women priests

  • Thread starter Thread starter mmmtoasty
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Women can’t become priests. I think that is a outdated rule and it should be changed. With all of the equal rights, women rights etc; you would think by now a women would be able to become a priest. It is only a matter of time till it is changed.

-Scott
Well then, by the same token, men should be allowed to have babies. I mean,we’re in the 21st century. Restricting child bearing to women is just sexist; or is that just how God made us. The same is said for the priesthood being for Catholic men. Just as the laws of nature cannot allow men to have babies, the Church cannot allow a female priesthood. It is not even up to the Church. There is no argument for such a matter.
 
No, I’m not softening my position.

The priesthood doesn’t provide the emotional provisions women require, even in a monastery. There could be exceptions, but in general, the priesthood entails a lonely existence. Its also a thankless job.

But the bottom line to it all is, it isn’t up to you or me, but to God.

If God wants women to be ordained, they will be. However, I have never heard people calling for prayers on the issue, and I doubt that those who are calling for the ordination of women, would accept God’s will unless it went their way.

So I’m doubtful to it will ever happen.

Jim
No way. First, the current model of 1 priest per rectory is not by design. Even secular priests should ideally be living in a small community of 2+ priests.

While the priesthood is not a job – it’s a vocation, it’s FAR from being “thankless.” While it’s perhaps the single most difficult and demanding vocation a man might undertake, it’s also clearly the most rewarding or at least potentially rewarding.

Ordained female priests are clearly an impossibility.
 
Spiller
No way. First, the current model of 1 priest per rectory is not by design. Even secular priests should ideally be living in a small community of 2+ priests.
Even if there are 5 priest living in a rectory or monastery together, male bonding is different than the relationships that females require. The male priest, even when living with other priest, is lonely. Its more of a male thing than a priest thing.
While the priesthood is not a job – it’s a vocation, it’s FAR from being “thankless.” While it’s perhaps the single most difficult and demanding vocation a man might undertake, it’s also clearly the most rewarding or at least potentially rewarding.
Yes, its a vocation and rewarding, but its also a thankless job. Heck, hang around this forum for a while and you’ll wonder why some priest just don’t walk off the job.
Ordained female priests are clearly an impossibility.
Thats what I’ve been saying. So why have you arguing about it? 🤷

Jim
 
Actually it’s you that is wrong when it comes to doctrine and dogma. While dogmas can be more fully revealed to man, their meaning cannot be reversed.
Exactly where did I say dogmas could be reversed??? I didn’t! Doctrines also CANNOT be reversed or changed, they can simply be developed in understanding more fully.
Dogmatic elements of the deposit of faith need not be defined if they are clearly evident. That’s precisely the case with Ordinatio Sacerdotalis. There was no new dogmas defined, but the document made it clear that the male-only priesthood is a part of the deposit of faith that has always existed in the Church. The clearest most concrete dogma I can think of the the Holy Trinity – it’s not merely a doctrine.
Nope, it’s doctrines that need not be difined unless and until they come under significant misunderstanding and/or are being denied. It is at this time a dogmatic declaratioin would be published.
As for the Holy Trinity being dogma as apposed to doctrine, I may be wrong but I don’t think any dogmatic declarations on the Trinity have been issued. Please provide said document if it has been. I am open to correction when it is valid.
Doctrines (whose principal role is to support dogmas) can and do change to an extent greater than simply being more fully revealed.
Nope…doctrines CANNOT and DO NOT change!!! They can only be more fully developed and understood more deeply.
Doctrines are not to support dogma…they ARE the deposit of faith.
As far as limbo goes, it was never anything more than a theological construct.
Sounds almost exact to what I said.

I do see where your confusion might be coming in…from your bio I see you put Christian. I am coming from the standpoint of Catholic Christian Doctrine/Dogma/Discipline. I do know that in many (all?) non-Catholic groups, doctrine is not that big of a deal…it is something that can be believed or not depending on the person.
 
