Why won't Carter debate his book?

  • Thread starter Thread starter estesbob
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
from www.opinionjournal.com Best of the Web (12/21):
As we noted Monday, Jimmy Carter, author of a new Israel-bashing book, has been complaining that he has been told he is unwelcome at “university campuses with high Jewish enrollment.” According to Alan Dershowitz, writing in the Boston Globe, that isn’t quite true:Brandeis President Jehuda Reinharz had invited Carter to come to Brandeis to debate me, and Carter refused. The reason Carter gave was this: “There is no need to for me to debate somebody who, in my opinion, knows nothing about the situation in Palestine.” . . .
Jimmy Carter isn’t brave for beating up on Israel. He’s a bully. And like all school-yard bullies, underneath the tough talk and bravado, there’s a nagging insecurity and a fear that one day he’ll have to answer for himself in a fair fight.
When Jimmy Carter’s ready to speak at Brandeis, or anywhere else, I’ll be there. If he refuses to debate, I will still be there–ready and willing to answer falsity with truth in the court of public opinion.
 
What exactly do you think Reagan should have got a Peace Prize for? Invading Grenada? Bombing Libya? Funding the Contras? Arming Saddam Hussein? Refusing to apologise for the shooting down of an Iranian passenger plane? Funding the Mujahadeen in Afghanistan?

Arafat won the Peace Prize jointly with Peres and Rabin, at a time when Oslo looked like an important breakthrough. Perhaps it was somewhat premature, but I don’t see any bad faith in the award.

However, given that Kissinger won it, I have to agree that the Nobel Peace Prize can be somewhat of a farce.

Mike
Freeing millions and million of people in Eastern Europe from the opression of communism. Bringing down the Soviet Union-one of the most evil regimes in the History of the World.
 
It seems like Mr. Dershowitz is annoyed that Jimmy Carter won’t debate it with him, personally. His own article details various places where he has debated it in public, even if Mr Dershowitz isn’t satisifed with the quality of the debate. He was more than happy to write a column about it in The Guardian last week, for example.

books.guardian.co.uk/departments/politicsphilosophyandsociety/story/0,1970147,00.html

(well, ok, it was a reprint from the LA Times)

Mike
What specifially did Mr Dershowitz write that was factually incorrect?
 
Worst President since Buchannan. In the top 5 worst Presidents of all time.
:eek:

Oh come on you’ve skipped over quite a few stinkers in there …Harding, Coolidge, Arthur, LBJ, Bush 😉

Back OT

Why would Carter have to “debate” a book?
The nature of a book is that the thoughts of the author are already there in black and white.

Why in the world would someone who spent many many hours and thousands of words to develop an idea be tempted to parse that down to sound bites?

The best criticism of a book would be another book or an essay.

I don’t understand this talk radio world :nope:
 
"YOU CAN ALWAYS tell when a public figure has written an indefensible book: when he refuses to debate it in the court of public opinion. And you can always tell when he’s a hypocrite to boot: when he says he wrote a book in order to stimulate a debate, and then he refuses to participate in any such debate. I’m talking about former president Jimmy Carter and his new book “Palestine Peace Not Apartheid.”

docs.google.com/View?docid=ah6sxjndq9qq_173gxsbxd
Because his claims have no merit and cannot stand up to scrutiny.
 
Freeing millions and million of people in Eastern Europe from the opression of communism. Bringing down the Soviet Union-one of the most evil regimes in the History of the World.
If I recall the period correctly it was thousands of eastern Europeans in their little two-cycle engine cars skirting the wall and crossing the border in Hungary and Czechoslovakia that was the proximate cause of the collapse. (Not to mention the thousands of Germans who physically took down the wall or the masses of ex-soviet citizens and soldiers pulled Yeltsin’s and Gorbachev’s bacon out of the fire from the reactionary coup.)

The ultimate cause was the inherent weakness in Communism as an economic system of course but the peoples of the East freed themselves as the common soldiers and officials stopped enforcing the system.
 
What exactly do you think Reagan should have got a Peace Prize for? Invading Grenada? Bombing Libya? Funding the Contras? Arming Saddam Hussein? Refusing to apologise for the shooting down of an Iranian passenger plane? Funding the Mujahadeen in Afghanistan?
Funding the Contras!👍 😃

I remember that we could not do field training because we did not have the funding to buy gas for our vehicles and helicopters. Carter was the worst.
 
