Yet Another "NFP Stuggles" Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lookouts
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Just realized that you and I have been referring to searching as a “she” but clearly they are a “he”.

I think the scandal comes in how he is relating his hardships. In having the extreme anger be the primary thing showing in his posts it is breeding hostility. It is extremely commendable to follow the teaching without having the understanding but then the person should be trying to gain the understanding. Less “I hate the Church’s teaching but I do it anyway but it makes me angry but I do t but it sucks”.and more “I don’t understand or agree w/ this teaching but I am following it because that is what Christ would want. I’m also seeking to get a better understanding.” Do you see the difference?
Right… one is an attitude of pride (I know better than the Church but I do what they say to do anyway) and one of humility (I trust that the Church knows better than me, but I am struggling with understanding this teaching).
 
Okay, so you are struggling to conform your will to the teachings of the Church. That’s understandable and normal. Do you pray for it? Do you research WHY the Church teaches what it does about both conjugal sex and IVF? Do you work towards understanding the teachings?

That’s what we are supposed to do. No one said you have to have 100% understanding of all the Church’s teachings. Everyone has said, you cannot choose sin.
Not to derail the thread, but yes, I researched it, and I know why the Church forbids it. I still disagree with it, and I resent it. I think it’s bogus. Yes, I prayed about it. I don’t care about the teachings in this matter because I don’t agree with them – other than it’s a rule that I can’t break if I want to continue being Catholic. It’s my choice to remain Catholic, so I dropped IVF off my list of considations. End of story.
 
The Church’s ‘rules’ are God’s ‘rules’. The idea of eternal damnation drives a lot of people. It’s called imperfect contrition.
Yeah, it does drive a lot of people. It’s obviously driving people like Searching and me, who follow rules despite hating them. But don’t expect it to drive everyone…
 
Haha well that is the problem that needs to be addressed then. Doing something out of fear from God is not the ideal at all. The hope would be we follow the moral code because we see how it has our best interests at heart, and because we trust God to take care of us when it doesn’t appear to do so. Obviously this isn’t always the case and having the fear of God to fall back on in those tough times is needed. Doing something purely out of fear of God though always means a rough ride and a lot of suffering.
I think many people are avoiding certain sins merely because they fear offending God and it may not be the ideal at all. But the alternative would be not following the rules because they don’t fear offending God.
 
Just realized that you and I have been referring to searching as a “she” but clearly they are a “he”.

I think the scandal comes in how he is relating his hardships. In having the extreme anger be the primary thing showing in his posts it is breeding hostility. It is extremely commendable to follow the teaching without having the understanding but then the person should be trying to gain the understanding. Less “I hate the Church’s teaching but I do it anyway but it makes me angry but I do t but it sucks”.and more “I don’t understand or agree w/ this teaching but I am following it because that is what Christ would want. I’m also seeking to get a better understanding.” Do you see the difference?
Yes, I see the difference, but that’s how he feels. You want him to do the latter, while I acknowledge the former. There is nothing scandalous about it. He is angry and that’s what he’s trying to relate. Believe me, he’s not the only one. The alternative for him would be to just not follow the rules. Again, there’s nothing special about following rules one is totally on board with. That’s easy. The real sacrifice is following rules one hates and doesn’t agree with.
 
Relating how she is stewing about how she doesn’t agree with the teachings, but follows it anyway despite not believing in the teachings, is not wrong. If anything other people who share the same view will be able to relate to her. If someone is on the fence regarding that, and is knowledgeable about the teachings of the Church (which Searching doesn’t deny, and has posted about many times - I don’t recall her posting an incorrect teaching, just that she didn’t agree with the teaching), they need to come to their own conclusions like everyone else. The teachings are presented to all readers. All readers have to come to their own conclusiongs regarding them.

