I don’t think there is any evidence “proving” that contraception is tearing marriages apart. Where is this evidence?
It’s really unfair (and false) to say that Emmar and Debora are spreading untruths that “NFP hurts marriage”. They’re trying to communicate their experiences and
their marriage. They are speaking of their experiences, just like you are speaking about your experiences. It would be nice if all sides got together and tried to understand each other during these conflicts, but that doesn’t always happen.
People are flooding your inbox because Emmar and Debora find NFP difficult??? really? It’s all their fault?? Maybe you should refer them to an NFP intructor?
Rence, I really appreciate what you are trying to do. It is fair. I thank you for that. emmar and Debora have been referred. Whether they have taken that advice is unknown to me. Every few years on this forum we get a new batch of people coming in saying that Church teaching is wrong and the debates go round and round.
Unless you have been in every thread, please don’t presume that what I said is false. There are threads with the very title, “NFP hurts marriage.” And then there are many people supporting that very wrong idea. I used to be able to refer people coming into the Church to CAF, but I can’t anymore. I am very sad about losing this very wonderful resource. The Church says that NFP is a gift in marriage. There is *no *reason that people who struggle with NFP should have to defend against contraception.
The thread titles used to be, “Help, my spouse doesn’t want to abstain.” or “I am really struggling with Church teaching, please help.” Those were the common threads. Now they are much fewer. We used to be able to spend our time supporting each other in living out the sacrament of marriage. I have made some very real friends here at CAF. But now time on CAF is spent undoing damage.
I don’t get to meet people where they are anymore, because they are here for a different purpose. If you notice my post to the OP was all about support. Other people here wanted to give the OP support, but instead we have spent 100+ posts trying to fix very real misinformation.
You, yourself have said that you haven’t seen the research on what contraception does to marriage. Shouldn’t we be spending our time on a Catholic message board sharing that information? If you don’t know about it, please learn. You can be a voice of hope.
If you say, “everyone is different, not everything works for everyone,” I can only pray that you mean “every method of NFP, doesn’t work for everyone,” that I wholeheartedly agree with. I hope you are not saying, “it is all relative, and what works for you might not work for me,” since that is the rallying cry of the age of relativism that the Church is currently battling.
I hope that we can consider you an ally in meeting people where they are and being compassionate without giving a single inch on Church teaching. You seem to have a good head on your shoulders. I hope you are here to bring Truth.