Yet Another "NFP Stuggles" Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lookouts
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The OP’s problem s that his wife is suffering from depression. She needs help. What she doesn’t need is added sin. I don’t get why people think marriage should be about getting to have sex every day. Sex is important, as Debora has pointed out it is a renewal of the vows. A reminder of the Sacrament. But in normal life there are going to be times when you aren’t going to be able to have sex. This should not mean your marriage suffers. For some it will be harder than others but it is a fact that it will happen to every couple.
I totally understand that you don’t get why people think marriage should be about getting to have sex everyday. I do. But there are many many people who don’t get why some think marriage does not include getting to have sex everyday. And I’m sure that most marriages wouldn’t suffer with not being able to have sex everyday. But it’s clear that a good number of marriages suffer when they can’t have sex for weeks, sometimes months and years. It’s understandible that people will have to abstain due to illness or injury or other trauma. But it’s not easy to deal with when those barriers (i.e. fears of pregnancy at a time when pregnancy has to be avoided) are the only things in the way keeping the couple apart. As you say, sex is important and a renewal of the vows.
 
Rence, I really appreciate what you are trying to do. It is fair. I thank you for that. emmar and Debora have been referred. Whether they have taken that advice is unknown to me. Every few years on this forum we get a new batch of people coming in saying that Church teaching is wrong and the debates go round and round.
:confused:

What do you mean I have been “referred?”

And why would you say something like “trust me, you have not read every thread…” to another poster in reference to me?? (“trust me, I have read other threads, this person is a bad person”… really?)

I have not done or said anything even remotely against Church teaching in this thread, and haven’t even talked about this issue here on CAF in MONTHS. And in case you haven’t noticed (which I’m sure you have) I’ve been trying to move forward and keep personal things private.

So I think it is very uncalled for that you call me out in any sort of way due to something I may have said in a completely separate thread months ago. What purpose would you possibly have for doing that? To defame my character???
 
:confused:

What do you mean I have been “referred?”
I think she may have meant that Debora has been referred to. :flowers:

As in, some random member said to LittleDeb: Debora said this/that and I thought that was right/wrong, and now I don’t know what to do because I have difficulty/no difficulty with this/that. And I want to do this/that because Debora said it’s working/not working for her.

I think that’s what she’s saying. Someone has mentioned you or mentioned something you said in PMs to her, they have referred to you. And Emmar.

It’s 26 here, and that’s all that’s real to me right now. It was 70 just a few hours ago. What’s up with that? :winter:
 
I think she may have meant that Debora has been referred to. :flowers:

As in, some random member said to LittleDeb: Debora said this/that and I thought that was right/wrong, and now I don’t know what to do because I have difficulty/no difficulty with this/that. And I want to do this/that because Debora said it’s working/not working for her.

I think that’s what she’s saying. Someone has mentioned you or mentioned something you said in PMs to her, they have referred to you. And Emmar.

It’s 26 here, and that’s all that’s real to me right now. It was 70 just a few hours ago. What’s up with that? :winter:
Wow, I’m glad she is publicly announcing to all that someone has sent her a PM complaining about something I said.

Seriously, I feel more victimized here than I ever have in my life… this is worse than high school. Worse part is I never even said anything even remotely inappropriate in this thread and haven’t even touched on the subject of contraception in months.

Maybe I’ll change my screen name so I can stop being picked apart for views I shared with people I thought I could trust MONTHS ago.
 
Wow, I’m glad she is publicly announcing to all that someone has sent her a PM complaining about something I said.

Seriously, I feel more victimized here than I ever have in my life… this is worse than high school. Worse part is I never even said anything even remotely inappropriate in this thread and haven’t even touched on the subject of contraception in months.

Maybe I’ll change my screen name so I can stop being picked apart for views I shared with people I thought I could trust MONTHS ago.
I know exactly how you feel. I have heard my name being called every five minutes for the last half hour and I want to change my name too! 😛
 
Lookouts,
Welcome to CAF! I hope you haven’t been run off from so many harsh answers. One thing to really remember right now is that contraception doesn’t take away the risk. It will give a false sense of security. As my wise father says, “Everyone has faith. Some people have faith in the highway system. They will continue driving with the faith that the road in front is complete.”

