women priests

  • Thread starter Thread starter mmmtoasty
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I dont understand why there are no women priests. Can women even become priets?
Simple answer to the question:

Not in the One, Holy,Catholic and Apostolic church.

Pax Domini sit semper vobiscum.
 
Isn’t it against the law to discriminate? It’s only a matter of time before the church gets sued.
I see…separation of church and state so that the church doesn’t influence government and candidates don’t endorse a “state religion”.

But it’s perfectly ok to attempt to interfere with church policy and hierarchy.

How convenient. Have your cake and eat it too.
 
Did you watch Oprah the other day? She had a pregnant man on. Be careful what you say. 😉

PS: He was transsexual man (used to be a woman).
Oh…I’ll be careful…

It’s an abomination!!

An insinuation of Lucifer thru this person to bring us slowly into accepting (socially) the further abominations to come.

Probably in the not so distant future an “abomination that casues desolation”.
 
Did you watch Oprah the other day? She had a pregnant man on. Be careful what you say. 😉

PS: He was transsexual man (used to be a woman).
Still is a woman. A surgically and chemically mutilated woman but a woman nonetheless.
 
I see…separation of church and state so that the church doesn’t influence government and candidates don’t endorse a “state religion”.

But it’s perfectly ok to attempt to interfere with church policy and hierarchy.

How convenient. Have your cake and eat it too.
Hey I’m just sayin’… it doesn’t make much sense?

I’m not saying we should give in and ordain women priests.
 
Notice the OP has not been to CAF since he posted the question?
Yup. There’s another thread, over at the Back Fence, I believe, that commented on this very thing, referring to it as the “March 11” phenomenon or some such.

It seems there were a cropload of accounts created on 11 March, and then in the past few days did a drive-by of posting a really simplistic question (which generated an awful lot of debate) and then disappearing. Some have characterized this as trolling, but some other more charitable and enlightened souls have assumed good faith (God bless 'em – they should be on Wikipedia) and opined they might be a school class whose homework was to post a question on the forum.

It might be a good idea when such “drive-bys” happen would be to refer the poster to an already extensive thread on that topic (which as a rule exist) and await further enquiries from the new poster. That would encourage sincere enquirers to immediately read what has already been posted – rather than wait while people craft their answers – and would discourage trolls.

Just my opinion.

Funny thing is, we had an admitted troll come here with the express and stated purpose to whip up some antipathy. The first few posters refused to rise to the bait, but guaranteed, someone just *had *to fire back, and others joined in; his mission accomplished, the troll left, while the members of the forum continued to debate, ignoring the comments of “Um, dudes, like, he’s gone…”. As a matter of fact, new posters joined in to reply to the OP after the OP’s stated departure to give a piece of their mind. 🤷

Oh, and so as to be at least marginally on topic:

Rome has stated she does not have the authority to ordain women priests. HH BXVI stated while head of the CDF that was an infallible proclamation. So…I accept.
 
The major theological reason why women can not be ordained, has to do with the Mass. At the moment of the consecration, the priest becomes Christ. Christ is a male, and man can not change, what Christ is.

Also, and this is merely my personal opinion, women by nature could not handle the loneliness that the priesthood entails. Women in general, need other people, a spouse or other women, to share their emotional feelings and thoughts with. The priesthood does not provide this dimension.

Jim
I completely agree with the first part of your post, that the priest is “in persona Christi” and women can never be that.

However, about women not handling the lonliness that priesthood entails, I think I disagree with the part about priests being lonely. It seems to me that priests have a social life, being invited to and hosting many events, dinners, etc. I have lived alone for quite some time and do not feel “lonliness” because no one is actually alone. We have our guardian angels, and most importantly, Christ himself is with us. I have a darling cat, friends in choir and in my parish. I really think the priests and religious in their communities have more human companionship than I do. 🙂
 
Isn’t it against the law to discriminate? It’s only a matter of time before the church gets sued.
No way…

No one has a “right” to be ordained – including those men who are ordained.

No politician or judge in the right mind would dare try to sue the Church (or allow the suing) on this matter. And if some wacko did, it would be dismissed.

