Trusting the Catholic Church

  • Thread starter Thread starter Truthstalker
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Currently I’m reading Augustine’s Confessions slowly, City of God, McGrath’s Iustitia Dei, and Schaff’s history series.
For questions relating to ecumenism from a Catholic perspective, I would strongly recommend the work of Yves Congar. I find all of that French gang to be great (Congar, Danielou, De Lubac, Bouyer), but Congar is perhaps the most relevant here, and along with De Lubac probably the most theologically influential.

Lesslie Newbigin’s *Household of God *and Robert Jenson’s Unbaptized God are interesting works from the Protestant perspective.

Edwin
 
What about the majority who do? How does that perception affect them?
It seems Truthstalker believes Protestants who point to the exception as the rule is a problem on Catholics’ end.

But as I said in an earlier post, the nature of Judas diffuses all of the “untrustworthy” fallacies in the OP. The exception does not smother the reality. One must be able to counter the authentic teachings of the Church in order to neuter it.
 
joe370;3640285Also:
No. Two reasons:
  1. I meant he strikes me as perhaps the greatest pope since Gregory the Great. He may be able to undo the damage many of his predecessors have done. In other words, I have a very high opinion of him.
  2. As a Presbyterian I reject the concept of the papacy, so all of them are invalid.😃 No condemnation. But B16 has gotten my attention - from a very far distance.
Our theological differences are real.
 
For questions relating to ecumenism from a Catholic perspective, I would strongly recommend the work of Yves Congar. I find all of that French gang to be great (Congar, Danielou, De Lubac, Bouyer), but Congar is perhaps the most relevant here, and along with De Lubac probably the most theologically influential.

Lesslie Newbigin’s *Household of God *and Robert Jenson’s Unbaptized God are interesting works from the Protestant perspective.

Edwin
I’ve heard of Congar in connection with Thomism; the others are unfamiliar. What do they bring to the table? Is a short response such as can be attained in a post possible? I realize that may be like asking what “that Summa thing Aquinas wrote” is all about.
 
I’ve heard of Congar in connection with Thomism; the others are unfamiliar. What do they bring to the table? Is a short response such as can be attained in a post possible? I realize that may be like asking what “that Summa thing Aquinas wrote” is all about.
They were all good historical scholars, for one. De Lubac wrote a mammoth study of medieval exegesis and helped rehabilitate Origen. He is most famous perhaps for his book criticizing what had become the traditional Catholic concept of the “supernatural,” arguing that it was a late scholastic innovation (he wasn’t arguing for materialism but rather saying that earlier Christians saw everything as full of God’s presence–at least that’s how I understand it). I have not read this book myself, but it’s the one other people mention to me as his most distinctive contribution (I’ve read a lot of his historical work and some more general books about Catholicism). Danielou is primarily a historian of the early Church. Bouyer wrote a book called *The Church of God *which I find one of the most winsome overall presentations of Catholic ecclesiology.

Newbigin was a Congregationalist missionary and then one of the first bishops of the united Church of South India. He’s written a lot about missiology as well as ecumenism. Jenson is a Lutheran theologian on the Catholic side of that tradition. He’s one of the people who thinks that the classical concept of God as “timeless” and impassible needs to be abandoned (as “unbaptized”), but for my money he’s one of the most interesting and worthwhile of the theologians who argue this. (I find Moltmann very interesting too but have read less of him.)

Edwin
 
What about the killing of thousands of Catholics by the Protestants under the reign of Elizabeth I of England?
##** It’s mostly a myth, with just enough truth in it to require comment.**