Your wife has been lied to by our current culture. This way of thinking is very new as a mainstream thought. The embrace of contraception was because of eugenics. It is a long a windy history, but if you are ever interested in more information, I am happy to share the resources. They would absolutely overwhelm this thread. Suffice to say that abstinence has always been considered normal until the 20th century. And before the 20th century, couples actually stayed married. Please don’t let your wife’s current panic shoot your marriage in the foot.

My husband and I have to abstain a LOT. It has very little to do with our fertility. Even though I have absolutely wonky fertility, my charts are very easy to interpret. I know my body. Believe me, my secular friends who have finally made the leap from condoms and charting, to NFP only, are very thankful. The fertility awareness method does work, but it really sucks for your marriage. Condoms don’t unite.

Our abstinence has everything to do with my bad health. The very reason we have been called to our small family, is the reason we are called to a lot abstinence. I was bed-bound again today. I live with chronic pain. To have relations with my husband takes all of the energy of running a marathon. As I typed that last sentence, my 7 year old walked up and asked why we missed indoor gym today. (Playing in the church gym each week is important in bad weather.) It isn’t because I can’t have another baby. It is because of my health.

In a nutshell: your wife is placing blame. Our culture tells her that she should be able to have sex without consequences. Even she doesn’t believe that. What she is really upset at is her health problems (and maybe yours as well, I don’t know). But having to abstain is an easy target for her anger. If you had say, broken your pelvis, like my dear friend’s husband did 3 months ago, she would not be saying, “well, now we can’t have SEX!” She would be worrying about how to help you recover. But after a few months, she might start to resent that she can’t have sex. But all the resentment in the world will not heal a broken pelvis.

She has health problems. From what you have said, her health problem has worry built right in. A condom will not calm her fears. It will just give her a false sense of calm. The question you have been asked is a legitimate one. Is she going to feel better when the man-made design fails? Will your marriage survive with her leaning on the created instead of the Creator?

NFP is just a name that has been given to this set of observing signs. Sex with a condom is empty sex. Literally, empty. Needing a barrier from your spouse doesn’t bring you closer. Our world’s staggering divorce rate has proven that. You will find all of these couples telling you, “We use condoms and we are happily married.” But those who have *really *been married for 50 years call bull on that. It has been shown across all religious beliefs, condoms do NOT contribute to a happy marriage. My secular friends who use NFP are the ones who have stayed married. My Catholic friends and family (and all other religions) who contracept are the ones crashing and burning.

Please look really carefully. The Church is old and wise. Believe HER. Don’t believe our very young culture. You wouldn’t take marital advice from a teenager. Our protestant brethren are only 500 years old. They embraced contraception, just like they have embraced every other form of divide among themselves.

Tell your wife that you love her too much to feed that fear. Remind her over and over that this won’t be FOREVER. I promise that it won’t. My parents, married 47 years, promise that it won’t. Your baby will get older. He or she WILL! It will get better. Don’t kill your marriage in the long term for what really amounts to a short term problem. Her fertility can be interpreted. I PROMISE. I have not failed at interpreting a chart yet. Even other people’s charts. If there is a chart anomaly, I have had it. Double patches, pre-shift spikes and post shift dips, even in one cycle. That one was funny.

God is so good! I can promise that if you are faithful to Him, He will deliver! As we have entered the years where we are called to abstain every fertile cycle, possibly until menopause, my cycles are easy as can be. Charting my fertility has helped me fix my health problems. Please seek out really great medical help in your local area. It is worth it!! Love your wife through this time of abstinence. It will bring you closer. If it doesn’t, then your marriage needs other intervention.

It has been said by those wiser than I, “Abstinence isn’t the problem, but it does clarify the problem.” (Paraphrased from quite a few wonderful popes.) I believe the Vicars of Jesus, not any random person on a Catholic bulletin board.
Thank you for posting this. Out of all the posts on here, this resonates the most. Makes sense from a psychological perspective, and I must admit I’m annoyed I didn’t pick up on this sooner.
 
