The incomplete Gospel

  • Thread starter Thread starter paul_c
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Hi Paul,

It seems that one of the things you all have in common as Catholics, is your faith in your religion. How is that any better or different from the most devout Muslims who are totally committed to their religion? I’m not trying to offend any of you, I’m just trying to point out that faith in a religion is no substitute for faith in Jesus. It is for this reason that I’m not terribly impressed by religious zealotry. It is, in my opinion, not the sort of faith that is going to save anyone. Jesus said, “I am the way.” If Jesus is the way, then nothing else will ever be acceptable to me. I only want to be with Jesus.
As Christians our faith is not in religion,it is in Christ, the Church is the Body of Christ, we are his Bride, he is the head of His Body the Church.As Church we follow him, he is the way.It is not just Jesus and me, it is Jesus and his body the Church.:thumbsup:Carlan
 
I haven’t got a clue what you are talking about here, Ina.
Ok Mick,

Let’s get down to it. You want to know where the real church is? You want to know why catholics believe that the catholic church is the one true church? Well let’s get started with this and stick to this topic.
First
We start with the keys. Keys in the bible are a symbol of Authority. The jews of the old testament new this extremely well.
The expression “power of the keys” is derived from Christ’s words to St. Peter (in Matthew 16:19). The promise there made finds its explanation in Isaiah 22, in which “the key of the house of David” is conferred upon Eliacim, the son of Helcias, as the symbol of plenary authority in the Kingdom of Juda. Christ by employing this expression clearly designed to signify his intention to confer on St. Peter the supreme authority over His Church. This is very important to understand the meaning of the keys, so read Isaiah 22 for reference and study the parallel between Isaiah and Matthew. Jesus being a Jew new exactly what he was doing when he choose to parallel Isaiah and Matthew.
Now the keys go hand in hand with the changing of Simons name to the Rock.
The New Testament contains five different metaphors for the foundation of the Church (Matt. 16:18, 1 Cor. 3:11, Eph. 2:20, 1 Pet. 2:5–6, Rev. 21:14). One metaphor that has been disputed is Jesus Christ’s calling the apostle Peter “rock”: “You are Peter, and on this rock I will build my Church, and the gates of hell will not prevail against it” (Matt. 16:18).

Some have tried to argue that Jesus did not mean that his Church would be built on Peter but on something else.

Some argue that in this passage there is a minor difference between the Greek term for Peter (Petros) and the term for rock (petra), yet they ignore the obvious explanation: petra, a feminine noun, has simply been modifed to have a masculine ending, since one would not refer to a man (Peter) as feminine. The change in the gender is purely for stylistic reasons.

These critics also neglect the fact that Jesus spoke Aramaic, and, as John 1:42 tells us, in everyday life he actually referred to Peter as Kepha or Cephas (depending on how it is transliterated). It is that term which is then translated into Greek as petros. Thus, what Jesus actually said to Peter in Aramaic was: “You are Kepha and on this very kepha I will build my Church.”

The Church Fathers, those Christians closest to the apostles in time, culture, and theological background, clearly understood that Jesus promised to build the Church on Peter, as the following passages show.
Christ left the adoption of a name for His Church to those whom he
commissioned to teach all nations. Christ called the spiritual society
He established, “My Church” (Mt. xvi, 18), “the Church” (Mt. xviii, 17).
In order to have a distinction between the Church and the Synagogue and
to have a distinguishing name from those embracing Judaic and Gnostic
errors we find St. Ignatius (50-107 A.D.) using the Greek word
“Katholicos” (universal) to describe the universality of the Church
established by Christ. St. Ignatius was appointed Bishop of Antioch by
St.Peter, the Bishop of Rome. It is in his writtings that we find the
word Catholic used for the first time. St. Augustine, when speaking
about the Church of Christ, calls it the Catholic Church 240 times in
his writings.
Don’t forget that St. Ignatius was taught and ordained by John, one of the original 12 and the author of revelation and the Gospel of John.
 
