. Therefore, it is necessary for salvation to be subject to the Roman Pontiff.
In this argument, the necessities are all normative necessities and the kind of membership being discussed is formal membership. The argument has a logically valid form (in fact, it expresses a variation on what is known as the “hypothetical syllogism” argument form), meaning that the truth of its conclusion depends only on the truth of the premises it contains.

When a Protestant objects to the above argument, it will be to the third proposition – that the Catholic Church is the Church Christ founded. Both sides agree on the other three points. While it is beyond the scope of this article to give a full proof of the third proposition (this is one of the major tasks of Catholic apologetics), we can offer a limited proof.

Both Protestants and Catholics agree that Christ founded some Church and that this Church will remain forever (Matt. 16:18). The question is whether this Church is a visible communion that can be identified or whether is it a purely spiritual communion made up of all the saved. If it is a visible communion, the Catholic Church is the only plausible candidate, since only this Church extends back far enough (the Eastern Orthodox communion did not finally break with Rome until the 1450s, a mere sixty years before the Protestant Reformation). We can thus give a limited argument for the third proposition by showing the Church Christ founded is a visible communion.

This is proven in Matthew 16:17-19, the passage in which Christ promised the gates of hell would never prevail against his Church (meaning that it would always exist). Several factors in the text show he was talking about a visible communion.

First, Jesus made Peter head of this Church (Matt. 16:18), yet Jesus was certainly not making Peter the head of an invisible Church. It is Christ’s own prerogative to be head of the invisible communion of Christians stretching from heaven to earth (Eph. 5:23). Therefore, he must have made Peter the head of a visible, earthly church. (We will not argue here that Jesus made Peter the head; even if one disagrees, the remaining arguments prove our case.)

Second, Jesus gave Peter the keys to the kingdom of heaven (Matt. 16:19), which are for use in Church government (compare Isa. 22:22 – the only Old Testament parallel to this verse). But one cannot govern an invisible communion of believers, only a visible one.

Third, Jesus gave Peter the power of binding and loosing (Matt. 16:19), which Matthew 18:17-18 indicates is used in Church discipline. But one cannot exercise Church discipline over an invisible body. Indeed, Matt. 18:17-18 refers it to public excommunication, in which an individual is treated by the church as “a gentile or a tax collector” (that is, as an unbeliever).

Fourth, Jesus explicitly stated that Peter would exercise the power of binding and loosing on earth. This shows his authority is an earthly one, over an earthly Church.

Fifth, Jesus promised the gates of hell would not prevail against his Church (Matt. 16:18), meaning that it would never perish. But it would be ridiculous to promise that an invisible Church would not pass out of existence since some of the Church’s members are in heaven and Christ’s heavenly Church cannot pass away by its very nature. Only a visible, earthly communion needs a promise that it will never perish.

There are thus abundant reasons to conclude that the Church Jesus was discussing in Matthew 16:17-19 was a visible communion of believers, and, since only the Catholic Church goes back that far, only it can be the one Christ founded.
 
According to your little formula, then, Protestant Christians are not saved. So, therefore, why do Catholics keep calling us “separated brethren” and saying things like "we’re part of the church but not in full communion with “the church?” Why don’t you just tell us that unless we submit to the Roman Pope and become Catholic, we’re all going to hell? That would be honest.
 
40.png
WindGirl:
I’m sorry, I just do not believe my salvation and forgiveness is tied to confessing to Catholic priests.
This is fine - I dont believe anyone claimed it was, actually. If you believe you are where God wants you and you are following his will then I do not condemn you. Honest.
OTOH, please dont pretend that the Bible is even remotely clear about:
  • whether we are to confess sins
  • who we are to confess them to
  • how we are to confess them and
  • what the consequences are for failing to do so.
It simply aint clear at all in Scripture. It is an assumption on your part that it was meant to be clear from Scripture alone. So if God is calling you to do what youve been doing - great. Im just not sure why you would be here attempting to defend a position that is so weak by apologetic standards. I find it odd that it would be Gods will to direct you here to deliver a message that you are so ill-prepared to deliver (after 30 years of preparation) and thereby open so many doors to rejecting the message. That, of course, is just my opinion. I wish you well.
 
This is fine - If you believe you are where God wants you and you are following his will then I do not condemn you. Honest.
OTOH, please dont pretend that the Bible is even remotely clear about:
  • whether we are to confess sins
  • who we are to confess them to
  • how we are to confess them and
  • what the consequences are for failing to do so.
It simply aint clear at all in Scripture. It is an assumption on your part that it was meant to be clear from Scripture alone. So if God is calling you to do what youve been doing - great. Im just not sure why you would be here attempting to defend a position that is so weak by apologetic standards. I find it odd that it would be Gods will to direct you here to deliver a message that you are so ill-prepared to deliver and thereby open so many doors to rejecting the message. That, of course, is just my opinion, and I wish you well.
Thanks for your non confrontational and polite spirit. I really don’t know why I’m here for sure. I need to get back to spending more time at the Christian board I usually go to. I wish you well also.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top