$15 Seattle Minimum Wage Not Working Out

  • Thread starter Thread starter Monte_RCMS
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
If a business cannot afford to pay its employees a fair wage then either the owner needs to cut his compensation, increase his or her efficiency, or some combination of the two.
And how do you know the owner is receiving any compensation to cut? Many start ups the owner takes nothing - all receipts for services is put immediately back into the company to grow it …

And define for me exactly in monetary terms what a “fair wage” is …

You should be able express this fair wage in monetary terms and for one individuals pay per hour …

To keep it simple - lets say the only requirements are a high school diploma, average intelligence and a willingness to work 40 hours per week - Easy right?

I’ll wait
 
If the work is only worth $1/hour, then $1/hour is fair. And maybe I’m not desperate, maybe I enjoy the work and would do it for free, or maybe I’m retired and I’m just working to get out of the house and earn some beer and cigarette money. Who are you to tell me how much my time is worth? I’m a big boy and can make my own decisions, thank you very much.

Compassion is allowing free people to make decisions according to what they determine their best interests to be, not some nosy busybody with affected moral superiority telling people what they have to do.
But apparently not when it comes to some of the hot-button, most personal social issues of the day. Then the State (and Church) can tell people exactly how to run their own lives.
 
If a business cannot afford to pay its employees a fair wage then either the owner needs to cut his compensation, increase his or her efficiency, or some combination of the two.
There is other things they can do like not hire employees or let them go if they have them. This is what my friend had to do. when the minimum wage went up here He let go of 1 employees and did not bring on any student employees over the summer. His work load went up but at least he gets to keep his company going. He was able to give his good experienced employees a raise but he will not hire students over the summer becuase he can’t afford them.
 
But apparently not when it comes to some of the hot-button, most personal social issues of the day. Then the State (and Church) can tell people exactly how to run their own lives.
Yup. Responsibility for thee, but not for me. The secular Left does the same thing, but in reverse.
 
If a business cannot afford to pay its employees a fair wage then either the owner needs to cut his compensation, increase his or her efficiency, or some combination of the two.
What does “fair wage” mean to you? It goes both ways. An employee should be paid X if their job is worth X, and the employer shouldn’t have to pay their employee more than X. Using the government to try and force them to do so is wrong.

And as I said, to accomplish this, the employer will have to take a pay cut, raise prices, or reduce hours. The money doesn’t just come from nowhere. And let’s remember that this affects small businesses, too.
 
Compassion has nothing to do with it. If you raise the minimum wage, the business owner has to take a pay cut, prices will have to be raised, or the employee’s hours are cut. More than likely, it will be some combination of the three. The customer, the employee, and the business owner all suffer for it.
So rather than spreading the burden across three parties, you advocate putting the entire burden on the shoulders of the employee? That would account for why American workers are so beaten down while productivity and profits have soared.
 
If the work is only worth $1/hour, then $1/hour is fair. And maybe I’m not desperate, maybe I enjoy the work and would do it for free, or maybe I’m retired and I’m just working to get out of the house and earn some beer and cigarette money. Who are you to tell me how much my time is worth? I’m a big boy and can make my own decisions, thank you very much.
We weren’t talking about volunteering, or retirees doing something to divert themselves. Those are special cases. We’re talking about those trying to support themselves and possibly also a family.
 
Yup. Responsibility for thee, but not for me. The secular Left does the same thing, but in reverse.
I think you would find that Secular liberals think that the State has a role to play in commerce, in foreign relations, but needs to be held off from personal matters. The line is, of course, fuzzy.

But religious conservatives tend toward the idea that it is proper for the State to legislate morality, except when they don’t like the moral teachings.
 
Compassion is allowing free people to make decisions according to what they determine their best interests to be, not some nosy busybody with affected moral superiority telling people what they have to do.
So compassion = self-interest. Care to share where you got that from? Not from a reputable dictionary, or from any Catholic source, I guarantee that.
 