Hi Della,

OK, let me see if I’ve got your circular argument right this time:
  1. The Catholic church is the same church that was founded by Jesus.
I never used the word “same”, you are. This is a subtle way of trying to put words in my mouth so you can tell yourself I am making a circular argument.
  1. We know that the CC is the one founded by Jesus because the ECF were Catholic.
I never claimed #2. Once again you are mischaracterizing my words. We know the CC was founded by Christ because it was. Historical fact. Period.
  1. We know that the ECF were Catholic because the writings of the ECF were Catholic.
No, we know they were Catholics because they were Catholics, ergo their writings are Catholic. Historical fact. Period.
Again, if I’ve mischaracterized your argument, please feel free to correct me!
There is nothing circular about relating simple historical facts. You are using the term circular argument wrongly, and you are putting words in my mouth to try to justify your misuse of the term. :tsktsk: There is no triumph here. I am not trying to win any agrument with you. I am telling you plain historical facts. That’s all.
 
I never used the word “same”, you are. This is a subtle way of trying to put words in my mouth so you can tell yourself I am making a circular argument.

I never claimed #2. Once again you are mischaracterizing my words. We know the CC was founded by Christ because it was. Historical fact. Period.

No, we know they were Catholics because they were Catholics, ergo their writings are Catholic. Historical fact. Period.

There is nothing circular about relating simple historical facts. You are using the term circular argument wrongly, and you are putting words in my mouth to try to justify your misuse of the term. :tsktsk: There is no triumph here. I am not trying to win any agrument with you. I am telling you plain historical facts. That’s all.
Hi Della,

Why is it that you are so competent to reason your way to the truth of the historical fact that “the CC was founded by Christ because it was” and millions of us are not competent to reason this?
 
Mick,

Let’s ask a few questions to highlight the problem you pose
  1. Are the Apostles infallible on issues of faith and morals?
  2. Is the bible infallible on issues of faith and morals?
  3. How do you know? Are you using Faith or Judgement?
  4. Now if the question becomes, is the Catholic Church the legitimate successor to the Apostles? Would you use Faith or Judgement to answer this question?
My answers to this:
  1. yes, the Apostles were infallible on Faith and Morals. They were taught the Faith by Jesus and inspired and protected by the Holy Spirit
  2. The bible is also infallible on Faith and Morals, being the teaching of the Apostles, protected by the Holy spirit.
  3. This truth of 1 and 2 are understood first by Faith. You can see their truth through reason, but it starts with faith. And you can understand that it is the truth because nothing from reason eliminates it from being the truth
  4. The truth is 4 is understood in the same way as 1 and 2. The advantage of the Catholic Church over any other church in this regard is that reason will discard any other church from being the Apostolic Church. For instance, Lutherans know their church started with Martin Luther.
Hi Paul,

I’m believing by faith in the teachings of the apostles and the trustworthiness of Scripture. But as you’ve probably noticed here in this discussion, many Catholics seem to JUST KNOW certain historical facts that millions of others (like me) just don’t know. When I ask how they JUST KNOW these historical facts, such as the ‘fact’ that the early church was Catholic, no one can tell me. So I conclude from this, that they JUST KNOW their history by faith.

Now the question is, what kind of faith is it that justifies us before God? Is it our Catholic faith? Or is it our faith in Jesus?
 
Hi Della,

Why is it that you are so competent to reason your way to the truth of the historical fact that “the CC was founded by Christ because it was” and millions of us are not competent to reason this?
Mick,
How did you reason that the Catholic Church was not founded by Christ? I mean after all, there is continuity of leadership and doctrine that demonstrate this fact pretty clearly.
Are you one of those that tries to claim that the Catholic Church apostacized? If so, we’d love to see your evidence of this because no one has ever demonstrated this to my knowledge.

And what is your reasoning that your church (whatever that happens to be) is the original chruch of Christ? That would also be interesting to understand because no one has ever been able to demonstrate that on these pages for a church other than the Catholic Church.
Maybe you have some fresh data or insight to make this point.
 
