Yet Another "NFP Stuggles" Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lookouts
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Whoa whoa… wait a minute. When did I do that??

Did I ever say the words “NFP hurts marriage?” Did I promote or even MENTION contraception on this thread? The only time I even acknowledged contraception was when someone asked me about it personally, of which I thought was uncalled for - and I didn’t say anything about it either way.

And lastly… what in the world “misfortune” am I spreading???

All I did was reiterate that NFP is difficult, and say that I feel lied to by all the promoters who painted this wonderful picture without even mentioning the difficulties or that it could possibly not even work! Heck, I wish someone had told ME nfp would be difficult before I got married… I’d be much better prepared for it if that was the case, and maybe it would’ve worked out better for me!
With all due respect you have, in numerous posts, given the impression that you cannot use NFP and are instead using ABC. If that isn’t the case and you don’t want it to seem that way perhaps you should re-read your posts before hitting submit. As a few of us have mistaken that.
 
I am happy for you and anybody else when you are lucky and it works.

I am sorry to burst a bubble for people here but Catholic marriages suffer and break due to sex issues and NFP.

Please, just be patient and considerate with people like OP.
Marriages do not break down due to NFP. If the lack of sex is causing that serious of an issue in your marriage then you have other problems. Also, let’s be clear here. The OP wants to use NFP…his wife wants HIM to sin and use a condom. On top of their combined depression issues, do you really think adding mortal sin will help?
 
Marriages suffer and break down because of sin. A valid marriage lived according to God’s plan, worked at by two people who put God first and seek frequent grace of Confession is a marriage that lasts til death.
Nice way to be considerate.
How is the view from the high horse?
 
Please look at what you are doing. You blaming NFP for something that has absolutely nothing to do with NFP. Contraception will tear you apart. *Not *contracepting will bring you together! That is a fact that our society of broken marriages, has proven!
I don’t think there is any evidence “proving” that contraception is tearing marriages apart. Where is this evidence?
Please, please, I beg you both to look at the untruths you are believing. Please don’t spread these untruths that “NFP hurts marriage.”
It’s really unfair (and false) to say that Emmar and Debora are spreading untruths that “NFP hurts marriage”. They’re trying to communicate their experiences and their marriage. They are speaking of their experiences, just like you are speaking about your experiences. It would be nice if all sides got together and tried to understand each other during these conflicts, but that doesn’t always happen. 🤷
Our culture is already so broken! Contraception is deadly to marriage! Please, please don’t do this! You are making my work doubly hard to have to unteach all of the misinformation you are spreading. There are times after the two of you post that my PM inbox lights up like someone lit it on fire. People are believing you and they are going into marriage contracepting.
People are flooding your inbox because Emmar and Debora find NFP difficult??? really? It’s all their fault?? Maybe you should refer them to an NFP intructor? :confused:
 
With all due respect you have, in numerous posts, given the impression that you cannot use NFP and are instead using ABC. If that isn’t the case and you don’t want it to seem that way perhaps you should re-read your posts before hitting submit. As a few of us have mistaken that.
I never stated that I don’t use NFP. I simply stated I have had problems with it, because I was trying to point out the flaws in how it gets promoted. It’s no one’s business what method of BC I use, which is why I haven’t given out that information. You can speculate if you’d like, you seem VERY interested for some reason, considering you won’t take the hint and drop the subject after I’ve already twice told you that it’s no one’s business and that I’m not going to give out that information on this thread.

And even if I DO use contraception, I am in no way guilty of promoting it (as been accused), considering I’ve hardly even mentioned it.
 
I’m slightly confused about something.
Why are women waiting until marraige prep to learn about their cycles, about when ovulation happens compared to when menstuation starts?
Shouldn’t this knowledge be had around puberty and adolescence? Women are only fertile about 6 days per cycle. It isn’t hard to notice the changes during the cycle.
Because there’s not much confidence in NFP as an effective tool to avoid conception. It has a poor reputation in general for being ineffective. Most people equate NFP with the old rhythm method. And when speaking specifically (if you get that at all, as opposed to the rhythmn method), it’s got a poor reputation for being difficult to learn and difficult to follow.

I think it’s awful that pubescent and adolescents aren’t taught about NFP. They should know something about tracking their cycles and signs of their cycles when they get their period. How will they know something is off if they don’t know what’s normal?
 
