B
bookgirl32
Guest
Yes, I got it. I understand what you believe. You have every right to believe this. What I don’t understand is why you picked the Catholic Church to be a member of, since you disagree so staunchly with it’s defined dogma.Actually, I do believe that grace rained on every single ensouled human being from the first moment our anscestors began to be ensouled.
But I believe that Eve is a hypothetical woman, written-about in a hypothetical to portray to us what each of WOULD do IF grace were not available; and that Adam is a hypothetical man, written-about to portray Christ taking our sins upon Himself.
It’s not sufficient to convey theological truth? What in the world was it for then? Entertainment?The Garden of Eden story is about the same speed as a Dr. Seuss story. It isn’t written with details sufficient to answer questions like the one you ask.
Yes, because the whole point of the story would’ve been to incorrectly portray the nature of sin so that we were all misled.Sin doesn’t really occur the way it is portrayed in the story.
A near occasion of sin is not a sin.A real Eve would have committed the first sin the instant she glanced at the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil, because she was entertaining a near occasion of sin.
Last I checked being subject to temptation was not a sin. Nor is honestly entertaining doubts about God. To decide, willyfully and with full knowledge, after entertaining these doubts, going to the source you know to be The Truth, and denying these truths, giving into the doubts, would be sinful. But not anything you described above.She would have committed another sin by listening to the serpent’s words after the first sentence. She committed another sin by taking the time to entertain doubts about God’s prohibitions.
Okay, there, now you have the sin part right.She committed another sin by forming the intent to reach for the fruit. She committed another sin by willing to reach for the fruit. She committed another sin by plucking it off the tree and bringing it to her mouth. The actual eating was only the last of many sins.
What exactly do you mean by “match Adam up with animals”?God is portrayed in a moronic fashion in the story, before Eve is pulled ftom Adam’s side: He tries to match Adam up with animals. That effort fails. God finally conceives of the idea of Eve.
If you mean that it is not to be used as a scientific text book, I completely agree with you. But the theological truth of original sin, according to the Church, demands an original pair of human parents. I understand that you don’t believe this, fine. But don’t deny that this is what the Church teaches.Do you see what I mean? Top to bottom, the story is a detail-less fable, not non-fiction. It is fiction teaching theology.
Or many. Do you realize how arrogant you sound?Good for you for that sentence referring to Purgatory. How many Catholics here understand the concept of purgation so well? Few, I bet.
Yes, when they hid from him. And when He kicked them out, b/c they were no longer able to be in His presence.Re your point, notice that God is with them in person AFTER the sin
And I’m supposed to care about what your aunt says because . . . ???My Aunt, who was head of the Dominican Ordeer of Nuns in the Western Hemisphere, and a theologian in Catholic University, used to say, “Don’t look to the Church for guidance on Scripture. It has only talked about 5% of it – maybe less.”
How so?If you believe in inspiration, it’s philosophically necessary. Every result of inspiration of the Magisterium would be “news” in theology.
A manifestation of the sensum fidelium would require more than just you, first of all, and would also require that the belief would not be in contradiction with already defined dogma. So if you’re using it to refer to your own belief, you’ve already disproved it.It’s a non-technical reference to the sensum fidelium.
Maybe you could look for the revealed truth guided and guarded by the Church Christ Himself established and assume, rightly, that it knows more than you do?When I see “X,” should I say, “Look! There’s ‘X’!”? Or should I say, “Look! There’s ‘Not-X’!”?