The Eucharist; superstition?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Zundrah
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes that is right, but her/his belief is not the same as my belief. So which is true, or is this realtive?
Your opinions and comments are relative. The catholic church does not claim Zundrah worships any other God than the very one you do.

Take it up with your church, but don’t say/imply her God is not your God.

You have zero basis to make such a statement.

You both worship the same God.
 
And you figured this out how? He said take, eat this IS my body, this IS my blood. Is= to be. 0 symbolism/metaphors, what have you. And the diciples DID take and DID eat Christ’s BODY and BLOOD.

Now I HIGHLY recommend you watch at least the first link I posted. It covers exactly what we are talking about now.
…
And you figured this out how?
By going to church and reading the bible, and not believing superstition.
 
The Real Presence in the Eucharist is a real key to deciding which branch of Christianity is right, and which is wrong. If the Real Presence is a false belief, then you must immediately rule out the Catholic and Orthodox Churches, and possibly the Anglican, Episcopalian, and Lutheran denominations as well. If however, we can prove to you that belief in the Eucharist is correct, then the only Protestant denominations that even have a hope of being true are the ones I just mentioned, the Anglicans, Episcopalians, and Lutherans.
I will stay in the catholic church, thanks.
 
:rolleyes:

The eastern rites of the catholic church are just as catholic as you are in the latin rite.
The bishop of Rome approves many things, but in this instance he can not even stop this practice if he wanted to.
Nor was there ever a need for the east to have “approval” from the bishop of Rome to preform the Mass in this manner. Unless, I am mistaken and you can provide some help to me on this.

It was never even “on the table” as far as I know.
They were probably laying down on the floor at the last supper.
 
The way I look at it, Jesus was a faithful Jew. So, he would have been using unleveaned bread. However, the eastern rites use leavened bread I think. I also believe some even use this method called intiction ? Where the priest dips the bread into the wine and then drops it gently from a spoon into the mouth of the person partaking. I think this is to re-inforce his risen nature?

Can someone help out here that knows about the eastern rite?

I am sure I don’t have a good grasp of it yet. So, I don’t want to confuse you about something so serious.

Zundra, you will get the answers you are looking for, because you believe.
The truth be told; I have read about a million different writings about the eucharist…

Only christ can give me faith and living water, not a wafer and some wine…
You are looking only at the wafer and wine. God can create miracles, no? The transubstantiation of the wafer and wine into the body and blood of Christ is one of His miracles. It is also a tenet of Fatih which no one can “give” you, but God Himself.

The Eucharist is the most holy, important Sacrament of the Catholic Church. This is the most important one through which those who believe, receive the Grace promised by Christ. Grace is a gift, the Sacraments of Baptism, Confirmation, Holy Eucharist, Matrimony, Holy Orders, Reconciliation, Sacrament of the Sick (once given only on one’s deathbed) are the means through which God/Christ gives Grace.

By denying that the Holy Eucharist is the body and blood of Christ, a Sacrament, the ultimate Sacrifice, which can only be performed by an ordained Catholic priest, we refuse the Gifts of God’s Grace. To believe that the wafer and wine do become the body and blood of Chirst, is Faith. No one can “prove” it to you.
 
I will stay in the catholic church, thanks.
Rolltide is a pretty good guy Zundrah. IMHO.

He sticks to the facts, and he can be brutally honest about things many catholics don’t discuss much.

Take care and be at peace
 
Good times!
Because he was sacrificed for the sins of the whole world rather than just for one person or just for one sin.
Correct!
By killing a lamb or goat ect…
Correct again!

Now, are you aware that in order for the ritual to be properly instituted, the lamb had to be consumed afterward?

Jesus said, “I come not to destroy the Law, but to FULFILL it”.

So… if the lamb had to be consumed, and Jesus was there to fulfill the law… does that bring any further meaning to the Last Supper?
No, it is just critical to believe in catholic eucharist which once again has come about by twisting scripture such as “the body and blood of Christ”; just to keep high numbers in the catholic church because they believe that it is sin to miss the eucharist.
Two more questions:
  1. What did the first and second generations of Christians believe?
  2. Are you aware that this is NOT just a Catholic belief, but also the belief of 500 million Orthodox, plus Lutherans, and some Anglicans and Episcopalians from the Protestant denominations. It is NOT just a Catholic belief. In fact, the vast majority of Christians hold to this view.
 
