Why won't non-Catholic Christians recite the Holy Rosary?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jimmy_B
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah we go every year to see the lights. I usually buy several books at the Shrine bookstore.

On rosary-making: I need one made of cord because chain-link rosaries are so easily broken and the wire-wrapped versions are very expensive.
Did you try Catholic Supply on Jamison and Watson Roads in St. Louis? They have an awful lot of stuff there. The girl with the website above may be able to make something specific like that for you.
 
I wonder if the reason why Protestants do not recite the rosary, is because it reminds them of Buddhism?

I’m friendly with a number of Buddhists, and they have a string of beads called mala beads, on which they say prayers. They even hold their hands as Christians do when they pray and show reverence (folded hands while praying is an ancient pagan custom.)

For more info on them, see: buddhistmala.com

Tibetan Buddhists use a string of 108 beads, and they recite prayers using them (the beads help them keep track of how many prayers they have said.) I’ve also heard some Buddhists refer to them as “rosaries” (probably so non-Buddhists will more easily grasp what they are for.)

I have found that a LOT of former Catholics gravitate toward Buddhism, and I wonder if this is a reason…because it reminds them a bit of Catholicism?
 
Prayer beads exist in Islam, Baha’i, Hinduism, and Sikhism, too.
It is just an ancient, pre-printing press method of organizing prayers. Protestants don’t have them only because they came into existence around the same time as the printing press.
 
Mary is central to the Catholic Church…
I just wanted to ask about this statement. I am not sure if this was intentional so I don’t want to take it that way but wouldn’t Christ be central to the Catholic Church and not Mary? Though Mary is Christ’s mother she is still a supporting character in Chrisitanity. Isn’t Christ the center?

I am not trying to make this a ‘Mary’ thread but this statement kind of caught me off guard…

As for the rosary, especially in comparison to the ‘Lord’s Prayer’, I have always believed that the ‘Lord’s Prayer’ was a format to adhere to when praying to God. Which is why Christ says ‘This, then, is how you should pray’ in Matthew 6. He doesn’t say ‘This, then, is WHAT you shoud pray’ but HOW. He also says to pray to God this way. No mention of any other that should receive prayers. Since there is no evidence that Christ prayed to anyone but His Heavenly Father I try to be like Him and pray to God.😊
 
Since there is no evidence that Christ prayed to anyone but His Heavenly Father I try to be like Him and pray to God.😊
Well, we know from the Transfiguration in Luke 9:28-36, that Jesus and the Apostles went up on a mountain to pray. While Jesus was* praying*, Moses and Elijah appeared, talking with Jesus. How do you interpret that? Was he praying or not when Moses and Elijah appeared and began conversing with Him? Luke specifically calls it “praying” when this event occurs and states the purpose of the trip was to pray. I’m curious as to your take on these passages.
 
I just wanted to ask about this statement. I am not sure if this was intentional so I don’t want to take it that way but wouldn’t Christ be central to the Catholic Church and not Mary? Though Mary is Christ’s mother she is still a supporting character in Chrisitanity. Isn’t Christ the center?

I am not trying to make this a ‘Mary’ thread but this statement kind of caught me off guard…

As for the rosary, especially in comparison to the ‘Lord’s Prayer’, I have always believed that the ‘Lord’s Prayer’ was a format to adhere to when praying to God. Which is why Christ says ‘This, then, is how you should pray’ in Matthew 6. He doesn’t say ‘This, then, is WHAT you shoud pray’ but HOW. He also says to pray to God this way. No mention of any other that should receive prayers. Since there is no evidence that Christ prayed to anyone but His Heavenly Father I try to be like Him and pray to God.😊
Saying that Christ is central but Mary not is like you saying your husband is central in your life but your children are not. For a normal wife and mother BOTH husband and children are absolutely central, and it doesn’t take anything away from her love of either husband or children to say so. Indeed there’d be something wrong with her if she loved her husband but didn’t equally love the children that are so much a part of him.

Same with Christ and Mary - there’s nothing lacking in your love for Christ if you say that Mary is also central in your life. And Mary is such an important part of Christ’s life - there’s no-one else who was literally there every step of His human existence with Him, from the Annunciation to the Ascension - that if you truly want to imitate Him you’ll make her an equally important part of yours.