Hi Paul,

I’m believing by faith in the teachings of the apostles and the trustworthiness of Scripture. But as you’ve probably noticed here in this discussion, many Catholics seem to JUST KNOW certain historical facts that millions of others (like me) just don’t know. When I ask how they JUST KNOW these historical facts, such as the ‘fact’ that the early church was Catholic, no one can tell me. So I conclude from this, that they JUST KNOW their history by faith.

Now the question is, what kind of faith is it that justifies us before God? Is it our Catholic faith? Or is it our faith in Jesus?
Well, it can be pretty easily demonstrated that the Catholic church presided over the creation of the Bible Canon, so if you believe that the bible is trustworthy, you should also see that only a trustworthy church would have been tasked with its compilation, right?

You said you’ve read Eusebius’, right? If you knew Catholic dogma and you read the History of the Church, you would see that the Early church was clearly Catholic. So its more than blind faith that leads us to see the that Catholic Church has a clear line of doctrine and leadership back to Christ.

It is faith in Jesus that justifies us before God, but Jesus set up the church to tell us what that means and to administer grace through the sacraments. Its not an either or question. The Catholic Church was instituted to bring people to Jesus. Even though you consciously separate yourself from the Catholic Church, it is still bringing you to Jesus because you use the Bible, a Catholic teaching tool, to find what you know about Jesus. Unfortunately, you don’t trust the church to teach you the fullness of the faith so you sometimes misinterpret what you read, to your own detriment.
 
Ok Mick,

Let’s get down to it. You want to know where the real church is? You want to know why catholics believe that the catholic church is the one true church? Well let’s get started with this and stick to this topic.
First
We start with the keys. Keys in the bible are a symbol of Authority. The jews of the old testament new this extremely well.
The expression “power of the keys” is derived from Christ’s words to St. Peter (in Matthew 16:19). The promise there made finds its explanation in Isaiah 22, in which “the key of the house of David” is conferred upon Eliacim, the son of Helcias, as the symbol of plenary authority in the Kingdom of Juda. Christ by employing this expression clearly designed to signify his intention to confer on St. Peter the supreme authority over His Church. This is very important to understand the meaning of the keys, so read Isaiah 22 for reference and study the parallel between Isaiah and Matthew. Jesus being a Jew new exactly what he was doing when he choose to parallel Isaiah and Matthew.
Now the keys go hand in hand with the changing of Simons name to the Rock.
The New Testament contains five different metaphors for the foundation of the Church (Matt. 16:18, 1 Cor. 3:11, Eph. 2:20, 1 Pet. 2:5–6, Rev. 21:14). One metaphor that has been disputed is Jesus Christ’s calling the apostle Peter “rock”: “You are Peter, and on this rock I will build my Church, and the gates of hell will not prevail against it” (Matt. 16:18).

Some have tried to argue that Jesus did not mean that his Church would be built on Peter but on something else.

Some argue that in this passage there is a minor difference between the Greek term for Peter (Petros) and the term for rock (petra), yet they ignore the obvious explanation: petra, a feminine noun, has simply been modifed to have a masculine ending, since one would not refer to a man (Peter) as feminine. The change in the gender is purely for stylistic reasons.

These critics also neglect the fact that Jesus spoke Aramaic, and, as John 1:42 tells us, in everyday life he actually referred to Peter as Kepha or Cephas (depending on how it is transliterated). It is that term which is then translated into Greek as petros. Thus, what Jesus actually said to Peter in Aramaic was: “You are Kepha and on this very kepha I will build my Church.”

