The USCCB has published a free summary of an article by an MD on the effectiveness of natural family planning:
usccb.org/issues-and-action/marriage-and-family/natural-family-planning/medical-research/upload/CMR-Winter-Spring-2013-FINAL.pdf The actual article was a research experiment published in the journal of Contraception
ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23153900 to compare the effectiveness of electronic hormonal fertility monitor (EHFM) group and cervical mucus monitoring (CMM) group natural family planning. It looks like the Electronic Hormonal Fertility monitor NFP method was 100% effective when used perfectly, but about 93% effective at 1 year when the instructions weren’t followed correctly. Has she been taught natural family planning by a qualified NFP teacher so she can follow it correctly? If she is really devoted to Mary, then she would want to be like Mary and allow for the remote possibility of a pregnancy (Jesus) even though there should be near perfect avoidance through abstinence from sex (Mary) or NFP (her).
The poor people in India were taught NFP. Don’t know much about the details of this, but the British Medical Journal in 1993 said that a study of 19,843 poor women in India using NFP has a pregnancy rate approaching zero. It doesn’t seem that NFP should be much more expensive than artificial contraception and shouldn’t come with some of the complications, i.e. infections, pain, death associated with some methods of sterlization and all surgeries.
ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/8401097
The National Survey on Family Growth (NSFG)/ Center for Disease Control (CDC) web site referenced by the USCCB (
cdc.gov/nchs/nsfg/key_statistics/d.htm#divorce) compared the divorce rate of 505 Catholic women (aged 21-44) selected from NFP programs with the 10,471 women in the 1995 NSFG. She found that 3% of the NFP users in the NFP programs reported they were divorced as compared with 15% of the Catholic women in the 1995 (Cycle 5) of the NSFG. Wilson concluded that there is less divorce among NFP couples than couples using contraception.
usccb.org/issues-and-action/marriage-and-family/natural-family-planning/medical-research/upload/CMR-Summer-Fall-2013-Divorce-and-NFP-edited.pdf Sex is meant to express wedding vows, making the words of the wedding vows flesh - the commitment of a man and woman in a free, total, faithful, and fruitful way to each other until death along with canonical promises to fidelity, indissolubility, and openness to life (as rephrased from a well known Catholic moral theologian). People are supposed to express with their bodies what was expressed at the altar with their minds and hearts, so actually artificial contraception - by being unfaithful to the wedding vows - should theologically and empirically cause her husband to be more likely to stray with other women.