Was sexual PERVERSION the original sin?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ziggamafu
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Actually, I do believe that grace rained on every single ensouled human being from the first moment our anscestors began to be ensouled.

But I believe that Eve is a hypothetical woman, written-about in a hypothetical to portray to us what each of WOULD do IF grace were not available; and that Adam is a hypothetical man, written-about to portray Christ taking our sins upon Himself.
Yes, I got it. I understand what you believe. You have every right to believe this. What I don’t understand is why you picked the Catholic Church to be a member of, since you disagree so staunchly with it’s defined dogma.
The Garden of Eden story is about the same speed as a Dr. Seuss story. It isn’t written with details sufficient to answer questions like the one you ask.
It’s not sufficient to convey theological truth? What in the world was it for then? Entertainment?
Sin doesn’t really occur the way it is portrayed in the story.
Yes, because the whole point of the story would’ve been to incorrectly portray the nature of sin so that we were all misled.
A real Eve would have committed the first sin the instant she glanced at the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil, because she was entertaining a near occasion of sin.
A near occasion of sin is not a sin.
She would have committed another sin by listening to the serpent’s words after the first sentence. She committed another sin by taking the time to entertain doubts about God’s prohibitions.
Last I checked being subject to temptation was not a sin. Nor is honestly entertaining doubts about God. To decide, willyfully and with full knowledge, after entertaining these doubts, going to the source you know to be The Truth, and denying these truths, giving into the doubts, would be sinful. But not anything you described above.
She committed another sin by forming the intent to reach for the fruit. She committed another sin by willing to reach for the fruit. She committed another sin by plucking it off the tree and bringing it to her mouth. The actual eating was only the last of many sins.
Okay, there, now you have the sin part right.
God is portrayed in a moronic fashion in the story, before Eve is pulled ftom Adam’s side: He tries to match Adam up with animals. That effort fails. God finally conceives of the idea of Eve.
What exactly do you mean by “match Adam up with animals”?
Do you see what I mean? Top to bottom, the story is a detail-less fable, not non-fiction. It is fiction teaching theology.
If you mean that it is not to be used as a scientific text book, I completely agree with you. But the theological truth of original sin, according to the Church, demands an original pair of human parents. I understand that you don’t believe this, fine. But don’t deny that this is what the Church teaches.
Good for you for that sentence referring to Purgatory. How many Catholics here understand the concept of purgation so well? Few, I bet.
Or many. Do you realize how arrogant you sound?
Re your point, notice that God is with them in person AFTER the sin
Yes, when they hid from him. And when He kicked them out, b/c they were no longer able to be in His presence.
My Aunt, who was head of the Dominican Ordeer of Nuns in the Western Hemisphere, and a theologian in Catholic University, used to say, “Don’t look to the Church for guidance on Scripture. It has only talked about 5% of it – maybe less.”
And I’m supposed to care about what your aunt says because . . . ???
If you believe in inspiration, it’s philosophically necessary. Every result of inspiration of the Magisterium would be “news” in theology.
How so?
It’s a non-technical reference to the sensum fidelium.
A manifestation of the sensum fidelium would require more than just you, first of all, and would also require that the belief would not be in contradiction with already defined dogma. So if you’re using it to refer to your own belief, you’ve already disproved it.
When I see “X,” should I say, “Look! There’s ‘X’!”? Or should I say, “Look! There’s ‘Not-X’!”?
Maybe you could look for the revealed truth guided and guarded by the Church Christ Himself established and assume, rightly, that it knows more than you do?
 
But I believe that Eve is a hypothetical woman, written-about in a hypothetical to portray to us what each of WOULD do IF grace were not available; and that Adam is a hypothetical man, written-about to portray Christ taking our sins upon Himself.

The Garden of Eden story is about the same speed as a Dr. Seuss story.
Allow me to prove that.

God is portrayed in a [edited] fashion in the story,
Obviously, this is not the teaching of the Catholic Church.

One main flaw is the misinterpretation of original sin as one finds it in the* Catechism of the Catholic Church *www.scborromeo.org/ccc.htm
Another flaw is not seeing the two creation stories as a complimentary whole.
A third flaw is the generic use of the word grace.
As to the use of the word moronic – I am embarrassed by that.
 
Yes, I got it. I understand what you believe. You have every right to believe this. What I don’t understand is why you picked the Catholic Church to be a member of, since you disagree so staunchly with it’s defined dogma.

It’s not sufficient to convey theological truth? What in the world was it for then? Entertainment?

Yes, because the whole point of the story would’ve been to incorrectly portray the nature of sin so that we were all misled.

A near occasion of sin is not a sin.

Last I checked being subject to temptation was not a sin. Nor is honestly entertaining doubts about God. To decide, willyfully and with full knowledge, after entertaining these doubts, going to the source you know to be The Truth, and denying these truths, giving into the doubts, would be sinful. But not anything you described above.

