The Eternal [Mormon] Temple in the Eternal City [of Rome]

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ahimsa
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The Mormon Temple is very beautiful. Personally, I think St. Peter’s Basillica still wins hands down. However, St. Peter’s is just one Church. The Roman Catholic Church has a description as well, and that puts both the Mormon Temples and our Basillicas to shame:

“A woman clothed with the sun, with the moon under her feet, and upon her head a crown of twelve stars.”

Even if Michelangelo, Bramante, and the Mormons all worked together, they will never build a Church as beautiful as ours.

Long live the Pope, Long Live the Catholic Church!
 
The Mormon Temple is very beautiful. Personally, I think St. Peter’s Basillica still wins hands down. However, St. Peter’s is just one Church. The Roman Catholic Church has a description as well, and that puts both the Mormon Temples and our Basillicas to shame:

“A woman clothed with the sun, with the moon under her feet, and upon her head a crown of twelve stars.”

Even if Michelangelo, Bramante, and the Mormons all worked together, they will never build a Church as beautiful as ours.

Long live the Pope, Long Live the Catholic Church!
You should see some of those beautiful churches. One of my favorite in Rome was Santa Maria degli Angeli e dei Martiri:

(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)





Simply stupendous.
 
You should see some of those beautiful churches. One of my favorite in Rome was Santa Maria degli Angeli e dei Martiri:

http://www.vignaclarablog.it/wp-content/uploads/2009/04/foto-2-la-basilica.jpg

http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3028/2695766135_9587562831.jpg

http://static.flickr.com/117/254859483_12e184a7bd_o.jpg

Simply stupendous.
God has humbled the House of Caesar. The Circus of Nero is gone, the Colloseum in ruins, the Palaces of the Emperors destroyed, and the once worshipped gods of the Romans are now mere tourist attractions.

The Almighty has supplanted the Caesars, and in their place his Church has built truly magnificent temples of the Lord.
 
Conor,

I accept your apology.

I was like you, very open to the Mormons…I became friends with a Mormon doctor I assisted…he liked me and wanted me to do my internship with him. He asked where my kids went to school, and when he found out, a dark pale crossed over him. I found out later on he was Mormon…We ended up liking each other very much. One day I kidded him and said, may be the reason why he likes me is that I am a Catholic…he just about gagged but really laughed. Some how, I think he changed.

I met some more of his friends. I initiated a dialogue with them as I never knew any Mormons in my entire life, and I am pretty old. I found baselines to share with them, and they were surprised we shared some of the same concerns, values and interpretations. All good. But then they moved away to Utah.

So I wanted to learn more about Mormonism with an open and positive heart. When I came into their bookstore, and found some books on their teachings, I was shocked at their position and stand, and that the great Roman Church was the abomination, its teachings corrupt, and so on. I called the LDS in SLC about this kind of material, and the store is located next to a highly affluent neighborhood. They knew nothing. When I went back to again see the title, the book was pulled. It was one going back to the 1850’s. It was considered a classic.

I went online and did my own search. I read about the old Mormon ritual of denouncing the Catholic Church for the men, the treatment of women and how they had the highest use of Prozac in the country…and that stood out in my mind because the doctor I worked with said they should just give housewives Prozac. I found their theology of becoming gods coupled with their justification in rejecting the Catholic Church very false, along with the day to day practices that became more and more questionable, even harmful. Joseph Smith was not a polygamist, no–this group surrounding him never did say they witnessed his work as a fraud and so on. A poster here put out links revealing many ideas and practices on Mormonism, and going back to check on them, saw them pulled.

It is a cover up, it is deceptive.

So I find it disconcerting that, although I have already stated to people here not to worry about Mormon baptisms for the deceased, etc., it is disturbing having seen their materials and their judgment against the Roman Church to now set itself up next to it in its own ball park, and to go about its back, and its natives back to do rituals on their people without their knowledge or permission…I mean, this is all so indicative its own constructs.

People, especially women from what I am reading on Ex Mormon.org are rushed into baptism, no questions asked, and then begin to find out this religion has ideas very contrary to Christianity. Switch and bait. And women going to the eternal kingdom to perpetually bear spirit children.

And the integrity of family life. I just shared on another post my perception of Protestantism growing up…it was this oppositional spirit and divorce. The whole thing a spirit of divorce. This leads to warped understanding of faith, scripture, and Christian unity, as well as the breakdown of family. This is the Jewish Catholic perception, yes I am an associate with them, that Protestantism led to the breakdown of family, then that led to the Enlightenment with Descartes,…I think, therefore I am…the beginning of relativism.