“Lookouts” was an account I made this afternoon because I wanted to vent some steam, and frankly I was embarrassed to post under my usual user name. I proceeded to lose the password, and the E-Mail account I used isn’t working. Perhaps this is God’s way of saying I need humility.

My wife are quite aware of Church teaching on contraceptives. When we did our marriage course we didn’t need to be told what the Church’s stance on the issue was, we knew it already. I’m a Catechist who prescribes to Dominican spirituality, I’m well aware of the Church’s teaching, and well equipped to discuss and teach said teaching. Yet myself being against contraceptives is not theological, but more philosophical and psychological. Don’t get me wrong, I understand the theological and agree with it, but I agreed with the other two methods of thinking first (as Dominicans often do).

That said, we WERE told at our marriage prep by the priest who ran it. We also saw a NFP couple, and we bought Taking Charge of Your Fertility. We made it all work, and we conceived when we decided to go weapons free. There’s no reason why it won’t work again, it’s just been a long eight months until her period came back so we can start looking at things. The system did work for us, and that’s why I got upset when she said what she said. Even after we had a long chat about it, and I talked about how we can add even more things to help us do things right (like the pee on a stick monitors).

My wife loves the Church, but this is an issue she struggles with. But I think LittleDeb is on the money; what you said makes perfect sense, she’s projecting the problem onto the belief.

Please keep in mind she’s been treated for depression for five or sex years now, and she’s seeing one of the best doctors in the country. Myself, I have a mental illness being treated. I have chronic pain issues, arthritis, a severe back problem, and a blood vessel disorder. And a bum elbow. We have issues that will take time to heal, to the point where I’m not sure we should have another child. One might be all we are called to have. We both would like one, but right now one would destroy us. And I think the fear is being projected, like you said LittleDeb.

Thank you all for your posts. I knew before I wrote the OP what had to be done, I knew what should be done, and I know what will be done. I was mostly venting and seeking some kind words.
 
Lookouts: You stated that his wife is clinically depressed (seriously) and you have your own issues for which you have just begun treatment. Right now, your wife does not trust trying NFP again without condoms as well. But it may be her depression speaking. Depression always focuses on the negative.

I know that it takes a bit of time to fine-tune the treatment for depression. It means finding the right combination of meds, which take awhile to kick in, and the right therapist. All of this takes time.

I don’t read her refusal to attempt to use NFP without condoms as onerous. Nor her menopause statement. You will know better, but I suggest that you consider if it might be the depression that is speaking and it may not be permanent. If she were clinically depressed, and is suffering from post-partum depression as well or stressed as a new mother with a fussy baby, she has a double burden.

I would like to throw out a glimmer of hope to you. It may take time, but I don’t think (and will pray) that this is not definitive in her present condition. As her doctor(s) fine-tune her treatment, you may find that she may have a more positive outlook and be more open to trying NFP again, without condoms. Afterall, (and I’m assuming here) it did seem to work, as I read it in the original post, until you both decided to stop using it and had your son. Since she’s depressed, she might even feel unable to chart. With depression, as I’m sure you know, everything becomes more difficult. And with the negativity, depressives are not open to suggestion because they are always certain that something will not work or is just too hard. I hope you see something helpful here.

I would strongly suggest that your wife, if at all possible, see a psychopharmacologist for her meds (if she is on meds for depression), separate from her therapy (if she is receiving talk therapy). Not merely a psychiatrist who is an M.D., but a psychopharmacologist. The psychopharmacologist is well-schooled in fine tuning those meds to hit on the right combo that will give her some relief.

You may find that when they hit on the right combo (I am assuming that she is on some meds) (and I pray that you find the right doctor), that your wife may have a more positive attitude. This, along with the offer for child care, (and some therapy), you may then find that your wife and you can have that discussion again on NFP, without the use of condoms, and she won’t feel so “punished.” This also sounded to me like it was the depression talking.