Catholics were put to death under Queen Elizabeth (1558-1603) - but:
  • **some of them were by any interpretation guilty of treason, & fully deserved their punishment (which was thought up the Catholic Edward I, in 1283). Those Catholics involved in the Babington Plot of 1586 were traitors, not martyrs, & have never been listed as martyrs. **
  • **At the most, about 600 English Catholics from the period 1535 to 1680 have at one time or another been regarded as possible candidates for a cause of canonisation. 240 or so of these are not regarded as Venerable, nor is the fact of their martyrdom established. **
  • Of these, 190 from the period 1570-1602 are regarded as certainly martyrs, & are either Venerable, or Blessed, or Saint
  • **This figure does not include those put to death in Ireland - there are at most 257 people recognised as among the Irish Martyrs, most of them not from the reign of Elizabeth. **
  • **The above does not include those who were imprisoned because they were Catholics, but are not regarded as martyrs; nor those ruined by fines. So plenty of human suffering is not recorded - the same can be said of those Protestants who suffered for their convictions without dying in public. If we include all who suffered under Elizabeth for being Catholics, we must do likewise for the many Protestants not burned in England under her half-sister who died as prisoners for their faith. **
    So where did the figure of thousands come from ? AFAIK, from some 16th-century Spanish Trinitarian, who came up with a stat of 12,000 martyred Catholics. I don’t have his name, so it’s very difficult to trace the sources.
 
“So where did the figure of thousands come from ? AFAIK, from some 16th-century Spanish Trinitarian, who came up with a stat of 12,000 martyred Catholics. I don’t have his name, so it’s very difficult to trace the sources.”

Yeah, and we all know how honest protestants have been through the years regarding the Spanish inquisition:D

Who are you going to believe regarding historical events, impartial professional historians or the general public, catholic or protestant(s)? Quote from a non-catholic article; see link, "But in recent years the Inquisition has been subject to greater investigation. In preparation for the Jubilee in 2000, Pope John Paul II wanted to find out just what happened during the time of the Inquisition’s (the institution’s) existence. In 1998 the Vatican opened the archives of the Holy Office (the modern successor to the Inquisition) to a team of 30 scholars from around the world. Now at last the scholars have made their report, an 800-page tome that was unveiled at a press conference in Rome on Tuesday. Its most startling conclusion is that the Inquisition was not so bad after all. Torture was rare and only about 1 percent of those brought before the Spanish Inquisition were actually executed. As one headline read “Vatican Downsizes Inquisition.”

The amazed gasps and cynical sneers that have greeted this report are just further evidence of the lamentable gulf that exists between professional historians and the general public. The truth is that, although this report makes use of previously unavailable material, it merely echoes what numerous scholars have previously learned from other European archives. Among the best recent books on the subject are Edward Peters’s Inquisition (1988) and Henry Kamen’s The Spanish Inquisition (1997), but there are others. Simply put, historians have long known that the popular view of the Inquisition is a myth. So what is the truth…? Keeping in mind, this article is not from any catholic apologetic site.

nationalreview.com/comment/madden200406181026.asp

I’m pretty sure Truthstalker at this point is thinking, what does this have to do with the O.P.???
 
##** It’s mostly a myth, with just enough truth in it to require comment.**

Catholics were put to death under Queen Elizabeth (1558-1603) - but:
  • **some of them were by any interpretation guilty of treason, & fully deserved their punishment (which was thought up the Catholic Edward I, in 1283). Those Catholics involved in the Babington Plot of 1586 were traitors, not martyrs, & have never been listed as martyrs. **
  • **At the most, about 600 English Catholics from the period 1535 to 1680 have at one time or another been regarded as possible candidates for a cause of canonisation. 240 or so of these are not regarded as Venerable, nor is the fact of their martyrdom established. **
  • Of these, 190 from the period 1570-1602 are regarded as certainly martyrs, & are either Venerable, or Blessed, or Saint
  • **This figure does not include those put to death in Ireland - there are at most 257 people recognised as among the Irish Martyrs, most of them not from the reign of Elizabeth. **
  • **The above does not include those who were imprisoned because they were Catholics, but are not regarded as martyrs; nor those ruined by fines. So plenty of human suffering is not recorded - the same can be said of those Protestants who suffered for their convictions without dying in public. If we include all who suffered under Elizabeth for being Catholics, we must do likewise for the many Protestants not burned in England under her half-sister who died as prisoners for their faith. **
    So where did the figure of thousands come from ? AFAIK, from some 16th-century Spanish Trinitarian, who came up with a stat of 12,000 martyred Catholics. I don’t have his name, so it’s very difficult to trace the sources.
Heres something that might interest you.
mccarthy.montana.com/Articles/TheLastKing6.html
 
You said------So I ask Catholics how they plan to overcome these barriers if they really look for reunification and are not out simply to condemn Protestants. There’s been way too much of that on this Forum.

and----1) I meant he strikes me as perhaps the greatest pope since Gregory —the Great. He may be able to undo the damage many of his predecessors have done. In other words, I have a very high opinion of him.

and------2) As a Presbyterian I reject the concept of the papacy, so all of them are invalid. No condemnation. But B16 has gotten my attention - from a very far distance.

