Wife doesn't want me to attend daily Mass

  • Thread starter Thread starter nevadairenaeus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
It is indeed a miracle and it happened by the grace of God. I was actually employed by LDS church when I decided to leave Mormonism. That meant I had to find a new job and move. Worries about possible divorce, ruptured family relations, unemployment, financial ruin, and the loss of my home - I don’t want to go through that again! Becoming Catholic was the hardest thing that I have ever done.
You will be so blessed for all your sacrifices 🙂 You have even given me strength to not give up. To continue to take my whole family with me to mass on Sundays, to continue to pray that my husband converts, to get all my children baptized and to push to get us into RCIA.
Thank you, and may God bless you so much :angel1:

-Nicki
 
Hi! Blessings be on you, and may our dear Lord help you in this little skirmish. I’ve not taken the time to read ALL the posts (just page 1), so I am not sure what faith your wife follows, but I expect it may be LDS as you had been. She simply may not understand how overwhelming it is to be really TOUCHED BY GRACE, and to have to follow Him no matter the cost to ourselves! Back on Page 1, somebody suggested the Valentine’s Day approach, and it seems like very good advice. It puts her on an understanding level where she can relate to your spiritual feelings, and may help her to feel that you, while choosing to embrace Catholicism, have in no way decided to turn your back on HER. If she’s coming across as controlling and insecure, I’d wager THAT is her main concern. She is obviously loving you and is deeply afraid of losing your love. As a loving husband – a loving, Christian, catholic husband, you want to reassure your wife that you married her for better and for worse, till death do you part. If she still is LDS, or some other faith, in time, seeing how much YOU love our Lord, and how much YOU wish to be in close union with Him, she may decide to look more closely to see just exactly what it is about catholicism which draws you so completely to God. I will pray for you, and hope that this would be the outcome of your struggle – that she may JOIN YOU in the faith – and who knows, she may even join you at daily Mass when she no longer feels threatened by this wonderful all-consuming, yet all-merciful, all-fulfilling God!
 
I haven’t read all the posts, so I hope I’m not repeating too much.

If it’s your lunch break, and it’s taking no time away from things you should be doing with/for your family, I don’t see the problem going to daily Mass, even if your wife disapproves. (I wouldn’t advise too much that takes away from family time.) But I hope you are taking the Graces from the Masses and Holy Communion’s and using them to be the best husband your wife could imagine. It will help her immensely to see that this change is not just a change of buildings and rituals, but a true change of heart. You are not turning away from your former beliefs, but are turning towards something that is more fulfilling.
 
nevadairenaeus,

I can really relate to you in that my dh is Agnostic and really dislikes Catholicism.

When I reverted back to Catholicism I was so on fire for my faith! I volunteered in my parish, went to daily mass, and Adoration of the Most Blessed Sacrament.

My husband will not go to mass with me, he sometimes mocks my religion and he turns off EWTN radio when I am listening, saying he won’t listen to THAT PREACHING!

It really is a cross to not share the same faith. Sadly I have backed off of volunteering in the parish, daily mass, and going to our Adoration chapel in order to be with my dh at home more. I still go to the nursing home and give Catholics the Eucharist, pray and visit with them, but I feel less and less a part of my parish now. I feel so alone at mass on Sundays. I’ve noticed that I am living more like I used to before I came back to the Church.😦

I am going to take your example and start to go to daily mass again at least twice a week.🙂
 
She actually told me that she was worried that going to daily mass was the first step on the path to having an affair. Go figure. 🤷
Turn the tables–tell her you want her to give you a play by play of what she did all day to ensure it meets your approval.
 
I am a cradle Catholic, I know nothing of the trials of conversion. I am married, but to a Lutheran, raised in the Lutheran church, and we do attend Catholic Mass together.

With that being said…

First… I saw you mention somewhere “God or your family”.
No. It’s “God FOR your family”…

Second. Why did you become Catholic? If you mentioned that somewhere, I missed it.

Third. This is the hard one. Talk to your wife about your answer to question #2. This will be very hard, but you two need to seriously talk. Without talking, your marriage will implode.

Do not lie to your children about your faith.
Do not lie to your wife about your faith.
Do not lie to yourself about your faith.

Would you lie and say you do not know Jesus to keep the peace in your house?

