Torture American Style

  • Thread starter Thread starter Debunkerman
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
40.png
Asking:
How do we know if they were terrorists or just people defending themseles, or their country?

In the 70´s my country was ruled by a dictator, quite evil, he killed more than 30.000 of his own people.

But If my country had been invaded back then, I guess I would have fought for my country agaisnt the invaders.
Would that mean that I was a terrorist?
The difference is whether you are a uniformed, or non-uniformed combatant, as well as the tactics used in battle. Here are some definitions:

A soldier (uniformed military):
  • In uniform: Wear distinctive clothing making them recognizable as soldiers from a distance.
  • Openly bearing arms: Carrying guns or small arms and not concealing them.
  • Under officers: Obedient to a chain of command ending in a political leader or government.
  • Fighting according to the laws of war: Not committing atrocities or crimes, not deliberately attacking civilians or engaging in terrorism.
A Non-uniformed Guerilla (such as a civilian who takes up arms):
  • That of being commanded by a person responsible for his subordinates;
  • That of having a fixed distinctive sign recognizable at a distance;
  • That of carrying arms openly;
  • That of conducting their operations in accordance with the laws and customs of war." (From Article 4)
Unlawful Combatant:
This Describes a person who engages in combat without meeting the requirements for a lawful belligerent according to the laws of war as specified in the Third Geneva Convention. Countries that identify such unlawful combatants may not necessarily accord them the rights of prisoners of war described in the Third Geneva Convention, though they retain rights under the Fourth Geneva Convention in that they must be “treated with humanity and, in case of trial, shall not be deprived of the rights of fair and regular trial”.

A Terrorist would be an unlawful combatant, who commits acts of war against a civilian population, or other illegal acts against non-combatants (beheading prisoners would be a good example).
 
We had many dictators during the 70´s, and early 80´s, the army, navy, and air force had their own dictators too, who co-ruled, but the most important who was there for the longest time one was Videla.

I mean Argentina in the 70´s, the dictatorship ended after the loss in the Falklands war.

Untill the Falklands war the government was allied to the USA, in fact, almost all the 30.000 people killed were university professors, students, union workers, suspected of being communists or peronists ( an outlawed populist party which now is in power).

The would kidnap the people from their houses, or form the university, with no trial, put them inside containers, and throw them from helicopters into the ocean.

Do you think it is not terrorism as long as the government is allied to the USA and those who die are commies?
 
40.png
Asking:
Do you think it is not terrorism as long as the government is allied to the USA and those who die are commies?
By asking that question, you imply we would answer in the affirmative and support such terrorism.

I suggest you rephrase your remarks.
 
40.png
Asking:
We had many dictators during the 70´s, and early 80´s, the army, navy, and air force had their own dictators too, who co-ruled, but the most important who was there for the longest time one was Videla.

I mean Argentina in the 70´s, the dictatorship ended after the loss in the Falklands war.

Untill the Falklands war the government was allied to the USA, in fact, almost all the 30.000 people killed were university professors, students, union workers, suspected of being communists or peronists ( an outlawed populist party which now is in power).

The would kidnap the people from their houses, or form the university, with no trial, put them inside containers, and throw them from helicopters into the ocean.

Do you think it is not terrorism as long as the government is allied to the USA and those who die are commies?
So this is the fault of the US?
 
Ani Ibi:
So this is the fault of the US?
Everything is the fault of the US. Without the US, there would be no crime, no poverty, no terrorism. It was the US that committed Original Sin, you know.
 
vern humphrey:
Everything is the fault of the US. Without the US, there would be no crime, no poverty, no terrorism. It was the US that committed Original Sin, you know.
Is that in the Constitution? :rotfl:
 
40.png
Scott_Lafrance:
While I agree, studies have shown that hugging suicidal terrorist to be ineffective in curtailing their behavior.
I hear the term “suicidal terrorist” almost daily from the news media. The “suicidal terrorist” is someone generally accepted to exist because we are incessently told they exist and want to kill us.

One of the best known and most publicized examples of “suicidal terrorists” was the mass murder of almost 3000 Americans on September 11, 2001. However, much less publicized news reports from the NY Times and BBC News have reported that some of these “suicidal terrorists” are alive and well.
news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle_east/1559151.stm

This violates a first principle of rational reasoninn that a thing cannot both be and not be at the same time. If we have not been told the truth about “suicidal terrorists” we would be wise to wonder what else we may have been told that is false
 
I was disugusted at seeing the pictures of the acts of torture from both the US and UK army, it was shocking, especially the ones where they seemed to be doing it just for a joke. As for terrorism, I am sure that if one takes it from a particular point of view Blair and Bush could both be accused of being terrorists, the war has caused terror, and has caused terror under questionable motives, terror that could have been avoidable and “the main goal” (if we really know what that was) acheived without violence.
 