If you outright reject the papacy as invalid which is tantamount to saying, it’s logically inconsequential and useless in your mind, then why do you think b6 could perhaps be the greatest pope since Gregory the Great and why do you have a high opinion of b6, and have confidence that b6 with the C.C. will be able to undo the damage many of his predecessors have reputedly done?

How can the C.C. ever hope to overcome these barriers, in your mind if the papacy is invalid?

I consider sola scriptura utterly invalid and I totally reject this man-made doctrine and would never have a high opinion of it. If your really looking for reunification, you’ll never find it using sola scriptura and private interpretation; wouldn’t you agree? Do you appeal to the Presbyterian church as your sole authority, and ultimate interpreter or to sola scriptura as your sole authority with you as the ultimate interpreter? Without checks and balances, the institutional mechanism for preventing power abuse, disunity, division, dissension, and chaos, authority runs amok leading to disunity division, dissension, and chaos; all the things we see in the protestant churches. Do you really think it’s the responsibility of the C.C. to offer the olive branch and figure out a viable solution for the reunification of Christianity? Before the C.C. can do anything, the protestant churches must overcome their own inter-barriers, differences and division, and that will never happen.
 
It seems Truthstalker believes Protestants who point to the exception as the rule is a problem on Catholics’ end.

But as I said in an earlier post, the nature of Judas diffuses all of the “untrustworthy” fallacies in the OP. The exception does not smother the reality. One must be able to counter the authentic teachings of the Church in order to neuter it.
I agree.
But who turns their heads?, is it Apostolic Tradition to split and leave the Church. The Apostles very objectivly described Judas’s betrayal and his fate, they did not split into factions or new churches nor did they sink into anguish - they drew lots and replaced the one who fell, and continued their mission.
Maybe the devil turns peoples heads - no-one gains.
 
And your point is?
and my point is very obvious that The word “CATHOLIC CHURCH” is biblical and can be read in the bible:

ἐκκλησία= EKKLESIA means Church

καθ ολης= KAtholes=Catholic (James 1:1 -Douay Version- Catholic or Universal)

CATHOLIC from greek word:

kata (2596) (kat-ah’)- καθ’ κατ’ κατὰ -->A primary particle; (prepositionally) down (in place or time), in varied relations (according to the case (genitive, dative or accusative) with which it is joined) – about, according as (to), after, against, (when they were) X alone, among, and, X apart, (even, like) as (concerning, pertaining to touching), X aside, at, before, beyond, by, to the charge of, (charita-)bly, concerning, + covered, (dai-)ly, down, every, (+ far more) exceeding, X more excellent, for, from… To, godly, in(-asmuch, divers, every, -to, respect of),… By, after the manner of, + by any means, beyond (out of) measure, X mightily, more, X natural, of (up-)on (X part), out (of every), over against, (+ your) X own, + particularly, so, through(-oughout, -oughout every), thus, (un-)to(-gether, -ward), X uttermost, where(-by), with. In composition it retains many of these applications, and frequently denotes opposition, distribution, or intensity.(Link: strongsnumbers.com/greek/2596.htm)
Holos (3650) (hol’-os)
ὅλῃ ὅλην ὅλης ὅλον ὅλος ὅλου ὅλους ὅλῳ -->A primary word; “whole” or “all”, i.e. Complete (in extent, amount, time or degree), especially (neuter) as noun or adverb – all, altogether, every whit, + throughout, whole. (Link: strongsnumbers.com/greek/3650.htm)