See love isn’t like a pie where there’s a limited amount and a big piece for one person means a smaller piece for others, it’s like a muscle that grows and expands in all directions when you exercise it in any way. That’s why Jesus said love of neighbour was like love of God. :yup: :love:

As for praying to God - Jesus requested the Apostles to pray, did He not? “When you pray” and all that? ‘Pray’ means ‘ask’ - so if Our Lord asked them to pray then He did indeed pray to them, and so can you if you want to follow His example.
 
Why won’t non-Catholic Christians recite the Holy Rosary?
Hi

Did JesusYeshuaIssa recite any rosary? If he did not; why should his followers do it? Jesus is the role model for his followers.

Thanks
 
Hi

Did JesusYeshuaIssa recite any rosary? If he did not; why should his followers do it? Jesus is the role model for his followers.

Thanks
Did Muhammad drive a car or use a computer? If not, why should HIS followers do either of these things? He is the perfect role model for HIS followers.
 
Because Catholics do it.
The rosary is our thing…the item and the prayer it represents. It is Catholic. Protestants and other non-Catholic Christians don’t have the same relationship with the Blessed Mother that we do. To us, Mary is OUR mother too. To them, she was the vessel used for Christ’s birth. I feel very priviledged to share the relationship that Christ had with his mother. She’s not God, no, and we all know that. But who could be a better role model for anyone who wants to know and love Jesus than His own mother? I pray to her to help me deal with my own family problems. St. Monica is right up there for me too, because my sons are not the people they could be and I ask her to guide me and intercede for them that they open their eyes and hearts to Our Lord, just as her son did. In addition to the rosary, I say the Chaplet of Divine Mercy every day on the way home from work, for my sons and all of our adult children who need to turn their lives around.

Maybe we could introduce other Christians to the Chaplet. That might fit their prayer traditions better than the rosary, and they could understand what those “repetitious” prayers do for us.
 
Hello

You asked why non-Roman Catholics don’t use the Rosary? The answer is that many Christians use a Prayer Rope. Why don’t you use the Prayer Rope and what are western catholic fearful of Hummmmmmm??

The Prayer Rope must easier then the Rosary, and it is much user friendly. Hey Eastern Catholic use only the Prayer Rope and not the Rosary why don’t you asked them??

bye
 
Hello

You asked why non-Roman Catholics don’t use the Rosary? The answer is that many Christians use a Prayer Rope. Why don’t you use the Prayer Rope and what are western catholic fearful of Hummmmmmm??

The Prayer Rope must easier then the Rosary, and it is much user friendly. Hey Eastern Catholic use only the Prayer Rope and not the Rosary why don’t you asked them??

bye
I’ve never even heard of a prayer rope. What makes it easier and more user friendly?
 
There is only one prayer on it and it is said over and over until completed at the end of the Prayer Rope. The Prayer is called the Jesus Prayer.
 
Very interesting. There’s a picture of one, and some links to how you can make one. I like the Jesus prayer. It’s something you could just say off and on all day, as time and activities allow.
 
You got it.

See I was right. It is easier to say and how much better can it be then that.
 
It’s different, and perhaps easier. I wouldn’t say better. After 50 some years of saying the rosary, it’s pretty easy. I’m planning to stick to my rosary and chaplet, and maybe I’ll remember to say the Jesus prayer a few times each day. It couldn’t hurt!
 
Hi friend!

I just asked if Jesus spoke the word “Rosary” from his mouth.!? Did he? Please.

Thanks
Hi there Paarsurrey,

Did Jesus ever say in the Bible “paarsurrey” from his mouth? And yet you are here in this Catholic forum, how funny lol

Truth is Jesus knows who you are and loves you The Virgin Mary loves you, that is the reason why you are here, you may think and believe otherwise, but he has you here to become Catholic.

The Rosary comes from the Bible every word of it!
**Hail Mary Full of Grace the Lord is with Thee,
Blessed art thou Amongst Woman and Blessed
is the Fruit of thy womb (Jesus)

Holy Mary Mother of God Pray for us Sinners Now
and at the Hour Of Our Death. AMEN**

Ufamtobie
 
Does anyone here make Rosaries?
http://bestsmileys.com/waving/5.gifI do!!!:yup:
That is just a *beautiful *rosary. I love the metal beads, they look like real roses!
I think the whole Christian faith is summed up in the Rosary.
Yes! It is!!
I remember once, here in the forums, somebody asked what we would do, if we lost all the Gospels, and we decided that we could reconstruct them, by reciting the rosary…
No wonder it is such a:love: :love: prayer!!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top