You do yourself and your family a disservice for hiding your faith, there is no reason for it.
Unfortunately, at some point, you’re going to have to point out to your wife that her idea of the “the one true church” came along around the 1820’s… hmmm… yeah… she might have some thinking to do on that.

I would never advocate for a divorce unless abuse arises, so please don’t think of that as an option. If your wife and/or her family want to see that happen, ask your wife what that says about her faith.

I have friends who are Mormon. To each their own, but you should never hide your true faith in God to satisfy the selfish needs of another, wife or otherwise.
 
I couldn’t disagree more. The OP’s wife is being a control freak by telling him what he can and cann’t do over his lunch hour. If he caves into his wife, the things she will control and dictate what he can and cann’t do will only get worse.
I agree, the sooner she gets used to him actually doing what he wishes with his lunch hour the better. She ought to be grateful, lots of men run to strip clubs for lunch and all other sorts of things. She’s never going to be OK with it family, she is LDS. It’s best to say that it’s lunch hour, it’s not taking away from family or marriage time, and he’s doing it. I really can’t see how this is a problem UNTIL the LDS came into it. I would never give up Jesus in the Mass especially when it’s your lunch hour for crying out loud.
 
I am a cradle Catholic, I know nothing of the trials of conversion. I am married, but to a Lutheran, raised in the Lutheran church, and we do attend Catholic Mass together.

With that being said…

First… I saw you mention somewhere “God or your family”.
No. It’s “God FOR your family”…

Second. Why did you become Catholic? If you mentioned that somewhere, I missed it.

Third. This is the hard one. Talk to your wife about your answer to question #2. This will be very hard, but you two need to seriously talk. Without talking, your marriage will implode.

Do not lie to your children about your faith.
Do not lie to your wife about your faith.
Do not lie to yourself about your faith.

Would you lie and say you do not know Jesus to keep the peace in your house?

You do yourself and your family a disservice for hiding your faith, there is no reason for it.
Unfortunately, at some point, you’re going to have to point out to your wife that her idea of the “the one true church” came along around the 1820’s… hmmm… yeah… she might have some thinking to do on that.

I would never advocate for a divorce unless abuse arises, so please don’t think of that as an option. If your wife and/or her family want to see that happen, ask your wife what that says about her faith.

I have friends who are Mormon. To each their own, but you should never hide your true faith in God to satisfy the selfish needs of another, wife or otherwise.
No, a choice between God and my family was forced on me. It was made very clear to me that leaving the LDS church and becoming Catholic could very likely lead to divorce. I had to choose: do nothing and preserve my marriage or follow where I felt Christ was calling and risk a break-up. Divorce hasn’t happened yet, but it remains a possibility. If I started to openly live my faith and teach it to my kids divorce would follow almost certainly. My hope right now is that over time this may change. And I am not lying to my kids. Saying something like “don’t worry about it” or “I will explain it later when you are older” or simply not telling them where I am going on Sunday morning is not lying. Hiding things from them would be more accurate.

Jesus told us that following him would sometimes cause division in families and that we must always choose him. Not peace but a sword as the gospels put it. One of those ‘hard sayings’ of Jesus, the kind we don’t normally like to think about.

I became Catholic because I believe what the church teaches. I believe it to really be the Body of Christ in its fullness. I believe that if I refused to become Catholic then I would be rejecting Christ.
 
You will be so blessed for all your sacrifices 🙂 You have even given me strength to not give up. To continue to take my whole family with me to mass on Sundays, to continue to pray that my husband converts, to get all my children baptized and to push to get us into RCIA.
Thank you, and may God bless you so much :angel1:

-Nicki
I pray that both our families come into the Church. :signofcross:
 
Have you thought about inviting your wife to a daily Mass with you? Even tho she is not Catholic, she could attend (and perhaps receive a blessing at Communion if the priest allows). Or consider inviting her to be part of some parish-related function, perhaps being careful in picking one where she would feel have a tendency to feel the most welcome.

Do you ever take your wife out to lunch? A “double”-date with (1) Mass plus (2) lunch, might help your wife not feel so much like an outsider. Maybe you could manage this on your day off (assuming you have one.)

I think it must be hard for your wife to see you enjoying something [your new Catholicity] so much, since it takes time away from her. Maybe she doesn’t even believe that you are just going to church for the love of the Mass.

