It’s not wrong to love Mary. Protestants include her in their nativity scenes, for example. But lavish adoration of Mary is quite another thing. I see the Rosary recited often on EWTN and there are ten Hail Marys for every one Our Father. Ten prayers directed at Mary to everyone directed at God. Hm! Is that a good balance?
You miss one of the most important parts of the prayer “Blessed is the fruit of thy womb, Jesus”. God is present even in the Hail Mary.
Mary is at the cross, a very important scenario, of course. But two things from the Bible always struck me.
Code:
(1) After the nativity stories in Matthew and Luke, Mary is rarely mentioned in the gospels. And when she is it almost sounds as though Jesus is rebuking her. See John 2:4 and Luke 8:21.
Jesus isn’t rebuking. He’s pointing out that she isn’t important only because she is his mother, but because she also belives and does the will of God.
(2) If Mary is so central to Christian worship, why doesn’t her name appear in Acts, the letters of St. Paul and all the other epistles of the New Testament? That omission strongly suggests that she wasn’t that central to the earliest Christians.
You need to remember, she was alive during these years. Only Revelation was written after her death and assumption. Which is where Rev. 12:1 comes into play. John sees her after her death, assumption, and cordination
It seems that Mariology got a great impetus when Christianity had to compete with the mystery religions, where virgin goddesses often played a key role.
If your trying to convert someone you preach the truth. If some elements happen to be similar, you play on that. Most holidays were orginially pagan. Doesn’t detract it from the truth.
Honor Mary, of course. But the central role she plays in Catholicism today is unBiblical and - sorry - pagan.
Really…I wonder how Jesus feels about you calling his mother a pagan.
At the same time, if Catholics want to continue it, fine. I respect nearly all other faiths even when I cannot agree with them. I say ‘nearly’ because I do have trouble with extremist elements within all faiths, whether hyper-Muslims, Jews, Catholics or evangelical Protestants who look down on every faith but their own and consider the rest of us as heretics, inferior or hell-bent.