I see. So if a business decided that its balance sheet, risk profile, debt structure, analysis of demand reaction to price increases, levels of international competition, skills needs, and seasonal analysis required that its employees be paid $1 an hour, the government ought not have a say?
“Logic” demands that the government stay out and leave these decisions to market forces? The worker has no option but to accept what’s given, even if it is only subsistence crumbs? The worker is only a cog in a vast impersonal machine that runs in the Newtonian universe of market forces?
You’re probably unaware, but this is directly contrary to Catholic teaching. Morality and justice, according to Catholic teaching, reside at the heart of every economic transaction, just as they do in every interaction between human beings. This most definitely includes wages.
Unfortunately, Catholic teaching has gotten lost in a society in which avarice and greed are justified as “market forces” governed by an “invisible hand” – notions which are little more than rationalizations of theft.
Your argument is a bit sophomoric. No one is suggesting a wage of $1 and hour. What is being suggested is that there are a number of entry level jobs which are currently being occupied by people who should have well above entry level jobs.
The problem is not what entry level jobs are being payed, currently; it is that there are not enough above entry level jobs to supply work for adults, including family wage earners as well as singles.
Paying what needs to be an above-poverty level wage for what is an entry level job and often has traditionally been occupied by high school and college age kids part time gets into an oxymoron.
To wit: No one is discussing the following: Minimum wage jobs in Oregon are at $9.75/hour. Raise that, and what does it do to the person currently making $13/hour? $15/hour? Both of those levels indicate something more than entry level; and the scale goes on up. Washington was a bit below Oregon in 2016: $9.47.
A sizable number of those entry level jobs have been in the fast food business - e.g. McDonalds. What the liberals’ push for higher wages is already starting to cause is a loss of those jobs through robotics. Please, tell me how that benefits those who would be working part time - students?
And how does a move to robotics benefit those who can’t find an above entry level job - which is not going to be magically created by raising the minimum wage?
Seattle is on the pathway to increase minimum wages 58%. If you work in Washington, do you think all wages are going to go up 58% in the same time frame? 40%? 25%? 10%? What you are going to have is a wage squeeze, and that guarantees major problems all around.
As many entry level workers are in the food industry, to stay in business, owners wil have to either cut hours and jobs, or increase prices, or both. And the short of it is that it will also cause bankruptcies or businesses simply closing their doors - and guess what - no employees art all there. And for those who wish to buy food instead of prepare it, the fact that their wages have not escalated at the same rate will mean less money to spend on a hamburger at McDonalds, or a lunch or dinner at a local restaurant. And fewer meals means businesses closing. You are day dreaming if you think that owners of such businesses are on fat profit margins.
The problem is not minimum wage levels; the problem is that our economy has been dragging ever since the debacle of 2007 - 2009; the economy shrank 8.2% in 2008 (so if the economy going in was 100, by the end it was 91.8) In 2009 it shrank again, by 5.4% ( so it went from 91.8 to about 86.84. The short of that is that we are still playing catch-up to where we were back in 2007 in terms of jobs/wages. And raising the minimum wage as much as projected is not going to grow jobs; it will shrink them. Who benefits by that?