Yes, your wife’s reaction seems somewhat “controlling”, but If I were you, I would see this as a normal reaction on your wife’s part. A type of jealously, mixed with fear. If you could gently accept her reaction, answer any questions she might have about the Faith, BUT 👍 try to keep going to Mass.

And yes, I’ll bet this is something your RCIA coordinator has some insights on.
 
So I just converted to Catholicism this Easter and have been going on my lunch break to Mass when my work schedule permits. I really feel a need and desire for the Eucharist. I feel the need for the grace and life that it brings. It’s something new and wonderful. Since my wife is not Catholic nor supportive of me becoming Catholic, I haven’t told her that I am attending Mass during the week. Talking about religion always seems to create more tension.

However, the situation changed today. I was coming out of Mass when she called. She asked where I was and I told her. She became very upset and feels that I am sneaking around with all this Catholic stuff. She feels that I am obsessed (which i probably am, but in a good way I hope). She doesn’t understand why I am going since it is not an obligation to attend. I have trouble communicating with her about my spiritual life. To her its all strange and unfortunately she doesn’t want to know anything about it. Kind of a ‘don’t ask, don’t tell’ situation.

So now she is asking me not to go to Mass on the weekdays. Its not a requirement of the faith, so I guess I could stop going if it is causing problems in my marriage. On the other hand, as I stated above, I feel the spiritual need to be there and receive Christ in the Eucharist. I feel somewhat spiritually fragile. I’m not sure what to do.
Dear nevadairenaeus,

You are a ‘young’ Catholic and you deserve all of the support that the Catholic community, in your place of worship as well as here online, can give you. Being a Catholic is the biggest and most meaningful GIFT that any human being can ever be given. I rejoice with you at your newfound faith; I also understand 1000% why you have a strong wish to attend Mass, and especially to partake of the Eucharist.

You are nurturing your relationship with CHRIST, not primarily with your wife, when you attend Mass. That you go on weekdays will bring you into especially tender connection with Him. Don’t think He does not care or that He does not notice. He most certainly does!

I believe that if I were in your shoes, I would consider telling my spouse that this is between you and CHRIST. In Catholicism, no one has the right to interfere with the Sacraments we receive. No one has the right to ask what we confess. This is our covenant with God. And, while it is very nice when friends and family members understand and share our sentiments, we must always remember that Christ comes FIRST. He alludes to this in the Gospels, when He says that if anyone is more important to us than Him, then we are not worthy of Him. And, that He has come, in one sense, to bring division: one spouse will be taken, one may be left behind. He is well aware of the struggle and consternation you are going through; and you most certainly are not alone!

My own mother lived with my father, who was hostile to Catholicism during the first 52 years of their marriage. She had 52 years of attending Mass ALONE on Sundays, Holy days, often during the weekdays, and any other times that she wished. This was despite his unhappiness about this, his complaints to her and to us children, & his trying to put up obstacles to this. She prayed for him every single day. Well, after the 52 years, he happened to take a very painful and distressing trip to the cancer ward at age 78. One day, he asked everyone to leave his hospital room. Then my father asked for a priest. He explained this to no one - not my mother, no one. The priest visited him, and my father became a Catholic during that one hospital room visit. He went to Mass, then, faithfully, with my mother until he died at age 90.

Do not despair. Give your difficulties with your wife to the Lord and ask Him to guide you both. Prayer can go a long, long way toward bringing you both a measure of peace or at least of acceptance. Your faith may be used by God to help your wife - you cannot know this. My mother’s being unwavering, solid, steadfast, most certainly was a powerful witness that my dad took hold of, when he was finally vulnerable. 🙂

Please do remember: Christ always must come first, in our hearts and in our actions. Since Christ brings you joy, I am wondering why your wife would be upset. Perhaps a priest - or, if your wife is hostile to a priest - then perhaps a licensed therapist who your priest knows, would understand this; and deal with it masterfully and with love and tact, with both of you. I think this could be of great help to both you and your wife.

Blessings to you! I am delighted you are here! 👍 😃
 
No, a choice between God and my family was forced on me. It was made very clear to me that leaving the LDS church and becoming Catholic could very likely lead to divorce. I had to choose: do nothing and preserve my marriage or follow where I felt Christ was calling and risk a break-up. Divorce hasn’t happened yet, but it remains a possibility. If I started to openly live my faith and teach it to my kids divorce would follow almost certainly. My hope right now is that over time this may change. And I am not lying to my kids. Saying something like “don’t worry about it” or “I will explain it later when you are older” or simply not telling them where I am going on Sunday morning is not lying. Hiding things from them would be more accurate.