Please stick to the original topic, everyone. Take side discussions into new or existing threads. Thank you all.
 
Women can’t become priests. I think that is a outdated rule and it should be changed. With all of the equal rights, women rights etc; you would think by now a women would be able to become a priest. It is only a matter of time till it is changed.

-Scott
I don’t think the Church will ever change their position on this. If for no other reason, the Church has been against it so long, they are kind of backed into a corner. To reverse their position on this, would throw the Church into turmoil.

If you take the Bible as a whole, there are numerous passages which show women in important roles, including teaching, prophesying, and I even think Paul called one an apostle. In Galatians, it’s stated “There is neither Jew nor Greek, slave nor free, male nor female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus”. IMO, Christ does not recognize gender as an important issue, but the Church leadership does not agree.

I’m not an active advocate for women priests, and while it would take a little getting used too if it were ever to occur (which it won’t), I’m not against it either.
 
**I don’t think the Church will ever change their position on this. ** If for no other reason, the Church has been against it so long, they are kind of backed into a corner. To reverse their position on this, would throw the Church into turmoil…
It cannot. It’s not that the Church chooses not to ordain women, it lacks the authority to do so. It cannot.
 
I don’t think the Church will ever change their position on this. If for no other reason, the Church has been against it so long, they are kind of backed into a corner. To reverse their position on this, would throw the Church into turmoil.
The Church cannot ordain women to the priesthood. It lacks the authority to do so.
If you take the Bible as a whole, there are numerous passages which show women in important roles, including teaching, prophesying, and I even think Paul called one an apostle. In Galatians, it’s stated “There is neither Jew nor Greek, slave nor free, male nor female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus”. IMO, Christ does not recognize gender as an important issue, but the Church leadership does not agree.
There were no women ordained in the Bible – nor were there any female Apostles.
I’m not an active advocate for women priests, and while it would take a little getting used too if it were ever to occur (which it won’t), I’m not against it either.
Impossible…
 
This is a issue of obedience to the Magisterium. To even bring it up for discussion is disobedience to the Church. It is our duty to accept it without questioning. Please pass this along to any Catholic friends, parishioners, etc. who bring it up.

Pax Christi,

trob
Amen
Deacon Ed B
 
This is a issue of obedience to the Magisterium. To even bring it up for discussion is disobedience to the Church. It is our duty to accept it without questioning. Please pass this along to any Catholic friends, parishioners, etc. who bring it up.

Pax Christi,

trob
That’s simply not true. You are not only wrong, it’s bad to suggest people are “disobedience to the Church” for discussing it. We are not.

That said this topic is not open for further discussion amongst the clergy of the Church as if there was a possibility to ordain women to the priesthood.
 
The Church cannot ordain women to the priesthood. It lacks the authority to do so.

There were no women ordained in the Bible – nor were there any female Apostles.

Impossible…
If it were so inclined and moved by the Holy Spirit, IMO the Church can do anything it wants too.

In Romans, Junia was called by Paul indirectly an Apostle, although obviously she was not one of the original 12. BTW, I noticed you totally ignored the scripture I provided from Galatians, which kind of puts a dent in the no women priests argument.

Again however, I’m really neutral on this and for whatever reason, I know women priests will never happen.
 
I’ve heard it said (and I agree): Women cannot become priests anymore than a man can give birth.
Did you watch Oprah the other day? She had a pregnant man on. Be careful what you say. 😉

PS: He was transsexual man (used to be a woman).
 
That’s simply not true. You are not only wrong, it’s bad to suggest people are “disobedience to the Church” for discussing it. We are not.