Marriages do not break down due to NFP. If the lack of sex is causing that serious of an issue in your marriage then you have other problems. Also, let’s be clear here. The OP wants to use NFP…his wife wants HIM to sin and use a condom. On top of their combined depression issues, do you really think adding mortal sin will help?
The OP just proves that there are serious sex and NFP issues in Catholic marriages.
That’s all I am pointing out.

… and maybe you are right. If some people were warned beforehand then maybe they would not get married in the first place.
 
I’m slightly confused about something.

Why are women waiting until marraige prep to learn about their cycles, about when ovulation happens compared to when menstuation starts?

Shouldn’t this knowledge be had around puberty and adolescence? Women are only fertile about 6 days per cycle. It isn’t hard to notice the changes during the cycle.

The deciding whether being intimate or not is more difficult, but the couple needs to assess, what need is greater, the need to be intimate vs the need to postpone or avoid a pregnancy.

I think that this is where the upset lies, “Hey, I can’t have sex when I want and avoid pregnancy simultaneously with NFP”
I first heard about NFP when I started reading Mary Beth Bonacci back when I was 14 years old. I then moved on to Christopher West during my late teens/early twenties, and learned more about it through his books. I started charting a little less than a year before my wedding day, during which time I bought an NFP machine and took a class.
 
I am happy for you and anybody else when you are lucky and it works.

I am sorry to burst a bubble for people here but Catholic marriages suffer and break due to sex issues and NFP.

Please, just be patient and considerate with people like OP.
Um, I hope you’re not referring to me in this. I don’t think I’ve ever been harsh or inconsiderate in cases like these. If I have, I apologise.

Also, I don’t count myself as “lucky”. I think God has given me huuuge blessings, and that scares me because I kind of assume He expects huuuge things back from me. I’d rather be suffering and have less expected of me. 😛
 
Um, I hope you’re not referring to me in this. I don’t think I’ve ever been harsh or inconsiderate in cases like these. If I have, I apologise.

Also, I don’t count myself as “lucky”. I think God has given me huuuge blessings, and that scares me because I kind of assume He expects huuuge things back from me. I’d rather be suffering and have less expected of me. 😛
Admonsta, everyone is different. What is easy for you won’t be easy for someone else. And what you find difficult will be easy for someone else. Count your blessings if NPF is easy for you, and yes, you’re lucky 🙂 But I’m sure there are other things you struggle with instead. And those things you struggle with will be easy for other people, and they probably won’t understand what you find so difficult about it. And hey, if you don’t have any struggles at all, that means you’re extra-lucky 🙂
 
They have bragged about their contraception use and told those of us who don’t contracept to “stop judging them.” Understand: They came to a Catholic board and pushed very wrong behavior as a good alternative and then accused faithful Catholics of judging them.
I’ve never seen anyone “brag” on this board about using contraception. Why would anyone brag about that? You pretty much get labeled with a scarlet letter that follows you in every thread here if you openly admit to using contraception.

Maybe you mistook them being honest and relying something to the people here as them bragging?

On another note, it could be very silly that they’d accuse anyone of “judging”… but it could not be so silly depending on what was actually said. If what was said to that person was merely objective and just stating what the Church teaches and why, then absolutely not, that is not judgmental.

And it’d be silly for anyone to think so.

But if things got personal and other people started telling the person that he/she had a bad marriage, had an invalid marriage, was selfish, or anything else personal like that, then yes, I would consider that to be uncalled for and judgmental.
 
Admonsta, everyone is different. What is easy for you won’t be easy for someone else. And what you find difficult will be easy for someone else. Count your blessings if NPF is easy for you, and yes, you’re lucky 🙂 But I’m sure there are other things you struggle with instead. And those things you struggle with will be easy for other people, and they probably won’t understand what you find so difficult about it. And hey, if you don’t have any struggles at all, that means you’re extra-lucky 🙂
👍👍👍

Rence, I like you. So logical and always charitable… it’s refreshing! 🙂
 
LucyLight and others who struggle with periodic continence:

Abstinence is like a highlighter. Having to abstain when you don’t want to, or having to get in the mood when you didn’t really want to is about bring light into the marriage. The most long-married happy people I know have embraced abstinence as part of their marriage, whether fertile or not. It is a HUGE part of the sacrificial season for the Eastern Catholics. Fast and abstinence in the Eastern Catholic rites often means truly that. They abstain from all things of the flesh. But they don’t abstain because they are bad. They abstain because they are good and pleasurable. (Though not being a huge meat eater, fasting from meat has never been a big sacrifice for me, so I give up something else as well during no meat Fridays.)