So rather than spreading the burden across three parties, you advocate putting the entire burden on the shoulders of the employee? That would account for why American workers are so beaten down while productivity and profits have soared.
Hmm, not what I said. What I said was, an employee worth X should be paid X. If that’s all their job is worth, that’s all the employer should be obligated to pay them. If they can pay them more, that’s awesome. Forcing business owners (especially small ones) to pay their employees more forces them to make a decision. Do they slash hours, take a pay cut (they probably have to do this anyways), raise prices (probably have to do this, too), lay people off, or stop hiring?

We’re not talking about just one business, either. This would affect everyone. That means every business would either stop hiring, cut hours, raise prices, etc. So that milk you used to get for $2 is probably $2.05 or $2.10. Which doesn’t sound so bad, until you consider that everything else in the store is similarly marked up. And that your own employer was forced to cut your hours or something similar, leaving you with a bigger paycheck per hour (unless your income bracket changed, then say hello to more taxes) but less hours worked.

Also your wait in line is longer, because fewer people are working right now.
 
We weren’t talking about volunteering, or retirees doing something to divert themselves. Those are special cases. We’re talking about those trying to support themselves and possibly also a family.
They are all special cases … which is why the minimum wage does not work … the entry level worker trying to raise a family on a minimum wage is a special case …

Students [High School/College], singles still living at home - two unmarried singles living together no kids, single parents, divorced, over the age of 50, retired, those with and without a HS diploma, with/without a college degree - and in what major, physical shape - good/bad/average, who will/can - won’t/can’t work shifts and or weekends or overtime, addiction to drugs and alcohol, reliable / unreliable … THEY ARE ALL Special and ergo Special cases …

Again - define a “Fair Wage” in monetary terms - and if government mandated - what is that federally mandated minimum “Fair Wage”? Still waiting 🤷
 
I see. So if a business decided that its balance sheet, risk profile, debt structure, analysis of demand reaction to price increases, levels of international competition, skills needs, and seasonal analysis required that its employees be paid $1 an hour, the government ought not have a say?

“Logic” demands that the government stay out and leave these decisions to market forces? The worker has no option but to accept what’s given, even if it is only subsistence crumbs? The worker is only a cog in a vast impersonal machine that runs in the Newtonian universe of market forces?

You’re probably unaware, but this is directly contrary to Catholic teaching. Morality and justice, according to Catholic teaching, reside at the heart of every economic transaction, just as they do in every interaction between human beings. This most definitely includes wages.

Unfortunately, Catholic teaching has gotten lost in a society in which avarice and greed are justified as “market forces” governed by an “invisible hand” – notions which are little more than rationalizations of theft.
Your argument is a bit sophomoric. No one is suggesting a wage of $1 and hour. What is being suggested is that there are a number of entry level jobs which are currently being occupied by people who should have well above entry level jobs.

The problem is not what entry level jobs are being payed, currently; it is that there are not enough above entry level jobs to supply work for adults, including family wage earners as well as singles.

Paying what needs to be an above-poverty level wage for what is an entry level job and often has traditionally been occupied by high school and college age kids part time gets into an oxymoron.

To wit: No one is discussing the following: Minimum wage jobs in Oregon are at $9.75/hour. Raise that, and what does it do to the person currently making $13/hour? $15/hour? Both of those levels indicate something more than entry level; and the scale goes on up. Washington was a bit below Oregon in 2016: $9.47.

A sizable number of those entry level jobs have been in the fast food business - e.g. McDonalds. What the liberals’ push for higher wages is already starting to cause is a loss of those jobs through robotics. Please, tell me how that benefits those who would be working part time - students?

And how does a move to robotics benefit those who can’t find an above entry level job - which is not going to be magically created by raising the minimum wage?

Seattle is on the pathway to increase minimum wages 58%. If you work in Washington, do you think all wages are going to go up 58% in the same time frame? 40%? 25%? 10%? What you are going to have is a wage squeeze, and that guarantees major problems all around.

As many entry level workers are in the food industry, to stay in business, owners wil have to either cut hours and jobs, or increase prices, or both. And the short of it is that it will also cause bankruptcies or businesses simply closing their doors - and guess what - no employees art all there. And for those who wish to buy food instead of prepare it, the fact that their wages have not escalated at the same rate will mean less money to spend on a hamburger at McDonalds, or a lunch or dinner at a local restaurant. And fewer meals means businesses closing. You are day dreaming if you think that owners of such businesses are on fat profit margins.

