The incomplete Gospel

  • Thread starter Thread starter paul_c
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Mick,
How did you reason that the Catholic Church was not founded by Christ?
Hi Paul,

The main obsticle for me is the way “the church” is viewed as the goal and the way to salvation. If this view were, in fact, accurate, it would make the CC something fit for our worship, love, and devotion, exactly as we see numerous times with Catholics here. But when I read the bible, the church is nothing without the Good Shepherd, Jesus Christ, who founded and sustains His church through His Holy Spirit and through His Holy bible. It seems to me me that, any view of the church that makes the church an object of worship and glorification is a blatant form of idol worship. It is God who is infallible and worthy of all praise, glory, and honor.
I mean after all, there is continuity of leadership and doctrine that demonstrate this fact pretty clearly.
If this could be demonstrated, it would have been demonstrated, would it not? Where is the continuity in the teaching of papal infallibility? In the existence of a papal office as it exists today? Where is the continuity on the perpetual sinlessness of Mary? On the celibacy of priests? How are popes chosen? Are there anti popes at various times? How does that happen? These just a tiny sample of legitimate questions that need to be taken seriously.
Are you one of those that tries to claim that the Catholic Church apostacized? If so, we’d love to see your evidence of this because no one has ever demonstrated this to my knowledge.
I’m glad you raised this issue! How should apostasy be recognized? I believe that the veneration of human traditions as though they are equal to Scripture is a serious form of apostasy.
And what is your reasoning that your church (whatever that happens to be) is the original chruch of Christ? That would also be interesting to understand because no one has ever been able to demonstrate that on these pages for a church other than the Catholic Church.
Maybe you have some fresh data or insight to make this point.
It is not my goal to promote any sect or religion. The church that was founded by Jesus is His bride, and His bride only wants Him. If it ever happens that my local church takes its focus away from Jesus and His Holy word, I will leave it, and look for a local church that worships God in Spirit and in truth.
 
Hi Paul,

It seems to me, after having participated in this excellent discussion, that there is no way for Catholics to demonstrate that the “fullness of truth” whatever that is, can only be found within the Catholic church. Ultimately, your faith, as you’ve defined it, lies in your religious institution. As I’ve already proven, there is no religion that can be a substitute for faith in the finished work of Jesus. If God deemed it important for His sheep to follow Peter or a religious system involving infallible popes, we ought to find such a system somewhere in Scripture…unless Scripture is horribly deficient for doctrinal teaching, correcting, etc, so that the man of God will be thoroughly equipped.
Mick you keep bringing up ** 2 Tim. 3:16-17 **All scripture is inspired by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness, that the man of God may be complete, equipped for every good work.
You need to look at the whole passage:
2 Timothy 3:14-17
But as for you, continue in what you have learned and have firmly believed, knowing from whom you learned it and how from childhood you have been acquainted with the sacred writings which are able to instruct you for salvation through faith in Christ Jesus. All scripture is inspired by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness, that the man of God may be complete, equipped for every good work."

We spoke earlier in the thread about Paul speaking of the old testament when he wrote this. Don’t put your own interpretation to the words, lets read and analyze them for what they say.

Paul is speaking to Timothy saying But as for you He also speaks of continue in what you have learned and have firmly believed So here their is already a belief instilled in him(Timothy)Paul speaks of. Paul does not want timothy to abandon this belief because Paul says he knows where he(Timothy) learned it from knowing from whom you learned it and some thing even more interesting than that, he speaks of scripture. and how from childhood you have been acquainted with the sacred writings which are able to instruct you for salvation through faith in Christ Jesus. Not only were all the writings not written when this book was written, but Paul is speaking of the old testament writings. and how from childhood you(Timothy) have been acquainted with the sacred writings As a child timothy only had the old testament writings to rely on and Paul is speaking of them as sripture.

The passage you quote to us quite often ** 2 Tim. 3:16-17 **All scripture is inspired by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness, that the man of God may be complete, equipped for every good work. has no bearing on what scripture is inspired and even less bearing on Sola Scriptura.
 