You are looking only at the wafer and wine. God can create miracles, no? The transubstantiation of the wafer and wine into the body and blood of Christ is one of His miracles. It is also a tenet of Fatih which no one can “give” you, but God Himself.

The Eucharist is the most holy, important Sacrament of the Catholic Church. This is the most important one through which those who believe, receive the Grace promised by Christ. Grace is a gift, the Sacraments of Baptism, Confirmation, Holy Eucharist, Matrimony, Holy Orders, Reconciliation, Sacrament of the Sick (once given only on one’s deathbed) are the means through which God/Christ gives Grace.

By denying that the Holy Eucharist is the body and blood of Christ, a Sacrament, the ultimate Sacrifice, which can only be performed by an ordained Catholic priest, we refuse the Gifts of God’s Grace. This is Faith. No one can “prove” it to you.
It was a metaphore, but no one can prove that either!
 
Rolltide is a pretty good guy Zundrah. IMHO.

He sticks to the facts, and he can be brutally honest about things many catholics don’t discuss much.

Take care and be at peace
Thanks for the nice compliment, StrawberryJam 🙂 You’re an asset to the thread as always!
 
Rolltide is a pretty good guy Zundrah. IMHO.

He sticks to the facts, and he can be brutally honest about things many catholics don’t discuss much.

Take care and be at peace
Okay strawberry jam, I am not picking an argumant with him, if you say that he is nice then I will believe you. 😃
 
Which is true? Well let’s start here; protestants split from the catholic church because they didn’t trust it any more…
Protestants split from the Catholic (capital C) Church not because the didn’t trust the Church, but because they no longer trusted God and took a religion thousands of years old and made it into something they thought they could live with. Are they happy yet?
 
It was a metaphore, but no one can prove that either!
So… we say the passage is literal.
You say it’s a metaphore.
No one’s opinion alive today can confirm this.

But… there are LOTS of historical documents from early Christians (and even the pagan ROMANS) on the matter. Many of them even date to the time of the Apostles, some written by people personally taught by John, Paul, and Peter. Would it not be logical to assume that these documents would be helpful in making a case for one side or the other?
 
Rolltide;5542208]Correct!
Of course! :cool:
Correct again!
Obviously!
Now, are you aware that in order for the ritual to be properly instituted, the lamb had to be consumed afterward?
Only when they had to spray the blood up the doors to stop their first born from dying.
Jesus said, “I come not to destroy the Law, but to FULFILL it”.
Yeah, too true.
So… if the lamb had to be consumed, and Jesus was there to fulfill the law… does that bring any further meaning to the Last Supper?
We did consume him; by taking into ourselves his holy spirit and accepting his death for our payment of sins!
Two more questions:
I’m ready!
  1. What did the first and second generations of Christians believe?
🤷
  1. Are you aware that this is NOT just a Catholic belief, but also the belief of 500 million Orthodox, plus Lutherans, and some Anglicans and Episcopalians from the Protestant denominations. It is NOT just a Catholic belief. .
But it is not a belief of my methodist church. 😃
In fact, the vast majority of Christians hold to this view
…that’s because they are superstitious.
 
Protestants split from the Catholic (capital C) Church not because the didn’t trust the Church, but because they no longer trusted God and took a religion thousands of years old and made it into something they thought they could live with.
Wrong, they didn’t trust what the church was teaching; superstition.
Are they happy yet?
I am, because I found christ, not by a wafer but by his divine grace!
 
Which is true? Well let’s start here; protestants split from the catholic church because they didn’t trust it any more…
:rolleyes:

The eastern rites of the catholic church are just as catholic as you are in the latin rite.
The bishop of Rome approves many things, but in this instance he can not even stop this practice if he wanted to.
Nor was there ever a need for the east to have “approval” from the bishop of Rome to preform the Mass in this manner. Unless, I am mistaken and you can provide some help to me on this.