Relating her struggles is not scandalizing anyone. If anything those on the fence should see how much she suffers but has decided to follow the teachings anyway, even if she feels she is being coerced to do so. There is nothing really special about following the rules when one is totally on board about them, and they’re not a burden for one. But it takes a lot to bend to the rules when everything inside of you is screaming the opposite. So I give Searching a lot of credit, even though she hates the rules and and resents those who made them, and thinks they are complete bogus, she still trusts the Church enough to follow the rules. Having that much faith and trust is guiding her actions, despite the lack of faith and trust in the Church. The balance is tipped in favor of the Church in her case and no one can deny that because it’s obvious in her struggles. I think her dialogs are important because she is real.
First, a sincere thank you. Second, um, I a guy. 😃 But you are dead on in where I’m coming from, so thank you.

It bothers me so much in these forums that it is presented that guys are only after sex. It is so far from the truth. I hurt that I feel separated from my wife for a lack of sexual intimacy; it tears my heart out that we disagree and there is nothing I can do about it. Yes, there were and still are other things that impact our marriage - like raising four kids into adults, jobs, finances. We were still able to talk and communicate to some degree even in disagreements over all of that, which was not easy. But when the world was crashing down on us, we had our sexual intimacy for emotional support and bonding, and yes, it was at times non-intercourse sex in between NFP Phases. But when even sexual intimacy was taken away from me (if we were/are lucky, we had intercourse maybe, maybe once per month), I felt like I lost my God-given wife. We had hardly any other connections at times except for that, and it was gone.

No, I do not fathom or believe for the life of me that God intends couples to deal with and live like that/this, all because the church says they cannot as a couple decide if the semen lands in the right spot each and every time. And by the church dictating what it does, it declares that that is what God wants. How can that be so??
 
Right… one is an attitude of pride (I know better than the Church but I do what they say to do anyway) and one of humility (I trust that the Church knows better than me, but I am struggling with understanding this teaching).
I don’t think Searching has an attitude of pride. I believe him to be suffering and angry and trying to come to terms with his decision to follow Church teachings despite not agreeing with them, and despite suffering from them. He has that much faith in the Church to bite the bullet and follow the teachings, despite struggling with his lack of confidence in the Church to know what’s best. He has a lifetime to come to terms with the teachings on his journey through life and faith development, and he has to do it his way and in his own time. I’m qutie sure that sharing his struggles is helpful to many. I certainly can relate to him…
 
Yes, I see the difference, but that’s how he feels. You want him to do the latter, while I acknowledge the former. There is nothing scandalous about it. He is angry and that’s what he’s trying to relate. Believe me, he’s not the only one. The alternative for him would be to just not follow the rules. Again, there’s nothing special about following rules one is totally on board with. That’s easy. The real sacrifice is following rules one hates and doesn’t agree with.
Ok so then what does this do? I’m not saying you can’t voice your frustrations just asking what dwelling on it does for you. Having that level of hostility is no better for your soul than committing the sin. And I contend that it causes more problems for those reading these posts. So what isthe purpose?
 
First, a sincere thank you. Second, um, I a guy. 😃 But you are dead on in where I’m coming from, so thank you.

It bothers me so much in these forums that it is presented that guys are only after sex. It is so far from the truth. I hurt that I feel separated from my wife for a lack of sexual intimacy; it tears my heart out that we disagree and there is nothing I can do about it. Yes, there were and still are other things that impact our marriage - like raising four kids into adults, jobs, finances. We were still able to talk and communicate to some degree even in disagreements over all of that, which was not easy. But when the world was crashing down on us, we had our sexual intimacy for emotional support and bonding, and yes, it was at times non-intercourse sex in between NFP Phases. But when even sexual intimacy was taken away from me (if we were/are lucky, we had intercourse maybe, maybe once per month), I felt like I lost my God-given wife. We had hardly any other connections at times except for that, and it was gone.

No, I do not fathom or believe for the life of me that God intends couples to deal with and live like that/this, all because the church says they cannot as a couple decide if the semen lands in the right spot each and every time. And by the church dictating what it does, it declares that that is what God wants. How can that be so??
Do you believe the Church to be God’s spokesperson? Because it seems likely you are separating God from His bride which seems like your issues are more than the Church’s stance on sexuality.
 
Okay, so you are struggling to conform your will to the teachings of the Church. That’s understandable and normal. Do you pray for it? Do you research WHY the Church teaches what it does about both conjugal sex and IVF? Do you work towards understanding the teachings?