Okay, there, now you have the sin part right.

What exactly do you mean by “match Adam up with animals”?

If you mean that it is not to be used as a scientific text book, I completely agree with you. But the theological truth of original sin, according to the Church, demands an original pair of human parents. I understand that you don’t believe this, fine. But don’t deny that this is what the Church teaches.

Or many. Do you realize how arrogant you sound?

Yes, when they hid from him. And when He kicked them out, b/c they were no longer able to be in His presence.

And I’m supposed to care about what your aunt says because . . . ???

How so?

A manifestation of the sensum fidelium would require more than just you, first of all, and would also require that the belief would not be in contradiction with already defined dogma. So if you’re using it to refer to your own belief, you’ve already disproved it.

Maybe you could look for the revealed truth guided and guarded by the Church Christ Himself established and assume, rightly, that it knows more than you do?
My wife and I are going for our “power walk,” now. GTG. “I’ll be back!”
 
I am guessing Peter means when he says “matching adam up with animals” is that, God in all his wisdom couldn’t figure out a proper and fitting partner for adam from the start? He starts out with giving adam animals, letting him name them and giving him domain over them, but was God so short sighted that he did not realize animals just would not cut it for adam for his entire lifetime?

It was only after God noticed adam was lonely, and recognized its not good for man to be alone, does eve come along.

It sounds absolutely laughable I have to say.:o
 
I am guessing Peter means when he says “matching adam up with animals” is that, God in all his wisdom couldn’t figure out a proper and fitting partner for adam from the start? He starts out with giving adam animals, letting him name them and giving him domain over them, but was God so short sighted that he did not realize animals just would not cut it for adam for his entire lifetime?

It was only after God noticed adam was lonely, and recognized its not good for man to be alone, does eve come along.

It sounds absolutely laughable I have to say.:o
It is laughable and also very sad that a wonderful, loving God is attacked.
 
It is laughable and also very sad that a wonderful, loving God is attacked.
Let me correct your misunderstanding. It is not your God being attacked, but the horrible narrative that has been interpreted horribly.
 
Yes, I got it. I understand what you believe. You have every right to believe this. What I don’t understand is why you picked the Catholic Church to be a member of, since you disagree so staunchly with it’s defined dogma.
The Catholic Church is God’s preferred conduit to salvation. It has defects, but it’s still God’s preferred conduit. “He never promised us a rose garden.”
It’s not sufficient to convey theological truth? What in the world was it for then? Entertainment?
The Garden of Eden story doesn’t answer all questions – only the ones the Holy Spirit wanted to answer at that point in the Bible.
Yes, because the whole point of the story would’ve been to incorrectly portray the nature of sin so that we were all misled.
It talked about sin in a first grade kind of way; we still got it wrong, didn’t we? Many people in this site still believe that there really was a place where mosquitoes did not suck blood from the two humans!!!
A near occasion of sin is not a sin.
That’s nice.

Now, please read what I actually wrote. “Entertaining a near occasion of sin” is a sin. You’ve made a decision to “dance with the devil,” a little bit. Sorry. That’s a sin.
Last I checked being subject to temptation was not a sin. Nor is honestly entertaining doubts about God. To decide, willyfully and with full knowledge, after entertaining these doubts, going to the source you know to be The Truth, and denying these truths, giving into the doubts, would be sinful. But not anything you described above.
You’re wrong. The boss said, “DON’T DO X.” Everything Eve did dancing in that direction was sinful. She even reflects that knowledge, when she rells the serpent, that they can’t even touch the fruit without sinning. Hypothetical Eve knew more about occasions of sin than you.

You’re not allowed to dance with the devil if you’re not allowed to marry him.
What exactly do you mean by “match Adam up with animals”?
For someone so quick to judge me as essentially non-Catholic, you don’t know much about your Catholic Bible…

18 The LORD God said: “It is not good for the man to be alone. I will make a suitable partner for him.” 19 So the LORD God formed out of the ground various wild animals and various birds of the air, and he brought them to the man to see what he would call them; whatever the man called each of them would be its name.
20 The man gave names to all the cattle, all the birds of the air, and all the wild animals; but none proved to be the suitable partner for the man. Genesis 2:18-19.

God set out to give Adam a “suitable partner,” and the text tells us that, initially, God failed at thissk He gave Himself!
If you mean that it is not to be used as a scientific text book, I completely agree with you. But the theological truth of original sin, according to the Church, demands an original pair of human parents. I understand that you don’t believe this, fine. But don’t deny that this is what the Church teaches.
I humbly disagree.

Question: Why is monogenesis important? Answer: To verify that we inherit from our parents the same sin-proneness they had.

