Thousands protest over abortion legislation

  • Thread starter Thread starter IrishKnight
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Eminent Irish oncologist Dr John Crown has said: I don’t think I ever had a case where abortion was necessary to save mom
With all due respect to Dr. Crown, how is the opinion of an oncologist relevant?

I don’t support abortion, but why in the world are you quoting a cancer specialist?
 
You don’t understand. I accept your statement that few abortions are done in order to save the life of the mother. If Ireland has legalized abortion only in the cases where the mother’s life is in danger, there will be few abortions, by your own premise. That there was never an abortion done to save the life of the mother in the whole history of medicine is pretty idealistic, though.
What Abyssinia means is that an abortion is never needed to save the life of a mother. In the case that a child is compromising a woman’s health, there is always some OTHER external reason why it is so. And the treatment of that external reason of the mother may lead to the loss of the child. But it is my understanding that the Church does not consider secondary deaths of unborn children as a result of treatment of the mother’s medical condition to be an abortion. An abortion is the killing of the child as “treatment” for the mother, a “treatment” that is never required.
 
Our Lady of Knock, please pray for Ireland!

Saint Patrick, adopted son of Ireland, please pray for them!

Lord have mercy on Ireland,
amen.

mlz
 
What Abyssinia means is that an abortion is never needed to save the life of a mother. In the case that a child is compromising a woman’s health, there is always some OTHER external reason why it is so. And the treatment of that external reason of the mother may lead to the loss of the child. But it is my understanding that the Church does not consider secondary deaths of unborn children as a result of treatment of the mother’s medical condition to be an abortion. An abortion is the killing of the child as “treatment” for the mother, a “treatment” that is never required.
I can’t accept the statement that “an abortion is **never **needed to save the life of a mother”. The Church acknowledges that there **are **such cases. There may be a few instances e.g. an ectopic (tubal) pregnancy where the removal of the Fallopian tube—to treat the condition and save the life of the mother–results in the loss of the fetus. This is not considered abortion, yet the death of the fetus is the end result.

I don’t know what you mean by an “external reason” and that there is **always **an “external reason” why a fetus is threatening the life of the mother. In an ectopic pregnancy, the baby **is **the reason. You are probably thinking of a case like uterine cancer, where the removal of the uterus to treat the woman’s cancer also results in the death of the fetus.

My one complaint about the Church in this area is that “Jane Ordinary Catholic” has to go through a lot of esoteric rules to help her make a critical decision: “When is an abortion not an abortion?” You have to be a Doctor of the Church with a degree in medicine to figure some of this stuff out. But such a decision is usually made under a lot of stress and usually with a critical time element. I don’t envy any woman facing such a situation.
 
I can’t accept the statement that “an abortion is **never **needed to save the life of a mother”. The Church acknowledges that there **are **such cases. There may be a few instances e.g. an ectopic (tubal) pregnancy where the removal of the Fallopian tube—to treat the condition and save the life of the mother–results in the loss of the fetus. This is not considered abortion, yet the death of the fetus is the end result.

I don’t know what you mean by an “external reason” and that there is **always **an “external reason” why a fetus is threatening the life of the mother. In an ectopic pregnancy, the baby **is **the reason. You are probably thinking of a case like uterine cancer, where the removal of the uterus to treat the woman’s cancer also results in the death of the fetus.

My one complaint about the Church in this area is that “Jane Ordinary Catholic” has to go through a lot of esoteric rules to help her make a critical decision: “When is an abortion not an abortion?” You have to be a Doctor of the Church with a degree in medicine to figure some of this stuff out. But such a decision is usually made under a lot of stress and usually with a critical time element. I don’t envy any woman facing such a situation.
The removal of the Fallopian tube in the case of an ectopic pregnancy is not considered an abortion by the Church as the doctors are not removing the baby, they are removing what the baby needs to be in its mother for legitimate medical reasons. There is not one case in the history of mankind where an abortion was needed to save the life of a mother.

May I add, also, that doctors use the “life of the mother” argument to abort children before doing chemotherapy because the child would have a high chance of being born with a physical or mental disorder. A life with a disorder is greater than no life at all.
 
You don’t understand. I accept your statement that few abortions are done in order to save the life of the mother. If Ireland has legalized abortion only in the cases where the mother’s life is in danger, there will be few abortions, by your own premise. That there was never an abortion done to save the life of the mother in the whole history of medicine is pretty idealistic, though.
What are the credentials in this bill in order to get an abortion to save life of the mother?’
 
With all due respect to Dr. Crown, how is the opinion of an oncologist relevant?

I don’t support abortion, but why in the world are you quoting a cancer specialist?
Cancer can be one of the most serious diseases and if an oncologist doesn’t think there has been a case of a woman needing an abortion to treat her cancer, that is an important note in the debate about women’s health and abortion.
 