Hi Paul,

The main obsticle for me is the way “the church” is viewed as the goal and the way to salvation. If this view were, in fact, accurate, it would make the CC something fit for our worship, love, and devotion, exactly as we see numerous times with Catholics here. But when I read the bible, the church is nothing without the Good Shepherd, Jesus Christ, who founded and sustains His church through His Holy Spirit and through His Holy bible. It seems to me me that, any view of the church that makes the church an object of worship and glorification is a blatant form of idol worship. It is God who is infallible and worthy of all praise, glory, and honor.
You’ll be happy to learn, then that the Church is not our “goal” in any shape, form, or matter. God is our only goal. As to the means of salvation, there are many. Jesus is our redeemer and therefore our savior. However, whatever leads us to God can be said to be a means of salvation. A means is not the end–it is only a way that takes one to the end, and the end is God. For example, prayer is a means of salvation, but it is not salvation itself. Adoration is a means of salvation, being faithful is a means of salvation, etc. Union with God in the Beatific Vision is our goal, and it is Christ who made that possible. We don’t worship the Church any more than we worship prayer or the Bible or any other such thing. Wherever did you get the idea that we do?
If this could be demonstrated, it would have been demonstrated, would it not? Where is the continuity in the teaching of papal infallibility? In the existence of a papal office as it exists today? Where is the continuity on the perpetual sinlessness of Mary? On the celibacy of priests? How are popes chosen? Are there anti popes at various times? How does that happen? These just a tiny sample of legitimate questions that need to be taken seriously.
And there are cogent answers to all of them. It’s up to you to read reliable Catholic material that deals with these topics. You can find several good articles and resources for further study right here on the Cather Answers website.
I’m glad you raised this issue! How should apostasy be recognized? I believe that the veneration of human traditions as though they are equal to Scripture is a serious form of apostasy.
Once again, you’ll be happy to learn that Catholics don’t put human traditions on the same level as Scripture. We do hold to Sacred Tradition in which Scripture is a huge part, but we don’t hold to man made traditions as if they were God-given.
It is not my goal to promote any sect or religion. The church that was founded by Jesus is His bride, and His bride only wants Him. If it ever happens that my local church takes its focus away from Jesus and His Holy word, I will leave it, and look for a local church that worships God in Spirit and in truth.
And more power to you and your local church. But, to tell us we aren’t doing the same as you just because you don’t understand what we believe, and more importantly why we believe it, does not help your argument. I too once was a member of what you would term a “Bible believing” ecclesial community, but I looked into the Catholic Church for myself and discovered what I was told about it was wrong. It was not only reasonable in its teachings, its claims to being the historical Church, guided by the Holy Spirit, teaching Christ’s own words, bringing Christ to the world as he intended it, etc., it was absolutely true. I could never have entered the Church otherwise.
 
Hi Paul,

The main obsticle for me is the way “the church” is viewed as the goal and the way to salvation. If this view were, in fact, accurate, it would make the CC something fit for our worship, love, and devotion, exactly as we see numerous times with Catholics here. But when I read the bible, the church is nothing without the Good Shepherd, Jesus Christ, who founded and sustains His church through His Holy Spirit and through His Holy bible. It seems to me me that, any view of the church that makes the church an object of worship and glorification is a blatant form of idol worship. It is God who is infallible and worthy of all praise, glory, and honor.
Mick, Frankly you have a complete misunderstanding of how Catholics view the church. Catholids see the chruch as providing two things to help us in our goal of being united with God in heaven. First, it administers the sacraments, visible means of achieving God’s grace. Secondly, it teaches us the way to God through Jesus Christ our savior. It does this in numerous ways. It teaches us to be saved and how to state in the state of Grace through living the Christian life… It teaches us devotions that will help us develop our personal relationship with Jesus. We don’t worship the Church. We worship in communion with the church, helping each other to work toward. true holiness. The church IS not replacing the Good Shepard, its leading us to the Good Shepard.
I mean after all, there is continuity of leadership and doctrine that demonstrate this fact pretty clearly.
Mick, this has been demonstrated very thoroughly but not everyone has seen those demonstrations and some that have seen them, are not open to them. That doesn’t mean they are any less true. The Pope has been infallible in teachings of Faith and Morals since day one. This is true because he teaches what he was taught through the succession of Popes back to St. Peter. The roles of the Pope were defined in Acts and haven’t changed appreciably in 2000 years, despite huge changes in society . After all, Peter taught the faith (acts 2), excommunicated Simon Magnus and condemned Anias and Sapphira, replaced an Apostle (Judas), called a council (Jerusalem in 49AD), healed many people, brought a woman (Tabitha) back from the dead, established doctrine (Christians did not have to be Jewish), and wrote teaching epistles to the world. There are references to the sinlessness of Mary even in Scripture (Hail Mary, Full of Grace)…Priesthood celibacy is not a doctrine but a practice in the Roman Rite to focus all the priest attention on his ministry. It could be changed in the future and 22 Eastern Catholic Chruches have married priests. Popes are chosen by the remaining Bishops (and more lately Cardinals as the chruch has expanded). Yes, there were on a couple of occassions, men who falsely declared themselves Popes. These Antipopes were never true popes. I hope I’ve adequately answered your questions.
I’m glad you raised this issue! How should apostasy be recognized? I believe that the veneration of human traditions as though they are equal to Scripture is a serious form of apostasy.
A full scale apostacy is not practical within the Catholic Church. There are over 1Billion members and thousands of bishops that keep the faith. moving such a large group from the true faith, against the wishes of God, is impossible. By the way, what human traditions do you claim are equal to scripture?
It is not my goal to promote any sect or religion. The church that was founded by Jesus is His bride, and His bride only wants Him. If it ever happens that my local church takes its focus away from Jesus and His Holy word, I will leave it, and look for a local church that worships God in Spirit and in truth.
This is a very telling statement. It says that you are the final authority on what comes from God and that you will search for a faith community that suits your views. You see Catholics would never think like that. We read the Bible and know that the Catholic Church was set up by Jesus to help us find our way to him. We therefore trust it to tell us the truth. When it says something that doesn’t seem right to us, instead of turning our backs on it, we go back and understand why it has taken the position it did. When doing so, I have always found the Church considered factors i did not and that they were right. If you study the Catholic Chruch’s teachings in debth, I have faith you will come to the same conclusions.
 