Question: What do I stoutly maintain? Answer: That because flesh gives birth to flesh, and because flesh is innately sin-prone in the case of a being with an intellect and free will, we absolutely inherited fromk our parents the samne sin-proneness they had.

A hypothetical Eve does this just fine.
Or many. Do you realize how arrogant you sound?
Ask around. You’re wrong. Almost no Catholic understands that Purgatory is a cleansing to enable you to stand before a special presence of God, which would otherwise find you intolerable. Interestingly, the special presence of God is so “particular” and “extreme” in its taste for perfection that standing before the full presence of God is destructive.
Yes, when they hid from him. And when He kicked them out, b/c they were no longer able to be in His presence.
The story portrays them as being in God’s presence, talking to Him face-to-face, AFTER the sin but BEFORE being kicked out, not because that is theologically sound, but because the story is fiction – making the point of ineligibility to be in the divine presence in a slow, first-grade fashion.

We still got it wrong, didn’t we?
And I’m supposed to care about what your aunt says because . . . ???
You don’t have to care. You can be cold. Go ahead. I have seen coldness in response to fellowship before.

But I will read what you have to say, friend.
Maybe its better if I gave you a case in point.

Before the year 1950 A.D., did the Holy Spirit declare the Assumption of Mary to be an essential part of the belief of evety Catholic?
A manifestation of the sensum fidelium would require more than just you, first of all, and would also require that the belief would not be in contradiction with already defined dogma. So if you’re using it to refer to your own belief, you’ve already disproved it.
I disagree. Not only was St. Athanasius alone, but the Pope affirmatively condemned him.

It was “Athanasiuis against the world.”

He won.

He was simply the beginning point of the sensum fidelium.

I believe that I am.

How many people called Athanasius arrogant, do you think?
 
Lastly…
Maybe you could look for the revealed truth guided and guarded by the Church Christ Himself established and assume, rightly, that it knows more than you do?
By and large, the Church does a good job.

But it fails, in some ways. Very, very, very badly.
 
You don’t have to care. You can be cold. Go ahead. I have seen coldness in response to fellowship before.

But I will read what you have to say, friend.
You’re right Peter, I was frustrated and very uncharitable in that comment and I hope you’ll forgive me.

As for the rest of the post, I’ll see you tomorrow :).
 
Let me correct your misunderstanding. It is not your God being attacked, but the horrible narrative that has been interpreted horribly.
I was referring to the word moronic (post 80) which in my neighborhood indicated a personal attack on a person’s dignity. Name calling was verboten.

As far as Adam and Eve, I believe they existed. Maybe they were Jane and John Doe. Saying that they are hypothetical and worse is not Catholic teaching.
 
40.png
Peter_Dawson:
The same old story deserves the same old response. 😉

For Catholic teachings, please check the Catechism of the Catholic Church
www.scborromeo.org/ccc.htm
 
I was referring to the word moronic (post 80) which in my neighborhood indicated a personal attack on a person’s dignity. Name calling was verboten.

As far as Adam and Eve, I believe they existed. Maybe they were Jane and John Doe. Saying that they are hypothetical and worse is not Catholic teaching.
Hello Grannymh,

I understand now. I thought you were replying to me, because you quoted me.

As far as the interpretation of the passages in Genesis go, I can understand your concerns.

I do know one thing, and it is that the passages in Genesis ask of us more questions than there seem to be answers.

Unless, we can’t ask them anymore.:o
 
Hello Grannymh,

I understand now. I thought you were replying to me, because you quoted me.

As far as the interpretation of the passages in Genesis go, I can understand your concerns.

I do know one thing, and it is that the passages in Genesis ask of us more questions than there seem to be answers.

Unless, we can’t ask them anymore.:o
I agree that the passages in Genesis ask of us more questions than there seem to be answers. Personally, there are two questions which will always be with me. Where did I come from? and Where am I going? At death, which is when I can’t ask them anymore, I will trust in the answers offered by Catholicism.

Blessings and many good thoughts,
granny

The universe is a joy to be thankful for.
 
I agree that the passages in Genesis ask of us more questions than there seem to be answers. Personally, there are two questions which will always be with me. Where did I come from? and Where am I going? At death, which is when I can’t ask them anymore, I will trust in the answers offered by Catholicism.

Blessings and many good thoughts,
granny

The universe is a joy to be thankful for.
Can people in purgatory still ask questions, I mean- they can still take the time there to get their questions answered even through pain?

I’m not asking because I think I will be there, but just asking from a general desire to understand. I know I will be in hell if I die tonight.
 
That is your personal view.
Well, in part it’s Church teaching, Granny!

In the gospels, Peter fails Christ in spectacular ways, again and again.

I believe that this was to prepare us for the failed human rlrment in our Church. In other words, those incidents are there to tell us, “Your Church leaders will fail you badly – but it’s still My preferred conduit to Heaven!”
 