Acts 9:42 And it was known throughout all Joppa; and many believed …
… γνωστὸν δὲ ἐγένετο καθ’ ὅλης τῆς] Ἰόππης καὶ ἐπίστευσαν πολλοὶ ἐπὶ τὸν κύριον. …
Acts 9:42 Multilingual: And it became known throughout all Joppa, and many believed in the Lord. - 44k

Acts 10:37 That word, I say, ye know, which was published …
… ὑμεῖς οἴδατε τὸ γενόμενον ῥῆμα καθ’ ὅλης τῆς Ἰουδαίας, ἀρξάμενος ἀπὸ τῆς …
Acts 10:37 Multilingual: you yourselves know what happened throughout all Judea, beginning from Galilee after the baptism that John proclaimed: - 51k
More results from Index of /multi/acts ]

Luke 4:14 And Jesus returned in the power of the Spirit into …
… καὶ φήμη ἐξῆλθεν καθ’ ὅλης τῆς περιχώρου περὶ αὐτοῦ. … …
Luke 4:14 Multilingual: And Jesus returned in the power of the Spirit to Galilee, and a report about him went out through all the surrounding country. - 50k

Luke 23:5 And they were the more fierce, saying, He stirreth up …
… οἱ δὲ ἐπίσχυον λέγοντες ὅτι ἀνασείει τὸν λαὸν διδάσκων καθ’ ὅλης τῆς Ἰουδαίας …
Luke 23:5 Multilingual: But they were urgent, saying, 'He stirs up the people, teaching throughout all Judea, from Galilee even to this place.' - 52k

Exodus 22:11 Then shall an oath of the LORD be between them both …
… ἀνὰ μέσον ἀμφοτέρων ἦ μὴν μὴ αὐτὸν πεπονηρεῦσθαι καθ’ ὅλης τῆς παρακαταθήκης τοῦ …
Exodus 22:11 Multilingual: an oath by the LORD shall be between them both to see whether or not he has put his hand to his neighbor's property. The owner shall accept the oath, and he shall not make restitution. - 45k

Numbers 4:16 And to the office of Eleazar the son of Aaron the …
… καὶ ἡ θυσία ἡ καθ’ ἡμέραν καὶ τὸ ἔλαιον τῆς χρίσεως ἡ ἐπισκοπὴ ὅλης τῆς σκηνῆς …
Numbers 4:16 Multilingual: And Eleazar the son of Aaron the priest shall have charge of the oil for the light, the fragrant incense, the regular grain offering, and the anointing oil, with the oversight of the whole tabernacle and all that is in it, of the sanctuary and its vessels.' - 50k (Link: bibleq.com/search?q=%CE%BA%CE…t_co llection)

Rom. 1:8 (NOVUM TESTAMENTUM GRAECE) “He pistis humon KATangeketai en HOLO to kosmo…”

“Cor ad cor loqvitvr”
-heart speaks to heart-

Thank you:)
 
You said------So I ask Catholics how they plan to overcome these barriers if they really look for reunification and are not out simply to condemn Protestants. There’s been way too much of that on this Forum.

and----1) I meant he strikes me as perhaps the greatest pope since Gregory —the Great. He may be able to undo the damage many of his predecessors have done. In other words, I have a very high opinion of him.

and------2) As a Presbyterian I reject the concept of the papacy, so all of them are invalid. No condemnation. But B16 has gotten my attention - from a very far distance.

If you outright reject the papacy as invalid which is tantamount to saying, it’s logically inconsequential and useless in your mind, then why do you think b6 could perhaps be the greatest pope since Gregory the Great and why do you have a high opinion of b6, and have confidence that b6 with the C.C. will be able to undo the damage many of his predecessors have reputedly done?

How can the C.C. ever hope to overcome these barriers, in your mind if the papacy is invalid?

I consider sola scriptura utterly invalid and I totally reject this man-made doctrine and would never have a high opinion of it. If your really looking for reunification, you’ll never find it using sola scriptura and private interpretation; wouldn’t you agree? Do you appeal to the Presbyterian church as your sole authority, and ultimate interpreter or to sola scriptura as your sole authority with you as the ultimate interpreter? Without checks and balances, the institutional mechanism for preventing power abuse, disunity, division, dissension, and chaos, authority runs amok leading to disunity division, dissension, and chaos; all the things we see in the protestant churches. Do you really think it’s the responsibility of the C.C. to offer the olive branch and figure out a viable solution for the reunification of Christianity? Before the C.C. can do anything, the protestant churches must overcome their own inter-barriers, differences and division, and that will never happen.
I probably won’t be posting over the next few days, but I thought I might throw some more your way, since you seem puzzled.

