What happens when only one side defines hate

  • Thread starter Thread starter Cathoholic
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Emeraldlady when I presented principles . . .
The rest of the irrelevant rant aside, . . .
Emeraldlady . . .
And reparations aren’t ‘collective guilt’, they are justice.
There is no justice blaming someone else for what others have or have not done.

You are just plain wrong.

It is the opposite of “justice”.

But assuming you believe what you are saying . . .

Have you sent any peoples YOUR money based upon past issues that were the fault of others Emeraldlady?

Emeraldlady . . . .
They are never going to undo what was done
Thanks for admitting that.

Emeraldlady . . . .
. . . but represent recognition
If you want, YOU fork out YOUR hard earned money for “recognition” but please don’t tell other people that THEY need to too. That is an abuse of Government power.
 
Last edited:
I thought reparations were for slavery.

Are you changing the definition?
A “reparation” is something done to make amends for a wrong that has been done. It is a cognate of the word “repair.”

(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)
 
Partly true. The country thrived because of the sweat and brawn and brains and risk taking of people of all races.
To completely white wash over the difference between free and slave in this work is one of the hallmarks of white privilege.
We are now in a multi racial society that goes way beyond the outmoded black/white dichotomy. In fact Asians have greater median household income on average than whites.
Again, to whitewash the fact of slavery and it’s generational repercussions from the discussion is an injustice and it also assumes that long held white supremacy no longer exists in society as any sort of problem.
 
And reparations aren’t ‘collective guilt’, they are justice. They are never going to undo what was done but represent recognition that a segment of society was discriminated against so fiercely that they were behind the eight ball no matter what. There are people still alive who were denied education and the right to vote or to secure a loan, simply because they were black. Just open a basic history book to see that millions of the most able bodied Africans were kidnapped for whites in the New World to advance themselves. The US thrived because of the work of these kidnapped people who slaved on cotton farms and on the railroads and other industries the generated white wealth. And for an American who has the basic knowledge of how his country thrived because of these kidnapped African people and how African countries suffered because their best and strongest were taken away, what a disgusting deplorable comment to call them ‘sh-thole’ countries. It is just a ghastly lack of respect and insult that can only be the result of deep seated racist views that prevent any kind of recognition of how all those scenarios panned out to start with.
So should the Democratic Party be made to pay the reparations for this?
 
40.png
Emeraldlady:
There are people still alive who were denied education and the right to vote or to secure a loan, simply because they were black.
I thought reparations were for slavery.

Are you changing the definition?
Do you also disagree that the honouring returned soldiers and the financial legacy for the families of soldiers killed during wars is unnecessary?
 
Last edited:
40.png
Emeraldlady:
And reparations aren’t ‘collective guilt’, they are justice. They are never going to undo what was done but represent recognition that a segment of society was discriminated against so fiercely that they were behind the eight ball no matter what. There are people still alive who were denied education and the right to vote or to secure a loan, simply because they were black. Just open a basic history book to see that millions of the most able bodied Africans were kidnapped for whites in the New World to advance themselves. The US thrived because of the work of these kidnapped people who slaved on cotton farms and on the railroads and other industries the generated white wealth. And for an American who has the basic knowledge of how his country thrived because of these kidnapped African people and how African countries suffered because their best and strongest were taken away, what a disgusting deplorable comment to call them ‘sh-thole’ countries. It is just a ghastly lack of respect and insult that can only be the result of deep seated racist views that prevent any kind of recognition of how all those scenarios panned out to start with.
So should the Democratic Party be made to pay the reparations for this?
It’s an obligation of a government whatever party.
 
It is the opposite of “justice”.
It is the opposite of justice.

It is taking from people who did not enslave and giving to people who were not enslaved on the basis of righting the historical wrong of slavery in deference to the Left’s ideology/religion of identity politics that apparently everyone must accept.

If these people believe their religion/ideology so strongly, let them pay for the sins of the Democratic party. I have no objection to that. The objection is when the Democratic Party try to shift the blame and get everyone to pay in line with their identity politics religion.
 
Last edited:
White supremacy no longer exists.That is a fact. People of all races regardless of when or how they came here can by working hard be a success if they choose. There is no excuse for anyone in this day and age.
 
It’s an obligation of a government whatever party.
It is the obligation of government to compensate people who were treated unjustly under its rule.

There are no people alive today in the United States who were slaves before the Republican anti-slavery bill was passed.
 
Last edited:
There is no justice blaming someone else for what others have or have not done.

You are just plain wrong.

It is the opposite of “justice”.

But assuming you believe what you are saying . . .

Have you sent any peoples YOUR money based upon past issues that were the fault of others Emeraldlady?
Again, it isn’t about blame or guilt. It is recognising that the general status of white people and the general status of black people still today, is the result of discrimination up until the most recent history. It’s about doing what we can to address that imbalance and by doing so, eliminating any of these toxic ideologies like class and race superiority.
If you want, YOU fork out YOUR hard earned money for “recognition” but please don’t tell other people that THEY need to too. That is an abuse of Government power.
You talk as though no one should have a voice in public forum except yourself and those you agree with. I reject that ideology.
 
This is a non-answer ThinkingSapien.

@vz71 did not ask merely about the definition of reparations but contextually about how it is applied (“tied to slavery”). At least concerning today’s American political atmoshere. At least as far as my reading went in the context of this thread.

Here it is again from vz71 . . .
And common use has it (reparations) tied to slavery.
Do you wish to change this?
(Parenthetical addition mine for context.)
40.png
What happens when only one side defines hate World News
I thought reparations were for slavery. Are you changing the definition?
 
Last edited:
40.png
ThinkingSapien:
A “reparation” is something done to make amends for a wrong that has been done. It is a cognate of the word “repair.”
And common use has it tied to slavery.
Do you wish to change this?
What are you talking about? Reparation is not a word attached to slavery? It’s used daily in the context of legal settlements all the time.
 
What are you talking about? Reparation is not a word attached to slavery? It’s used daily in the context of legal settlements all the time.
Ok.
Then what legal wrong has been committed against whom? And by who?
And of what monetary value do we attach to it?

If you truly wish legal reparations, then you must show the loss, document it, and specify the monetary redress is due. For each individual.
 
Again can we get over the outmoded black/white dichotomy. There are plenty of other races in the country besides these two. Have you ever seen a homeless East Asian. I haven’t. Why? Because they aren’t looking for handouts or making excuses. They get up every day and work their tails off. This is true of most Americans of all races. No more excuses and crutches for any group.
 
And common use has it tied to slavery.
The first known use of the word was in the 14th century. And as already mentioned the word is commonly used in the legal field for actions such as monetary restitution.
 
40.png
Emeraldlady:
It’s an obligation of a government whatever party.
It is the obligation of government to compensate people who were treated unjustly under its rule.
So since the 20th century Palestinian government didn’t take Israel, they are right to disagree with giving over their land based on historical injustice?
 
Last edited:
Again, it isn’t about blame or guilt. It is recognising that the general status of white people and the general status of black people still today, is the result of discrimination up until the most recent history. It’s about doing what we can to address that imbalance
But it is Leftist ideology that believes this as part of its identity politics.

Where is your proof that the different averages of say, household income, today is based on slavery from 200 years ago?

It is nothing more than Leftist ideology which seeks to foster division based on resentment and taking from people based on this fostered resentment.

 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top