Jesus told us that following him would sometimes cause division in families and that we must always choose him. Not peace but a sword as the gospels put it. One of those ‘hard sayings’ of Jesus, the kind we don’t normally like to think about.

I became Catholic because I believe what the church teaches. I believe it to really be the Body of Christ in its fullness. I believe that if I refused to become Catholic then I would be rejecting Christ.
The whole picture came into play when you brought in the fact that not only are you an Ex-Mormon, but your wife is a current active Mormon. By converting, you’ve basically thrown away her Eternity because she cannot go to the Celestial Kingdom without you. Well, you know, if the Celestial Kingdom doctrine was true. Mormon women also are engrained since childhood that they are complete failures if they don’t marry a returned missionary, get married in the temple, and live their life as faithful Mormons. Your conversion is not just a threat to your marriage, it is construed as a failure on her part, and I’m sure not only by her but by her family and ward members. The balance to be both a faithful Christian and Catholic, and a faithful husband, will be a huge challenge for you.

As an ex-Mormon Catholic convert, with a non-Catholic husband (not Mormon, Blessed be God!), here’s my recommendation. Continue to go to Daily Mass. But go to the earliest Sunday service you can so that you can be home with the family as much as possible on that day. Continue to keep the Sabbath day holy in their eyes, by reading the Bible and doing quiet things. Do your best to foster a very robust relationship with God by praying often, including things like praying the rosary. I’m a big fan of praying the Rosary on my commute to and from work, it keeps me calm and gives me a chance to pray it every day. And pray the Rosary every day, even if you don’t understand it or even if it is a challenge to find the time.

Buy some Gregorian Chant CD’s and play them in your home. I had a Gregorian Chant CD that I listened to every single evening as I drifted off to sleep for years before I converted - I truly believe that hearing the word of God, even if I didn’t understand it, helped play a part in my conversion. Plus they are an instant stress-reducer. I’d also recommend downloading Audio Sancto homilies onto your iPod or smartphone and listening to them in the car. They will teach you about how to live as a good Catholic.

Embracing Christ’s Passion will be very foreign to you as an ex-Mormon, but understanding His suffering and learning how to carry your own cross for love of Him is crucial to your holiness and sanctification, and these concepts are completely absent in LDS theology. Meditate often on his Passion, and on his love for you. Learn about the devotion to the Sacred Heart. Making the conversion from being a “good Catholic” to learning to accept the love of God has been like a second conversion for me this last year.

Get online and find a copy of “Introduction to the Devout Life” by St. Frances de Sales. He was a master at teaching holiness to the laity. His emphasis is to become holy in your vocation, whatever that vocation may be. You don’t have to do more devotions to be more holy, you simply have to do your current devotions with more ferver and devotion and love. Daily Mass is an amazing opportunity to grow in love for God and to gain the strength you will need to persevere through this growing stage. You should also read “Practicing the Presence of God” by Brother Lawrence. It’s a short read, but it absolutely changed my life. Basically, the idea of living in the presence of God is to do for God what you used to do for yourself. He famously said, “I flip my little omlette in the pan for love of God.” Imagine everything you do - washing dishes, driving to work, tucking your child into bed, taking out the trash - as an offering to God to show Him your love, and a way to grow in holiness. He has given you this vocation, of marriage, and a state in life, and will give you all the tools you need to become holy and sanctified through this vocation.

Focus very strongly on staying focused on your family and on your wife when you are at home, going above and beyond to show the charity of Christ through your actions. Unite yourself with Christ as you sacrifice for your family and show them that you don’t have a new religion, you have truly begun a walk with the real Christ.
 
Jesus told us that following him would sometimes cause division in families and that we must always choose him. Not peace but a sword as the gospels put it. One of those ‘hard sayings’ of Jesus, the kind we don’t normally like to think about.

I became Catholic because I believe what the church teaches. I believe it to really be the Body of Christ in its fullness. I believe that if I refused to become Catholic then I would be rejecting Christ.
You are right on target here. I think we should give you support in this. It is a difficult journey. Thank you for taking it. I still recommend counselling.

With a Christian OH I have a family on the verge of rupture. Right now, each is getting individual counselling.

some of the answers here are sarcastic and from those who just don’t “get” your situation. It is heartbreaking because, it just is.