For one thing, it’s not an either/or: either the Pope is who he claims to be, or he is nothing. He is something. I don’t deny his existence. He occupies one of the most ancient episcopal chairs in the world, a center of power. Rome managed to fall on the right side in the great councilar debates, something I have noted in considerations of its claim towards doctrinal rightness. The pope is the head of some one billion Christians. I don’t deny his occupation of the bishopric of Rome. The Catholic Church has developed widely, from theology to art to science in an astonishing depth, width, height and breadth over the centuries. There is much that is beautiful, soaring, sublime and true in the Catholic Church. This particular pope seems very wise, very kind, very smart. Good selection, cardinals, at least so far.

The objection, I think, centers around the idea of the Church as something we belong to, with a direct knowledge of God, as opposed to something that mediates our relationship with God. I simply don’t need a pope to lead me into all truth. I trust the Holy Spirit for that. I am not there yet. I do not think the Catholic Church is there yet, either.

Part of the damage we are all suffering is the concept that theological time froze at the reformation. Catholics look back to Trent as reformers and Lutherans look back at their respective confessions. That was one day or week in the whole life of the church, and we need to move on into our high calling. To turn back to discussing the papacy, one of the 6 major items on the table between us, as an example of the issues that separate us, and not as a topic in itself, though it could be, I wonder if there could not be a synthesis that is palatable to all of us, a deeper understanding that transcends our differences, something that would allow the Catholic a greater depth of understanding while being acceptable to the Protestant, something that a Presbyterian could accept without giving up his integrity. Too often it seems that the Catholics want total surrender from the Protestants, without being willing to budge an inch. And then there is B-16, and that wonderful statement that CM posted, in which it seems that the war-cries often heard on CAF do not emenate so much from Rome as from some other source. We are brethren, for crying out loud, not enemies.

And if the Catholic Church is right, and the true church and all that, and the body of Christ, then yes it should and must take the lead in restoring the broken relationship. To reject Church teaching and say the Protestants will never reunite is a curious thing for a Catholic to say, a private interpretation if ever there was one. Rome has spoken; we will reunite. Quit trying to continue the separation. It is curious to me that I feel like I am closer to what Rome desires in this than many Catholics. The cafeteria is closed and the blame-game is over. That is what your pope is saying.
 
I probably won’t be posting over the next few days, but I thought I might throw some more your way, since you seem puzzled.

For one thing, it’s not an either/or: either the Pope is who he claims to be, or he is nothing. He is something. I don’t deny his existence. He occupies one of the most ancient episcopal chairs in the world, a center of power. Rome managed to fall on the right side in the great councilar debates, something I have noted in considerations of its claim towards doctrinal rightness. The pope is the head of some one billion Christians. I don’t deny his occupation of the bishopric of Rome. The Catholic Church has developed widely, from theology to art to science in an astonishing depth, width, height and breadth over the centuries. There is much that is beautiful, soaring, sublime and true in the Catholic Church. This particular pope seems very wise, very kind, very smart. Good selection, cardinals, at least so far.

The objection, I think, centers around the idea of the Church as something we belong to, with a direct knowledge of God, as opposed to something that mediates our relationship with God. I simply don’t need a pope to lead me into all truth. I trust the Holy Spirit for that. I am not there yet. I do not think the Catholic Church is there yet, either.