The removal of the Fallopian tube in the case of an ectopic pregnancy is not considered an abortion by the Church
Correct.
as the doctors are not removing the baby, they are removing what the baby needs to be in its mother for legitimate medical reasons.
I think I know what you’re saying: they are not removing the baby for the sake of removing the baby. They’re removing the baby and the tube that he/she was in for the health of the mother.
**There is not one case in the history of mankind **where an abortion was needed to save the life of a mother.
Now here’s where I have a problem. Man has been on the planet for about 300,000 years. The first abortion was ca. 1760 BCE. So, there has **never **been an abortion to save the life of the mother in the last 3,773 years? Just how old are you to know this??? 🙂
May I add, also, that doctors use the “life of the mother” argument to abort children before doing chemotherapy because the child would have a high chance of being born with a physical or mental disorder. A life with a disorder is greater than no life at all.
I have no doubt that many excuses have been used in order to procure an abortion. In the case of a pregnant woman who needs chemo, chemo is most devastating in the first trimester, when it can cause both internal and external birth defects. Chemo later in the pregnancy is also a tremendous risk. My interpretation is that the Church will not allow abortion at all in this circumstance. As far as the statement “A life with a disorder is greater than no life at all”, sorry, I disagree 100%, but this is an argument for another thread.
 
Now here’s where I have a problem. Man has been on the planet for about 300,000 years. The first abortion was ca. 1760 BCE. So, there has **never **been an abortion to save the life of the mother in the last 3,773 years? Just how old are you to know this??? 🙂
Because there is not one medical complication, illness, etc. in existence that would require the removal of the child while it is living. If a child dies as a result of treatment of the mother, that is not an abortion.
I have no doubt that many excuses have been used in order to procure an abortion. In the case of a pregnant woman who needs chemo, chemo is most devastating in the first trimester, when it can cause both internal and external birth defects. Chemo later in the pregnancy is also a tremendous risk. My interpretation is that the Church will not allow abortion at all in this circumstance. As far as the statement “A life with a disorder is greater than no life at all”, sorry, I disagree 100%, but this is an argument for another thread.
People have abortions in these cases so that they don’t give birth to so-called “defective” children. I have known of many stories of Catholic women giving birth to stillborns, let alone children with developmental disorders!! Who are we as women not to give those little ones their chance to live? I take issue that any child’s life is ‘defective’ :). Everyone only gets one life in this world, and that child deserves his or her spotlight in life, even if it’s only for one year, one month, or one day, or if they have to struggle during life. Think about it this way. Children with PKU (phenylketonuria) have a very tough time getting through life; their diet is extremely controlled, and if they deviate, they do severe neurological damage. Should we end their life in the maternity ward when they’re diagnosed?
 
It also allows abortions for rape and incest. It is the stepping stone for abortion on demand and their is no term limit so it can be done near birth. I forgot to clarify that, its sickening.
If it passed only northern Ireland and Malta will be abortion free in Europe.
 
Okay, if only a minute amount of abortions are done to save the life of the mother,*** that would mean there would be few abortions. *** If that is so, what’s the problem? The new law would save the lives of a couple of mothers. Did I miss something? :confused:
This is absolutely sick. “What’s a few dead children?”
 
You know, one thing that gets me about politicians inserting such “abortion in cases for the life of the mother” type things is that they will often be sure to word it in such a way that all a woman would have to do to qualify for this exception is to claim she’ll commit suicide if she doesn’t get an abortion. That is just stupidity. A woman who is suicidal doesn’t need her baby to be murdered. What she really needs is hospitalization until she is stable and then medication and therapy to help with whatever mental illness is causing the suicidality. If its not a mental illness causing the suicidality but is instead some situation such as an abusive household then she needs a social worker or something to help her get out of the situation causing her to despair. To sum it up, a suicidal pregnant woman does not need an abortion!!! What she needs is help so that she is no longer suicidal!

That said, I will concur with others who have said that abortion is never needed to save the life of the mother. There has never been such a case in all of history that I know of.
 
It’s unfortunately likely to pass the Dail, even with the opposition of the 10 Deputies from Fine Gael, Sinn Fein and pretty much most of Fianna Fail. The Government has too large a majority.

The next step is to send it to the Seanad. Unlike the US Senate, they may only delay the passage of a bill, not blcok it entirely. But they can refer the matter to the President and recommend a referendum be held on the issue.

The sad thing is that Fine Gael is supposedly a Christian Democratic party, and that the Taoiseach promised the voters that if they kicked out Fianna Fail from power, he would under no circumstances referse pro-life legislation.
 
Sacred Heart of Jesus,
Turn Ireland back to you. Amen.

Lord, have mercy! + 😦
 
Okay, if only a minute amount of abortions are done to save the life of the mother, that would mean there would be few abortions. If that is so, what’s the problem? The new law would save the lives of a couple of mothers. Did I miss something? :confused:
NeedsMercy, you are talking about innocent little babies here. New life created by God. All life is precious. Why is the mother’s life deserving of being saved but not the baby’s? Why is it ok to just kill a baby without a second thought, but, the mother’s life must be saved at all cost? Why the preferential treatment? An unborn baby deserves life just as his mother does. All attempts should be made to save the lives of both mother and baby. One life is not more precious than another.
 
maybe its time for the Consecration of IRELAND to Mary’s Immaculate Heart…
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top