I wish that this gives you some hope that your wife may be speaking from her present depressive state, and it may not be a irreversible decision on her part to refuse to try your suggestions, without condoms. She may begin to be more open to discussing this with you again soon in a more positive manner.

I am sorry if I am speaking “out of turn.” I honestly did not see your most recent post until I had submitted mine.

Good luck and God Bless.
 
:confused:

What do you mean I have been “referred?”

And why would you say something like “trust me, you have not read every thread…” to another poster in reference to me?? (“trust me, I have read other threads, this person is a bad person”… really?)

I have not done or said anything even remotely against Church teaching in this thread, and haven’t even talked about this issue here on CAF in MONTHS. And in case you haven’t noticed (which I’m sure you have) I’ve been trying to move forward and keep personal things private.

So I think it is very uncalled for that you call me out in any sort of way due to something I may have said in a completely separate thread months ago. What purpose would you possibly have for doing that? To defame my character???
Many, many people have tried to be supportive of you, Debora. I have read the threads where they have asked you to seek out a strong NFP teacher.

You have said that NFP hurts marriage. Please don’t deny that.

I have personally tried to gently approach you months ago and you completely shut me down. Since we share a name, I have been praying for you since that time. I am glad that you are trying to keep your personal life, personal. That is step in the right direction. I had hopes that you would still try to defend Church teaching even if you struggle with it.

Yes, I was asked by more than 6 people to try to talk to you because you seemed to be really struggling with Church teaching. I used to be known as a very gentle soul who could get to the heart of it. Since your interaction with me was so incredibly harsh, I have generally stayed out of your way. It will take a bit of searching to find the threads where I tried, but they are there.

I wasn’t “calling out” about a thread months ago. I was addressing was what was said in this thread and a very recent previous one. Rence asked why you hadn’t been referred to an NFP teacher. I said you had been.

I don’t call out. I answered the post. I have gone to great lengths over the years to really meet people where they are. It has been very hard to know where to begin with you. So far, the people who have tried to interact with you have really not been able to see where you are coming from. They want to, but have been shot down as well. Hard. I was asked to PM you, but I declined. If you are this harsh in public, I wasn’t sure if it was the best idea to have a private conversation with you.

I would like to understand your POV, honestly. I can usually read people pretty well, but I haven’t been able to crack your shell. It sounds like you tried to get the answers before marriage, but felt lied to, but then other statements say that you knew the answers and disagree with Church teaching. I am guessing it is a little of both. I don’t generally think people have a totally split way of looking at it.

If you are ready to be approached exactly where you are, I am here for you. But please stop insulting me. I do have feelings and they can be hurt. I would love to see your marriage be everything God wants it to be. The first years are hard. Some couples are married for 50 years, other couples are married the first year over and over, for 50 years. God has a great design for marriage and we can ALL live it, no matter our circumstances.
 
Okay, so NFP doesn’t work for them and I will give you the benefit of doubt that they have exhausted ALL the doctors, NFP instructors, and every other channel available to see WHY NFP doesn’t seem to work for them.

Still, why does that mean that they have to abstain for 20-30 years? Is their situation not EVER going to change? Are they NEVER going to find them in a position where they could extend the generosity to accept another child? EVER?

Now how often do you think it happens that 1. a couple struggles making NFP work. 2. they exhaust all methods of help and NFP still doesn’t work for them, and 3. their just/serious reasons for for needing to avoid a pregnancy NEVER changes?
Children with special needs that the parents have difficulty parenting. I have a disability myself and I’m not saying that the child having a disability means there can’t be other children, but that some children are very difficult for their parents to raise.

It used to be this didn’t come up b/c you adapted to life in the “regular” world or were cared for at home or sent to an institution. But in these times, I would say if having another child meant the end of physical or other therapy for a disabled child - or it meant not being able to afford health care, such as for a child with cancer - then it’s not for the best.

My husband had a severe childhood illness that struck at age 5 and did not really start to resolve until over 15 years later when he had a transplant. it does happen. there are times when an existing child will remain ill, disabled or even die if there is not enough money. I saw a statistic that said raising some children with cerebral palsy to adulthood can cost over $900,000.00. Parents often end up paying too much of that without help.
 