You’ll be happy to learn, then that the Church is not our “goal” in any shape, form, or matter. God is our only goal.
Let’s continue reading and lets see if your beliefs match your claim that “the Church is not our “goal” in any shape, form, or matter. God is our only goal.”
As to the means of salvation, there are many.
Jesus is our redeemer and therefore our savior. However, whatever leads us to God can be said to be a means of salvation. A means is not the end–it is only a way that takes one to the end, and the end is God.
There can’t be many means to salvation if there is only one. Jesus said, “I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me.”

Jesus said, “I tell you the truth, the man who does not enter the sheep pen by the gate, but climbs in by some other way, is a thief and a robber.”
Jesus is our redeemer and therefore our savior. However, whatever leads us to God can be said to be a means of salvation. A means is not the end–it is only a way that takes one to the end, and the end is God.
As you are probably aware, the CC in past centuries taught that there is no salvation outside of the CC. Although the CC no longer teaches this, it is a direct contradiction of the verses I’ve shown above.
For example, prayer is a means of salvation, but it is not salvation itself. Adoration is a means of salvation, being faithful is a means of salvation, etc. Union with God in the Beatific Vision is our goal, and it is Christ who made that possible. We don’t worship the Church any more than we worship prayer or the Bible or any other such thing. Wherever did you get the idea that we do?
Then if what you are telling me is true, then your whole project here is defeated. We have no need for the CC or its magisterium if we can reach the goal without the CC. Now you can see why I keep trying to point out the utter futility of emphasizing, adoring, and placing faith, in a mere religion or sect. It is useless!
And there are cogent answers to all of them. It’s up to you to read reliable Catholic material that deals with these topics. You can find several good articles and resources for further study right here on the Cather Answers website.
I thought we had already agreed that the goal, salvation, which is only by one way (Jesus Christ) is what’s important and not the religious institution. If Jesus is the one and only way, then what do I need “Catholic material” for?
 
Let’s continue reading and lets see if your beliefs match your claim that “the Church is not our “goal” in any shape, form, or matter. God is our only goal.”

There can’t be many means to salvation if there is only one. Jesus said, “I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me.”

