What is a 'devotion to Mary'?

  • Thread starter Thread starter rcwitness
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
True -
However a given set of practices and beliefs (devotion) can be approved by the Church and a person can misuse, or misunderstand them.
The individual can have a “bad devotion” - or perhaps more correctly, an erroneous or defective or false devotion.

Peace
James
You are correct.

Less we lose sight of what “devotion to Mary” is all about take Fatima as an example.

St Mary came to Fatima at the behest of the Heavenly Father for the salvation of souls. The method of salvation She explained was for little souls to **consecrate themselves to her **and offer up their daily duties and responsibilities according to their station in life to her and she will apply them to the interest of the Sacred Heart of Jesus. The morning offering goes like this. “Oh my Jesus I desire today to gain every indulgence and merit I can and I offer them together with myself to Mary Immaculate that she may best apply them to the interests of thy most Sacred Heart.” By this method we take solace in joining the Communion of Saints and work to save souls for God.
 
St Mary came to Fatima at the behest of the Heavenly Father for the salvation of souls. The method of salvation She explained was for little souls to consecrate themselves to her…

Mary said this?
 
Mary said this?
This is what She said:

Second apparition of Our Lady
On June 13 1917 “I would like to ask you to bring us to Heaven”, said Lucy. "Yes, Giacinta and Francis will be among the few, but you must stay here for a long time. Jesus wants to help Himself of you to make Me known and loved. God wishes you to remain in the world for some time because He wants to use you to establish in the world a devotion to my Immaculate Heart. I promise salvation to those who embrace it,
 
This is what She said:

Second apparition of Our Lady
On June 13 1917 “I would like to ask you to bring us to Heaven”, said Lucy. "Yes, Giacinta and Francis will be among the few, but you must stay here for a long time. Jesus wants to help Himself of you to make Me known and loved. God wishes you to remain in the world for some time because He wants to use you to establish in the world a devotion to my Immaculate Heart. I promise salvation to those who embrace it,
Ok, thats very different than THE method of salvation is for souls to consecrate themselves to her.

So she told us to devote to her heart. How is this accomplished?
 
You see, If somehow Mary takes our worship aimed towards God through Jesus and “manages all of it for Him” then so be it. What I don’t understand, is why Mary would seek some kind of spotlight and attention in order to do so, if we are already devoted to Jesus in His Sacraments, and service.

I would love for someone to address the essential difference with offerring all of their love for God through Mary in hopes that she applies it to Him more appropriately and placing Mary as a high priestess in their hearts. 🤷
 
You see, If somehow Mary takes our worship aimed towards God through Jesus and “manages all of it for Him” then so be it. What I don’t understand, is why Mary would seek some kind of spotlight and attention in order to do so, if we are already devoted to Jesus in His Sacraments, and service.

I would love for someone to address the essential difference with offerring all of their love for God through Mary in hopes that she applies it to Him more appropriately and placing Mary as a high priestess in their hearts. 🤷
What?
Who said a devotion to Mary, or loving Mary, was placing her as a high priestess in our hearts??? And do you truly think that Mary has asked for the spotlight, and wants to elevate herself? Or are you trying to continue disagreement and argument? It is beginning to seem like your problem isn’t with those who have devotions to Mary (true, or ‘false’ (by your definition) ones), but with Mary, period.
 
What?
Who said a devotion to Mary, or loving Mary, was placing her as a high priestess in our hearts??? And do you truly think that Mary has asked for the spotlight, and wants to elevate herself? Or are you trying to continue disagreement and argument? It is beginning to seem like your problem isn’t with those who have devotions to Mary (true, or ‘false’ (by your definition) ones), but with Mary, period.
Hi ccmcmg,

Thanks for staying with my thread. No, I certainly do not have a problem with Mary. I am trying to discern what is true devotion to her. What is devotion intended by God.

Of course nobody says Mary is a high priestess. They need not say it to be deceived by it. But my deepest intention is to NOT make her a high priestess in my devotions to her. There is such a close line, which tends to get blurred when some of the language and concepts of offering all of our hopes, efforts, love, deeds, ect to her, in order to be more pleasing to God.

