The importance of immigration

  • Thread starter Thread starter YourNameHere
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
There’s a lot of confusion circulating as to what “sanctuary cities” truly are. I found an article that explains it best.
Basically, sanctuary cities are cities that have adopted either a de jure or de facto policy of not checking immigration status at the time of an arrest or other lawful law enforcement encounter. At the same time, many of these de jure policies also bar local law enforcement from coordinating with federal law enforcement when the local law enforcement does learn of a suspect’s immigration status. It’s the immigration equivalent of “don’t ask, don’t tell.”
Law enforcement is actually under tremendous pressure to “work with” the feds, so it’s easy to see why their role is confusing to a lot of immigrants.
 
My mother used to tell me how her grandmother, who mostly spoke Polish, would complain about “those dummy Americans.”
I wish Babcza were still alive so I could have her deported for her anti-American refusal to assimilate.
And my own grandmother told me she would only go to Confession with a Polish-speaking priest because she was more comfortable making her confession in Polish. I am so ashamed now.
 
Who’s taking jobs?

If you look at U.S. employment rates and immigration rates going back to 1900, you will see that periods of LOW unemployment correlate with periods of HIGH immigration.

And if immigrants are “taking” jobs, why are so many jobs going in filled? I personally know guys who manage manufacturing and construction companies, and they can’t find workers regardless of race, ethnicity, or national origin. The rural, middle American whites who feel most threatened by immigrants can’t get the jobs because they can’t pass the drug tests. THAT is the problem.
 
If you look at U.S. employment rates and immigration rates going back to 1900, you will see that periods of LOW unemployment correlate with periods of HIGH immigration.
The 1920’s had very little immigration, yet the economy was buzzing, new industries like automobiles, radio, consumer economics were launched and our entire suburban/ car culture came into existence.
 
In all seriousness–our county’s chamber of commerce recently held one of its conferences and the chairman talked all about how our booming industries and manufacturers are looking at a whole host of problems because they can’t find enough people to fill vacant positions since The Feds put the clampdown on immigration.

By the way, I live in a county once characterized by Karl Rove as the most reliably Republican county in the U.S. We’re conservatives here. Businessmen and conservatives. We have only a single Democrat elected to a state-level office.

And even WE understand the hurt that restricted immigration will do to the economy.
In economics that’s called supply and demand.

We are at the first time in many decades where there is such demand for the worker, why shouldn’t the worker experience a period where their labor is valued and sought after? This is such a boon to citizens who have been struggling in poverty, working part time, or under employed. The market will lift their wages and circumstances without a mandated wage increase.

Why do you want to immediately flood the market with more cheap labor?
 
Last edited:
You know it wasn’t that long ago that the locals were fuming and furious about all the Irish Catholics coming over in their potato boats, taking all the jobs.

But it’s a foregone conclusion that the immigration during the 1800s is what gave the US the push it needed into the industrial age, and onward into the 1900s.

Immigration creations jobs, it creates customers, it creates growth.
 
LOL
No

It was the industrial age that pushed the US into the industrial age.
It did the same thing to most developed countries, regardless of their immigration.
 
Last edited:
Population is what drove it all, friend. It put people in the steel mills and the construction sites, and the factories, and the shops. Population that grew due to immigration. Immigration is uniquely how the US exploded in the nineteenth century, especially out west. Immigration is a huge topic of the era.

You think the calendar did it? Ages are built by people, not the other way around. It is demonstrated time and again in US history that immigration is good for the economy, it creates jobs and wealth, and makes our nation stronger.
 
Last edited:
but the irish did assimilate. Just as the Italians. Unlike immigrants of today that demand their culture replace western culture. Just look at European countries that are starting to remove immigrants from their country.

I would have no problem with immigration at todays current levels if we end the welfare state for both people and businesses.
 
Last edited:
Immigration creations jobs, it creates customers, it creates growth.
I think you have it backwards. growth in industry creates a need for immigration for jobs in the growing field…
 
growth in industry creates a need for immigration for jobs in the growing field…
BTW, that’s exactly what President Trump would like to do. Bring in highly qualified immigrants that will be able to contribute to the economy and not be a burden on the US taxpayer
 
Population is what drove it all, friend. It put people in the steel mills and the construction sites, and the factories, and the shops. Population that grew due to immigration. Immigration is uniquely how the US exploded in the nineteenth century, especially out west. Immigration is a huge topic of the era.

You think the calendar did it? Ages are built by people, not the other way around. It is demonstrated time and again in US history that immigration is good for the economy, it creates jobs and wealth, and makes our nation stronger.
No, technology drove it all. The industrial revolution was built by a massive jump in technical advancement. If you had to pick one thing, it would be the steam engine.
 
No, technology drove it all.
That’s exactly right, technological advances like the Bessemer process led to new uses for steel in construction and transportation, which led to more need for coal and for oil, and a need to bring people in to dig it up.

But if the technology doesn’t exist for steel in massive quantities and reasonable prices, the country continues to build with wood and masonry and continues to use horses, donkeys, elephants for transportation. No need for new people.
 
That is why my family only took one. My dad would tell me that italian was not allow to be spoken. Both of my grandparents family only spoke english in the house. The only time my father heard italian was when he and his grandfather were out hunting. My grandfather couldnt speak a word of Italian and neither did my dad. Same for me
 
Last edited:
There’s a difference between struggling to learn a foreign language and - how did you word it? - “demand[ing] their cultures replace western culture.”

There’s a sizable body of research showing that adult language acquisition can take many years, even with continual exposure and immersion. The process moves more quickly in children due to both brain development and ELL programs in public schools.
 
There’s a sizable body of research showing that adult language acquisition can take many years, even with continual exposure and immersion.
If the immigrants in question are college educated and technically adept- the kind of immigrants the country needs- they are usually able to read English even if they have a rough time speaking the language. I’ve had no problem at all communicating with my immigrant periodontist from Korea, who was educated here in America.
 
There’s a difference between struggling to learn a foreign language and - how did you word it? - “demand[ing] their cultures replace western culture.”

There’s a sizable body of research showing that adult language acquisition can take many years, even with continual exposure and immersion. The process moves more quickly in children due to both brain development and ELL programs in public schools.
It is more than just language that people are demanding we change. Just look at what is happening with governments in Europe. Brexit is just the start of the end of the EU. Why are so many people in these countries wanting to exit the EU? If we keep up this policy of come on come all, you will see states wanting to exit the US. If it happens this time there wont be the moral debate of slavery to start a civil war over.

 
They do favor a screening process.
Seems anything short of a captial crime and they think you are good to go.
Pretty low standards if you ask me.

Don’t you wan’t your kids to be a bit selective in whom they marry, or invite into your family?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top