It was never even “on the table” as far as I know.
I belong to the Western Rite, that is why I used the word Western. Please re-read my post and see if I inferred ANYTHING about the Eastern Rite.:rolleyes: I didn’t say ANYTHING “between the lines”, thank you very much.:confused:

You asked for info. I gave it.
 
Rolltide;5542230]So… we say the passage is literal.
You say it’s a metaphore.
No one’s opinion alive today can confirm this.
My opinion is not what counts, but what is true counts; I have recieved christ (truth) and it didn’t happen by a wafer (opinion)!
But… there are LOTS of historical documents from early Christians (and even the pagan ROMANS) on the matter. Many of them even date to the time of the Apostles, some written by people personally taught by John, Paul, and Peter. Would it not be logical to assume that these documents would be helpful in making a case for one side or the other?
They have been missinterpritated, hence there is superstition.
 
I belong to the Western Rite, that is why I used the word Western. Please re-read my post and see if I inferred ANYTHING about the Eastern Rite.:rolleyes: I didn’t say ANYTHING “between the lines”, thank you very much.:confused:

You asked for info. I gave it.
Don’t be a meanie to strawberryjam! :tsktsk:
 
Your opinions and comments are relative. The catholic church does not claim Zundrah worships any other God than the very one you do.

Take it up with your church, but don’t say/imply her God is not your God.

You have zero basis to make such a statement.

You both worship the same God.
Good Grief, why don’t you read what I post without a blind eye? I made no statement such as you imply because if I said I believe there is more than one God??? I said no such thing. Get it straight.:coffeeread:
 
I understand all of this but it just isn’t sinking in… I have read endless amounts of literiture about the eucharist.
I like how you dismiss everything else I wrote and hone in on one thing.
Apparently the people there at the time believed that He was talking about the reality of His flesh and His blood-or there wouldn’t have been any difficulty
Finally it’s not about intellectualizing,reading and studying.Fianlly it is a concept that reaches into your heart or it doesn’t. It really finally about Love. Did Jesus love us to give us this very special gift of his Real Presence in the Eucharist that has been in the Church since it’s inception?
The Real Presence in the Eucharist is a real key to deciding which branch of Christianity is right, and which is wrong. If the Real Presence is a false belief, then you must immediately rule out the Catholic and Orthodox Churches, and possibly the Anglican, Episcopalian, and Lutheran denominations as well. If however, we can prove to you that belief in the Eucharist is correct, then the only Protestant denominations that even have a hope of being true are the ones I just mentioned, the Anglicans, Episcopalians, and Lutherans.
I am going to iterate what other posters have already stated. If you are not ready to accept the reality of Jesus Christ present in the Eucharist, then you are not ready to convert to Catholicism, if that was your intention.
Beginning with the Anabaptists, there are some non-Catholic denominations that see the Sacraments as merely symbolic of the faith we profess. For us Catholics, they are real efficacious signs of God’s grace. When we consume the Eucharist, we consume Christ. Unlike ordinary food that becomes a part of who we are after it is consumed, when we consume Christ in the Eucharist, we are united to Him who created us. Paraphrasing John the Baptist, we decrease that He might increase. The life we lead is no longer our own. Rather it is Christ who lives through us.
This is a great mystery that will not be solved through intellectual reading and research into what Catholics believe. It is a mystery to be entered into with faith.
If you lack faith, then pray that the Holy Spirit enlighten you that you might respond in faith to the Faith that you receive through Jesus Christ.
It is because of our shared belief in the Presence of Christ in the Eucharist that communion is denied to those who do not accept this truth.
You are not the first to question the Real Presence. Some individuals have received answers with dramatic signs. These too, from what I gather, would be simply dismissed as pious stories, as fables so I will leave them out of this discussion.
If and when you are willing to enter into the mystery, you are invited to Eucharistic Adoration when it is offered at the Catholic Church you currently attend. Members of any faith may adore Christ. As you sit before the Eucharist, allow the Lord to direct your heart to the truth.
The Eucharist is essential to my Faith, and I have a personal relationship with Jesus Christ. The Eucharist allows me to surrender more fully to Christ within that relationship.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top