Torture American Style

  • Thread starter Thread starter Debunkerman
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
40.png
Debunkerman:
I asked how do we know, the people held there are illegal combatants and highly dangerous?
Who’s “we?”

Do you expect classified information to be published in the Sunday Supplement?

Most of them were taken arms in hand. Others were tracked down by Miltary Intelligence.
40.png
Debunkerman:
You are now saying “most of them” which is different. Is it possible some of these captives are innocent?
This is a war. “Innocent” no more applies to those people than to the German troops we captured in WWII.

We process the detainees, which includes questionning them, collating information and interpreting it. Some are more dangerous than others. Those who turn out to be unimportant are turned loose.
40.png
Debunkerman:
How do you know “most of them” were fighting our troops?
When they’re taken arms in hand, there can be little doubt.
40.png
Debunkerman:
How do you define “the war is over” against the abstract noun, “terrorism”?
How do you justify such a silly question?
40.png
Debunkerman:
Please define “illegal combatant.”
Read the Geneva convention – a person who engages in combat operations and who is not under a command responsible for his actions. Terrorists and their supporters are by definition illegal combatants.

If you disagree, tell me the National Command Authority whom we can hold responsible for their crimes.
40.png
Debunkerman:
The Military Tribunal at Nuremberg called the waging of aggressive war “essentially an evil thing . . . to initiate a war of aggression . . . is not only an international crime; it is the supreme international crime differing only from other war crimes in that it contains within itself the accumulated evil of the whole.” The nations of Afghanistan and Iraq did not attack the United States. Our army invaded these countries. What is the difference between a legal combatant and an illegal combatant?
lewrockwell.com/orig6/gaddy3.html
You’re a sea lawyer?http://forums.catholic-questions.org/images/icons/icon12.gif
 
vern humphrey:
You’re not alone. Torture is absolutely, morally wrong. It is also counter-productive.

Those who debate what torture is are simply wrong. Torture must be rejected out of hand – and if there’s a question about, “Is this torture or not?” the answer must be, “It is. Stop it immediately.”
Yes, but there are those who consider sleep deprivation and hard-line interogation to be torture. There are those who would consider the things that happen in Fraternity hazings to be torture. I think an objective standard needs to be defined, but the military must have some latitude as to how they obtain vital information from hostile and resistant enemy combatants. Lives usually depend on it.
 
40.png
Scott_Lafrance:
Yes, but there are those who consider sleep deprivation and hard-line interogation to be torture. There are those who would consider the things that happen in Fraternity hazings to be torture. I think an objective standard needs to be defined, but the military must have some latitude as to how they obtain vital information from hostile and resistant enemy combatants. Lives usually depend on it.
Sleep deprivation is torture. It can have serious psychological effects.

On a more practical level, a person under torture – and that includes sleep deprivation – will tell the interrogator what he wants to hear – which may have no relation at all to the truth.

Sleep deprivation adds another dimension. A person suffering from sleep deprivation loses touch with reality – just as a person who is dreaming does.
 
vern humphrey:
Who’s “we?” The American people. How do they know the people held there are illegal combatants and highly dangerous?
vern humphrey:
Do you expect classified information to be published in the Sunday Supplement?
Yes. Evidence of guilt or innocence should not be secret. People should never be imprisoned for years without end based on “secret evidence” you call “classified.”
vern humphrey:
Most of them were taken arms in hand. Others were tracked down by Miltary Intelligence.
Is there any proof of this?
vern humphrey:
When they’re taken arms in hand, there can be little doubt.
Do you have proof or is this a religious belief?
vern humphrey:
How do you justify such a silly question?
What is silly about asking How do you define “the war is over” against the abstract noun, “terrorism”? since you said this is when the captives will be released and allowed to go home. This is not a “silly question” to an innocent prisoner, or their mother, sons, daughters or loved ones. It would not seem silly if you were unjustly imprisoned until “the war is over.” How can you be certain that not one innocent person is being held?
 
vern humphrey:
I mentioned the impact these techniques had on the Irish detainees upon whom they were tried, did I not?

If I said pulling out fingernails was torture, would you demand “support” for that statement?
You did not specify and show the direct link. I need to see more homework.
 
Scott Waddell:
You did not specify and show the direct link. I need to see more homework.
One very good open source that I can recommend is the back issues of An Phoblacht.
 
40.png
Debunkerman:
The American people. How do they know the people held there are illegal combatants and highly dangerous?

Yes. Evidence of guilt or innocence should not be secret. People should never be imprisoned for years without end based on “secret evidence” you call “classified.”
And in the next section of the Sunday Supplement, we should print detailed instructions on how to make nuclear weapons, nerve gas and precision guidance systems, right?
40.png
Debunkerman:
Is there any proof of this?

Do you have proof or is this a religious belief?
When you accuse this country of wrong-doing, where is your proof? Or is this a double standard?

I still have many contacts in the service. I talk to people who actually captured some of these terrorists.

What do you have?
40.png
Debunkerman:
What is silly about asking How do you define “the war is over” against the abstract noun, “terrorism”? since you said this is when the captives will be released and allowed to go home.
What’s silly is that murder is not an abstraction.

These are dangerous people and can be released only when we are assured of the safety of such an act.
40.png
Debunkerman:
This is not a “silly question” to an innocent prisoner, or their mother, sons, daughters or loved ones. It would not seem silly if you were unjustly imprisoned until “the war is over.” How can you be certain that not one innocent person is being held?
How can you be certain that if we follow your philosophy not one innocent person will be killed by these people?
 