Can you really not acknowledge where I am coming from? I know I have rubbed you wrong here in this thread. I wish those with deep belief, devotion and consecration to Mary would show some understanding and kindness. You usually get so offended by others who wish to discern where the line between loving her, and creating a false image in our hearts of a “high priestess figure” that you take it as an attack on Mary herself. 🤷

That being said, I don’t mind a firm stance at all, and I am seriously glad you are still responding in my thread. I would suggest the best way to get to my heart, is through the faith I have in Christ’s Church and His Teachings. I am not well educated on Fatima. I am not closed to understanding this event. It is, afterall, the single greatest contribution to devotion/consecration to Mary.
 
Ok, thats very different than THE method of salvation is for souls to consecrate themselves to her.

So she told us to devote to her heart. How is this accomplished?
St. Lucy who “He (Jesus) wants to use you to establish in the world a devotion to my Immaculate Heart” taught us that the best way to devote ourselves to her Immaculate Heart is by consecration.
 
St. Lucy who “He (Jesus) wants to use you to establish in the world a devotion to my Immaculate Heart” taught us that the best way to devote ourselves to her Immaculate Heart is by consecration.
This event and apparition of Mary (and Jesus, if I’m not mistaken?) is deemed valid by the Church. The efforts taken by the Pope and all the Bishops in response to the message, was and still is practiced in belief and obedience to its prophecy, right?

But the message and devotion seems to lack anything substantial according to Sacred Scripture’s Revelation. What I mean, is there is such a greater record and revelation in the Scriptures regarding how we should devote ourselves, and with even much higher authority and weight. There are the works of the Lord Jesus Himself, the Sacraments, the Corporal and Spiritual works of Mercy, The beatitudes, the Divine Authority, the instruction from the Apostles. The miracles which the Lord performed and His disciples were miracles that healed, helped and showed mercy on the weak and sick. These seemed to be a great sign of goodness behind the “show”.

Fatima, seems to display a grand and mysterious show, but did it have these humble and mercifull miracles like the Lord and His Apostles delivered? Where there people being fed? Where there people being restored to health? Where demons being cast out?

Im not saying I don’t believe. You know I give lots of respect to Church approval. But as someone who is consecrated, and has deep belief in the goodness and fruits of their consecration, share with me what constitutes a devotion to Mary. Is it just statues and promises to Mary? Is it more than reciting the Rosary? Share with me why it is better than a devotion to the Eucharist, to Church Teaching. Or show me how it is related? How is it not one and the same? How are we not pleasing Mary enough to devote to receiving His Eucharist with a pure conscience, seeking our forgiveness from Jesus when we fall short of His Commands?
 
You see, If somehow Mary takes our worship aimed towards God through Jesus and “manages all of it for Him” then so be it.
Amen
What I don’t understand, is why Mary would seek some kind of spotlight and attention in order to do so, if we are already devoted to Jesus in His Sacraments, and service.
You lost me here…
I know of no place where Mary seeks the spotlight. On the other hand, if God asks her to do something, she will do it. If individuals wish to shine a “spotlight” on her…that is not her doing.
I would love for someone to address the essential difference with offering all of their love for God through Mary in hopes that she applies it to Him more appropriately and placing Mary as a high priestess in their hearts. 🤷
Don’t really understand what you are asking here.
How would Mary apply our Love to God “more appropriately”?
Just trying to understand.

Peace
James
 
You lost me here…
I know of no place where Mary seeks the spotlight. On the other hand, if God asks her to do something, she will do it. If individuals wish to shine a “spotlight” on her…that is not her doing.
I dont see Mary as seeking any spotlight, but thats why I wonder why she would have souls consecrate themselves to her? Her role was to tell others to listen to Him, now after these appirations, she reveals we should go through her.
Don’t really understand what you are asking here.
How would Mary apply our Love to God “more appropriately”?
Just trying to understand.
I have no idea, that’s what im trying to figure out with devotions like Ed is trying to explain.
You are correct.
The method of salvation She explained was for little souls to **consecrate themselves to her **and offer up their daily duties and responsibilities according to their station in life to her and she will apply them to the interest of the Sacred Heart of Jesus. The morning offering goes like this. “Oh my Jesus I desire today to gain every indulgence and merit I can and I offer them together with myself to Mary Immaculate that she may best apply them to the interests of thy most Sacred Heart.”
 