You may feel as though you are on this road without a road map. It is important to take this one day at a time. Daily Mass is a good anchor for you. It may not be a “requirement” but it is a necessity for you. commit to it but also be flexible to take your wife to lunch sometimes. It isn’t feasible to do that every day, but it is feasible to Consume Jesus…to bring his Grace home.

Peace…one step at a time. You are realistic to see that this could end up in divorce, but try to put that away and use the grace you have access to now. If she leaves, then it won’t be because you didn’t love her enough it will be because she just doesn’t understand. Probably fear.
 
I am happy that you found the catholic church and found it to be a welcoming place for you and you feel great about being a part of something wonderful.

As for your wife…I think your first mistake was hiding going to mass from her. She might feel like you are not giving her much attention or attention at all. As much as you love the church you have to show that same kind of love and adoration to your wife if not MORE SO. I speak from experience. My husband and I volunteer for the church A LOT! We used to teach CCD for children and my husband is the choir director as well for our english mass. For a while there…we had no HUSBAND/WIFE time at all. He worked 6 days a week, was going to school full time. Came home nearly at midnight to continue homework or finish up work stuff. Weekends he went to go teach CCD then of course go to mass where he sings. I was feeling LEFT OUT! I was feeling like I was not important anymore. There were times where he had lunch as had the ability to just give me a call and ask “Hey hun…wanna go out to lunch?” Or “Hey babe…I have time during lunch time, are you making anything for lunch so I can come home and eat?” Instead he would go eat lunch with the guys from work. I will admit… we women are VERY NEEDY…and not in the bad way. WE want to be with our husbands…we love our husbands…I tell my husband…“Hey if you work more that’s fine…but I expect to be compensated. No one takes my time from my husband and me away…and I get left with NOTHING!” So I let him know how I felt. We fought a lot. He didn’t seem to understand. It came to a point where he and I were just to more people living in the same house. And he noticed it…cause I wasn’t affectionate anymore. We came to a compromise. He gave up the CCD teaching…we eat lunch at least 3 times a week together…unless his work load is very heavy.

So come to a compromise with your wife. Let her know that if she felt so strongly about anything she took on, she wouldn’t expect that you put severe strict limitations on her. She would resent you right? So make a deal with her. Go to church 2 or 3 days on the weekdays…and then go to church on Sundays. Go eat lunch with HER… make her feel special. That way she wont be upset that you are spending more time with the church…and leaving her behind. Most of us women are not to far from men in attitude . We are proud…and we sometimes do not want to make known how much we hurt…so we lash out. Its pride…and its bad. Talk to your wife…hope everything works out well for you!
 
Take the advice that Scott Hahn was given - Lay off the theology ( trying to convert his wife) and beef up the romance.

Use your love for the Eucharist and Christ in your actions, to show your wife that this love, your experience in the fullness of faith is about you being the best you can be in Christ’s image. Use your love, devotion, time to show her. Kimberley Hahn started to realize that although she did not believe or understand Reconcilliation, she could not deny that Scott was kinder, more patient etc… when he returned home after celebrating the Sacrament.
 
You have stated that your wife is not Catholic so that begs the question, what is she? Is she a Christian? If so, then what denomination is she? I ask these questions because some Protestants do not like Catholics and don’t approve of Catholic activities, whatever they may be. Anything that appears to be a “work” is suspect. Is she really concerned with where you go on your lunch breaks or does she have an ax to grind with the Church? On the one hand, I would say that she has no right dictating how you worship God, but on the other hand, I can see how sensitivity on your end would possibly soften the resistance.
 
You have stated that your wife is not Catholic so that begs the question, what is she? Is she a Christian? If so, then what denomination is she? I ask these questions because some Protestants do not like Catholics and don’t approve of Catholic activities, whatever they may be. Anything that appears to be a “work” is suspect. Is she really concerned with where you go on your lunch breaks or does she have an ax to grind with the Church? On the one hand, I would say that she has no right dictating how you worship God, but on the other hand, I can see how sensitivity on your end would possibly soften the resistance.
She’s Mormon, so no, not Christian. At least not the way the majority of Christendom explains Christianity.
 
I have the same problem with my husband. He is so jealous of God. Be patient. Do not put her against you. If she see on you the change that God do she will follow you:thumbsup:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top