40.png
shockerfan:
BTW, the Geneva Convention does not apply to enemy combatants. That does not imply my endorsement of true torture, its just saying that people that complain about the Geneva Convention not being enforced, don’t understand the Genveva Convention.
Almost right, the Geneva Convention applies to members of the military or recognized countries, not terrorist organizations. NONE of the detainees are covered by the convention. We would be within our rights to hold trials in Iraq for anyone caught fighting for Osama, then executing them on the spot. Remember those old movies showing pirates getting hung for a ship after they were caught? Those laws are still in effect. I believe the officer needs to be an 0-6 to issue a death sentence in time of war. Not done very often because of the availability of more thorough courts, but still an option.
 
40.png
Debunkerman:
How do they know *the people held there are illegal combatants and highly dangerous?
*

When they return fire with a weapon, they are enemy combatants.
40.png
Debunkerman:
Yes. Evidence of guilt or innocence should not be secret. People should never be imprisoned for years without end based on “secret evidence” you call “classified.”
Secret to whom. Not all information is for public knowledge. Some of that knowledge comes from places where friends of mine WILL die if it is discovered. The judge/court is the only one who needs access to the information, along with the proper security classification.
 
40.png
mjdonnelly:
When they return fire with a weapon, they are enemy combatants.
Secret to whom. Not all information is for public knowledge. Some of that knowledge comes from places where friends of mine WILL die if it is discovered. The judge/court is the only one who needs access to the information, along with the proper security classification.

I said it was a silly question, but it’s getting downright surreal.
 
Do you know whats really sad? Throughout this topic we’ve heard about sleep deprivation, white noise, force feeding what the military is allowed or not allowed to do. We have heard about what is or is not secret, what the President thinks, what the politicians think, what the military think, what everybody on this forum thinks; guess what nobody’s mentioned?

What would Jesus think!

Catholics? …maybe…
 
vern humphrey:
One very good open source that I can recommend is the back issues of An Phoblacht.
That’s a bit…err… socialist for you, isn’t it Vern? 😉

Mike
 
40.png
geezerbob:
Most of them, if I recall correctly, were captured in Afghanistan, and were fighting our troops. They can go home just as soon as the terrorists quit doing what they’re doing. Just like POW’s (which they’re not), they can go as soon as the war is over.
Which it isn’t going to be, even on Mr Cheney’s estimate, for at least ten years - and given I don’t see terrorism ever being completely eliminated, given it has always been with us, that would actually be for the rest of time.

Do you think it is right to hold people forever without charge? I don’t. I believe in habeas corpus.

More pragmatically, this policy is acting as a beacon for recruitment and support of the extremists, insurgents, and terrorists. Not a good plan.

Mike
 
Elaine's Cross:
Various organizations have studied the situation and concluded that 75-80% or more of those picked up in sweeps have nothing to do with terrorism. Yet, they are stressed, if not actually tortured, too.
The 9 British people ‘detained’ at Gitmo had a very brief chat to police when we got them back and were swiftly released within the day. Given the increasingly draconian and alarming powers the government is passing, there are all manner of things that could have been done to these people on British soil. But we assessed they posed little or no risk and let them go.

Three of them were accused by interrogators of appearing in a video with Osama Bin Laden in 2000 while they were demonstrably actually in Britain at the time. How many other people are being accused of things they didn’t do, with no opportunity to answer their accusers, in for example a fair trial?

Detaining people based solely on ‘intelligence’ is a very dangerous path - especially given the recent record of ‘intelligence’ services.

Mike
 
vern humphrey:
What’s silly is that murder is not an abstraction.

These are dangerous people and can be released only when we are assured of the safety of such an act. How can you be certain that if we follow your philosophy not one innocent person will be killed by these people?
“Terrorism,” “hate” and “poverty” are abstract. A war against “terrorism” does not have a tangible enemy like a specific people or a nation. It is not silly to ask how the end of such a war is defined. If “terrorism” will not come to a table to negotiate peace and sign a surrender document how will it end?

People should be imprisoned for crimes committed NOT for crimes they may commit.

I believe in Jesus. God cannot deceive or be deceived. Men can and do deceive. We can be fooled. When we kill one another we do not do what Jesus commanded us to do.

Rene Descartes said, “It is a mark of a prudence never to place complete trust in those who have deceived us even once.” The American press places fear of terrorism in the public mind and vilifies those we “should kill.” Fools trust the American press, wise men trust in God.
 
40.png
walstan:
What would Jesus think!
.
We know what Jesus would think.
I give you a new commandment: love one another; you must love one another just as I have loved you.
 
40.png
Debunkerman:
We know what Jesus would think.I give you a new commandment: love one another; you must love one another just as I have loved you.
If you could all just do us a favor and give us the proper theological definition of love now. Jesus loved the money-changers when he made a whip out of chords and drove them out of the temple.
 
40.png
mjdonnelly:
When they return fire with a weapon, they are enemy combatants.
How do we know that all of the prisoners at Bagram and Guantanamo returned fire with a weapon? I am asking where is this evidence? If they did “return fire” this implies they were fired upon in order to “return fire.” Is it possible they were defending themselves or their children? People should not be imprisoned forever without proof of guilt of some crime.
40.png
mjdonnelly:
Secret to whom. Not all information is for public knowledge. Some of that knowledge comes from places where friends of mine WILL die if it is discovered. The judge/court is the only one who needs access to the information, along with the proper security classification.
All Americans look guilty in the eyes of our fellow man when we tolerate secret trials and secret evidence. Your friends should come into the light. They don’t need a security clearance to stand with Jesus. I have come into the world as light, to prevent anyone who believes in me from staying in the dark anymore. John 12:46
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top