I dont see Mary as seeking any spotlight, but thats why I wonder why she would have souls consecrate themselves to her? Her role was to tell others to listen to Him, now after these appirations, she reveals we should go through her.
Is it “she” who asks this - or is it God who uses her?
I think that is the belief of those who go for the consecration. That they are obeying the Father. Note in Ed’s earlier post that he says, “St Mary came to Fatima at the behest of the Heavenly Father…”
I have no idea, that’s what im trying to figure out with devotions like Ed is trying to explain.
OK - Thanks…lets see if we can clarify…
Consider the prayer that Ed relayed and you quoted…
“Oh my Jesus I desire today to gain every indulgence and merit I can and I offer them together with myself to Mary Immaculate** that she may best apply them to the interests of thy most Sacred Heart.**”
The idea here being that Mary would take any merits we gain and use them in whatever way Jesus wishes…the “interests” of Jesus sacred heart.

This is quite different from what you said in your post:
offering all of their love for God through Mary in hopes that she applies it to Him more appropriately
So where the prayer is speaking of merits and indulgences, you are speaking of Love. Where the Prayer speaks of Mary applying these merits to the interests of Jesus, you are speaking of her applying them to Him

Like you - I prefer sending my prayers directly to the Father and letting Him do as He wishes with them, though I do pray to Our Lady as well.
But the above demonstrates how easily we can mis-communicate on these matters.

Peace
James
 
Is it “she” who asks this - or is it God who uses her?
I think that is the belief of those who go for the consecration. That they are obeying the Father. Note in Ed’s earlier post that he says, “St Mary came to Fatima at the behest of the Heavenly Father…”
Yes, that is true according to the apparition 👍 But it is also true that we are free to believe that or not believe it. So while I do give great respect to what the Church has deemed “believable” we also have to remember that this is not the same as an infallible Confirmation, which in itself makes me very curious why Our Father decides to present Mary as someone who through a devotion of total consecration (which is some sort of ritual promise, which St James seems to condemn) would promise salvation and “manage our merits and indulgences to Jesus” under the less than authoritive means of Confirmation.

.
OK - Thanks…lets see if we can clarify…
Consider the prayer that Ed relayed and you quoted…
“Oh my Jesus I desire today to gain every indulgence and merit I can and I offer them together with myself to Mary Immaculate** that she may best apply them to the interests of thy most Sacred Heart.**”
The idea here being that Mary would take any merits we gain and use them in whatever way Jesus wishes…the “interests” of Jesus sacred heart.
Ok, Mary would “manage” our merits and use them as the Lord wishes. This is all only if we consecrate ourselves to “her”. You see, this consecration seems to be the whole desire of this spirit… Why?
James 5:12
12 Above all, my beloved,[f] do not swear, either by heaven or by earth or by any other oath, but let your “Yes” be yes and your “No” be no, so that you may not fall under condemnation.
This is quite different from what you said in your post:
offering all of their love for God through Mary in hopes that she applies it to Him more appropriately
So where the prayer is speaking of merits and indulgences, you are speaking of Love. Where the Prayer speaks of Mary applying these merits to the interests of Jesus, you are speaking of her applying them to Him
Fair enough. These correction, I see I have unfairly represented 👍
Like you - I prefer sending my prayers directly to the Father and letting Him do as He wishes with them, though I do pray to Our Lady as well.
But the above demonstrates how easily we can mis-communicate on these matters.
Peace
James
And I appreciate your genuine efforts to see the genuine faith in the consecration to Mary. I am doing my best to believe all things.
 