The problem is not minimum wage levels; the problem is that our economy has been dragging ever since the debacle of 2007 - 2009; the economy shrank 8.2% in 2008 (so if the economy going in was 100, by the end it was 91.8) In 2009 it shrank again, by 5.4% ( so it went from 91.8 to about 86.84. The short of that is that we are still playing catch-up to where we were back in 2007 in terms of jobs/wages. And raising the minimum wage as much as projected is not going to grow jobs; it will shrink them. Who benefits by that?
 
Again - define a “Fair Wage” in monetary terms - and if government mandated - what is that federally mandated minimum “Fair Wage”? Still waiting 🤷
Easy there, I was getting to you. There are ways through econometrics to determine roughly what a worker in a certain task contributes to the final value of a product or service. That is a fair wage. This isn’t that mysterious, much as you would like to make it seem so. It may not be possible to p(name removed by moderator)oint scientifically an appropriate wage, but there is certainly a range within which a wage is reasonable, and outside of which it is not. At the very least, if you have someone diligently working 40 hours a week and not able to keep themselves and their family reasonably fed, healthy and sheltered then they are ipso facto not being paid fairly.
 
So compassion = self-interest. Care to share where you got that from? Not from a reputable dictionary, or from any Catholic source, I guarantee that.
I am not sure why you think every business owner is a crook, a “slave driver” who does not want to pay their employees fairly … Hiring and turnover is had on business - especially small businesses - who need dependable hard workers providing a quality service to keep the doors open - rewarding those good employees is a priority - because you cant afford the cost of advertising, interviewing and training - let alone being short handed …

And it is not just conservatives who start business is it? Are not there some liberal out there starting businesses and employing people - here at CAF they seem to know exactly what it takes to do it … but then - they might end up like this one

mlive.com/news/grand-rapids/index.ssf/2016/11/grand_rapids_worker-run_vegeta.html

It was a nice idea - living wages, no bosses - empowered workers, everyone equal, no tipping - but then with no boss employees failed to open on time - long 40 minute waits for a sandwich , Golly gee - it was almost Nirvana 😉
 
Easy there, I was getting to you. There are ways through econometrics to determine roughly what a worker in a certain task contributes to the final value of a product or service. That is a fair wage. This isn’t that mysterious, much as you would like to make it seem so. It may not be possible to p(name removed by moderator)oint scientifically an appropriate wage, but there is certainly a range within which a wage is reasonable, and outside of which it is not. At the very least, if you have someone diligently working 40 hours a week and not able to keep themselves and their family reasonably fed, healthy and sheltered then they are ipso facto not being paid fairly.
But what the worker contributes towards the final value of the product or service does not lend itself to the government one size fits all “Minimum Wage” … because it is different for every industry and business model … which is the point …

And even if one argues that a minimum wage is necessary - is the Federal Level where that minimum should be set - I argue that the answer in practice in absolutely not -

Many states have set a different [always higher then the fed minimum by law] their own - minimum wage based on the states economics - so federally it makes zero sense to set one … But should it be determined at the state level - Since we see many municipalities [Like Seattle WA and others] establishing minimums - based on their economics well - then perhaps the State level is not it either -

Then some states like Hawaii by law allow owners to use tip income calculated into the Workers pay to reach the minimum wage - so they restaurant does not actually pay the minimum the pay less - the customer in essence makes up that difference. In Oregon - a restaurant has to pay the minimum and 100% of the Tips in in addition to the minimum wage …

Its time to get the government out of wage setting
 
Hmm, not what I said. What I said was, an employee worth X should be paid X. If that’s all their job is worth, that’s all the employer should be obligated to pay them. If they can pay them more, that’s awesome. Forcing business owners (especially small ones) to pay their employees more forces them to make a decision. Do they slash hours, take a pay cut (they probably have to do this anyways), raise prices (probably have to do this, too), lay people off, or stop hiring?