I shared with the Mormons here a piece on St. Justin the Martyr who was requested by the Emperor of Rome around 150 AD to explain what happened at Mass. He spoke of the Mass of Baptism, and then he wrote another piece on how Mass is said in Rome and the Roman countryside. The basic elements of the Mass, the spirit and tone were the same as is said today. And this is how Mass was generally said in Christiandom at that time. I brought up the ancient catacombs and the signs of faith that would lay down their lives for Christ. And yet it all meant nothing…we have documentation, and that is why the Vatican has the greatest library in the world.

So there is a long, long culture of Catholic faith in Rome, the people there as everywhere else have a checkered past, but there is authentic faith there. And the Italians…they are known for such care for their families. You read on Ex Mormon and others who testify here about knowing a mother and the family not being allowed to see the sealing ceremony of their grown child. That is profoundly hurtful. I know of no culture that will split up a family like that.

So no, I am not a relativist. And I am piqued that the Mormons are all rejoicing now that they are getting their temple up near the great Roman church of which they so soundly label as corrupt. They said on BYU they hope the world will hold their temple in awe just like the Vatican and the Eternal City.

As I said before, no human hands can create anything to please God, only humble and contrite hearts in need of our Savior Jesus Christ. All the human hands that worked to build Vatican City were working for the honor and praise of Almighty God.

So I see the writings and doings and rituals of what Mormon leaders have done and convinced their followers of my people and my faith, and it isn’t a big win really. But there is a blindness and lack of sensitivity, and not owning up to the Mormons’ past stand against the Church, and really, the Italian people need to really really know what that temple will be used for. Fair disclosure. Then it is up to them.
 
Very very big difference indeed.

(and I say that as a former Mormon who has done baptisms for the dead)
Sure, there are differences, but the similarity is that both involve a person of religion A, doing something such that a person of religion B, will be induced to join religion A.
 
Thank you for the beautiful photos! I stayed in a hostel across the street from the Vatican, walked across the top where all the large statues are…it was like I could hear faint rejoicing of the angels who do indeed surround our church.

The Vatican Library was covered by the New Yorker, I believe Jan. 3, and it is most interesting all that the library holds. I wish I had gone there. The priests who were going into the missions with me took me to Assisi, and we went into a little church that was one of those built by St. Francis himself…not used as a church anymore and most plain and simple, as he then realized building the Church was building believers in Christ.

They took me to northern Italy where we visited Don Bosco’s old church, actually a number of churches, so incredible. Italy is also the land of so many saints. My friend lives in Puglia and he has a number of pictures of churches in his area, and he also has done some renovation in those.

A lady told me there that Italy is a garden. I have a large book on this country, and there is so much history, so much architectural beauty, and a beautiful way of living…find something to celebrate with your loved ones every day…
 
Thank you for the beautiful photos! I stayed in a hostel across the street from the Vatican, walked across the top where all the large statues are…it was like I could hear faint rejoicing of the angels who do indeed surround our church.

The Vatican Library was covered by the New Yorker, I believe Jan. 3, and it is most interesting all that the library holds. I wish I had gone there. The priests who were going into the missions with me took me to Assisi, and we went into a little church that was one of those built by St. Francis himself…not used as a church anymore and most plain and simple, as he then realized building the Church was building believers in Christ.

They took me to northern Italy where we visited Don Bosco’s old church, actually a number of churches, so incredible. Italy is also the land of so many saints. My friend lives in Puglia and he has a number of pictures of churches in his area, and he also has done some renovation in those.

A lady told me there that Italy is a garden. I have a large book on this country, and there is so much history, so much architectural beauty, and a beautiful way of living…find something to celebrate with your loved ones every day…
I hope that if you ever go back to visit, you will take the chance to explore Rome for yourself. Rome literally has a church on every street corner. Each one absolutely beautiful. I think it’s kind of a shame that most tourists are lost to see just the classic Christian sites - the Vatican, the Catatombs - which are stunning, of course. But there are so many other churches that people do not see everyday that are breathtaking. When I took a year there to study, I’d put on my earphones and start exploring and I would discover so much.
 