Well, in part it’s Church teaching, Granny!

In the gospels, Peter fails Christ in spectacular ways, again and again.

I believe that this was to prepare us for the failed human rlrment in our Church. In other words, those incidents are there to tell us, “Your Church leaders will fail you badly – but it’s still My preferred conduit to Heaven!”
I think Judas was quite enough preparation for that.🤷

What more does one need to get the point?:confused:
 
Can people in purgatory still ask questions, I mean- they can still take the time there to get their questions answered even through pain?

I’m not asking because I think I will be there, but just asking from a general desire to understand.
Purgatory is one of those “good news - bad news” places. The good news is that it is our final dash to heaven. It is our transition into glory. The bad news is that we get to see the remains of sin on our soul. We can’t wiggle out of the fact that we have an imperfect relationship with God which needs to be repaired. Purgatory is like a healthy dose of yucky medicine. The good news is that we are like the Good Thief who was crucified with Jesus. We see our punishment as just so we call loudly to Jesus to remember us. And He does. (Luke 23: 39-43)

Regarding if people in purgatory can still ask questions and can they take their time there to get their questions answered even through pain? I did not find a direct answer. So I will make up an answer.😉

No matter what our beliefs or non-beliefs are, we understand Jesus as the Good Shepherd. I know the paintings show Jesus carrying a white sheep. I just wish, that for once, an artist would paint a “black sheep” because that is more the reality of life.

Jesus said: “I am the Good Shepherd, and I know Mine and Mine know me…”
(John 10: 1-18) He does know our questions and I personally believe that somewhere along the line, we will have the answers. That is plain common sense. As to questions/answers taking place in purgatory, I don’t know.

The Catholic tradition on purgatory speaks of a purification like unto a cleansing fire.
A poetic description sees our soul being immersed in the fire of Christ’s love which burns away the dead branches of earthly life. In other words, in purgatory we lose our attachments to material earth and the sins found there so that our love for God becomes completely pure. My guess is that somehow in that process would be answers to many questions. When we finally come into God’s loving presence, we come without our baggage.

As to the real basic questions we have about the meaning of life on earth and the meaning of life after death, those answers start coming as we search for God.

Since I am a direct descendent of the doubting apostle Thomas 😉 I am sure that I will have questions as I find my seat in the last row of purgatory. 🙂 I am confident that when I walk, make that run, into heaven all my questions will be answered. I can imagine myself saying: “Wow! You really are God!”

For further information about Catholic teaching on this subject, read Catechism of the Catholic Church, Second Edition, Purgatory, paragraphs 1030 -1032, Communion of Saints paragraphs 1474-1477, The Punishments of Sin Paragraphs1472-1473.
www.scborromeo.org/ccc.htm

Blessings,
granny

All human life is meant for eternal life.
 
Can people in purgatory still ask questions, I mean- they can still take the time there to get their questions answered even through pain?

I’m not asking because I think I will be there, but just asking from a general desire to understand. I know I will be in hell if I die tonight.
Then, it might be a good idea to start doing something about it, no? At least begin with helping others…
Jesus said he would judge us by whether or not we fed the hungry, gave drink to the thirsty, clothed the naked, visited the sick or imprisoned, etc…

An agnostic can do those things too, no?
And, you never know…ONLY God knows! 😉
Purgatory is the ‘foyer’ to Heaven, where we go until we are able to stand being in the Presence of God…

We are in pain here, and we ask questions, why wouldn’t they? And, they can pray for us, but not for themselves…that’s why we pray for them, and some of them might pray for us while in Purgatory and once they finally arrive in Heaven as well.
 
If we are essentially good, why, unlike immaculate Mary, did Eve sin, on her first real test, in the story of Adam and Eve?

Because of Free Will.

The Catholic Church teaches, “The LORD looks down from heaven upon the human race, to see if even one is wise, if even one seeks God. *All *have gone astray; *all *alike are perverse. Not one does what is right, not even one.”

All of this is AFTER THE FALL…not before…so all those people, and us, are under concupiscence.

Jesus would be excepted-out because the corruption of the human race taught by our Church is the reason why He came; Mary would be excepted-out because while the Church teaches that Mary was immaculately conceived, this state was achieved by the grace won by Christ on the cross. I.e., but for the grace of the cross, Mary, also, would have a perverse heart, gone astray.
Mary did not sin either, out of her FREE WILL. She did not have perverse heart, and chose not to develop one by sinning.

He came to solve the problem of the FALL caused by Adam & Eve, not by God. God created good and perfect beings endowed with Intellect and Free Will. We messed up. To say that we are -by nature- anything less than that, is to say that God created imperfect, depraved, perverse creatures…

I KNOW you are NOT saying that! Are you?:confused:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top