What happens when only one side defines hate

  • Thread starter Thread starter Cathoholic
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
So since the 20th century Palestinian government didn’t take Israel, they are right to disagree with giving over their land based on historical injustice?
We can talk about this if you like but we are changing the underlying area of discussion. I am not following exactly what you are saying here. There is an ongoing Arab Israeli war and no agreement on even the right of Israel to exist. The Arabs don’t see Israel as their government and want it dismantled in favour of a new government and state.
 
Last edited:
It wasn’t so long ago that on these forums there was one poster who posited a number of white supremacist views; in particular around the inherent superiority of Europeans. When I went through a list of core “technologies” of civilization; animal domestication, agriculture, urban living, writing, metalworking, and so forth, invented while Europeans were still in the Neolithic, he declared that that was fake history. As I recall he was also an advocate of segregation by race, and some statements suggestive of him believing America should be a white nation.
 
niceatheist . . .
It wasn’t so long ago that on these forums there was one poster who posited a number of white supremacist views . . . As I recall he was also an advocate of segregation by race . . .
Thanks for defending against racism here on CAF niceatheist (I am serious).

Good work!
 
The point is that if as you claim, governments are only responsible for repairing injustice that happens under their rule, then the Jews had no right to claim Israel from Palestine because it didn’t happen under modern day Palestines rule.
 
Thank you. If there is one part of the Catholic ethos I am most appreciative of it is Rome’s strong anti-racial statements.
 
niceatheist . . .
If there is one part of the Catholic ethos I am most appreciative of it is Rome’s strong anti-racial statements.
Well if you ever get appreciative of many other things in “Rome”, I for one would love to have you aboard.
 
Peeps. Are you white?

Why do whites hate whiteness so much?
Yes, I’m white.

I think whites have been trained since the 1970s in public schools and in the media to be ashamed of their whiteness and to celebrate the beauty of blackness and brownness.

I don’t think that’s necessarily a bad thing. Before the 1960s, many of us were overly-proud of our whiteness and I know that many whites considered themselves superior to black, brown, and yellow people. (The prejudice against Asians was probably a product of WWII and the Korean War–my mother told me that my dad used to have panic attacks when he saw an Aisan person.)

Our city was founded and settled by Scandinavians, and when I was a child, they were very proud of their heritage and held dinners, festivals, and joined clubs that kept Scandinavian culture alive.

But then it all went away, and we no longer saw flags of various Scandinavian countries flying from private homes, and only 1 Lutheran church in town continued hosting a St. Lucia Fest. The Scandinavian museum stopped publicizing itself and nearly went out of business.

It’s almost as if they were ashamed of their white European heritage.

Lately, though, in the last few years, we’re seeing a resurgence of interest in all things Scandinavian. I’m sure some of this is because the Scandinavian countries are winning “Happiest Country in the World” surveys, and Denmark is doing really well with their “hygge” promotion (I’m very into Hygge!! drives my husband and kids nuts! Maybe I’ll start a CAF thread about hygge so I can drive CAF members nuts!)

And in our city lives a major rock band (still touring internationally) who proudly promote Sweden!

And in the last few years, the Scandinavian community has started promoting itself again, with a nice festival for MidSommar and a renovated center for Scandinavian culture.

UFF DA!

But yes, I truly think that we were taught in public schools and colleges that our people have been conquerors and oppressors for centuries, and this made us ashamed.

The people who are facing extreme prejudice against their heritage in the last few years is the Italian Americans. The Italian parish in our city (over a hundred years old) has always held an annual celebration of Christopher Columbus and they even have a statue of him in their parish garden (beautiful garden, BTW–great place for prayer and contemplation!). The celebration emphasized Columbus’ desire to bring Christ and the Church to new countries and the backing that he received from Queen Isabella.

But in the last few years, we’ve heard no mention of it in the news, and I’m not even sure the parish still has a celebration. We’ve all been taught in the media and on the local news that “most scholars” now consider Christopher Columbus responsible for conquering the Native American peoples in the “New World” and spreading European diseases that killed off entire populations of Native Americans. He is considered a “villain.”

So sad. And to be honest, I’m not sure who’s right about this one.
 
Again, white-shaming. It’s called “truth about history,” but the effect it has is to make us ashamed and to make us believe that the U.S. is a “bad country” that should start all over again.

And as I said in an earlier post that I’m sure infuriated some CAF members–what seems to be happening now is white ennui–many whites are throwing up their hands and saying things like, “So what?! It wasn’t me who held slaves! It wasn’t me who spread smallbox around! Leave me alone! Stop bullying me about racism!”

And we’re beginning to be very cynical about racism and many whites utterly oppose any government programs that help minorities, often citing evidence that these programs have not produced measurable results and haven’t improved the quality of life of minorities.

