Why won't Carter debate his book?

  • Thread starter Thread starter estesbob
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Perhaps…maybe…possibly…😛

I don’t really care what Carter fears. I just want to see a good debate by two experts. From where I sit, Carter has only spoken with the compliant press about his work. It would be nice to see him debate it with someone who disagrees with him.

Dershowitz’ critisicism of Carter as a bully and hypocrite are pretty mild. Carter was a politician. Do you think he is unable to handle real mudslinging? Btw…what good is served by any of us paying attention to Carter?
Maybe Jimmy Carter just doesn’t want to get into the mud with Dershowitz.

Read Dershowitz’s attack piece. He persoanlly attacks Mr Carter as a “hypocrite” and a “bully”. He also refers to certain reviews of Mr Carter’s book calling it “moronic”, “anti-historical” and “riddled with errors and bias”. It’s a safe bet that Mr Dershowitz shares that opinion. I don’t know what good can be served by Mr Carter paying any attention whatsoever to Mr Dershowitz.
 
Mr Carter neither hates Israel nor supports murderers and terrorists. I don’t know where you’re getting this.

If you can find any public statements by Mr Carter to the effect that he really does “hate” Israel or that he “supports” murderers and terrorists, I’d love to see them. Shouldn’t be too hard to find if they exist.
*Nor is Carter the unbiased observer of the Middle East that he claims to be. He has accepted money and an award from Sheik Zayed bin Sultan al-Nahyan , saying in 2001: “This award has special significance for me because it is named for my personal friend, Sheik Zayed bin Sultan al-Nahyan.” This is the same Zayed, the long-time ruler of the United Arab Emirates, whose $2.5 million gift to the Harvard Divinity School was returned in 2004 due to Zayed’s rampant Jew-hatred. Zayed’s personal foundation, the Zayed Center, claims that it was Zionists, rather than Nazis, who “were the people who killed the Jews in Europe” during the Holocaust. It has held lectures on the blood libel and conspiracy theories about Jews and America perpetrating Sept. 11. Carter’s acceptance of money from this biased group casts real doubt on his objectivity and creates an obvious conflict of interest. *

He accepts awards from Virulent anti-israel and antismetic despot. He has Yassar Araft, a brutal terorist as his guest in the White House. you lie with dogs you get fleas.

But the larger question is refusal to anser any of these charges prefering instead to wallow in the adoration of a compliant press and the likes of the apologists we have seen in this thread.
 
"YOU CAN ALWAYS tell when a public figure has written an indefensible book: when he refuses to debate it in the court of public opinion. And you can always tell when he’s a hypocrite to boot: when he says he wrote a book in order to stimulate a debate, and then he refuses to participate in any such debate. I’m talking about former president Jimmy Carter and his new book “Palestine Peace Not Apartheid.”

docs.google.com/View?docid=ah6sxjndq9qq_173gxsbxd
How could he debate the book with out being labeled an anti-Semite?
 
What is the core issue of the BOOK to you?
You aren’t being clear with your points. Are you saying that you believe Carter is anti-Semitic and can’t see how you could debate him without telling him he is? That’s easy - you don’t use the term.

-OR-

Are you saying that Dershowitz has claimed Carter is anti-Semitic, so Carter shouldn’t debate him because Dershowitz won’t be able to avoid calling him anti-Semitic? If so, I don’t see evidence of Dershowitz doing such.

My opinion of Carter’s book or his feelings toward Israel are unrelated to the thread, which is about his unwillingness to debate Dershowitz.
 
You aren’t being clear with your points. Are you saying that you believe Carter is anti-Semitic and can’t see how you could debate him without telling him he is? That’s easy - you don’t use the term.

-OR-

Are you saying that Dershowitz has claimed Carter is anti-Semitic, so Carter shouldn’t debate him because Dershowitz won’t be able to avoid calling him anti-Semitic? If so, I don’t see evidence of Dershowitz doing such.

My opinion of Carter’s book or his feelings toward Israel are unrelated to the thread, which is about his unwillingness to debate Dershowitz.
um, um, um
So you say what is in the book is irrelavent.
um, um,
I think that was the point!
 
Another professor thinks Jimmy Carter has gone over the edge. He is Mel Konner, a professor at Emory University.
When Soledad O’Brien of CNN, showing deep concern about the severe criticisms directed against the book, asked him how he would respond, he laughed. He has not once answered the many specific criticisms except to say, again and again, that his book is completely accurate.
He has said or hinted repeatedly that Jews control the Congress and the media, a classic anti-Semitic slur. It seems that Cuban-Americans can speak up on Cuba, Irish-Americans can support the IRA, Mexican-Americans can lobby on immigration law, but when Jewish-Americans speak our minds about Israel, we don’t deserve the same constitutional protections and a former president can try to silence us.
Read the whole article

ajc.com/opinion/content/opinion/stories/2006/12/21/1222edkonner.html
 
um, um, um
So you say what is in the book is irrelavent.
um, um,
I think that was the point!
I didn’t say it was irrelavent. I said my opinion of the book is unrelated to the thread. There is no reason to be rude.

It would be nice if you made clear statements and answered direct questions though…
 
I didn’t say it was irrelavent. I said my opinion of the book is unrelated to the thread. There is no reason to be rude.

It would be nice if you made clear statements and answered direct questions though…
The answer to your question is Carter is smart. Now what to do about explaining what that means…

If I said that your “expert” is not a rabbi would that help you? How about if I add Carter was a President of the U.S., thus your boy can tell you what is important to U.S. Presidents but most of us will listen to Carter on that issue. I really to not need to hear the opinion of your “expert”, he is free to speak on the over extension of the U.S. to Israel anytime he wishes, but that will not achieve his objective. So what is the actually objective he has?