Jesus said, “I tell you the truth, the man who does not enter the sheep pen by the gate, but climbs in by some other way, is a thief and a robber.”
Instead, let’s not cherry pick Bible verses to fling at one another. I have an arsenal just as full as yours. We’d accomplish nothing at all except to prove the Bible is not it’s own interpreter.
As you are probably aware, the CC in past centuries taught that there is no salvation outside of the CC. Although the CC no longer teaches this, it is a direct contradiction of the verses I’ve shown above.
Sorry, you are wrong about this. The Church still claims there is no salvation outside it. The Catechism of the Catholic Church very carefully explains what the Church means/doesn’t mean by that. You need to read it.
Then if what you are telling me is true, then your whole project here is defeated. We have no need for the CC or its magisterium if we can reach the goal without the CC. Now you can see why I keep trying to point out the utter futility of emphasizing, adoring, and placing faith, in a mere religion or sect. It is useless!
Just the opposite! Just because prayer is a means to salvation doesn’t mean one does not need sound theology to make that prayer right and proper. This isn’t an either/or kind of thing. It’s much more full than that. The Church gives us the means of attaining God’s grace in its sacraments (the means of salvation) and it gives us the truths that guide us into praying properly, acting properly, and believing properly. These things go hand-in-hand. It all works together because the Church is Christ’s Body, which can do and does nothing without him.
I thought we had already agreed that the goal, salvation, which is only by one way (Jesus Christ) is what’s important and not the religious institution. If Jesus is the one and only way, then what do I need “Catholic material” for?
I never said the Church was unimportant or unnecessary. You are reaching way beyond my words to make a scenario of your own out of thin air. You need to read Catholic material in order to understand Catholic teaching, which is what you claimed you wanted to do. I’m just trying to help you do that. Why the constant arguments and challenges? You are shadow boxing a non-existent enemy, dear friend.
 
There can’t be many means to salvation if there is only one. Jesus said, “I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me.”

Jesus said, “I tell you the truth, the man who does not enter the sheep pen by the gate, but climbs in by some other way, is a thief and a robber.”
It think you are talking past each other in this exchange. Jesus is the way, the truth and the life, but there are different ways to approach Jesus because we all have different skills and gifts to bring to bear.
As you are probably aware, the CC in past centuries taught that there is no salvation outside of the CC. Although the CC no longer teaches this, it is a direct contradiction of the verses I’ve shown above.
Actually neither statement is true. the Catholic Church continues to teach that their is no salvation outside the church with the exception of special conditions like invinsible ignorance, where a person never heard of the Catholic church but still follows what it teaches about love of God and Neighbor. This is because Jesus established the church for the specific purpose of bringing people to himself through its teaching and sacraments. If you know this and still keep apart, you are willingly separating yourself from God’s chosen instrument and missing out on the associate graces and the fullness of truth. and their is only one truth.
Then if what you are telling me is true, then your whole project here is defeated. We have no need for the CC or its magisterium if we can reach the goal without the CC. Now you can see why I keep trying to point out the utter futility of emphasizing, adoring, and placing faith, in a mere religion or sect. It is useless!
Well, this is based on a false premise . You absolutely need the Catholic church for salvation. Its in the catechism:
COLOR=“Blue”]
“Outside the Church there is no salvation”

846 How are we to understand this affirmation, often repeated by the Church Fathers? Re-formulated positively, it means that all salvation comes from Christ the Head through the Church which is his Body:

Basing itself on Scripture and Tradition, the Council teaches that the Church, a pilgrim now on earth, is necessary for salvation: the one Christ is the mediator and the way of salvation; he is present to us in his body which is the Church. He himself explicitly asserted the necessity of faith and Baptism, and thereby affirmed at the same time the necessity of the Church which men enter through Baptism as through a door. Hence they could not be saved who, knowing that the Catholic Church was founded as necessary by God through Christ, would refuse either to enter it or to remain in it.

847 This affirmation is not aimed at those who, through no fault of their own, do not know Christ and his Church:

Those who, through no fault of their own, do not know the Gospel of Christ or his Church, but who nevertheless seek God with a sincere heart, and, moved by grace, try in their actions to do his will as they know it through the dictates of their conscience - those too may achieve eternal salvation.

848 "Although in ways known to himself God can lead those who, through no fault of their own, are ignorant of the Gospel, to that faith without which it is impossible to please him, the Church still has the obligation and also the sacred right to evangelize all men.

Here is the entire section of the catechism on the church so you can see how this fits into Catholic church doctrine.scborromeo.org/ccc/p123a9p3.htm
 
It think you are talking past each other in this exchange. Jesus is the way, the truth and the life, but there are different ways to approach Jesus because we all have different skills and gifts to bring to bear.
Hi Paul,

I’m not ignoring you, but I have limited time these days for addressing every post in depth. You are quite right in saying that we are talking past each other on the issue of the one way to salvation. Yes, there are several ways to approach Jesus, but we must come to Jesus on His terms, empty of all hope in all other things. If we are coming to Him filled with worldly and unnesesary stuff, then there will be no room for Jesus. Remember the rich young ruler in Mark 10? He viewed himself as a good man–a follower of the law. But Jesus showed him that he had another greater love, and that was his love for his money. The rich man walked away sad because he realized that his money was extremely important to him. So important that it got in the way of his desire to follow Jesus on Jesus’ terms.
 