I hope that if you ever go back to visit, you will take the chance to explore Rome for yourself. Rome literally has a church on every street corner. Each one absolutely beautiful. I think it’s kind of a shame that most tourists are lost to see just the classic Christian sites - the Vatican, the Catatombs - which are stunning, of course. But there are so many other churches that people do not see everyday that are breathtaking. When I took a year there to study, I’d put on my earphones and start exploring and I would discover so much.
I’ve been to Rome twice; wish I had more time to see more of the beauty of the Christian Churches there.
 
So there is no similarity between praying for the dead and baptizing the dead?
Perhaps; but my point was simply that praying for other people (which is something Christians do, often without permission) is done with the hope of leading people to voluntarily engage in a particular religious practice. In that sense, praying for other people is similar to the Mormon practice baptizing the dead.
 
Perhaps; but my point was simply that praying for other people (which is something Christians do, often without permission) is done with the hope of leading people to voluntarily engage in a particular religious practice. In that sense, praying for other people is similar to the Mormon practice baptizing the dead.
But the proposed comparison was between praying for the dead and baptizing the dead. So without an example, I’ll take your ‘perhaps’ as a ‘no, there are no similarities between them’.
 
But the proposed comparison was between praying for the dead and baptizing the dead. So without an example, I’ll take your ‘perhaps’ as a ‘no, there are no similarities between them’.
I misunderstood what you said. Let me rephrase the statement:

Yes; there is a similarity. Praying for other people (which is something Christians do, often without permission) is done with the hope of leading people to voluntarily engage in a particular religious practice. In that sense, praying for other people is similar to the Mormon practice baptizing the dead.
 
I misunderstood what you said. Let me rephrase the statement:

Yes; there is a similarity.* Praying for other people*** (which is something Christians do, often without permission) is done with the hope of leading people to voluntarily engage in a particular religious practice. In that sense, praying for other people is similar to the Mormon practice baptizing the dead.
But the proposed comparison was between praying for the dead and baptizing the dead. Your example fails, so you are still left with ‘no, there are no similarities between them’.
 
But the proposed comparison was between praying for the dead and baptizing the dead. Your example fails, so you are still left with ‘no, there are no similarities between them’.
Most Christians (non-Mormons) pray that other people, often non-Christian, become Christian.

Mormons engage in proxy post-death baptism, in which a living person is baptized in place of the deceased (say, non-Christian) person.

In both instances, we have Christians engaging in ritual practices designed to induce a non-Christian to become Christian.

Praying for the dead, in Catholicism, would not be a good comparision, because in Catholicism, the only people who can be effectively prayed to, are those who are already headed for heaven. And one’s ultimate fate, in Catholicism, in decided at one’s death.

However, in the Orthodox Church, prayer for the dead is efficacious for all the dead, since in Orthodoxy, one’s ultimate fate is not set until at the Last Judgement, which hasn’t happened yet, and may not happen for hundreds, millions, or billions of years.

So, if we do compare praying for the dead and Mormon post-death baptism, then the comparison should be between Orthodox (and maybe Eastern Catholic) praying for the dead and Mormon post-death baptism.
 
JUst curious, do you feel an lds baptism for the dead is any more harmful or intrusive than a Christian Mass for the dead?
My comment goes back to this comment.

Yes, there is a difference, a very big one, between praying for someone who has died and having a proxy baptism done by a different faith.

Baptism is seen by most Christian faiths as a rite/sacrament of initiation into that faith.
Prayer is not a rite.
 
Baptism is seen by most Christian faiths as a rite/sacrament of initiation into that faith.
The Mormon post-death baptism is different from Catholic baptism. Catholic baptism automatically makes a mark on the soul. Mormon post-death baptism only initiates person into the faith, if the person freely, with his/her free-will, accepts the offer that the post-death baptism provides.

(That’s assuming, of course, that the Mormon post-death baptism actually does what Mormos believe it does.)
 
The Mormon post-death baptism is different from Catholic baptism. Catholic baptism automatically makes a mark on the soul. Mormon post-death baptism only initiates person into the faith, if the person freely, with his/her free-will, accepts the offer that the post-death baptism provides.

(That’s assuming, of course, that the Mormon post-death baptism actually does what Mormos believe it does.)
You are comparing Mormon proxy baptism to Catholic baptism
I am comparing Mormon proxy baptism to Christian funeral Mass.

Christian funeral Mass is praying for the one deceased. It’s not any type of initiation rite in to the faith.

That was the question Tony888 was asking and was what my comment was going back to.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top