Ani Ibi:
So now you are talking about imprisonment. I thought the thread was about torture. Since you have changed the subject, I am forced to assume you have conceded that the American authorities are responding in a responsible fashion to allegations of torture in their ranks. Are you starting a new thread?
No. This is not a new thread. Inmates imprisoned by our troops are tortured. haveeru.com.mv/?page=engdetails&id=5879
It is cruel to secretly hold people indefinitly in prisons without even releasing the names of the captives. Who can advocate for the release of captives who are secret.
Ani Ibi:
The darkness? Are you making a point? If so, would you clarify?
Yes I am making a point that evil deeds seek the cover of darkness and honorable deeds can withstand scrutiny in the light. We would not be hiding our deeds, including the names of captives if were not ashamed of how we treat our prisoners. Keeping prisoners at off shore military intstallations invites abuse because wrong-doing is beyond the law. It is wrong and we should not tolerate government torture of prisoners. What we allow to be done to others may someday be done to us.
Men have preferred the darkness because their deeds were evil. -John 3:19
 
40.png
Debunkerman:
I hear the term “suicidal terrorist” almost daily from the news media. The “suicidal terrorist” is someone generally accepted to exist because we are incessently told they exist and want to kill us.

One of the best known and most publicized examples of “suicidal terrorists” was the mass murder of almost 3000 Americans on September 11, 2001. However, much less publicized news reports from the NY Times and BBC News have reported that some of these “suicidal terrorists” are alive and well.
news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle_east/1559151.stm

This violates a first principle of rational reasoninn that a thing cannot both be and not be at the same time. If we have not been told the truth about “suicidal terrorists” we would be wise to wonder what else we may have been told that is false
I hear the term “elderly” almost daily from the news media. The “elderly” is someone generally accepted to exist because we are incessently told they exist and need medical care and so on which me must provide.

However, much less publicized news reports from the NY Times and BBC News have reported that some people are actually new-born babies.

This violates a first principle of rational reasoninn that a thing cannot both be and not be at the same time. If we have not been told the truth about the “elderly” we would be wise to wonder what else we may have been told that is false?
See how silly this is?

Do you claim the terrorists on board the aircraft hijacked on 9/11 did not commit suicide?

Or do you claim they were not terrorists?

Do you deny that people have strapped explosives to their bodies and walked into crowds or got in line with other people and detonated those explosives?

What is your point?
 
Ani Ibi:
How can you be certain that not one guilty person is being held?
We can be more certain when people are given a fair public trial and evidence of guilt or innocence is presented in the open for everyone to see.

I wonder what Elmer “Geronimo” Pratt, the decorated Vietnam veteran and Black Panther leader would say. Mr. Pratt was released from prison a few years ago after serving 27 years in prison. Our government framed Elmer Pratt and false witnesses testified against him to convict him of a murder he did not commit.

Americans did not care about the innocence of Elmer Pratt while he was in prison. Americans knew he was “guility” because he had been convicted of murder. Surely Elmer Pratt always knew he was innocent and God knew he was innocent even if we did not.
 
40.png
Debunkerman:
We can be more certain when people are given a fair public trial and evidence of guilt or innocence is presented in the open for everyone to see.
Because they’re held as illegal combatants. They aren’t charged with crimes (although some may be.) We hold them because they’re dangerous.

Trials would require us to make public everything we know - including a lot of stuff that would hurt us if the enemy knew about it.
40.png
Debunkerman:
I wonder what Elmer “Geronimo” Pratt, the decorated Vietnam veteran and Black Panther leader would say. Mr. Pratt was released from prison a few years ago after serving 27 years in prison. Our government framed Elmer Pratt and false witnesses testified against him to convict him of a murder he did not commit.

Americans did not care about the innocence of Elmer Pratt while he was in prison. Americans knew he was “guility” because he had been convicted of murder. Surely Elmer Pratt always knew he was innocent and God knew he was innocent even if we did not.
I wonder what the Groene family, the family that was massacred by a sexual predator out on parole would say. The man who wiped out that family, taking two children with him, raping them both and killing one – leaving a little girl as the only survivor – was released opn bail while awaiting sentencing to prison
See how silly this is?

I take it by your radical change of subject from torture to the case of Elmer Pratt, you have conceded the argument.
 
40.png
Scott_Lafrance:
That all depends. Do I have specific knowledge of a plan to detonate a portable nuclear device in downtown Manhattan? “Do unto others” take on a whole new meaning when you are dealing with the lives of 10 million people.
What, are you suggesting we should give into the ‘Dirty Harry Syndrome’. If someone elses life is at stake, we should torture them even though torture is generally ineffective?
 
40.png
wabrams:
What, are you suggesting we should give into the ‘Dirty Harry Syndrome’. If someone elses life is at stake, we should torture them even though torture is generally ineffective?
Torture is ineffective – and most especially in a case like the scenario presented (an immediate threat.)
 
Scott Waddell:
I want to be on your side, but you need to support these statements. Otherwise they are just dead-stick opinions and you are right–there is no debate, just a bunch of triumphal declarations.

Scott
No, Vern’s correct on this. If you want some hard evidence that torture doesn’t work, go take some Criminal Justice courses. You intro law and police method course teach how torture doesn’t work and why we have Miranda and so forth, to prevent torture.
 