That said this topic is not open for further discussion amongst the clergy of the Church as if there was a possibility to ordain women to the priesthood.
Agreed! God gave us a brain. To actively and publicly promote and go against the Church on some subject is one thing, but just discussing it, shouldn’t be a problem. If it is, then maybe this forum should be shut down, since disagreement is supposedly is not allowed. :rolleyes:
 
If it were so inclined and moved by the Holy Spirit, IMO the Church can do anything it wants too.
And following God through His Church and not doing what our egos begs of us is exactly what separates Catholics and Protestants.
In Romans, Junia was called by Paul indirectly an Apostle, although obviously she was not one of the original 12. BTW, I noticed you totally ignored the scripture I provided from Galatians, which kind of puts a dent in the no women priests argument.
No, it doesn’t. While there were certainly female (a)postles (or disciples), none of the original 12 (A)postles were women – no matter what your personal interpretation of Scripture might suggest to you.
Again however, I’m really neutral on this and for whatever reason, I know women priests will never happen.
Nothing to be neutral about. This is a non-issue.
 
Agreed! God gave us a brain. To actively and publicly promote and go against the Church on some subject is one thing, but just discussing it, shouldn’t be a problem. If it is, then maybe this forum should be shut down, since disagreement is supposedly is not allowed. :rolleyes:
Just so people know what I meant:

Acceptable: Us discussing this matter in this manner.

Unacceptable: Pastor preaching from the ambo that the Holy Spirit has not yet spoken to him about this matter and that he’s keeping an open mind because it just might happen.
 
Scott, with respect, and as a believing Catholic, I disagree with you. For one thing, the twentieth century is not the first time the topic of ordaining women has come up in the Church and been rejected as impossible in light of the nature of the Church’s divine constitution. The Early Church also faced this debate on more than one occasion, with certain heretical sects (gnostics I believe being one, but I could be mistaken) “ordaining” women on their own initiative. Some important things to keep in mind-not a single one of the 12 Apostles were women. All were men. There are other reasons, stemming from and tied in with this exposition which the Church has traditionally looked to and stated that because of, ordaining women is contradictory to the infallible teachings of the Church. These include that as the priest is acting “in the person of Christ,” part of which includes the symbolic role which necessitates a male, as Christ was male, but also includes acting in the husbandly role of Christ to the Church, which obviously a woman cannot carry out, because of these reasons among others; to try and ordain a woman to the the priesthood would be to try to have a sacrament using invalid matter. Therefore, it would be impossible.
Not only did Jesus choose 12 men to share the Last Supper with, he chose 12 Jews eventhough he had begun to begun to preach to non-Jews e.g. the Samaritan woman at the well, He even had a theological discussion with her and did not condemn her for arguing a point with him. If it follows that only 12 men were chosen should it follow that all of them should be Jews (albeit converted to Christianity). We must also bear in mind that Jesus never condemed slavery yet we would be horrified if the Church today said slavery is not wrong. During the middle ages the Church debated whether or not black people have Souls. Thank God things do change. It is also worth bearing in mind that the Church is the People of God as stated in Vatican 2. Of course ordination as we know it did not begin until the 300s AD
 
The Church cannot ordain women to the priesthood. It lacks the authority to do so.

There were no women ordained in the Bible – nor were there any female Apostles.

Neither were Jentiles, black people or slaves

Impossible…
 
Notice the OP has not been to CAF since he posted the question?
 
If you take the Bible as a whole, there are numerous passages which show women in important roles, including teaching, prophesying,
You forgot ‘mother’, or don’t you consider that to be an important role.?

And why would it be necessary for a woman to be a priest in order to be ‘important’?
and I even think Paul called one an apostle.
Nope, Paul said that a woman and here husband had been well noted by the Apostles. Not the same thing as actually being an Apostle

Rm 16:7
In Galatians, it’s stated “There is neither Jew nor Greek, slave nor free, male nor female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus”. IMO, Christ does not recognize gender as an important issue, but the Church leadership does not agree.
Are you saying that the Church leadership doesn’t consider women to be among the Body of Christ?
 
Women can’t become priests. I think that is a outdated rule and it should be changed. With all of the equal rights, women rights etc; you would think by now a women would be able to become a priest. It is only a matter of time till it is changed.

-Scott
Isn’t it against the law to discriminate? It’s only a matter of time before the church gets sued.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top