Lookouts: You stated that his wife is clinically depressed (seriously) and you have your own issues for which you have just begun treatment. Right now, your wife does not trust trying NFP again without condoms as well. But it may be her depression speaking. Depression always focuses on the negative.

I know that it takes a bit of time to fine-tune the treatment for depression. It means finding the right combination of meds, which take awhile to kick in, and the right therapist. All of this takes time.

I don’t read her refusal to attempt to use NFP without condoms as onerous. Nor her menopause statement. You will know better, but I suggest that you consider if it might be the depression that is speaking and it may not be permanent. If she were clinically depressed, and is suffering from post-partum depression as well or stressed as a new mother with a fussy baby, she has a double burden.

I would like to throw out a glimmer of hope to you. It may take time, but I don’t think (and will pray) that this is not definitive in her present condition. As her doctor(s) fine-tune her treatment, you may find that she may have a more positive outlook and be more open to trying NFP again, without condoms. Afterall, (and I’m assuming here) it did seem to work, as I read it in the original post, until you both decided to stop using it and had your son. Since she’s depressed, she might even feel unable to chart. With depression, as I’m sure you know, everything becomes more difficult. And with the negativity, depressives are not open to suggestion because they are always certain that something will not work or is just too hard. I hope you see something helpful here.

I would strongly suggest that your wife, if at all possible, see a psychopharmacologist for her meds (if she is on meds for depression), separate from her therapy (if she is receiving talk therapy). Not merely a psychiatrist who is an M.D., but a psychopharmacologist. The psychopharmacologist is well-schooled in fine tuning those meds to hit on the right combo that will give her some relief.

You may find that when they hit on the right combo (I am assuming that she is on some meds) (and I pray that you find the right doctor), that your wife may have a more positive attitude. This, along with the offer for child care, (and some therapy), you may then find that your wife and you can have that discussion again on NFP, without the use of condoms, and she won’t feel so “punished.” This also sounded to me like it was the depression talking.

I wish that this gives you some hope that your wife may be speaking from her present depressive state, and it may not be a irreversible decision on her part to refuse to try your suggestions, without condoms. She may begin to be more open to discussing this with you again soon in a more positive manner.

Good luck and God Bless.
She is seeing literally one of the best psychiatrists in the country. This is not hyperbole, this is fact, he is legitimately one of the best. I will go so far as to say the best, and he has the papers to prove it. She is also seeing a psychologist and going to a mom’s with depression support group. I’m seeing a psychiatrist and a social worker. I need to see some other specialists for my physical issues, but mental health wise we are well covered and very blessed to be seeing the professionals we are.

On all other points you are wise. I believe I will copy/paste your points and use them as a reference for this situation, and others in a similar one if I meet them.
 
She is seeing literally one of the best psychiatrists in the country. This is not hyperbole, this is fact, he is legitimately one of the best. I will go so far as to say the best, and he has the papers to prove it. She is also seeing a psychologist and going to a mom’s with depression support group. I’m seeing a psychiatrist and a social worker. I need to see some other specialists for my physical issues, but mental health wise we are well covered and very blessed to be seeing the professionals we are.

On all other points you are wise. I believe I will copy/paste your points and use them as a reference for this situation, and others in a similar one if I meet them.
Thank you and God Bless you and your family.
 
“Lookouts” was an account I made this afternoon because I wanted to vent some steam, and frankly I was embarrassed to post under my usual user name. I proceeded to lose the password, and the E-Mail account I used isn’t working. Perhaps this is God’s way of saying I need humility.

My wife are quite aware of Church teaching on contraceptives. When we did our marriage course we didn’t need to be told what the Church’s stance on the issue was, we knew it already. I’m a Catechist who prescribes to Dominican spirituality, I’m well aware of the Church’s teaching, and well equipped to discuss and teach said teaching. Yet myself being against contraceptives is not theological, but more philosophical and psychological. Don’t get me wrong, I understand the theological and agree with it, but I agreed with the other two methods of thinking first (as Dominicans often do).