Part of the damage we are all suffering is the concept that theological time froze at the reformation. Catholics look back to Trent as reformers and Lutherans look back at their respective confessions. That was one day or week in the whole life of the church, and we need to move on into our high calling. To turn back to discussing the papacy, one of the 6 major items on the table between us, as an example of the issues that separate us, and not as a topic in itself, though it could be, I wonder if there could not be a synthesis that is palatable to all of us, a deeper understanding that transcends our differences, something that would allow the Catholic a greater depth of understanding while being acceptable to the Protestant, something that a Presbyterian could accept without giving up his integrity. Too often it seems that the Catholics want total surrender from the Protestants, without being willing to budge an inch. And then there is B-16, and that wonderful statement that CM posted, in which it seems that the war-cries often heard on CAF do not emenate so much from Rome as from some other source. We are brethren, for crying out loud, not enemies.

And if the Catholic Church is right, and the true church and all that, and the body of Christ, then yes it should and must take the lead in restoring the broken relationship. To reject Church teaching and say the Protestants will never reunite is a curious thing for a Catholic to say, a private interpretation if ever there was one. Rome has spoken; we will reunite. Quit trying to continue the separation. It is curious to me that I feel like I am closer to what Rome desires in this than many Catholics. The cafeteria is closed and the blame-game is over. That is what your pope is saying.
Well said…

“I wonder if there could not be a synthesis that is palatable to all of us, a deeper understanding that transcends our differences, something that would allow the Catholic a greater depth of understanding while being acceptable to the Protestant, something that a Presbyterian could accept without giving up his integrity.”

Me too!! I have a sister who is a non-denominationalist, for lack of a better word, and about 6 months ago she actually told me I was going to hell because I was a catholic; my point is, I think we have a very long road ahead of us in the unity department, but I will continue to pray that it comes sooner rather than later!

God bless…👍
 
You know, I admire the ‘trustingness’ of children, they will believe their parent with no trouble. Perhaps that is why ‘theirs is the Kingdom of Heaven’ is a revealed truth. There is no child who is not like that.
It gets more difficult, though, to move from unbelief to belief as one gets older, and also to move from tradition to tradition. The adult mind more often than not has to face pride. It cannot be seen to give - it must save face and come out of the contest feeling in its own mind at least as if it has bettered its opponent somehow to some satisfactory degree.
But, Truthstalker, the Catholic Church is never your opponent, it has always been your advocate, simply because it is the advocate of Truth. Truth came to you from its storehouse. It is not a question of us against them, *it * is something that belongs to you as much as it belongs to me. It is your spiritual ancestors spiritual home, it is where they came from. It is what they left, either willingly, or under some kind of duress, and that ‘leaving’ is your inheritance. 500 years of experimentation have led right back to its door again. But one cannot enter with the Truth which one wants, but rather, one must recieve the Truth as it always is. One must, perhaps, learn to be a child again - learn to trust.
 
Part of the damage we are all suffering is the concept that theological time froze at the reformation.
I think this is largely due to the inception of the printing press and the effects that the rapid transmission of information via quick duplication processes. It seems to have taken a ‘snap shot’ in time that is still intellectually held in mary parts of the world today. For that matter, even people who had not directly experienced Christianity were able to read in great detail what the various denominations taught, and this second-hand knowledge seem to have perpetuated many false memories too.

The mass produced printed words have rather effectively burned a memory into our minds that is exceptionally hard to erase precisely because so much material is out there. This isn’t to say that long-burned memories didn’t last a long time before the printing press was introduced. They most certainly did. But the inception of the printing press greatly augmented the persistence of everyone’s memories, for good or bad.

I would even argue that the whole idea of ‘bible alone’ teachings have been greatly proliferated by the printing press. The very fact that many could have the ‘bible alone’ without any recourse to any church seems to have led some to conclude that Bible was more reliable than the Church. Others, by using the intermingled sophistry of the secularism of the renaissance with Catholic doctrines concerning salvation, likewise felt that their understanding of the Bible, especially in light of the behavior of the Church, was better than the Church’s understanding-- precisely because they now had unhindered access to the Bible but did not have an unhindered access to the Church.

I could be wrong but I see a connection with the arrival of the printing press and the emergence of the bible alone doctrines.
 
You know, - learn to trust.
There are times when a wife is counseled not to return to the home where the husband abused her, when children are put in foster care, when an employee is fired, or one must quit a job, or a restraining order is put on someone, because of breach of trust that cannot be restored.

Sometimes I think that may be an underlying justification for the split. He may be her legal husband, or the child’s father, or whatever, but the relationship is broken and cannot be restored.