We abstain because we are called to abstain. Scripture says when we fast from food and when we abstain from sex. It doesn’t say, “if.”

And when it says “when you abstain” is says do so ‘by mutual agreement and use the time for prayer.’ If one of you doesn’t want to abstain, then don’t! Don’t abstain unless you are called to abstain!

NFP isn’t the trouble in marriage. Looking out at a secular culture who tempts us to sin constantly, is the trouble. If you had never heard about contraception, (even the withdrawal method) it wouldn’t be an issue. We want to contracept because we fear that God isn’t who He says He is! Somewhere in the backs of our minds we don’t really think that God will provide if we are faithful.

Day in and day out I struggle to know that God really will take care of me. I was a LUMP in my bed today, an absolute speed bump. I barely moved. Yet people still cared for me and loved me. Why? I did nothing to earn it! I was sick. Some might say that, oh, I will return the favor, like life is some mutual pact of care. The day might come that I can’t move at all. “I will take care of your diapers when you are a baby as long as you take care of me when I am elderly.” But what if I become so disabled that I can’t do anything?

Our culture certainly has proven that! Our culture would have us believe that only the capable and fit deserve to have kids. I was advised in high school by teachers no less, to “never have kids. Your health won’t let you keep up.” Seriously!

Whatever the *reason *you need to space births or not have any more babies at all is the thing to offer before our Lord to beg for answers or peace. He has a purpose and a plan for your life. If abstinence is so tough, then embrace it! For me, it has been letting people give to me when I can’t give back that I have had to embrace. I don’t mind abstinence. I have a fairly high sex drive, but I GET what God is doing there. I get it.

If you, Lucy, or anyone else came and said, “I am really struggling with the reasons we are abstaining. I am sad that these things are in our life.” I would get that. But that is not what people are addressing. They are sad that they don’t get to have sex whenever they feel like it! (I do get upset at the other side as well too, so don’t get me wrong.) I get almost as irritated with the, “Look at us, we can have sex whenever we feel like so we are more holy,” people as well. I have certainly taken *them *to task on this board more than I have taken the NFP strugglers.

My entire point can be summed up in the thesis, “NFP is not the problem. NFP has amplified the problem.” That I agree with. For that, people have my heartfelt prayers and deep compassion. Marriage is hard. God didn’t design it to be hard, but our very first act as humans was to disobey God and do it our way. Bl. John Paul often emphasized the design of the UN-fallen man. That is our goal in life is to reach the state of “unfallenness” To live forever with God in paradise. That was the design.
 
I never stated that I don’t use NFP. I simply stated I have had problems with it, because I was trying to point out the flaws in how it gets promoted. It’s no one’s business what method of BC I use, which is why I haven’t given out that information. You can speculate if you’d like, you seem VERY interested for some reason, considering you won’t take the hint and drop the subject after I’ve already twice told you that it’s no one’s business and that I’m not going to give out that information on this thread.

And even if I DO use contraception, I am in no way guilty of promoting it (as been accused), considering I’ve hardly even mentioned it.
I don’t want to know, I just want you to know what you are projecting. Because I for one would not want people to think I am living contrary to the teachings of the Church. I didn’t say you are promoting it. However I will say that it comes off as promoting ABC if you say “oh yeah it’s so hard I get why you would use a condom” what should be said is that it is very hard it is a cross but adding sin to it won’t make it better.
 
LucyLight,
My heart goes out to you.

I agree that people who struggle aren’t necessarily promoting contraception. There are people who in other threads, who were being addressed, who do. They have bragged about their contraception use and told those of us who don’t contracept to “stop judging them.” Understand: They came to a Catholic board and pushed very wrong behavior as a good alternative and then accused faithful Catholics of judging them.

As to your more important issue, I would like to address it if I can, but it might be more appropriate in a PM to get to the nitty gritty. I will try in my next post since it is relevant to this thread, though. God bless you, LucyLight!
Thank you Deb,

I should probably clarify why NFP has been difficult for my marriage. I don’t want people to think that I am promoting artificial contraception. I have health reasons that would make having another child dangerous for me so we are using NFP permanetly. We only have relations in phase 3 (post ovulation days 20-28). I am thankful to have NFP but abstaining is a huge strain in our marriage because we have so many days of abstinence. Hopefully it will get easier as we get older.
 