The Church Fathers, those Christians closest to the apostles in time, culture, and theological background, clearly understood that Jesus promised to build the Church on Peter, as the following passages show.
Christ left the adoption of a name for His Church to those whom he
commissioned to teach all nations. Christ called the spiritual society
He established, “My Church” (Mt. xvi, 18), “the Church” (Mt. xviii, 17).
In order to have a distinction between the Church and the Synagogue and
to have a distinguishing name from those embracing Judaic and Gnostic
errors we find St. Ignatius (50-107 A.D.) using the Greek word
“Katholicos” (universal) to describe the universality of the Church
established by Christ. St. Ignatius was appointed Bishop of Antioch by
St.Peter, the Bishop of Rome. It is in his writtings that we find the
word Catholic used for the first time. St. Augustine, when speaking
about the Church of Christ, calls it the Catholic Church 240 times in
his writings.
Don’t forget that St. Ignatius was taught and ordained by John, one of the original 12 and the author of revelation and the Gospel of John.
Hi Ina,

OK, let’s say, for the sake of your argument, that Peter is a rock. Why didn’t Jesus say, “Peter, you are a rock, and on YOU I will build my church.” And let’s say, for the sake of your argument, that “this rock” refers to Peter. How do we get from, the church is founded on Peter, to Peter was the first in an unbroken chain of popes? Why would Jesus found His church on Peter, and why would Jesus not explain the concept of the papacy?

As you hopefully can see, your reading into this passage of Scripture a PAPACY built on Peter, completely takes the focus away from Jesus, who begins the dialogue by asking the disciples, “who do men say I am?” It is as if you had skipped the first part of the passage (Jesus’ question, who do men say I am) and just assumed that the whole thing was about who Peter was to become! What a convoluted path you have chosen!
 
Mick,
How did you reason that the Catholic Church was not founded by Christ? I mean after all, there is continuity of leadership and doctrine that demonstrate this fact pretty clearly.
Are you one of those that tries to claim that the Catholic Church apostacized? If so, we’d love to see your evidence of this because no one has ever demonstrated this to my knowledge.

And what is your reasoning that your church (whatever that happens to be) is the original chruch of Christ? That would also be interesting to understand because no one has ever been able to demonstrate that on these pages for a church other than the Catholic Church.
Maybe you have some fresh data or insight to make this point.
Exactly. :tiphat: The onus is on the one claiming the Church isn’t the one founded by Christ when all the historical evidence says it is.
 
Hi Ina,

OK, let’s say, for the sake of your argument, that Peter is a rock. Why didn’t Jesus say, “Peter, you are a rock, and on YOU I will build my church.” And let’s say, for the sake of your argument, that “this rock” refers to Peter. How do we get from, the church is founded on Peter, to Peter was the first in an unbroken chain of popes? Why would Jesus found His church on Peter, and why would Jesus not explain the concept of the papacy?

As you hopefully can see, your reading into this passage of Scripture a PAPACY built on Peter, completely takes the focus away from Jesus, who begins the dialogue by asking the disciples, “who do men say I am?” It is as if you had skipped the first part of the passage (Jesus’ question, who do men say I am) and just assumed that the whole thing was about who Peter was to become! What a convoluted path you have chosen!
Jesus founded the church with Peter as the leader to teach the people and give them the sacraments as he commissions them in Matthew 28. And Jesus did explain the concept about the Papacy when he explained that the leader had to server the others in Luke 22. and he told Peter to tend his sheep in John 21 as a final emphasis.

The reason Peter was picked was because he correctly identified that Jesus was the Messiah and that this knowledge came from God. This was the test Jesus applied to see who would be the leader of his church. This doesn’t take away from the focus on Jesus at all. Don’t be jealous for Jesus. He’s the one who set up the church to glorify him.
 
Jesus founded the church with Peter as the leader to teach the people and give them the sacraments as he commissions them in Matthew 28.
It is as though Catholics are convinced that by endless repetition no evidence is needed to establish that Jesus founded the church with Peter as the leader! Is anyone going to provide solid reasons for this belief or do we have to just accept it because millions of Catholics believe it?
And Jesus did explain the concept about the Papacy when he explained that the leader had to server the others in Luke 22. and he told Peter to tend his sheep in John 21 as a final emphasis.
Why does it take a pope to do what every priest ought to do? None of that establishes or explains any concept of a papal office.
The reason Peter was picked was because he correctly identified that Jesus was the Messiah and that this knowledge came from God. This was the test Jesus applied to see who would be the leader of his church. This doesn’t take away from the focus on Jesus at all. Don’t be jealous for Jesus. He’s the one who set up the church to glorify him.
Where in Scripture do we find that, the reason Peter was picked was because he correctly identified that Jesus was the Messiah and that this knowledge came from God.