That may well describe the situation.
 
Jesus said “A good tree does not bear bad fruit.”

If indeed the Catholic Church is the church instituted by Christ it cannot teach evil mixed with the truth.

Can individuals in it do that? Yes.

Can the Pope ever do that? No.

Can its doctrine ever be wrong? No.

If it were to be wrong then it would be bad fruit.

Either Christ is true or not and either the Catholic Church is Jesus’ chruch or not.

There can be no inbetween.

The only one who wants to peddle the idea that Christ’s Church can bear bad fruit mixed with good fruirt is the devil.
 
I just read an article on B16’s visit to the US. For Catholics, I suppose, it is implicit to trust the Church.

Protestants think of trust and the Catholic church as antithetical. Calvin and Luther both thought of Hus’s betrayal. Calvin knew many reformers who were burned in France, which contributed to his anger against the Church. There is a long and sad history of Catholic malevolence against Protestants, too long to go into here. The point is that Protestants look at the historical record and conclude that the Church is untrustworthy.

Secondly, Protestants compare Church teachings against Scripture and conclude that the Church has added or ignored certain things. The conclusion is that the Church is untrustworthy as an interpreter of Scripture.

Thirdly, many Protestants have had extremely negative experiences with Catholics in their own lives. The people who have hurt me the most have been Catholics. Practicing Catholics have done the most damage. On a personal level Protestants find Catholics are untrustworthy.

Fourthly, Protestants visit Catholic churches and observe how Catholics behave during Mass: disrespectfully leaving after the Eucharist or talking or not participating, slovenly receiving the Eucharist and otherwise behaving in a less than impressive manner.

Fifthly, some of the most strident, over-the-top posters on this Forum are ignorant of Catholicism and totally ignorant of Protestant belief. Some have pushed me away from Catholicism because I certainly do not want to drink out of whatever well they are drinking from.

Sixthly, Protestants look at Catholic claims for unity. While there seems to be a Catechism, it is widely disregarded. Many Catholics, as polls indicate, disbelieve it: Catholics don’t believe their own faith. I have attended Catholic homilies and teachings that are counter to basic Christianity, let alone Catholicism. At the last Mass I attended the priest’s homily centered around the point that God did His part, now it is totally up to us. Claims to teach truth ring very hollow.

Seventhly, Catholics seem to put the onus for the separation entirely on Protestant shoulders. An examination of history reveals there were mistakes on both sides. If an army unit falls apart, who gets the most blame? The leader. Instead Catholics seem to see their Church as sinless in this and nothing but sin in reformers.

Eighthly, there have been numerous historical falsifications in the cause of Catholicism, including the Isidorian decretals and interpolations in ancient texts to benefit the Catholic cause. Catholics cannot be trusted, it seems, to present an honest case for their religion.

Ninthly, Protestants observe things such as the abuse scandal and how Church officials covered it up. Kudos to B-16, but it was an awfully late response.

If this thread goes the way of most threads, each of these points will be hotly challenged. Instead I ask Catholics to realize this is how Protestants view their church, and that these are problems Catholics must overcome if they ever hope for unity with their separated brethren. So I ask Catholics how they plan to overcome these barriers if they really look for reunification and are not out simply to condemn Protestants. There’s been way too much of that on this Forum.
TruthStalker,

Seems you are a stalker being here at this Catholic Forum. Remeber this is a Catholic forum. The things that I have been reading thus far is that the Catholic Church Is not condemning no Protestant but the Protestants are condmning the Catholic Church.

We here are defending the Catholic Church therefore you are here only to presecute the Catholic Church. But The Lord Has something for you and I know you feel it.

I see that you are a Truthseeker than a TruthStalker, Stalker reminds me more of the “night salker Richard Ramerez”

Howevever being the Truthseeker that I believe you are, you are at the right place to find it, “TRUTH” see you are here for a reason and that reason is for you to become Catholic, YES CATHOLIC you are not here by chance to presecute to grab a few points for the Protestan faith, you are here by the Grace of Jesus Christ who wants you to become Catholic. You can laugh all you want, say all you want, but you feel that calling the reason why you are here. You have said it yourself you even attended Mass. Who brought you there to Mass, your two feet? Jesus Has answered that for you it was he who brought you to Mass, surely was not the Devil. Though it was the Devil who has interfered with Gods plan for you becoming Catholic. Its the Devil that has you talking bad about the homilies as you mentioned above.