Hi Paul,

I’m not ignoring you, but I have limited time these days for addressing every post in depth. You are quite right in saying that we are talking past each other on the issue of the one way to salvation. Yes, there are several ways to approach Jesus, but we must come to Jesus on His terms, empty of all hope in all other things. If we are coming to Him filled with worldly and unnesesary stuff, then there will be no room for Jesus. Remember the rich young ruler in Mark 10? He viewed himself as a good man–a follower of the law. But Jesus showed him that he had another greater love, and that was his love for his money. The rich man walked away sad because he realized that his money was extremely important to him. So important that it got in the way of his desire to follow Jesus on Jesus’ terms.
So, what Catholic teaching is in conflict with this?
 
Hi Paul,

I’m not ignoring you, but I have limited time these days for addressing every post in depth. You are quite right in saying that we are talking past each other on the issue of the one way to salvation. Yes, there are several ways to approach Jesus, but we must come to Jesus on His terms, empty of all hope in all other things. If we are coming to Him filled with worldly and unnesesary stuff, then there will be no room for Jesus. Remember the rich young ruler in Mark 10? He viewed himself as a good man–a follower of the law. But Jesus showed him that he had another greater love, and that was his love for his money. The rich man walked away sad because he realized that his money was extremely important to him. So important that it got in the way of his desire to follow Jesus on Jesus’ terms.
All true. But remember, what the rich man failed to do was to give up what he had and FOLLOW him. It is not enough to believe. We must also act out our beliefs to gain eternal life.
 
You’ll be happy to learn, then that the Church is not our “goal” in any shape, form, or matter. God is our only goal. As to the means of salvation, there are many.
"I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me.
Sorry, you are wrong about this. The Church still claims there is no salvation outside it. The Catechism of the Catholic Church very carefully explains what the Church means/doesn’t mean by that. You need to read it.
Hi Della,

It appears that you’re trying to have it both ways. God is your goal, AND the CC is the goal, since there is no salvation outside the CC. What would Jesus have said to the rich man in Mark 10, if the rich man had told Jesus that he was prepared to follow Jesus only on his own terms, not by cutting away his first love (his wealth)?

There is NO WAY to reconcile your position that, there is no salvation outside the CC, and the words of Jesus, "I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me.
You’ll be happy to learn, then that the Church is not our “goal” in any shape, form, or matter. God is our only goal. As to the means of salvation, there are many.
Either Jesus is right (I am the way) or the CC is right (the CC is the way). There is no possibility that both can be right.
 
"I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me.

Hi Della,

It appears that you’re trying to have it both ways. God is your goal, AND the CC is the goal, since there is no salvation outside the CC. What would Jesus have said to the rich man in Mark 10, if the rich man had told Jesus that he was prepared to follow Jesus only on his own terms, not by cutting away his first love (his wealth)?

There is NO WAY to reconcile your position that, there is no salvation outside the CC, and the words of Jesus, "I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me.

Either Jesus is right (I am the way) or the CC is right (there is no salvation outside of the CC). There is no possibility that both are right.
You are creating a false dichotomy. Its not either Jesus or the Church. Its Jesus through the Church he established on earth for that purpose. Jesus is the way to salvation and the Church is the way to Jesus. That’s how he set it up You can’t get to Jesus without going through the church. That’s the doorway. Even you practice it every time you open your bible, which came from the Church. The Church is the body of Christ, have you not read Corinthians. And when you read in Acts about Saul’s conversion on the Road to Damascus, what did Jesus say to Saul: Saul, Saul, why do you persecute me? Was Saul actually persecuting Jesus physically, who after all was out of reach in Heaven? No, he was persecuting the Church, the body of Christ. You can not separate one from the other.
 
All true. But remember, what the rich man failed to do was to give up what he had and FOLLOW him. It is not enough to believe. We must also act out our beliefs to gain eternal life.
Hi Paul,

There is no following Jesus on our own terms. Jesus taught that no one can serve two masters. What has become apparent here in this discussion, is that many Catholics are happy to “follow Jesus” only on their own terms, only by way of their worldly infallible authority–by their religion, and that entails serving two masters. It is placing a religion on the very top, and claiming that there is no possibility of salvation without the religion. In other words, it is a different gospel from that of Jesus and the apostles.
 