Where in Scripture do we find that, This was the test Jesus applied to see who would be the leader of his church.

If you can know all of this without Scripture, how can you know it?
 
Well, it can be pretty easily demonstrated that the Catholic church presided over the creation of the Bible Canon, so if you believe that the bible is trustworthy, you should also see that only a trustworthy church would have been tasked with its compilation, right?
Once again, if it can be pretty easily demonstrated that the Catholic church presided over the creation of the Bible Canon, then this ought to be settled by now, don’t you think?
You said you’ve read Eusebius’, right? If you knew Catholic dogma and you read the History of the Church, you would see that the Early church was clearly Catholic. So its more than blind faith that leads us to see the that Catholic Church has a clear line of doctrine and leadership back to Christ.
No, I have not read very much from Eusebius at all. If it really is clear from the writings of the ECF that the early church was clearly Catholic, then this whole issue should be settled by now. We would all be Catholics.
It is faith in Jesus that justifies us before God, but Jesus set up the church to tell us what that means and to administer grace through the sacraments. Its not an either or question. The Catholic Church was instituted to bring people to Jesus. Even though you consciously separate yourself from the Catholic Church, it is still bringing you to Jesus because you use the Bible, a Catholic teaching tool, to find what you know about Jesus. Unfortunately, you don’t trust the church to teach you the fullness of the faith so you sometimes misinterpret what you read, to your own detriment.
The Catholic church was instituted to bring people to Jesus? Where in Scripture do we find this? Is the CC doing its job? How would we know all of these things?
 
This, too, is circular.
:rotfl: Sure it is–if it makes you content to think so. :rolleyes: After all, you aren’t here to learn anything but only to assert what makes you feel right about you own beliefs. It’s an exercise in futility, really. And that truly is circular. :whacky:
 
On these pages, there are often discussions started by Evangelicals / Protestants that claim that we Catholics teach a different Gospel from them. Well, I would like to discuss a different hypothesis, that the Protestants/ Evangelicals actually teach AN INCOMPLETE GOSPEL in comparison with the Catholic Church, which has the fullness of truth. Of course, depending on the closeness of their teaching to the Catholic Church, different denomination’s Gospels are more or less incomplete.
Hi Paul,

It seems to me, after having participated in this excellent discussion, that there is no way for Catholics to demonstrate that the “fullness of truth” whatever that is, can only be found within the Catholic church. Ultimately, your faith, as you’ve defined it, lies in your religious institution. As I’ve already proven, there is no religion that can be a substitute for faith in the finished work of Jesus. If God deemed it important for His sheep to follow Peter or a religious system involving infallible popes, we ought to find such a system somewhere in Scripture…unless Scripture is horribly deficient for doctrinal teaching, correcting, etc, so that the man of God will be thoroughly equipped.
 
:rotfl: Sure it is–if it makes you content to think so. :rolleyes: After all, you aren’t here to learn anything but only to assert what makes you feel right about you own beliefs. It’s an exercise in futility, really. And that truly is circular. :whacky:
Hi Della,

I can certainly say that I’m here to learn. It is my hope that the points I’ve raised will be taken seriously and not simply dismissed. 🙂
 
Hi Della,

I can certainly say that I’m here to learn. It is my hope that the points I’ve raised will be taken seriously and not simply dismissed. 🙂
We take them seriously, all right. It’s just that most of us have “been there, done that”. We know what you believe, we know that you haven’t a clue what the Church teaches, or at least why it teaches what it does, and that you are stuck in a mind set that isn’t letting you see beyond it.