About the Scandals of the Catholic Church, There has been abuse since the begining, HOW SO, did not Judas betray our Lord now there is a scandal, what about Peter who denied Our Lord 1, 2, 3, times Not only Peter and Judas but all of the Apostle abandoned Our Lord, perhaps not John he was there at the Cross, He had to be there. Why? I tell you why, the truth is
Our Lord WANTED US TO KNOW that Virgin Mary is Our Mother
therefore John, You and I are brothers.

Getting Back to the Scandals, The Lord KNEW he was leaving his Catholic Church to sinful men and they perhaps would error form time to time as they did from the begining. But The Lord will protect the Catholic Churches Teachings for the Lord SAID not even the Gates of hell can prevail aganst it.

So go ahead throw all you can “Against It” you will not prevail get it out of your system and go to Mass Again, and truely listen to Jesus Calling, again it is the Only REASON WHYYOU ARE HERE.

I will pray for your journey Home

Ufamtobie
 
TruthStalker,

Seems you are a stalker being here at this Catholic Forum. Remeber this is a Catholic forum. The things that I have been reading thus far is that the Catholic Church Is not condemning no Protestant but the Protestants are condmning the Catholic Church.
That’s right!!
We here are defending the Catholic Church therefore you are here only to presecute the Catholic Church. But The Lord Has something for you and I know you feel it.
That is true my dear Brother…👍
I see that you are a Truthseeker than a TruthStalker, Stalker reminds me more of the “night salker Richard Ramerez”

Howevever being the Truthseeker that I believe you are, you are at the right place to find it, “TRUTH” see you are here for a reason and that reason is for you to become Catholic, YES CATHOLIC you are not here by chance to presecute to grab a few points for the Protestan faith, you are here by the Grace of Jesus Christ who wants you to become Catholic. You can laugh all you want, say all you want, but you feel that calling the reason why you are here. You have said it yourself you even attended Mass. Who brought you there to Mass, your two feet? Jesus Has answered that for you it was he who brought you to Mass, surely was not the Devil. Though it was the Devil who has interfered with Gods plan for you becoming Catholic. Its the Devil that has you talking bad about the homilies as you mentioned above.

About the Scandals of the Catholic Church, There has been abuse since the begining, HOW SO, did not Judas betray our Lord now there is a scandal, what about Peter who denied Our Lord 1, 2, 3, times Not only Peter and Judas but all of the Apostle abandoned Our Lord, perhaps not John he was there at the Cross, He had to be there. Why? I tell you why, the truth is
Our Lord WANTED US TO KNOW that Virgin Mary is Our Mother
therefore John, You and I are brothers.

Getting Back to the Scandals, The Lord KNEW he was leaving his Catholic Church to sinful men and they perhaps would error form time to time as they did from the begining. But The Lord will protect the Catholic Churches Teachings for the Lord SAID not even the Gates of hell can prevail aganst it.

So go ahead throw all you can “Against It” you will not prevail get it out of your system and go to Mass Again, and truely listen to Jesus Calling, again it is the Only REASON WHYYOU ARE HERE.

I will pray for your journey Home

Ufamtobie
And all of us here in Catholic Answers -Still hoping and Praying that all Protestant church might back again to the True Church Founded by Jesus Christ-the One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church…🙂
 
I just read an article on B16’s visit to the US. For Catholics,** I suppose**, it is implicit to trust the Church.
You suppose? Please! To dwell upon past wrongs is to cement your feet into what should have been instead of marching toward what will be. The past is a learning tool, not a place to live. Those who sinned either received forgiveness, or paid the eternal price.

Each of your eleven points, and innumerable others, have been heard over the past 2,000 years. None has any effect on the truth the church teaches, using sinful men, just as Christ did.

Christ founded one church. I sucked it up and joined.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top