Zundra,
Let me ask you this. It sounds like you’re relatively fixed in your position. You claim that it is your
opinion, and that we are superstitious. You read the Biblical passage metaphorically, so in order to convince you, we’re going to have to do one of a few things (or most likely, ALL of them, so you have enough evidence…):
- Use evidence from OTHER places in scripture, since it’s the inspired Word of God. That’s what I began doing with the post about Malchezidech and sacrifices and all that. However, I’d have to go into much more detail, and there’s MUCH more to share. You didn’t seem very convinced so far.
- Use evidence from history by showing what other early Christians believed that were trained by the Apostles, and their successors. That didn’t seem to impress you much either, but does, in fact, carry a lot of scholarly weight. We could also use evidence from the Romans persecuting the Christians, in that their errors about what Christians believe could only have come about if Christians believed in the REAL Presence, not a symbolic presence.
- We could try to convince you on some spiritual level, like by encountering Jesus in the Mass, or at Adoration. That’s not likely to work if you don’t believe.
Beyond those three ideas, can YOU think of any other types of information that would help you in understanding the Catholic viewpoint? I’m assuming you’re wanting to be convinced still, or you wouldn’t be here.