I strongly suggest you do some reading of solid Catholic material before telling Catholics they are wrong. You simply don’t have enough understanding to challenge the Church. I only wish I could help you see how truncated your view of God, man and the world truly is. Ah but, you’re just not ready for that, I’m afraid. 🤷
 
We take them seriously, all right. It’s just that most of us have “been there, done that”. We know what you believe, we know that you haven’t a clue what the Church teaches, or at least why it teaches what it does, and that you are stuck in a mind set that isn’t letting you see beyond it.

I strongly suggest you do some reading of solid Catholic material before telling Catholics they are wrong. You simply don’t have enough understanding to challenge the Church. I only wish I could help you see how truncated your view of God, man and the world truly is. Ah but, you’re just not ready for that, I’m afraid. 🤷
Hi Della,

I thought this was a serious discussion. Why do you say that, “you haven’t a clue what the Church teaches”? If you’ve been reading through this thread you would find that I understand very well what the CC teaches, but when I point out that the whole thing appears to be nothing more than just a circular argument, which means it is not really an argument at all, you get rather upset with me.

There must be some way for Catholics to verify their grand claims concerning the legitimacy of the CC. Are you going to present your evidence, or am I supposed to just accept it all because millions of Catholics believe it? Do you want to have a serious discussion? It is not helpful to insult those who are not yet persuaded by saying, “Ah but, you’re just not ready for that, I’m afraid.”
 
Hi Della,

I thought this was a serious discussion. Why do you say that, “you haven’t a clue what the Church teaches”? If you’ve been reading through this thread you would find that I understand very well what the CC teaches, but when I point out that the whole thing appears to be nothing more than just a circular argument, which means it is not really an argument at all, you get rather upset with me.

There must be some way for Catholics to verify their grand claims concerning the legitimacy of the CC. Are you going to present your evidence, or am I supposed to just accept it all because millions of Catholics believe it? Do you want to have a serious discussion? It is not helpful to insult those who are not yet persuaded by saying, “Ah but, you’re just not ready for that, I’m afraid.”
I meant no insult, truly. I just think you see things so very differently that you can’t see past it. I may be wrong about that, but that’s my perception.

History is our proof. I said it again and again. It is plain historical fact that the Church was founded by Christ and has existed since then with successors to the Apostles being ordained to carry on the right and duty of bringing Christ and his message to the world. It’s history, history, history. No circular argument needed. Look it up in any reliable, unbiased secular history book on the topic and you find all the proof you want. The onus is on you, to proof history wrong. It’s not us as Catholic you are arguing with it is history!
 
Once again, if it can be pretty easily demonstrated that the Catholic church presided over the creation of the Bible Canon, then this ought to be settled by now, don’t you think?

No, I have not read very much from Eusebius at all. If it really is clear from the writings of the ECF that the early church was clearly Catholic, then this whole issue should be settled by now. We would all be Catholics.

The Catholic church was instituted to bring people to Jesus? Where in Scripture do we find this? Is the CC doing its job? How would we know all of these things?
OK Mick you seem like a nice guy and I feel God sent you here to this forum for a reason. There seems to be a problem with your thinking and I believe it’s because it’s SOLA SCRIPTURA. You question how we get our information and we happily tell you. We go through the process of explaining not only through the bible but through history of the early church. You seem to not want to accept these what you would call theories. You need to get out of the bible alone mentality and open up to all of it, ie. ecf, history, bible…

For the first 1500 plus years the Church believed exactly what we teach today. Its only been 500 plus years that some people decided on their own to take a different route. Your telling me that for 1500 years the church had it all wrong. Be honest with yourself.

The bible besides being the word of God, it’s also a history book. If we rely on this history book to tell a story, why not rely on other history books to tell their stories.The first three popes after Peter were still living while the apostles were still alive and preaching. Theses people were taught by the apostles themselve and ordainded to teach others. Why would there writtings not be of value to the truth.
What i have been hearing you say is that the apostles got it right in the bible and everyone else afterwards got it wrong. Thats hard to swallow. If we are to be honest with ourselves and try to understand the fullness of the faith, then we need to look at all of it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top