Um, I hope you’re not referring to me in this. I don’t think I’ve ever been harsh or inconsiderate in cases like these. If I have, I apologise.

Also, I don’t count myself as “lucky”. I think God has given me huuuge blessings, and that scares me because I kind of assume He expects huuuge things back from me. I’d rather be suffering and have less expected of me. 😛
I don’t want to be cheap but only the first line was for you. 🙂
 
I don’t want to know, I just want you to know what you are projecting. Because I for one would not want people to think I am living contrary to the teachings of the Church. I didn’t say you are promoting it. However I will say that it comes off as promoting ABC if you say “oh yeah it’s so hard I get why you would use a condom” what should be said is that it is very hard it is a cross but adding sin to it won’t make it better.
Well lucky for me, I didn’t say that. 🙂
 
The OP just proves that there are serious sex and NFP issues in Catholic marriages.
That’s all I am pointing out.

… and maybe you are right. If some people were warned beforehand then maybe they would not get married in the first place.
The OP’s problem s that his wife is suffering from depression. She needs help. What she doesn’t need is added sin. I don’t get why people think marriage should be about getting to have sex every day. Sex is important, as Debora has pointed out it is a renewal of the vows. A reminder of the Sacrament. But in normal life there are going to be times when you aren’t going to be able to have sex. This should not mean your marriage suffers. For some it will be harder than others but it is a fact that it will happen to every couple.
 
Well lucky for me, I didn’t say that. 🙂
I was being general. I am posting from my phone and getting the formatting right is difficult. Actually I can’t even see most of what I type so I am not taking responsibility for my egregious spelling or grammar or random word usage either. 😉
 
I don’t think there is any evidence “proving” that contraception is tearing marriages apart. Where is this evidence?

It’s really unfair (and false) to say that Emmar and Debora are spreading untruths that “NFP hurts marriage”. They’re trying to communicate their experiences and their marriage. They are speaking of their experiences, just like you are speaking about your experiences. It would be nice if all sides got together and tried to understand each other during these conflicts, but that doesn’t always happen. 🤷

People are flooding your inbox because Emmar and Debora find NFP difficult??? really? It’s all their fault?? Maybe you should refer them to an NFP intructor? :confused:
Rence, I really appreciate what you are trying to do. It is fair. I thank you for that. emmar and Debora have been referred. Whether they have taken that advice is unknown to me. Every few years on this forum we get a new batch of people coming in saying that Church teaching is wrong and the debates go round and round.

Unless you have been in every thread, please don’t presume that what I said is false. There are threads with the very title, “NFP hurts marriage.” And then there are many people supporting that very wrong idea. I used to be able to refer people coming into the Church to CAF, but I can’t anymore. I am very sad about losing this very wonderful resource. The Church says that NFP is a gift in marriage. There is *no *reason that people who struggle with NFP should have to defend against contraception.

The thread titles used to be, “Help, my spouse doesn’t want to abstain.” or “I am really struggling with Church teaching, please help.” Those were the common threads. Now they are much fewer. We used to be able to spend our time supporting each other in living out the sacrament of marriage. I have made some very real friends here at CAF. But now time on CAF is spent undoing damage.

I don’t get to meet people where they are anymore, because they are here for a different purpose. If you notice my post to the OP was all about support. Other people here wanted to give the OP support, but instead we have spent 100+ posts trying to fix very real misinformation.

You, yourself have said that you haven’t seen the research on what contraception does to marriage. Shouldn’t we be spending our time on a Catholic message board sharing that information? If you don’t know about it, please learn. You can be a voice of hope.

If you say, “everyone is different, not everything works for everyone,” I can only pray that you mean “every method of NFP, doesn’t work for everyone,” that I wholeheartedly agree with. I hope you are not saying, “it is all relative, and what works for you might not work for me,” since that is the rallying cry of the age of relativism that the Church is currently battling.

I hope that we can consider you an ally in meeting people where they are and being compassionate without giving a single inch on Church teaching. You seem to have a good head on your shoulders. I hope you are here to bring Truth.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top