Yes, that is true according to the apparition 👍 But it is also true that we are free to believe that or not believe it.
So while I do give great respect to what the Church has deemed “believable” we also have to remember that this is not the same as an infallible Confirmation, which in itself makes me very curious why Our Father decides to present Mary as someone who through a devotion of total consecration (which is some sort of ritual promise, which St James seems to condemn) would promise salvation and “manage our merits and indulgences to Jesus” under the less than authoritive means of Confirmation.
Agreed - And I think this is really the point in much of this.
Whether it be Fatima, or DeMonfort, or whatever…the various devotions and consecrations etc. are indeed optional.
Ok, Mary would “manage” our merits and use them as the Lord wishes. This is all only if we consecrate ourselves to “her”. You see, this consecration seems to be the whole desire of this spirit… Why?
James 5:12
12 Above all, my beloved,[f] do not swear, either by heaven or by earth or by any other oath, but let your “Yes” be yes and your “No” be no, so that you may not fall under condemnation.
As to the why - I do not know except that those who undertake it feel they are being obedient to God and are attracted to it spiritually. To each his own.
Fair enough. These correction, I see I have unfairly represented 👍
We always want to be clear with each other…
And I appreciate your genuine efforts to see the genuine faith in the consecration to Mary. I am doing my best to believe all things.
If we seek to be understood, then we must seek to understand. I believe that through such understanding of each other, we can avoid errors on both ends of the spectrum.

Peace
James
 
which in itself makes me very curious why Our Father decides to present Mary as someone who through a devotion of total consecration (which is some sort of ritual promise, which St James seems to condemn
We could ask why the second person of the Trinity entered into the world through Mary and not just materialize from thin air? Because He wants to honor her.
This is all only if we consecrate ourselves to “her”. You see, this consecration seems to be the whole desire of this spirit… Why?
The consecration is not a vow and does not bind under sin. Nevertheless it is a promise – your word to your Heavenly Mother.

You have hit on a good point. Any soul in a state of grace can say in good faith the morning offering prayer.
 
We could ask why the second person of the Trinity entered into the world through Mary and not just materialize from thin air? Because He wants to honor her.
Jesus honors all men impartially.
What gives her honor? From Sacred Scripture, we see many instructions on how to devote ourselves to the Lord, what is pleasing to Him, and what the meaning of true religion really is. Do these things and keep them in your heart, and you will honor Mary no less than if we consecrated ourselves to Her. These are even the ways we are taught from Divine Revelation we can honor her, and all her children. But if we make additional promises, is that suppose to impress her more than works of mercy and pure devotion to Our Eucharist?

Filling our head with ideas of what is happening with our merits and indulgences and surrending them to a spirit through promises to tribute all of ourselves to this spirit is complicating things way more than I see as beneficial. But people are free to serve whom they desire and how.
The consecration is not a vow and does not bind under sin. Nevertheless it is a promise – your word to your Heavenly Mother.
You have hit on a good point. Any soul in a state of grace can say in good faith the morning offering prayer.
We already have been granted access to pray to the Lord from our hearts. And to honor one another so our prayers will be heard. This is our duty. And I ask for Mary’s prayers with a special reverence.

Im going to spend some more time looking into the consecrations to Mary. I have a feeling my MIL has done so, and sister in law.

Thanks Ed
 
I have talked to her about it! And she justifies her sterilization by stating it is only a tradition of man, and it is better to use our money to serve the poor instead of on 15 children. Also, not giving constant birth helps keep a woman’s body attractive so her husband wont lust for other women.
The USCCB has published a free summary of an article by an MD on the effectiveness of natural family planning: usccb.org/issues-and-action/marriage-and-family/natural-family-planning/medical-research/upload/CMR-Winter-Spring-2013-FINAL.pdf The actual article was a research experiment published in the journal of Contraception ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23153900 to compare the effectiveness of electronic hormonal fertility monitor (EHFM) group and cervical mucus monitoring (CMM) group natural family planning. It looks like the Electronic Hormonal Fertility monitor NFP method was 100% effective when used perfectly, but about 93% effective at 1 year when the instructions weren’t followed correctly. Has she been taught natural family planning by a qualified NFP teacher so she can follow it correctly? If she is really devoted to Mary, then she would want to be like Mary and allow for the remote possibility of a pregnancy (Jesus) even though there should be near perfect avoidance through abstinence from sex (Mary) or NFP (her). 🙂

The poor people in India were taught NFP. Don’t know much about the details of this, but the British Medical Journal in 1993 said that a study of 19,843 poor women in India using NFP has a pregnancy rate approaching zero. It doesn’t seem that NFP should be much more expensive than artificial contraception and shouldn’t come with some of the complications, i.e. infections, pain, death associated with some methods of sterlization and all surgeries. ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/8401097

