The Eucharist; superstition?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Zundrah
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
You didn’t insult me. You insulted my beliefs. Let’s take Eucharist, one of my most loved beliefs, and print it with a small e. That is insulting.
But you catholics call our denominations a church without a capital C even though you will say; Roman Catholic Church with a capital C… Is that not offensive to me that you call my church a denomination rather then to recognise it as a Church?
 
…you really believe that then?
If one is Catholic, one accepts ALL of the dogmatic, doctrinal tenets of the Faith. If one doesn’t then, one is not Catholic. Now that is not to say one does not have the right to question, but if one questions, one also has the obligation to seek the truth and never give up seeking and learning about the Faith.
 
Limited information that they had!? You seem to have forgotten that they deliberately left the information behind becuase they did not believe in it.
The first generation did. Catholics believe that many of these people were indeed misled into hell, although we CANNOT comment on the state of individual souls. Some might have been poor and uneducated, and not realized what they were doing. MANY people became Protestant for political reasons, because the king of their land forced them too (especially in Germany). Subsequent generations would have been brought up with a skewed knowledge of Catholicism, and raised without a choice. They wouldn’t fully understand their errors, and so would not be responsible for them. This is how we view most Protestants today. If, however, one actively understood or practiced Catholicism, and THEN rejected it, their salvation might be in doubt. This does occur on occasion, but for MOST people, it gives substantial reason for hope.
 
Zundra,
Let me ask you this. It sounds like you’re relatively fixed in your position. You claim that it is your opinion, and that we are superstitious. You read the Biblical passage metaphorically, so in order to convince you, we’re going to have to do one of a few things (or most likely, ALL of them, so you have enough evidence…):
  1. Use evidence from OTHER places in scripture, since it’s the inspired Word of God. That’s what I began doing with the post about Malchezidech and sacrifices and all that. However, I’d have to go into much more detail, and there’s MUCH more to share. You didn’t seem very convinced so far.
  2. Use evidence from history by showing what other early Christians believed that were trained by the Apostles, and their successors. That didn’t seem to impress you much either, but does, in fact, carry a lot of scholarly weight. We could also use evidence from the Romans persecuting the Christians, in that their errors about what Christians believe could only have come about if Christians believed in the REAL Presence, not a symbolic presence.
  3. We could try to convince you on some spiritual level, like by encountering Jesus in the Mass, or at Adoration. That’s not likely to work if you don’t believe.
Beyond those three ideas, can YOU think of any other types of information that would help you in understanding the Catholic viewpoint? I’m assuming you’re wanting to be convinced still, or you wouldn’t be here.
Well of course my initial plan was to become catholic but now I am stuck on a sticky stituation that i just can’t get around… It’s too complicted.

When i went into the roman catholic church, I felt christ there, not in the tabernacle, not in the montrounst (I spelt that wrong?), not in the statues and not in the altar but in the whole body of the church! Now tell me; would a christian ever leave a church if he or she felt christ’s presence? 🤷
 
If one is Catholic, one accepts ALL of the dogmatic, doctrinal tenets of the Faith. If one doesn’t then, one is not Catholic. Now that is not to say one does not have the right to question, but if one questions, one also has the obligation to seek the truth and never give up seeking and learning about the Faith.
I have lost what little faith I had in the catholic church but I am desperate to keep hold of it if I can, because I definately felt something in that church!

I am starting to believe that the eucharist really is just a hook to keep people coming, since it is not part of being a christian. Being baptized is, being in surrender to christ is, but not the eucharist.
 
…you really believe that then?
ect…? So my church is just an etc? Is that not offensive yet again!?
Give me a break.

I guess subconsciously, consciously I felt I would be insulting you naming your church. We have how many religions? Catholic, Eastern Catholic, Orthodox Catholic, Methodist (see I gave you fourth place), Russion Orthodox, Lithuanian, Lutheran, Presbyterian, Evangelical, United Church of Christ, E and R, Baptist, Islam, Budhest/Buddest/Buhdest? heck if I know how to spell it. Hindu. How may hundreds did I miss?
 
But you catholics call our denominations a church without a capital C even though you will say; Roman Catholic Church with a capital C… Is that not offensive to me that you call my church a denomination rather then to recognise it as a Church?
Catholics have a completely different definition of the word “Church” than Protestants, however. In order to be an actual “Church”, a denomination must have two things:
  1. Apostolic Succession. That means it’s clergy must be able to directly demonstrate that they were appointed by a successor of the Apostles. In other words, Peter appointed Linus as a bishop, who appointed Cletus, who appointed Clement, and so on… all the way down to Benedict XVI.
  2. A belief in the Real Presence at Communion.
By this definition, the Eastern Orthodox Churches, the Oriental Orthodox Churches, the Assyrian Church of the East, The Polish National Catholic Church, and the “Old Catholic” Church are true Churches. They are the only other groups that fulfill these two requirements currently. All others are referred to technically as “Ecclesial Communities”, since they are most definitely “Christian”, but not actually a hierarchical church with a structure traced back to the Apostles. That said, most WILL be referred to as churches with a lower-case “c” out of politeness.
 
I have lost what little faith I had in the catholic church but I am desperate to keep hold of it if I can, because I definately felt something in that church!