I’ve prayed, though it is hard, and yes I’ve read CCC and CW and all that. Still makes no sense.

That’s what we are supposed to do. No one said you have to have 100% understanding of all the Church’s teachings. Everyone has said, you cannot choose sin.
Nope, we don’t; we just have to follow it. And yeah, it stinks when you follow and neither agree nor understand nor believe.

Well, yeah, you can choose sin - that’s why sin is sin.
 
You did not come on here saying “I am struggling and questioning”. You can on here saying " I completely disagree with this. The Church is wrong. Couples can engage in other forms of sexual acts if they want to."

There is a vaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaast difference. One is acceptable. The other is not.
Oooooh, so I can say I’m struggling and questioning, but not say I disagree? So you are the definitive authority on what is acceptable as a Catholic?

I do disagree, I do believe the church is wrong on this, but I didn’t say couples “can” - I believe couples should in their hearts with prayer be able to discern what maybe correct for them at the time and not be condemend to hell for it by the loving God that gave them their spouse in the first place.

Tell me how the church teaching that makes any sense whatseover.
 
Ok so then what does this do? I’m not saying you can’t voice your frustrations just asking what dwelling on it does for you. Having that level of hostility is no better for your soul than committing the sin. And I contend that it causes more problems for those reading these posts. So what isthe purpose?
So again, I and others who feel the same are supposed to go sit in a corner? Causing problems for others? How about that is your impression because you don’t like or understand how someone else is struggling and disagrees vehemently because of the very real impact on their marraige? I can post more nicely that I diasgree - is that it?
 
It is NOT about furthering the cycle of “poor me, I’m such a victim of the circumstances of life”. It is not about encouraging those in sin. It is about instructing the ignorant and supporting people in the Faith.

So yes, that IS what is about. Which, by the way, is exactly what Deb did for the OP.
Did you even see what I specifically said directly to the OP?

Go back and see it, because no where in there did I say anything to the effects of swaying the OP’s decision to use NFP. I made one short statement to another person about how it was difficult for me because I felt I wasn’t prepared for what was ahead, and from that it’s all been me answering people’s questions and then having to defend myself for something I said on another thread back in March.

People can be so mean to others who struggle with things they themselves don’t struggle with. 😦
 
Do you believe the Church to be God’s spokesperson? Because it seems likely you are separating God from His bride which seems like your issues are more than the Church’s stance on sexuality.
I don’t believe the church has this right that God intends couples to live this way because of where semen ends up at some point. I can hear it now - church, God, Holy Spirit!

Yep, the church is God’s spokesperson led by the Holy Spirit, etc, etc. Not contended.

However, again, tell me that God wants couples to suffer and be told they are going to hell because they might have non-intercourse sex or something else for the sake of intimacy? Really? I can walk thru all the points where I feel and believe, in the end, that the church believes sex is for having kids, but I’d bet you disagree on that, too.
 
I mean the knowledge on how our cycles work more so than how to use that knowledge to achieve or postpone a pregnancy.

When I was young I was told that you get your period once a month. I never had my period once a month as a teen. It ranged from two weeks apart to one year when my period came just 4 times in a year.

I wasn’t told that about two weeks before you get your period you ovulate, you get certain symotoms when you ovulate, that is when you can conceive. The only thing I was told is that when you are pregnant, your period stops.

My DD will learn these things, so she doesn’t feel her body is not functioning properly.

It seems to me from the various threads on this subject, many people who don’t like NFP are not sure how their body works.
Ohh I see what you’re asking. Actually I first understood the biology behind cycles and fertile/infertile periods when I was taking a Nursing class back in college. But I learned more about it later on when I took an NFP course.
 
Did you even see what I specifically said directly to the OP?

Go back and see it, because no where in there did I say anything to the effects of swaying the OP’s decision to use NFP. I made one short statement to another person about how it was difficult for me because I felt I wasn’t prepared for what was ahead, and from that it’s all been me answering people’s questions and then having to defend myself for something I said on another thread back in March.

People can be so mean to others who struggle with things they themselves don’t struggle with. 😦
Did you think I was talking about you? I was saying that the other Deb offered support and advice without deviating from Church teaching. Which is what the forum is for.