We’re not talking about just one business, either. This would affect everyone. That means every business would either stop hiring, cut hours, raise prices, etc. So that milk you used to get for $2 is probably $2.05 or $2.10. Which doesn’t sound so bad, until you consider that everything else in the store is similarly marked up. And that your own employer was forced to cut your hours or something similar, leaving you with a bigger paycheck per hour (unless your income bracket changed, then say hello to more taxes) but less hours worked.

Also your wait in line is longer, because fewer people are working right now.
Here is a chart you commonly see in these debates about minimum wage:

http://talkingpointsmemo.com/images/productivity.png

“The continuing growth of the wage gap between high and middle earners is the result of various laissez-faire policies (acts of omission as well as commission) including globalization, deregulation, privatization, eroded unionization, and weakened labor standards,” he writes. “The gap between the very highest earners — the top 1 percent — and all other earners, including other high earners, reflects the escalation of CEO and other managers’ compensation and the growth of compensation in the financial sector.”
talkingpointsmemo.com/dc/40-years-of-workers-left-behind-chart

This chart goes back to the 2012 election and helps explain the rise of populist movements on the right and left in 2016.

I am no Trump supporter. I think the man is a self promoting con artist without any integrity at all. However, he wasn’t lying when he said the economy was rigged against the common worker, because this chart shows exactly that.
 
But apparently not when it comes to some of the hot-button, most personal social issues of the day. Then the State (and Church) can tell people exactly how to run their own lives.
Care to elaborate?
We weren’t talking about volunteering, or retirees doing something to divert themselves. Those are special cases. We’re talking about those trying to support themselves and possibly also a family.
Should the minimum wage be based on the size of the employee’s family? That seems like it would create a lot of unintended consequences.
So compassion = self-interest. Care to share where you got that from? Not from a reputable dictionary, or from any Catholic source, I guarantee that.
So, you don’t think allowing competent adults to make decisions in what they determine their own best interests to be is compassionate? You think compassion is telling people what they can do based on your own “superior” sense of morality? CS Lewis called that the worst kind of tyranny.
 
Here is a chart you commonly see in these debates about minimum wage:

http://talkingpointsmemo.com/images/productivity.png

“The continuing growth of the wage gap between high and middle earners is the result of various laissez-faire policies (acts of omission as well as commission) including globalization, deregulation, privatization, eroded unionization, and weakened labor standards,” he writes. “The gap between the very highest earners — the top 1 percent — and all other earners, including other high earners, reflects the escalation of CEO and other managers’ compensation and the growth of compensation in the financial sector.”
talkingpointsmemo.com/dc/40-years-of-workers-left-behind-chart

This chart goes back to the 2012 election and helps explain the rise of populist movements on the right and left in 2016.

I am no Trump supporter. I think the man is a self promoting con artist without any integrity at all. However, he wasn’t lying when he said the economy was rigged against the common worker, because this chart shows exactly that.
I wonder if the chart considers non-wage compensation and increases in other labor costs. Those costs could easily overwhelm any productivity increases and essentially leave both employers and employees running in place.
 
If the work is only worth $1/hour, then $1/hour is fair. And maybe I’m not desperate, maybe I enjoy the work and would do it for free, or maybe I’m retired and I’m just working to get out of the house and earn some beer and cigarette money. Who are you to tell me how much my time is worth? I’m a big boy and can make my own decisions, thank you very much.
The presumption here is that all workers get paid the value of their marginal product, which may or may not occur. For example, if an employer has monopsony power the wage rate could be well below the value of the marginal product. In a competitive market where neither worker or employer has too much power then the market wage may well be just. But if an employer is suppressing wages just because he can get away with it, then the wage rate may not be just.
 
The presumption here is that all workers get paid the value of their marginal product, which may or may not occur. For example, if an employer has monopsony power the wage rate could be well below the value of the marginal product. In a competitive market where neither worker or employer has too much power then the market wage may well be just. But if an employer is suppressing wages just because he can get away with it, then the wage rate may not be just.
My presumption is that competent adults are able to make decisions in their own interests without a bunch of self righteous busybodies inserting themselves. With respect to monopsony power, I think the best example of a monopsony is in the Washington DC metro area, where the government is the main purchaser of labor. Does anybody think government workers are underpaid?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top