A
AnnieHall
Guest
Annie, if Pope Francis spoke about Yoga being bad for people, he wouldn’t be doing it to insult, but to warn, or to steer, as this is his role as a very devoted Catholic Pope.Just thought I’d [post this again for any new visitors:
http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/p...s/rc_pc_interelg_doc_20030203_new-age_en.html
If he said not to do Yoga for spiritual reasons, this looks as if it is tame or neutral, but in fact says a whole deal about Yoga practice in general. He said in the article that all we need is the Holy Spirit, and Christians know we can pray to the Holy Spirit for ALL our needs - for anxiety and stress, for pain, for worries. These can ALL be of a spiritual nature, because, human beings are all spiritual beings as we are made in the image of God - the body and soul make up who we are. Sometimes if a person’s soul is healed their pain goes. There are people who have been seriously ill and Christians prayed for them and their pain or illness vanished. Others put their suffering into God’s hands and this can be enough to give them peace. This is not a rare phenomenon. So when he says not to seek spiritual answers in Yoga, he is saying that for all purposes Yoga is not in fact needed. There are no spiritual answers to any problem to be found in Yoga. Sure, doing any stretch may help the back, but this type of exercise can be achieved by a back specialist with no need for Yoga or for a position to be called Yoga. Yoga doesn’t need to be approached for any reason whatsoever. When people use the word ‘insult’, they forget that as Christians, to go against the tenets of their faith is insulting in a spiritual way as we are temples of the Holy Spirit.
I have so much respect for those innocent people in the Middle East who would not renounce their faith in the face of barbaric adversity, risking their lives; compared to here, in the West, where we can’t even put up with the slightest change to our daily routine for the sake of faith - me included in this in many ways, I’d be a hypocrite if I didn’t admit this, who is really innocent, is a sad state of affairs. However, New Age (Yoga being lumped in with this) is simply not an advisable route to go down.
Pain relief is just one reason a person may have for trying this out. Of course prayer is an excellent and wonderful gift and our relationship with God should come before all else, but I fail to see how pain treatments (whether something that leans more towards restorative/preventative like yoga, or something from a doctor/over the counter, or in some severe situations, maybe something even more related to medical sources) should be assumed to get in the way of a relationship with God.
I think exercise, stretching, strengthening muscles and our cores, are good ways for people to recover from injury (of course, taking it slowly and not pushing beyond what their body can handle), and for those that are healthy, it’s a great way to stay healthy. I’m talking about just exercise in general here. If you want to bring spirituality into exercise, I think you could do it with many other things - I mentioned previously, I believe, my bias towards running and swimming. Both of these are suited to the rhythmic/counting/breathing aspect of yoga, and if you’re thinking about mantas in yoga, you could easily apply these while running or swooning too (once you’ve reached the point where you can do these activities without actively thinking about what you’re doing). Our you could replace a mantra with a prayer, such as the Hail Mary.
I guess I have a hard time understanding why, if an exercise had a spiritual aspect, it wouldn’t just be an extension of the spirituality that you already have outside of the exercise. As long as it is something IN ADDITION TO your religion and spiritual guidance and education in other areas of your life. I agree with the pope that it shouldn’t be anyone’s soul source of spirituality, and that you Spyker go to yoga class to find God or to replace other aspects of your life, but as a purely physical exercise or a time to find some peace and relief, I think it’s okay. Intention matters, as with most things.