That said, we WERE told at our marriage prep by the priest who ran it. We also saw a NFP couple, and we bought Taking Charge of Your Fertility. We made it all work, and we conceived when we decided to go weapons free. There’s no reason why it won’t work again, it’s just been a long eight months until her period came back so we can start looking at things. The system did work for us, and that’s why I got upset when she said what she said. Even after we had a long chat about it, and I talked about how we can add even more things to help us do things right (like the pee on a stick monitors).

My wife loves the Church, but this is an issue she struggles with. But I think LittleDeb is on the money; what you said makes perfect sense, she’s projecting the problem onto the belief.

Please keep in mind she’s been treated for depression for five or sex years now, and she’s seeing one of the best doctors in the country. Myself, I have a mental illness being treated. I have chronic pain issues, arthritis, a severe back problem, and a blood vessel disorder. And a bum elbow. We have issues that will take time to heal, to the point where I’m not sure we should have another child. One might be all we are called to have. We both would like one, but right now one would destroy us. And I think the fear is being projected, like you said LittleDeb.

Thank you all for your posts. I knew before I wrote the OP what had to be done, I knew what should be done, and I know what will be done. I was mostly venting and seeking some kind words.
Oh Melchior, I am so glad you spoke up! I didn’t guess it was you since we have so many new people here. I am so sorry you are going through this! I can understand wanting to post under an assumed name. I felt like I was walking a plank years ago when I asked for prayers with my husband’s sleep-walking. It is weird to handle when people know you. It can make you feel very vulnerable in an environment like this.

Please keep us posted for prayers for you all!!:signofcross:
 
Thank you and God Bless you and your family.
And God bless yours as well. And as one who chronic pain to another, I pray that God continues to work in your life and, if it is his Will, to ease your pain.
 
Children with special needs that the parents have difficulty parenting. I have a disability myself and I’m not saying that the child having a disability means there can’t be other children, but that some children are very difficult for their parents to raise.

It used to be this didn’t come up b/c you adapted to life in the “regular” world or were cared for at home or sent to an institution. But in these times, I would say if having another child meant the end of physical or other therapy for a disabled child - or it meant not being able to afford health care, such as for a child with cancer - then it’s not for the best.

My husband had a severe childhood illness that struck at age 5 and did not really start to resolve until over 15 years later when he had a transplant. it does happen. there are times when an existing child will remain ill, disabled or even die if there is not enough money. I saw a statistic that said raising some children with cerebral palsy to adulthood can cost over $900,000.00. Parents often end up paying too much of that without help.
This is, yes, a very difficult circumstance, and my heart goes out to all of those in it. But Kristacelia’s point was 3-fold. She was making the point of the people who said they are the one unique couple who has to resort to contraception.

Many people are called to small family, but none of us will know, for sure, how many children we are called to have, until we are dead. If we have the ability to make babies, we still might be called, if we have the ability to adopt, God could still call us there. Even grandparents raising their grandchildren have, in a way, been called to more children.

Her point is that discernment is never really done, even in the seemingly most dire circumstances. None of us knows what God might have in store. Contraception is never the answer, no exceptions.

Prayers!
 
Many, many people have tried to be supportive of you, Debora. I have read the threads where they have asked you to seek out a strong NFP teacher. You have said that NFP hurts marriage. Please don’t deny that.
To be fair to Debora, many people have said that NFP hurts marriage. And I couldn’t even tell you which ones, you’d have to look through the posts. I do know that Debora doesn’t stick out as unusual. She’s never pushed her views on anyone.
I have personally tried to gently approach you months ago and you completely shut me down.
Debora is really a very private person when it comes to her personal life. She has said many times that what goes on at home is between her, her husband and God. If she completely shut you down, she’s only reiterating what she has made known publicly about herself, though I do realize you have the best of intentions 🙂
So far, the people who have tried to interact with you have really not been able to see where you are coming from… I would like to understand your POV,
I find Debora to be very approachable and I do know where she’s coming from and understand her. She’s very open about how she feels and very careful about imposing her views on others or counseling anyone. She speaks for herself and owns her decisions. 🙂

