Taylor Marshall's Twitter feed has disappeared

[TheBomb.Com]

It doesn’t necessarily cause heresy, but it can be a factor in fostering disbelief in the Eucharist. Before it was allowed, people were forbidden from touching the Eucharist at all. It began as a liturgical abuse, but it became so widespread, that it was allowed.

 

[aroosi]

It really depends from what is your heart disposition. I had Communion on the tongue and on the hands. When I receive it on the hands I imagine they are a cradle for Baby Jesus.

 

[TheBomb.Com]

Thank you for melting my heart

 

[Crusader13]

I realize that. However, go back and read the numerous articles regarding women serving at the altar. Pope JP2, said the same thing regarding that issue and three years later that was changed.

I’m not comforted by the words of Pope Francis. Especially lately with how he’s been handling this synod and the idols.

 

[MagdalenaRita]

Why you don’t believe the Pope but listen instead to people (like Marshall and Voris) that are making of ‘conspiracy theories’ and Church scandals …?

Can we listen to him? Msgr. Charles Pope? Or is he a conspiracy theoriest also?

http://m.ncregister.com/blog/msgr-pope/pray

How about Bishop Strickland? Can we listen to him?


Bishop J. Strickland
@Bishopoftyler

Please ask St John Paul II to intercede for the Church he loved & served so well. His personal experience of the evils of communism and socialism offers a lesson the world & the Church need to heed today. These ideologies are incompatible with the Church.

 

[Crusader13]

The problem instead seems to be that you haven’t responded to posts 229 and 234:

I thought I had. My response was that I can’t speak for Dr. Marshall but can only speculate based upon what I’ve heard him say in his shows and articles.

To me it sounds like he’s equating women altar servers with the heretical revolution that has been taking place, probably since before VII.

Meaning that these changes are all linked in some way, to radically change the Church and her teachings. With regards to the female altar servers, it’s not mandatory that a Church must include them, but I’ve been to a very progressive Church on several occasions which goes out of its way to emphasize the role of women serving at mass.

I took notice several times that all the readers were women, the EMs were probably 90’s women and one Mother’s Day the father actually yielded his homily time to allow a female employee to give a talk during Mass.

So I can definitely understand what he’s trying to say. There are some Churches that are going to push the limits and break them on occasion, to support what they desire to see happen on a larger scale.

 

[aroosi]

I will certainly pray for Saint John Paul II intercession, he was also falsely accused of heresy and idolatry in at least two separated occasions (Assisi meeting for Peace 1986/buddah statue controversy; kissing of the Kuran in Vatican City1999) and he can surely understand the anguish of Pope Francis.

 

[Crusader13]

I will certainly pray for Saint John Paul II intercession, he was also falsely accused of heresy and idolatry in at least two separated occasions (Assisi meeting for Peace 1986/buddah statue controversy; kissing of the Kuran in Vatican City1999) and he can surely understand the anguish of Pope Francis.

Yeah… His actions aren’t the best example to use when trying to defend the placing of those idols in our churches.

 

[Aquinas11]

Wow, so a video in a blog discussing a woman nursing a child is “strange”

But a photo in a Church showing a woman nursing a piglet is not.

We live in interesting times.

 

[MagdalenaRita]

I will certainly pray for Saint John Paul II intercession, he was also falsely accused of heresy and idolatry in at least two separated occasions

Saint John Paul II is one of my favorite popes and I think there is clearly a difference between him and Pope Francis. (and I don’t dislike Pope Francis) but

Saint John Paul II was pretty much very clear about Church teaching. There wasn’t a lot of ambiquity as far as wondering where he stood and he didn’t have all the social media Pope Francis has today to clearly get the gospel message out.

Point is, we better be praying for our Pope!! that he stands firm in the gospel message to the world. This really is a crucial moment.

 

[goout]

esieffe:

I have to wonder if anyone else is getting burnt out about all of this.

Yes I am…

That’s because the forum can be an echo chamber of confirmation bias.
Go out on the street, nobody has heard of this guy, and no one cares what he thinks about female altar servers. Nothing against him personally, it’s just that literally, no one cares what he thinks.

You’d be better off going to solid Catholic sources that are part of the continuous apostolic tradition instead of incendiary stuff from the fringes.

 

[aroosi]

You’d be better off going to solid Catholic sources that are part of the continuous apostolic tradition instead of incendiary stuff from the fringes.

^^^ THIS!!!

 

[MagdalenaRita]

Go out on the street, nobody has heard of this guy, and no one cares what he thinks about female altar servers.