I wasn’t even speaking about you.
 
Ok so then what does this do? I’m not saying you can’t voice your frustrations just asking what dwelling on it does for you. Having that level of hostility is no better for your soul than committing the sin. And I contend that it causes more problems for those reading these posts. So what isthe purpose?
The purpose is to open dialog, and lines of communication. It gives him a chance to commuicate how he feels, voice his frustrations and discuss it with others. If someone is not constantly being combative and accusatory, the anger and frustration will eventually subside. He wants acknowledgement and wants to talk with others who are having the same struggles as he is and wants to know how they are dealing with it and how (if) they came to terms with it. It doesn’t gave to be a tug of war with one side pulling and the other side pulling back.
 
Oooooh, so I can say I’m struggling and questioning, but not say I disagree? So you are the definitive authority on what is acceptable as a Catholic?

I do disagree, I do believe the church is wrong on this, but I didn’t say couples “can” - I believe couples should in their hearts with prayer be able to discern what maybe correct for them at the time and not be condemend to hell for it by the loving God that gave them their spouse in the first place.

Tell me how the church teaching that makes any sense whatseover.
In all seriousness I think you are not understanding where many of us are coming from. The fact that you failed to live up to the moral standards of the Church at times is nothing new and we have all failed as well at times I’m sure. No one blames you for failing especially given your situation. The problem we have is that you assume since you failed, the morals must be wrong. In blaming the morals instead of acknowledging the innate weakness in all of us and our need for God in order to live up to his moral standards you make it impossible to even have a chance. The only way a person can truly fail is to quit trying, and start believing their failure is not a failure at all.

Think of it this way:
You don’t believe what the Church is teaching is right, but you follow it anyways. This contradiction makes that part of your life a living hell. You have three choices:
  1. Continue living in this hell
  2. Assume what the Church is teaching is wrong, and live your life how you feel God is telling you specifically to.
  3. Assume what the Church is teaching is right and find some peace. Give up trying to understand it to God and just be content with doing it out of fear of God, and because you believe the Church does have the authority to speak on the issue. Allow yourself to be ok with the fact that you may never understand the teaching even up to your death. If your going to follow the teaching anyways, why choose to continue to live in a living hell of indecision? When you fall, pick yourself up (confession), acknowledge you fell, and forgive yourself and move on.
 
I don’t believe the church has this right that God intends couples to live this way because of where semen ends up at some point. I can hear it now - church, God, Holy Spirit!

Yep, the church is God’s spokesperson led by the Holy Spirit, etc, etc. Not contended.

However, again, tell me that God wants couples to suffer and be told they are going to hell because they might have non-intercourse sex or something else for the sake of intimacy? Really? I can walk thru all the points where I feel and believe, in the end, that the church believes sex is for having kids, but I’d bet you disagree on that, too.
I don’t disagree. The Church believes sex has a two fold purpose; to unite and to procreation. Both are extremely important. But do I believe God wants us to suffer. I don’t know if “wants” is the appropriate word but I’ll go w/ it. Yes I think suffering is important and I can point to numerous places in the Bible where it is written that not only we will but that it is good to suffer. Can you point to where we are promised happiness throughout our lives? Not everyone will suffer w/ this particular cross but everyone has a cross and we are called to suffer. I’m sorry you think it is mean or dismissive or whatever to say this but it is a fact. I am not denying that it is a burden for you or not real, I don’t think anyone is, but we are saying this may be your cross to bear right now.

Is that not what you want to hear? Why don’t you just tell me what you want to hear to make this less tedious.
 
The purpose is to open dialog, and lines of communication. It gives him a chance to commuicate how he feels, voice his frustrations and discuss it with others. If someone is not constantly being combative and accusatory, the anger and frustration will eventually subside. He wants acknowledgement and wants to talk with others who are having the same struggles as he is and wants to know how they are dealing with it and how (if) they came to terms with it. It doesn’t gave to be a tug of war with one side pulling and the other side pulling back.
I will agree that is what you want, but that is not how Searching comes across.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top