And…very sadly…some whites are becoming sympathetic with some of the “white supremacist” groups. Not necessarily joining them, but unwilling to take a visible stand against these hate groups.

Hate is not the answer. But is apathy the answer? I know many whites who have essentially 'given up" trying not to be racist, because everything they say and do is interpreted as “racism” and they’re tired of trying. I try, and I get people telling me that I’m “condescending.” So I’m pretty much at that point of not caring, too.

Just being honest, friends. That’s something that seems to be rare these days because when we’re honest, we lose our jobs, get banned from social media sites, and are given unsavory labels by the media.
 
How would reparations work?
Would those who benefited from affirmative action laws previously still receive reparations?
Would those families who immigrated after slavery also receive reparations?
Would those who have achieved a certain level of success still receive reparations?
What about mixed race individuals? What percentage of a mixed race person has to be of African descent to receive reparations? I have twin grandkids that are 25% African decent, but one looks white and one has a darker complexion. Would they be treated differently?
Implementing reparations would be a nightmare in itself. The administration of it likely would cost more than the funds given out.
 
We elected the first black president in 08. Clarence Thomas has presided in a SCOTUS position for decades.Oprah Winfrey is one of the wealthiest people in this country.There are many many more examples of blacks reaching the pinnacle of success in this country. They should be held up as examples rather than being called Uncle Tom’s ,traders to their race.Of course those prejoratives are only hurled at Conservative blacks by the left. This whole reparations issue is blatant pandering and hypocrisy by the Dems.Big surprise!:roll_eyes:
 
Last edited:
How does questing BO birth place equate to racism?
It doesn’t.Yet the left sees racism everywhere Lest you forgot,HC is the one who start d the whole birtherism issue
 
Last edited:
I have the same question as Jeanne. How is asking if Obama was born in the U.S. or Africa, a racist question?

You must be a U.S. born citizen to be president.

John McCain also went trough this scrutiny, because he was born outside the U.S. on an Army base. But it was not considered racist when asked about McCain.
 
How does questing BO birth place equate to racism?
It doesn’t.Yet the left sees racism everywhere Lest you forgot,HC is the one who start d the whole birtherism issue
Sorry, I don’t buy that Birtherism is somehow divorced from racism. It was a racist conspiracy theory, because an African-American won the presidency.
 
His black heritage served him well, he had zero chance to be POTUS in 2009 if he had identified with his white heritage.

Hey, it’s natural for people to identify with what get’s them the best outcomes. It used to be white, but not anymore. Some examples from the prior century


On the others,
  • Elizabeth Warren pretend to be Indian to significant advantage
  • Kamala claimed to be “African American” but was forced to settle for “black”, she could have passed as “Indian” but that doesn’t give equal advantage
  • Robert O’Rourke is just an irish punk who fakes his latinoness, because it’s essential to get elected where he’s at. LOL, he tried to join the Latino caucus in congress.
 
Last edited:
Emeraldlady . . .
You talk as though no one should have a voice in public forum except yourself and those you agree with. I reject that ideology.
No I don’t.

You are making phony charges against me here.

Please stop it.

As I said, If you want, YOU fork out YOUR hard earned money for “recognition” but please don’t tell other people that THEY need to too.

You can do “reparations” just fine without others if you feel so strongly about it.
 
Last edited:
niceatheist . . . .
Sorry, I don’t buy that Birtherism is somehow divorced from racism. It was a racist conspiracy theory, because an African-American won the presidency.
Do you have anymore evidence against Hillary (or at least her campaign who began the “birtherism” canard) that they are racists?
 
Thanks for the reply. That is the way to move a conversation forward. But at this time, I am having a hard time keeping my thoughts together and tell you my experience. I do have some personal issues, that affect my memory.

I can say this, if you remember the Candace Owens thread ,where she blamed the liberal policies, and people said that she is a white supremacist even though she is a black woman for blaming liberal policies. Well, I agree with her, because my experience does come from that. From poverty to getting out of it. Those policies punish getting out of them. example, and my numbers are made up. Government gives you $400 a week, plus food stamps, plus WIC, plus other goodies, and the moment you get a job, you loose all of that. Now your job makes you $300 a week. So you went from better money to working and paying taxes on a smaller paycheck.

It was hard to get our of it. I had to join the military, for those policies made a lot of people work under the table. Which in turn affected those who want to work. Those receiving government help, asked for less than minimum wage, they already had income. They had no specific hours, nothing attaching them to the job, and the business saved a dollar that way. So those who wanted an actual job, had a very hard to get one, due to many people working for less pay under the table. It was either work for less than minimum wage, no specific hours, more of a work when I need you type. How can a person make a living like that?

Anyhow, I am having trouble concentrating today.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top