I’m not sure if I would agree with that. A poll recently showed that most people get their information today from the internet and youtube, so most people on the street are plugged in. He h as a very good online Catholic college institute with excellent Catholic apologetics that you can earn certificates and another website Taylor Marshall .com with again very good Catholic answers to biblical questions, so apparently people have heard of him. He has had very good priests as guests on his youtube channel.

Nothing against him personally, it’s just that literally, no one cares what he thinks

That is a pretty blanket stsatement to take literally about everyone’s thoughts. It is apparently not true or this thread would not be here.

 

[goout]

goout:

Go out on the street, nobody has heard of this guy, and no one cares what he thinks about female altar servers.

I’m not sure if I would agree with that. A poll recently showed that most people get their information today from the internet and youtube, so most people on the street are plugged in. He h as a very good online Catholic college institute with excellent Catholic teaching and another website Taylor Marshall .com with again very good Catholic answers to biblical questions, so apparently people have heard of him. He has had very good priests as guests on his youtube channel.

Nothing against him personally, it’s just that literally, no one cares what he thinks

That is a pretty blanket stsatement to take literally about everyone’s thoughts. It is apparently not true or this thread would not be here.

ECHO echo echo echo…
In our parish, literally (in the most rigid sense of the word literally) no-one talks about this fellow and literally no-one is concerned about female altar servers.

If you spend to much time at the bar, you probly end up drinkin too much.
Go out into the light.

 

[aroosi]

Now every person waking up in the morning can get his/her ideas (even the craziest ones) out to the entire world through social media. I can easily imagine how could have been easily smeared and falsely accused even Saint John Paul II if he would be living nowadays. Imagine something like…he kissed the Koran… he is supporting ISIS secretly etc etc He met all religious leaders in Assisi, he is trying to undermine the Church teachings about Salvation coming from Christ… etc etc

 

[Aquinas11]

You’d be better off going to solid Catholic sources that are part of the continuous apostolic tradition instead of incendiary stuff from the fringes.

The thread as started based on a conspiracy theory that he deleted his tweets because he was behind the removal of the idols, so there is plenty of dissent to his views in the thread

You’d be better off going to solid Catholic sources that are part of the continuous apostolic tradition instead of incendiary stuff from the fringes.

but now that is advice, is it not? I thought we were only to trust “solid Catholic sources” , circular argument

 

[Gab123]

Wow, so a video in a blog discussing a woman nursing a child is “strange”

But a photo in a Church showing a woman nursing a piglet is not.

We live in interesting times.

What is strange is that he seems to be moving toward becoming unhinged and obsessed. Waking up in the wee hours of the night to be the “breaking news” of Pachamama and presenting false narratives which are nothing more than slanderous against the pope, while developing what seems like an emotional obsession. It reminds me of ultra-Catholic faithful Martin Luther in the 16th century,mwho went to Rome and was disillusioned with all the scandals and abuses, only to become an instrument of the devil.

Taylor’s self-reported vision is sounding like he’s starting to see himself as the beacon of light to guide for the online Church, now that he apparently has tens of thousands of YouTube followers participating in a global game of Chinese telephone.

As far as the native woman in the photo nourishing her baby and her pet, apparently that’s what some natives do. But get your facts straight, it was a weasel, not a piglet.

 

[MagdalenaRita]

Now every person waking up in the morning can get his/her ideas (even the craziest ones) out to the entire world through social media

I’m just saying that there is a lot of ways we have today to speak out firmly the Traditions handed to the Church from the Apostles, so that there is no ambiguity. Personally, though I dont think a lot of the hierarchy in the Church realize the powerful influence of social media today, just based on their age.

 

[MagdalenaRita]

It reminds me of ultra-Catholic faithful Martin Luther

So we need to stop accusing everyone who disagrees with the Pope as being another Martin Luther. Happens frequently here at CAF, and is just meant to be an insult. We are allowed to disagree with the Pope on things that are not infallible teaching.

Waking up in the wee hours of the night to be the “breaking news

Isnt that what most reporters do?

 

[goout]

goout:

You’d be better off going to solid Catholic sources that are part of the continuous apostolic tradition instead of incendiary stuff from the fringes.

The thread as started based on a conspiracy theory that he deleted his tweets because he was behind the removal of the idols, so there is plenty of dissent to his views in the thread

You’d be better off going to solid Catholic sources that are part of the continuous apostolic tradition instead of incendiary stuff from the fringes.

but now that is advice, is it not? I thought we were only to trust “solid Catholic sources” , circular argument

It’s not a circular argument. Follow me:
There are so many good orthodox Catholic sources. For instance
Word on Fire,
Augustine Institute which does Formed
Theology of the Body Institute
USCCB has educational materials
The list of orthodox Catholic catechesis is almost endless. You don’t need to listen to complainers with limited vision.

How is the point circular?