Thekla:
Dear Al,
I’ve read your first paragraph twice and I can’t get past the “international can mean anything someone wants it to mean…” part. What does it mean?
Code:
As for your second paragraph, I'm unclear if any of the locations where you are, or should I say the originator are, are in the United States.
You know, **I get phone calls from Italy but that doesn't make me Italian.** People in this country are endowed with rights; not phone lines or airplanes, people. And if some people want to give up their rights and have cameras installed in their living rooms, I can't stop them. But don't try and give away my rights or try and treat me like an inanimate object; a phone or an airplane.
There’s a literary technique in which the writer attempts to understand a statement by rephrasing it. So, I wrote “let me get this straight: international can mean anything you want it to mean”… which was in response to some confusion between domestic and international. That sort of thing.
The way laws are written, certain government agencies can only work on international issues or foreign issues. For example, the CIA is supposed to work on international or foreign stuff. Domestic stuff is supposed to be handled by the FBI.
The U.S. military is severely restricted in what it does in domestic stuff. Posse comitatus and all that.
So, strictly speaking “international” and “domestic” mean specific things. But, if a U.S. citizen appears to be receiving phone calls from someone overseas who is or is strongly suspected as being a terrorist, then it is an international call and is subject to a different set of laws than if the call was placed within the United States from someone in the U.S, to a person in the U.S.
I can’t help it if that’s the way the laws are written.
To use your example, if you get a call from Italy, as you say that doesn’t make you Italian, but… it is an international call. The call is subject to the jurisdiction of both Italy and the U.S. and if the call goes by cable and the cable passes through the Azores or Bermuda, then the Azorians and the British also have jurisdiction. So your call could be monitored four times.
If the call goes by satellite, then ANYONE… even a schoolchild … with a receiver can monitor your call.
if part of the call goes by microwave, then anyone in the line of sight of the microwave beam can monitor your call. Most calls use a variety of links, and are routed all over the place, so there is no telling how many people have access to your information.
It has nothing to do with rights. It has to do with jurisdiction. And it has to do with technology. Wireless communicaions is up for grabs. Ask your kids about if they ever listen to shortwave radio… most shortwave is private communications but anyone can listen in. That’s why important stuff is encrypted.
If you are driving a car with New York plates and drive up into Canada, you are then subject to Canadian law. It’s an international trip.