Ani Ibi:
When the terrorists come to the table to negotiate a peace and sign a surrender document – or when the terrorists are eliminated.
Before you eliminate people, I think it would be wise to be very certain that you are not being fooled into killing innocent people. We killed a lot of innocent people before by dehumanizing them and calling them “the enemy.”

We have taken the path to eliminate people before. Did you read the account of Cotton Hildreth that I posted earlier?
dcdave.com/article1/061098.html
Did you see the picture of his grandchildren?
 
40.png
wabrams:
No, Vern’s correct on this. If you want some hard evidence that torture doesn’t work, go take some Criminal Justice courses. You intro law and police method course teach how torture doesn’t work and why we have Miranda and so forth, to prevent torture.
If you want confessions, torture is an ideal method – if you don’t care whether the accused is guilty or not.

Films of the “show trials” in Russia in the 1930s show people confessing to things they didn’t do – and couldn’t possibly have done. There are even instances of people tearfully apologizing for acts they couldn’t possibly have committed – knowing they would be executed.

But if you want accurate, reliable information, torture, drugs and sleep deprivation are not the way to go.
 
vern humphrey:
Do you claim the terrorists on board the aircraft hijacked on 9/11 did not commit suicide?
Since the discussion is about torture and some are justifying locking up people in secret because they may be “suicidal terrorists” your question is a good one.

I am supplying links to seldom repeated and little known news reports that the “dead hijackers” according to the official 911 Report are in fact alive.
news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle_east/1559151.stm

portal.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2001/09/23/widen23.xml

Clearly if some of the people we have been told committed the mass murder of September 11th are alive someone other than them was responsible. Why is there no interest in knowing who committed these horrible crimes? Why do we continue to pretend that the 19 people officially named as responsible are guilty if some of them are alive? I do not have answers. Like you, I am asking questions especially since the 9-11 event has been a catalyst for war and so much misery, including torture.
 
40.png
Debunkerman:
I hear the term “suicidal terrorist” almost daily from the news media.
I have not heard the term ‘suicidal terrorist’ but I have heard the term ‘suicide bomber.’
40.png
Debunkerman:
The “suicidal terrorist” is someone generally accepted to exist because we are incessently told they exist and want to kill us…news reports from the NY Times and BBC News have reported that some of these “suicidal terrorists” are alive and well.
Yes, for some time we have been hearing the term ‘suicide bomber.’ And this has put the emphasis on the suicidal or – perhaps the sacrificial – nature of the final acts on Earth of those who would strap themselves to bombs or similar ordinance.

Some of these avowed bombers, as you rightfully point out, have survived. The second round of London bombers, for example, survived because, for various reasons, their bombs did not explode. Other bombers merely had to live with plans being changed.

At some point there was a movement afoot to change the terminology from ‘suicide bomber’ to ‘homicide bomber.’ No matter what term is used, however, the people in question are still bombers or would-be bombers and the principle of respect for human life remains at issue.

Moreover, one is confronted with the reality that many ‘would-be suicide bombers’ become ‘suicide bombers’ by virtue of succeeding in their plans, their plans being to approach non-combatants and combatants alike by means of stealth – misrepresenting themselves as non-combatants – and then exploding their bombs with lethal intent. It seems that some infrastructure also suffers as a result and that result harms non-combatants.
40.png
Debunkerman:
This violates a first principle of rational reasoninn that a thing cannot both be and not be at the same time.
Yes, that’s true. It might help clarity therefore if the term ‘would-be suicide bomber’ is used for those who did not get to carry out their plans to fruition. Or, as Proelium Frater has helpfully suggested, let’s call them them by their legal name which is ‘unlawful combatants.’ Proelium Frater’s terminology seems very useful all round actually: Soldier (uniformed military); Non-uniformed Guerilla; and Unlawful Combatant.
40.png
Debunkerman:
If we have not been told the truth about “suicidal terrorists” we would be wise to wonder what else we may have been told that is false
What do you propose has been said about ‘would-be suicide bombers’ or ‘suicide bombers’ or 'unlawful combatants which is false?
 
40.png
Libero:
I was disugusted at seeing the pictures of the acts of torture from both the US and UK army.
So let me weigh in on the subject of this thread. I oppose torture. It is morally repugnant to me. Moreover it is counterproductive. Imho, those engaged in torture are engaged in a self-indulgent activity which withholds energies otherwise available for a legitimate war effort, a legitimate humanitarian effort, or any legitimate effort. It wastes time, resources, energy, and lives to ends which cannot be justified. Many who survive commit suicide or, at best, limp along lives half-lived.

Raising consciousness about torture and bringing torturers to justice is an intergenerational struggle. We saw progress in the time between Canada in Somalia and the US in Abu Graib. And we saw progress in the time between Amnesty International first considering the option of lobbying to prosecute domestic torture laws and the present day, when domestic torture and stranger-on-stranger torture cases are portrayed as routine in the media.

Having said that, I guess I would pretty well want to have a reasonable suspicion that torture as defined by statute and convention is actually taking place before making any allegations. If we bandy that term about, then those who are unfortunate enough to be victims run the risk of not being taken seriously. And that is hurtful.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top