Hi Paul,

There is no following Jesus on our own terms. Jesus taught that no one can serve two masters. What has become apparent here in this discussion, is that many Catholics are happy to “follow Jesus” only on their own terms, only by way of their worldly infallible authority–by their religion, and that entails serving two masters. It is placing a religion on the very top, and claiming that there is no possibility of salvation without the religion. In other words, it is a different gospel from that of Jesus and the apostles.
No, it doesn’t mean serving two masters. It means serving the one master (Jesus) through the church he founded. This is not following Jesus on our terms. It is following Jesus on his terms by becoming a member of the body of Christ. It is the exact Gospel of Jesus and the Apostles.

I suggest you do some soul searching and see whether the charges you lay at our feet aren’t actually hypocritical After all, who chooses a church based on doctrines that agree with their own opinions? And who creates their own Gospel through personal revelation?
 
You are creating a false dichotomy. Its not either Jesus or the Church. Its Jesus through the Church he established on earth for that purpose.
Hi Paul,
Jesus said that wherever your treasure is, there your heart will be also. It isn’t that I’ve created a false dichotomy, it is that many Catholics have been attempting to reconcile two things that are by nature irreconcilable. If you wholeheartedly embrace a mere religion, then it is the religion that you will get. But if you have been brought to repentance by the power of the Holy Spirit, you will only desire Jesus. When a person only wants Jesus, it is Jesus that he or she gets. Is this so hard to understand? Is the simplicity of the biblical gospel unappealing to you?
 
Hi Paul,
Jesus said that wherever your treasure is, there your heart will be also. It isn’t that I’ve created a false dichotomy, it is that many Catholics have been attempting to reconcile two things that are by nature irreconcilable. If you wholeheartedly embrace a mere religion, then it is the religion that you will get. But if you have been brought to repentance by the power of the Holy Spirit, you will only desire Jesus. When a person only wants Jesus, it is Jesus that he or she gets. Is this so hard to understand? Is the simplicity of the biblical gospel unappealing to you?
Let me try to explain to you why this is the wrong way to think about it. You get all your information about Jesus from the Bible, right? Do you embrace the Bible or do you embrace Jesus? Is it not possible to embrace both because they are entertwined? Well that’s the same way we view the church, which is the Body of Christ. When you embrace the Church you embrace Christ, just as when you embrace your bible, you embrace Christ. And the Church is protected and directed by the Holy spirit. That was Christ’s scripturally documented promise.

Your view of Biblical simplicity is actually Biblically incomplete, with you ignoring anything it says beyond “have faith in Jesus.” What about Love? What about avoiding sin? what about doing acts of mercy and kindness? What about Following Jesus?
 
So, what Catholic teaching is in conflict with this?
Yes, to whatever extent it teaches a different gospel from that of Jesus and the apostles. If it is possible for Muslims, for example, to love their religion to such an extent that they will not accept Jesus on His terms, then it is possible for ANY religion to be loved to that extent. Faith in “infallible” human beings is no substitute for faith in Jesus. Faith in a mere religion is no substitute for faith in the finished work of Jesus. Where your treasure is, there your heart will be also. No man can serve two masters.
 
Let me try to explain to you why this is the wrong way to think about it. You get all your information about Jesus from the Bible, right? Do you embrace the Bible or do you embrace Jesus? Is it not possible to embrace both because they are entertwined?
True, they are intertwined. But I wouldn’t even know about Jesus without the bible. Devotion to the bible can’t save your soul. Lots of JW’s are seriously devoted to the bible and remain lost. The bible by itself, without the power of the Holy Spirit, is not enough to save anyone.
Well that’s the same way we view the church, which is the Body of Christ. When you embrace the Church you embrace Christ, just as when you embrace your bible, you embrace Christ. And the Church is protected and directed by the Holy spirit. That was Christ’s scripturally documented promise.
Lots of JW’s would say that when they embrace the Watchtower system (religion) they are embracing the Father. But what does Jesus say? “I am the way. No one comes to the Father except through me.”
Your view of Biblical simplicity is actually Biblically incomplete, with you ignoring anything it says beyond “have faith in Jesus.” What about Love? What about avoiding sin? what about doing acts of mercy and kindness? What about Following Jesus?
There is nothing about being loving, trying to avoid sin, doing acts of mercy and kindness, and following Jesus, that requires any kind of association with the CC. But all of these things are certain to be found in a person who has the spirit of God living inside. There is no religion that can ever be a substitute for genuine conversion of the heart and soul by the power of God.
 