The National Survey on Family Growth (NSFG)/ Center for Disease Control (CDC) web site referenced by the USCCB (cdc.gov/nchs/nsfg/key_statistics/d.htm#divorce) compared the divorce rate of 505 Catholic women (aged 21-44) selected from NFP programs with the 10,471 women in the 1995 NSFG. She found that 3% of the NFP users in the NFP programs reported they were divorced as compared with 15% of the Catholic women in the 1995 (Cycle 5) of the NSFG. Wilson concluded that there is less divorce among NFP couples than couples using contraception. usccb.org/issues-and-action/marriage-and-family/natural-family-planning/medical-research/upload/CMR-Summer-Fall-2013-Divorce-and-NFP-edited.pdf Sex is meant to express wedding vows, making the words of the wedding vows flesh - the commitment of a man and woman in a free, total, faithful, and fruitful way to each other until death along with canonical promises to fidelity, indissolubility, and openness to life (as rephrased from a well known Catholic moral theologian). People are supposed to express with their bodies what was expressed at the altar with their minds and hearts, so actually artificial contraception - by being unfaithful to the wedding vows - should theologically and empirically cause her husband to be more likely to stray with other women.
 
The USCCB has published a free summary of an article by an MD on the effectiveness of natural family planning: usccb.org/issues-and-action/marriage-and-family/natural-family-planning/medical-research/upload/CMR-Winter-Spring-2013-FINAL.pdf The actual article was a research experiment published in the journal of Contraception ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23153900 to compare the effectiveness of electronic hormonal fertility monitor (EHFM) group and cervical mucus monitoring (CMM) group natural family planning. It looks like the Electronic Hormonal Fertility monitor NFP method was 100% effective when used perfectly, but about 93% effective at 1 year when the instructions weren’t followed correctly. Has she been taught natural family planning by a qualified NFP teacher so she can follow it correctly? If she is really devoted to Mary, then she would want to be like Mary and allow for the remote possibility of a pregnancy (Jesus) even though there should be near perfect avoidance through abstinence from sex (Mary) or NFP (her). 🙂

The poor people in India were taught NFP. Don’t know much about the details of this, but the British Medical Journal in 1993 said that a study of 19,843 poor women in India using NFP has a pregnancy rate approaching zero. It doesn’t seem that NFP should be much more expensive than artificial contraception and shouldn’t come with some of the complications, i.e. infections, pain, death associated with some methods of sterlization and all surgeries. ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/8401097

The National Survey on Family Growth (NSFG)/ Center for Disease Control (CDC) web site referenced by the USCCB (cdc.gov/nchs/nsfg/key_statistics/d.htm#divorce) compared the divorce rate of 505 Catholic women (aged 21-44) selected from NFP programs with the 10,471 women in the 1995 NSFG. She found that 3% of the NFP users in the NFP programs reported they were divorced as compared with 15% of the Catholic women in the 1995 (Cycle 5) of the NSFG. Wilson concluded that there is less divorce among NFP couples than couples using contraception. usccb.org/issues-and-action/marriage-and-family/natural-family-planning/medical-research/upload/CMR-Summer-Fall-2013-Divorce-and-NFP-edited.pdf Sex is meant to express wedding vows, making the words of the wedding vows flesh - the commitment of a man and woman in a free, total, faithful, and fruitful way to each other until death along with canonical promises to fidelity, indissolubility, and openness to life (as rephrased from a well known Catholic moral theologian). People are supposed to express with their bodies what was expressed at the altar with their minds and hearts, so actually artificial contraception - by being unfaithful to the wedding vows - should theologically and empirically cause her husband to be more likely to stray with other women.
👍 awsome, thanks
 
How would you define a good devotion to Mary? How would you define a false devotion to Mary?
St. Louis Marie de Montfort discusses this in his excellent book True Devotion to Mary. I highly recommend that you read it if you haven’t already. God bless you.
 
For those with weak or no devotion to Mary, did you ever wonder…

What if at the Annunciation, her answer was ‘No, I will not serve.’?
Where would we be today? 😦

Since eternity hinged upon her ‘Yes’, where is the obvious debt of gratitude that we owe her, among all Christians?

Fiat … Let it be done! Today and every day.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top