I’m sorry that your feelings have been hurt and that you feel that you are being insulted. No one needs to feel that way, especially on a Catholic discussion forum. I think people feel very strongly about what they believe, and sometimes everyone (anyone) can come on a bit strong when it comes to things that are personal to them and that they feel strongly about. Family issues are particularly personal for people from NFP to childrearing to vaccines, etc. Like I mentioned before in a post, with us coming out and sharing our beliefs and experiences, one would hope we’d come out of the discussions understanding each other a bit more 🙂
 
I did understand that before marriage. 🙂

That is not what I was referring to.

I was told a lot of wonderful things about NFP. That it would bring a couple closer together, that it was 99.3% effective, that it was easy/fun… etc etc.

NFP promoters make it sound like it’s a wonderful thing, rather than preparing the couple for what it actually is - a very difficult thing that may not work for everyone.
I’m having a little trouble buying this honestly. Did you seriously not put two and two together here? Regardless of whether or not they were “promoting” it (and I do not Really think it’s Their responsibility to make sure you understand what a holy marriage will entail), you must have had to have thought (at least Once) something like “because this is The Only Moral form of birth control, it might mean that we won’t have sex for very extended periods of time!” That’s like the first thing people go to when criticizing it. They think of the generally far-fetched hypotheticals of where a couple might not get to have sex to show why NFP is clearly wrong.

Why did/do you think the Church finds it necessary to Encourage its use? Why did/do you think non-Catholics criticize NFP and rally for ABC so much? Did you think they just irrationally disliked the Church? No, they just have that same “I should get to have sex when I want to” mentality that all modern people have, and are offended by the notion that a couple might not get to have sex when they want to.

This whole issue is a little silly to me, though. ALL sexual issues revolve around the virtue of chastity. A person practices chastity Always (whether single, a monk, married, or otherwise), or he is not a good person. Getting married is not a free ticket to all the sex you want to have whenever you want to have it. That completely undermines the entire notion of chastity. Chastity just means using your sexual gifts appropriately. Does that mean you will you get to have sex often with your husband when you’re married? Yes, probably; the vast majority of the time, that’s the case. Could there exist a time when you Won’t be able to because it’s not appropriate? Yes, obviously.

If you honestly went into marriage thinking “oh, this NFP thing will allow me to do it even more often than if I were using ABC! Sweet!” then you were going into it with the wrong mindset to begin with. I imagine that’s the reason you didn’t really connect the dots—all the Church’s promotion aside. It’s just baffling to me that you didn’t realize that all of this would be difficult. Chastity, like every single virtue, is difficult. Maybe women have more trouble understanding this because they aren’t constantly struggling to avoid sexual sin like most men are? I have no idea.

I don’t mean to be too harsh, and I hope that your marriage continues on wonderfully and you continue to enjoy sex with your husband (you should!), but there was something that was bugging me about your “I didn’t know! They should have warned us!” attitude. I may even agree with you that the Church should spend more time focusing on the difficulties of life and maintaining the virtues, etc. That may be the case. I just don’t think you, or any like-minded person here, is really justified in promoting that how-could-I-have-known-it’s-not-fair-this-sucks victim attitude.
 
Wow, I’m glad she is publicly announcing to all that someone has sent her a PM complaining about something I said.

Seriously, I feel more victimized here than I ever have in my life… this is worse than high school. Worse part is I never even said anything even remotely inappropriate in this thread and haven’t even touched on the subject of contraception in months.

Maybe I’ll change my screen name so I can stop being picked apart for views I shared with people I thought I could trust MONTHS ago.
Hi Debora, please Take this with as much sympathy as you can, as i really am not trying to Come down on you.
You seem to genuinely not understand where the OP is coming from and I would just like to shed some light.

I myself, have only been an active member on CAF for about half a year, if that. All I can say is that these past few months have been enough for me as a reader to get an idea oh who is who among the regular Family Life posters.