If I recall the period correctly it was thousands of eastern Europeans in their little two-cycle engine cars skirting the wall and crossing the border in Hungary and Czechoslovakia that was the proximate cause of the collapse. (Not to mention the thousands of Germans who physically took down the wall or the masses of ex-soviet citizens and soldiers pulled Yeltsin’s and Gorbachev’s bacon out of the fire from the reactionary coup.)

The ultimate cause was the inherent weakness in Communism as an economic system of course but the peoples of the East freed themselves as the common soldiers and officials stopped enforcing the system.
You telling us that Reagan, Thatcher, and the Pope had nothing to do with it.

Hmmm, maybe we should have just boycotted the Olympics that would show them.
 
If I recall the period correctly it was thousands of eastern Europeans in their little two-cycle engine cars skirting the wall and crossing the border in Hungary and Czechoslovakia that was the proximate cause of the collapse. (Not to mention the thousands of Germans who physically took down the wall or the masses of ex-soviet citizens and soldiers pulled Yeltsin’s and Gorbachev’s bacon out of the fire from the reactionary coup.)

The ultimate cause was the inherent weakness in Communism as an economic system of course but the peoples of the East freed themselves as the common soldiers and officials stopped enforcing the system.
The why didnt it happen before Reagan? In 1976 Ronald reagan gave a major policy speech and outlined specifially how the Soviet Union could be bought down through a combination of military buildup and missle defense development. He was reviled as being ignorant and was told repeatedly that Commuism was here to stay and the only way to deal with the Soviet union was through appeasment and unilateral disarnment. When he took offece he implemented he policies and they worked exactly as he said they would. Even Ted kennedy admits he was instrumental in breing down communism.
 
Funding the Contras!👍 😃

I remember that we could not do field training because we did not have the funding to buy gas for our vehicles and helicopters. Carter was the worst.
Reagan stopped cold the spread of communism in Central America despite the efforts of the democrat congress to thwart him. For that alone he should have gotten the peace prize.
 
Estesbob-
Would your definition of “debate” mean having Carter going on Fox to be screamed at, insulted and badgered by the Right Wing Taliban?
 
Estesbob-
Would your definition of “debate” mean having Carter going on Fox to be screamed at, insulted and badgered by the Right Wing Taliban?
The topic at hand is Mr Carters refuasl to debate Alan Dershowitz. Im sorry Fox opffends you but if you want to attack them please start your own thread.
 
I’ll also take that as a “yes”.
The topic at hand is Mr Carters refuasl to debate Alan Dershowitz. Im sorry Fox opffends you but if you want to attack them please start your own thread.
 
Estesbob-
Would your definition of “debate” mean having Carter going on Fox to be screamed at, insulted and badgered by the Right Wing Taliban?
Please refrain from using terms and insinuations that you cannot back up. It is against forum rules.
 
Please refrain from using terms and insinuations that you cannot back up. It is against forum rules.
Interesting that thus far in this thread not one person has attemopted to defend Carters “facts” nor has one person cited anything wrong about Derschowitz’s “facts”. No wonder they want to change the subject to Fox news…
 
The topic at hand is Mr Carters refuasl to debate Alan Dershowitz. Im sorry Fox opffends you but if you want to attack them please start your own thread.
Why is it incumbent on Mr Carter to debate Mr Dershowitz? Authors are not required to debate their books, and their refusal to do so means nothing.

Nobody makes a big deal of someone refusing to debate David Duke, so why does Mr Dershowitz deserve that privelege?

Mr Carter is a strong defender of international law, while Mr Dershowitz defends targeted assassinations which, under international law, are considered war crimes. I really see no point to any debate between the two.
 
Freeing millions and million of people in Eastern Europe from the opression of communism. Bringing down the Soviet Union-one of the most evil regimes in the History of the World.
Even if I were to accept that, and I’m not going to debate that either way right now, he did enough other bad things - some of which I enumerated - that should automatically discount him from winning any sort of ‘peace prize’.

Mike
 
NOTICE

This thread has wandered off topic. Please return to the topic of the original post.

Thank you for your cooperation
 
What specifially did Mr Dershowitz write that was factually incorrect?
I don’t believe I said that he has said anything factually incorrect. I said he sounds annoyed that Carter won’t ‘debate’ with him, specifically. Why should Carter have to debate with him, specifically? I don’t understand why he should have such a fit of pique about it.

Mike
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top