In practical reasons the reason if hasn’t been tried it that it would trigger a fairly serious backlash even as the case was being dismissed.
 
No politician or judge in the right mind would dare try to sue the Church (or allow the suing) on this matter. And if some wacko did, it would be dismissed.

.
Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals.

You’d be amazed what that court would allow.
 
No, it doesn’t. While there were certainly female (a)postles (or disciples), none of the original 12 (A)postles were women – no matter what your personal interpretation of Scripture might suggest to you.
If you’ll reread my post, I clearly said that she WAS NOT one of the 12 apostles. :rolleyes:
 
Nope, Paul said that a woman and here husband had been well noted by the Apostles. Not the same thing as actually being an Apostle

Rm 16:7

Are you saying that the Church leadership doesn’t consider women to be among the Body of Christ?
I stand partially corrected, you are partially incorrect. It depends what translation of this passage you read. Some translations back up your premise, and some clearly say Paul was referring to her as an apostle. A couple even say, she was actually a man, but most research does not back that up.

Concerning your other point about the Church leadership doesn’t consider women to be among the Body of Christ? No, I don’t mean that at all. What I was trying to say and I suppose I did it poorly was that although the passage I quoted clearly says that being male or female doesn’t matter to Christ, thus technically having female priests shouldn’t matter either; the Church obviously doesn’t agree.
 
Maybe not in the Roman Catholic Church, but there are other, smaller, splinter Catholic Churches that do. Plus the Episopalians
Putting “Catholic” in your churches name does not make you Catholic.

If a church is ordaining women as “Catholic” priests, it is not Catholic.

Chuck
 
No she had a woman who chose to have her breast cut out, take testosterone and call herself a man on her show.

She can’t be ordained either.

Chuck
Did you watch Oprah the other day? She had a pregnant man on. Be careful what you say. 😉

PS: He was transsexual man (used to be a woman).
 
No she had a woman who chose to have her breast cut out, take testosterone and call herself a man on her show.

She can’t be ordained either.

Chuck
heh. It’s like that joke–If you call a dog’s tail a leg, how many legs does the normal dog have? Four, because calling a tail a leg doesn’t make it so.
 
Women can’t become priests. I think that is a outdated rule and it should be changed. With all of the equal rights, women rights etc; you would think by now a women would be able to become a priest. It is only a matter of time till it is changed.

-Scott
They won’t. Check out the link in the previous post
 
Speaking as a woman,I sincerely hope Never to see women priests in my time.

But then again,I believe that…

Boy Scouts are for BOYS only

Girl Scouts are for GIRLS only

so on and so on.

Jesus had many faithful women at His side through-out His ministry, He loved women and respected them enough to allow a Woman to be the first to see His risen glory, but He never appointed them to be Shepard’s of His flock. Why?, only He knows the answer to that, but it is enough that we follow His example.
In my not so humble opinion:

There is simply too much important work that needs to be done that only women can do that is not being done.

I believe that a civilization reflects the the soul and heart of women. I know this is a rather outmoded view but I believe that I am right. To quote Florence Nightingale when approached by women who wanted to enlist her support to have more women doctors she said, “I don’t need doctors. There are plenty of doctors. What I need are nurses.”

Don’t get me wrong, I am happy that my doctor is a women. I am prefectly happy that there are male nurses. But, there is still plenty of work that needs to be done that is not being done because men and women are engaged in power games and struggles.

And as long as the prevailing feminist view is predominantly pro-choice, I am not so sure I want women to rule the world.

That’s my tirade for the day.
 
My understanding on the subject is that Christ Himself is the ONLY one who even has the authority to change the design of a sacrament. Therefore, the design of Holy Orders will be reserved exclusively for men, until we hear from Jesus. 😃

It has nothing to do with discrimination, women’s rights, etc. The church (to whom priests are married) is female so Jesus doesn’t (and never will) allow females to be married to His female church. Jesus is the bridegroom, the church is His bride.
 
A priest acts in persona Christi during the mass. In the person of Christ. Christ is a man. A woman cannot be a man.

There is a multitude of roles for evangelization and service for us women to do in the church. We do not need to nor should be priests.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top