I do not mean to offend you, however I think this expert has no business in such a debate, nor Carter.
 
The answer to your question is Carter is smart. Now what to do about explaining what that means…

If I said that your “expert” is not a rabbi would that help you? How about if I add Carter was a President of the U.S., thus your boy can tell you what is important to U.S. Presidents but most of us will listen to Carter on that issue. I really to not need to hear the opinion of your “expert”, he is free to speak on the over extension of the U.S. to Israel anytime he wishes, but that will not achieve his objective. So what is the actually objective he has?

I do not mean to offend you, however I think this expert has no business in such a debate, nor Carter.
Well that clears things up… smileys.smileycentral.com/cat/359.gif %between%

smileycentral.com/sig.jsp?pc=ZSzeb113&pp=ZNxdm801CJUS
 
If I said that your “expert” is not a rabbi would that help you? How about if I add Carter was a President of the U.S., thus your boy can tell you what is important to U.S. Presidents but most of us will listen to Carter on that issue. I really to not need to hear the opinion of your “expert”, he is free to speak on the over extension of the U.S. to Israel anytime he wishes, but that will not achieve his objective. So what is the actually objective he has?
:ehh:
First of all, neither of them is “my expert.” 😛 I’m interested in hearing from both of them.

I have no idea what you mean by your “rabbi” comment. I don’t mean to offend you, but the rest of your sentences are also unintelligable. Really…give them a read.
Texas Roofer:
I do not mean to offend you, however I think this expert has no business in such a debate, nor Carter.
Are you saying neither of them is qualified to discuss the Israeli-Palestinean conflict?? That doesn’t make any sense.
 
How could he debate the book with out being labeled an anti-Semite?
Bob
The answer to the question you asked is *
Jimmy Carter would be smeared and labeled Anti-Semite.*
This would be incorrect but it is one of the 2 objectives by the anti-Carter crowd the other objective is to get personal publicity
 
Bob
The answer to the question you asked is
Jimmy Carter would be smeared and labeled Anti-Semite.
This would be incorrect but it is one of the 2 objectives by the anti-Carter crowd the other objective is to get personal publicity
Really? So, if you know these are the 2 objectives, you must have read it somewhere. Can you cite your source? I haven’t heard it written or voiced by anyone.
 
Really? So, if you know these are the 2 objectives, you must have read it somewhere. Can you cite your source? I haven’t heard it written or voiced by anyone.
I haven’t seen that anywhere either, but it seems obvious. If you can’t smear him one way or the other, you’re going to have to consider that he may be right. For some strange reason, it is taboo (in America) to even ask the question, “hey, is Israel handling that Palestinian situation fairly?” let alone declare that they aren’t. As Carter said, these are fair subjects hotly debated everywhere (including Israel) but not here.

I propose Deshowitz debates An American jew who agrees with Carter (yes, they exist) and better yet, an Israeli citizen who agrees with Carter. But I get the feeling he never would, because bringing down an ex-president and Nobel prize winner would bring him more of the attention he craves.
 
I haven’t seen that anywhere either, but it seems obvious. If you can’t smear him one way or the other, you’re going to have to consider that he may be right. For some strange reason, it is taboo (in America) to even ask the question, “hey, is Israel handling that Palestinian situation fairly?” let alone declare that they aren’t. As Carter said, these are fair subjects hotly debated everywhere (including Israel) but not here.

I propose Deshowitz debates An American jew who agrees with Carter (yes, they exist) and better yet, an Israeli citizen who agrees with Carter. But I get the feeling he never would, because bringing down an ex-president and Nobel prize winner would bring him more of the attention he craves.
I don’t see why Deshowitz has to debate someone who may or may not understand what Carter meant by what he said in his book. In the US the author normally defends his work himself (we got that tradition from places like Oxford, by the way 😉 ) And, after all, Carter is an experienced debator and should be able to handle himself.
 
Another professor thinks Jimmy Carter has gone over the edge. He is Mel Konner, a professor at Emory University.

Read the whole article

ajc.com/opinion/content/opinion/stories/2006/12/21/1222edkonner.html
How ironic, then, that Jewish-Americans are embroiled in a grim struggle against a Christian former president who is tainting our holiday joy.
***embroiled in a grim struggle? Tainting our holiday joy? *** This must be news on every channel! (but it’s not)
He has become an apologist for terrorists.
Slander anyone? When did the opinion page become a place for shock-jock radio style attacks?

We could go line by line, but it’s pretty exaggerated histrionics for a professor. (unless his specialty is drama)
Carter has changed. Something has happened to his judgment. I don’t understand what it is, but I know it is very dangerous.
Oh? So now you’re a doctor? Is this man qualified to make psychiatric diagnosis?
At a minimum, his legacy is irrevocably tarnished, and he will never again be a factor in the quest for Middle East peace. At worst, he is emboldening terrorists and their apologists in the Arab world, encouraging them to go on with their terror campaign and refuse even to recognize Israel’s right to just exist.
Yeah - that’s Jimmy. He not looking for fairness or justice - he’s lookin to embolden and encourage terrorists.

Here’s the big finish:
Carter’s bizarre book is a poisoned holiday gift for Jews and Christians, and a danger to Jews throughout the world.
(do not eat this book!)

No, professor, a nuclear-capable Iran is a threat to Israel, Carter just wrote a book, professor sky-is-falling-right-now-on-me-and-my people.
 
General Reminder:

The charity level of this discussion appears to be deteriorating. **Participants are reminded to refrain from using ad hominem remarks. **Please self-edit for tone and content before clicking the “Submit” button. If the charity level does not improve, this thread will have to be locked.

Also, please stay with the subject of the original post.

Thank you for your understanding and cooperation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top