As such, I can say, yours is a name that always stood out in NFP threads as being among the ones encouraging the poster in his/her negative sentiments towards NFP and calling the firm NFP believers judgmental and harsh.

Now, please understand, as someone who has gone through months and months of abstinence after each birth (9 and counting as we speak), I do believe NFP is hard. BUT, as a Catholic, I stand behind this teaching even if I were to never have sex again (God forbid!) and our duty IS and ALWAYS will be to encourage and help fellow Catholics in embracing this cross, not just telling them that they are justified in their bitterness or resentment and assuring them that we, as fellow Catholics, feel the same.

The latter in fact does a huge disservice to the Catholic Church.

Also, I wouldn’t be able to point to the post but at least on one occasion you made it very clear that you use ABC. I do very much appreciate the fact that lately you are much more private and subtle about this as it is certainly a reason for scandal, among other things.

Again, you make some wonderful contributions on here but in regards to NFP you have written many posts which undermine Catholic teaching.

Coming from someone who also struggles with NFP I can assure you that the problem is not the teaching but our own weaknesses. NFP and abstinence have deepened mine and DH’s relationship when we stayed close to God and to the sacraments but it also drove many wedges when we decided that we no longer want to bare with its sacrifice and were too consumed with “ourselves”. Both DH and I come from a very promiscuous sexual past and I can attest that NFP can bring lots of healing and has helped us experience intimacy beyond anything ever experienced in the past.

And this is not because we are an exception but it is because this is what it is meant to do if practiced with total faith and love of God- not that many of us have that, hence the falls and the struggles,

I pray you will find peace with all of this soon and keep in mind that the most important thing is not your marriage or your life or what we think about you but your soul.

God bless you and your husband!
 
I have to agree with Deb123 on this one. NFP was definitely advertised as something that was good for a marriage and would bring couples closer together, and that it was really a highly effective form of birth control.

My experience has been that NFP is a burden on our marriage and definitely made things worse.
 
All of these threads tend to confuse me and make me question what to expect regarding NFP. I’m getting married in a few months and have been charting for several years, because I had a health problem and wanted to figure it out. I’m thankful for the knowledge that I have and that there is a moral way to space births.

Our pre-marital class spent about five minutes talking about NFP, and they used such veiled references that I don’t think anyone else in the room even knew what they were talking about. I do know a lot and I am prepared, but that’s only because I took it upon myself to do so and I agree with the people who said that the church doesn’t do a great job in the marriage prep classes regarding what to expect. But I also think there is a level of personal responsibility people should take for seeking out the truth.

I don’t have any idea what situations my soon to be husband and I will find ourselves in, but we both understand that anytime we have sex, I could end up pregnant. We also both understand that just because we’re getting married doesn’t mean we should expect it all the time. We waited several years and I figure that if we were able to wait the whole time we were dating, we’ve become pretty good at self-mastery and delayed gratification and this will help us in our marriage, in matters related to and outside of sex.

So, I think we are well prepared and understand as much as an engaged couple can about NFP. But then I come on here and I wonder whether we really know what we’re in for. If we do have to abstain for months or years at some point, is that going to tear our marriage apart? I tend to agree with the posters who say that if it does, it’s not because of NFP but because of some other problem, but I get nervous. I anticipate it will be a sacrifice and will not always be easy, and once our reasons for using it are no longer issues, maybe we won’t even need to. I guess what I am wondering is, for those of you who it has been a real struggle, what specifically makes it so difficult? Abstaining now is not so hard to be honest, we’ve gotten used to it, but once you’re married is it different, harder to abstain? Is it being afraid of getting pregnant? I just want to know what to expect, so that I’m not disappointed when it’s harder than I thought it might be.

To the OP, as I’m not yet married I don’t think I really have anything useful to say, other than that I’ve been using the fertility monitor for awhile now and have found it to be very accurate and useful in the sense that the monitor shows me as ovulating when I think I am by reading other signs. If your wife already knows how to read her signs, then I think she would find it an extra consolation to have her hormones actually measured so that she knows she’s being accurate.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top