True, they are intertwined. But I wouldn’t even know about Jesus without the bible. Devotion to the bible can’t save your soul. Lots of JW’s are seriously devoted to the bible and remain lost. The bible by itself, without the power of the Holy Spirit, is not enough to save anyone.

Lots of JW’s would say that when they embrace the Watchtower system (religion) they are embracing the Father. But what does Jesus say? “I am the way. No one comes to the Father except through me.”

There is nothing about being loving, trying to avoid sin, doing acts of mercy and kindness, and following Jesus, that requires any kind of association with the CC. But all of these things are certain to be found in a person who has the spirit of God living inside. There is no religion that can ever be a substitute for genuine conversion of the heart and soul by the power of God.
Mick you keep bringing up 2 Tim. 3:16-17 All scripture is inspired by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness, that the man of God may be complete, equipped for every good work.
You need to look at the whole passage:
2 Timothy 3:14-17
But as for you, continue in what you have learned and have firmly believed, knowing from whom you learned it and how from childhood you have been acquainted with the sacred writings which are able to instruct you for salvation through faith in Christ Jesus. All scripture is inspired by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness, that the man of God may be complete, equipped for every good work."

We spoke earlier in the thread about Paul speaking of the old testament when he wrote this. Don’t put your own interpretation to the words, lets read and analyze them for what they say.

Paul is speaking to Timothy saying But as for you He also speaks of continue in what you have learned and have firmly believed So here their is already a belief instilled in him(Timothy)Paul speaks of. Paul does not want timothy to abandon this belief because Paul says he knows where he(Timothy) learned it from knowing from whom you learned it and some thing even more interesting than that, he speaks of scripture. and how from childhood you have been acquainted with the sacred writings which are able to instruct you for salvation through faith in Christ Jesus. Not only were all the writings not written when this book was written, but Paul is speaking of the old testament writings. and how from childhood you(Timothy) have been acquainted with the sacred writings As a child timothy only had the old testament writings to rely on and Paul is speaking of them as sripture.

The passage you quote to us quite often 2 Tim. 3:16-17 All scripture is inspired by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness, that the man of God may be complete, equipped for every good work. has no bearing on what scripture is inspired and even less bearing on Sola Scriptura.
 
True, they are intertwined. But I wouldn’t even know about Jesus without the bible. Devotion to the bible can’t save your soul. Lots of JW’s are seriously devoted to the bible and remain lost. The bible by itself, without the power of the Holy Spirit, is not enough to save anyone.
You wouldn’t even know about the Bible, from which you learned about Jesus, if it wasn’t for the Catholic church, from which it came. And I think its ironic that you recognize that the JWs can’t interpret the bible appropriately to save them. What makes you so sure you are different from them. You are also separated from the Catholic church, which wrote and accurately interprets the bible. What makes you so sure your interpretation is more truthful than the JWs you condemn?
Lots of JW’s would say that when they embrace the Watchtower system (religion) they are embracing the Father. But what does Jesus say? “I am the way. No one comes to the Father except through me.”
Sure he says he’s the way the truth and the life. but he also said to St. Peter that he would built his church on him and gave him the keys to the kingdom of heaven He also commissioned the Chruch, through the Apostles to teach and baptize all the nations into his body the church and stated that he would be with the chruch until the end of time. By the way, we know who started the JWs , Charles Taze Russell around 1880. You can judge the organization by its founder. It can be shown through history that the Catholic church began with Jesus and the Apostles. When did your church start and by whom?
There is nothing about being loving, trying to avoid sin, doing acts of mercy and kindness, and following Jesus, that requires any kind of association with the CC. But all of these things are certain to be found in a person who has the spirit of God living inside. There is no religion that can ever be a substitute for genuine conversion of the heart and soul by the power of God.
Well, doing acts fo mercy, avoiding sin and loving are all following the natural law and can be done by all men. Accurately following Jesus requires teaching and includes partaking of the sacraments, which can only be found within the Catholic Church (and for the most part, its sister, the orthodox church) . No real religion is a substitute for a genuine conversion of heart. The true religion helps you achieve genuine conversion of the heart and soul by the power of God…
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top