I am starting to believe that the eucharist really is just a hook to keep people coming, since it is not part of being a christian. Being baptized is, being in surrender to christ is, but not the eucharist.
There is only ONE TRUTH. If you felt something, search it out. Study it. Pray about it. Read the Early Church Fathers if you haven’t already. Listen to EWTN Catholic Radio Station. Watch it on TV. Go to Catholic websites, such as LIFENEWS. Or Lifesite. Keep looking. Don’t give up. :gopray2:
 
Give me a break.

I guess subconsciously, consciously I felt I would be insulting you naming your church. We have how many religions? Catholic, Eastern Catholic, Orthodox Catholic, Methodist (see I gave you fourth place), Russion Orthodox, Lithuanian, Lutheran, Presbyterian, Evangelical, United Church of Christ, E and R, Baptist, Islam, Budhest/Buddest/Buhdest? heck if I know how to spell it. Hindu. How may hundreds did I miss?
It doesn’t matter how many you missed, you knew I was methodist, that is the whole point… but I don’t really care too much if you hate my denomination, or if you hate protestants, I only care for the loss of my faith that I was so sure of when I enetrered my Catholic Church. BTW, I put a capital C on those for you… How is this; I am having problems with understanding the Eucharist… I use a capital E.

Should the argumant still continue or are you going to just give up on me after all this time…?

It is 7:57am, I have just made my self some coffe and I am probably not functioning properly now. I keep maikng so many spelling mistakes that correcting them before I hit “submit reply” is taking me ages… Are you going to give up on my dying faith so quickly? I don’t want you to…
 
I sent you a grand total of ONE PM. And hey, fair warning… my name is SaltySirena!
Your name is nothing to me, as is mine nothing to you. I don’t appreciate it when some one swears at me, what ever their name is.
 
Well of course my initial plan was to become catholic but now I am stuck on a sticky stituation that i just can’t get around… It’s too complicted.

When i went into the roman catholic church, I felt christ there, not in the tabernacle, not in the montrounst (I spelt that wrong?), not in the statues and not in the altar but in the whole body of the church! Now tell me; would a christian ever leave a church if he or she felt christ’s presence? 🤷
I would hope not. However, you are at the very beginning of a faith journey that will take your whole life. I’m 38, and I learn new things about Catholicism every day! I know FAR from everything about Christianity. However, I’m always willing to learn with an open mind about my faith.

The situation is complicated, but take heart in that MANY have dealt with your situation before and successfully come to a resolution.

It is indeed a blessing that you felt the presence of God in the Catholic Church. What may be necessary for the next step is to do what Jesus commanded - to just drop everything, and follow Him where He leads. Don’t expect to understand Communion in a day.

Why don’t you let us work through all three ways of convincing you, and see where we end up after that? Remember to look at the evidence with an open mind. If you’re simply going to refuse to hear evidence, we can’t really do much, can we? We understand that a single fact is NOT going to convince you. Much like a court case, it’s going to take an overwhelming number of facts, taken together as a whole, to convince you beyond reasonable doubt.
 
There is only ONE TRUTH. If you felt something, search it out. Study it. Pray about it. Read the Early Church Fathers if you haven’t already. Listen to EWTN Catholic Radio Station. Watch it on TV. Go to Catholic websites, such as LIFENEWS. Or Lifesite. Keep looking. Don’t give up. :gopray2:
I don’t want to give up…
 
I have lost what little faith I had in the catholic church but I am desperate to keep hold of it if I can, because I definately felt something in that church!

I am starting to believe that the eucharist really is just a hook to keep people coming, since it is not part of being a christian. Being baptized is, being in surrender to christ is, but not the eucharist.
ect…? So my church is just an etc? Is that not offensive yet again!?
Absolutely!!! Funny is as funny does.
 
I would hope not. However, you are at the very beginning of a faith journey that will take your whole life. I’m 38, and I learn new things about Catholicism every day! I know FAR from everything about Christianity. However, I’m always willing to learn with an open mind about my faith.

The situation is complicated, but take heart in that MANY have dealt with your situation before and successfully come to a resolution.

It is indeed a blessing that you felt the presence of God in the Catholic Church. What may be necessary for the next step is to do what Jesus commanded - to just drop everything, and follow Him where He leads. Don’t expect to understand Communion in a day.

Why don’t you let us work through all three ways of convincing you, and see where we end up after that? Remember to look at the evidence with an open mind. If you’re simply going to refuse to hear evidence, we can’t really do much, can we? We understand that a single fact is NOT going to convince you. Much like a court case, it’s going to take an overwhelming number of facts, taken together as a whole, to convince you beyond reasonable doubt.
But if i just came in an open mind then I would have already been misslead by mormons… as they ask me to do the same thing too.
 
This is funny, coming from the one who swears on all of her private mails, SaltySirena!
It doesn’t matter how many you missed, you knew I was methodist, that is the whole point… but I don’t really care too much if you hate my denomination, or if you hate protestants, I only care for the loss of my faith that I was so sure of when I enetrered my Catholic Church. BTW, I put a capital C on those for you… How is this; I am having problems with understanding the Eucharist… I use a capital E.

Should the argumant still continue or are you going to just give up on me after all this time…?

It is 7:57am, I have just made my self some coffe and I am probably not functioning properly now. I keep maikng so many spelling mistakes that correcting them before I hit “submit reply” is taking me ages… Are you going to give up on my dying faith so quickly? I don’t want you to…
You are the only one who can do anything about your dying faith. You won’t even know if I prayed for you or not.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top