$15 Seattle Minimum Wage Not Working Out

  • Thread starter Thread starter Monte_RCMS
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Easy there, I was getting to you. There are ways through econometrics to determine roughly what a worker in a certain task contributes to the final value of a product or service. That is a fair wage. This isn’t that mysterious, much as you would like to make it seem so. It may not be possible to p(name removed by moderator)oint scientifically an appropriate wage, but there is certainly a range within which a wage is reasonable, and outside of which it is not. At the very least, if you have someone diligently working 40 hours a week and not able to keep themselves and their family reasonably fed, healthy and sheltered then they are ipso facto not being paid fairly.
Or they have the wrong job.
 
Here is a chart you commonly see in these debates about minimum wage:

http://talkingpointsmemo.com/images/productivity.png

“The continuing growth of the wage gap between high and middle earners is the result of various laissez-faire policies (acts of omission as well as commission) including globalization, deregulation, privatization, eroded unionization, and weakened labor standards,” he writes. “The gap between the very highest earners — the top 1 percent — and all other earners, including other high earners, reflects the escalation of CEO and other managers’ compensation and the growth of compensation in the financial sector.”
talkingpointsmemo.com/dc/40-years-of-workers-left-behind-chart

This chart goes back to the 2012 election and helps explain the rise of populist movements on the right and left in 2016.

I am no Trump supporter. I think the man is a self promoting con artist without any integrity at all. However, he wasn’t lying when he said the economy was rigged against the common worker, because this chart shows exactly that.
How do you determine what portion of productivity gains should go to labor and to capital? I could make one case if the gains come from employees presenting themselves for work with better educations and able to work with less supervision, even adding to the enterprise with their own ideas about how to improve the business. I could make a different case if the productivity came almost exclusively from more capital investment from the company.

When I worked in the steel industry many years ago, productivity came from heavy investment in new processes like argon-oxygen decarburization, continuous casting, electric arc furnaces, and computer controlled machines. The education levels on the plant floor were just about the same as generations ago. Only a few key men in the plant needed upgraded skills. Crane operators, truck drivers, and order fillers changed very little. Unfortunately, that was not enough to save the industry because foreign steel makers in Asia spent even more to improve productivity. They also had a huge advantage in the cost of labor, but with the new technology the cost of labor mattered a lot less. It was productivity that compensated for the higher shipping costs to bring steel from Japan, Korea, or China.
 
This should not be particularly surprising. People who actually see what happens when the liberals get their dander up. People with real world experience understand the other side of the coin far better than the people with a lot of theory and absolutely no real world experience.

In an unrelated matter, word was unofficially out (as in there was no way of proving it was true) that in Seattle, when the wage hike went to $11/hour, some individuals were requesting their managers reduce the number of hours they worked; the cause being that it moved them off of come government assistance.

No clue if this was actually happening or was urban legend, but it should come as no surprise if, not now, soon it becomes true. Particularly among some young workers, they have a life style that is not focused on “getting ahead”.
 
We have to remember that employees are not helpless slaves. They have marketable skills that are either in demand or can be used to start businesses and help generate wealth.

One of the strengths of the west was strong independent families with an emphasis of education, working hard and using the extended family (and community and church) to help members get along.

My thoughts are that when we simply say I am entitled to this or that through abstract moralities enforced by the state we break those communal bonds, become increasingly dependent and weak, not to mention jealous and thieving towards those that have wealth. Many people don’t even notice this slide as it becomes normalised.

The importance of community and church is then reduced, people become hyper individualised and look to the state to be some sort of Santa Claus with never ending presents.

One of the worst aspects of this then becomes the belief that anyone or family that have wealth must be heavily taxed in the name of equality and a pretend ‘justice’ with is really just theft.

I think charity or welfare in the long run is better done through non government agencies such as family, community and church where real world relationships are formed based on the moralities of fairness, hard work, charity, reciprocal charity and sustainable lifestyles.

In the long run the state is not good at this and the taking of money in lockstep with secular moralities such as political correctness will not work but lead to collapse of both wealth generation and citizen support.
 
I also think the ‘logos’ or Christ knowledge and behaviour that builds the kingdom of God on earth is also reduced.
 
My presumption is that competent adults are able to make decisions in their own interests without a bunch of self righteous busybodies inserting themselves. With respect to monopsony power, I think the best example of a monopsony is in the Washington DC metro area, where the government is the main purchaser of labor. Does anybody think government workers are underpaid?
Do you think that all occupational licensing regulations should be eliminated? Should I be able to contract with a healthcare provider without busybodies like the AMA and ADA attempting to interfere with my freedom?

If you think the federal government is a monopsonist in the D.C. area, you need to understand the definition on monopsony. They are not close to a monopsonist. Indeed some government workers are underpaid. I know of one department where I work who lost two new hires to better offers. Happens all the time where I work.
 
I see. So if a business decided that its balance sheet, risk profile, debt structure, analysis of demand reaction to price increases, levels of international competition, skills needs, and seasonal analysis required that its employees be paid $1 an hour, the government ought not have a say?

“Logic” demands that the government stay out and leave these decisions to market forces? The worker has no option but to accept what’s given, even if it is only subsistence crumbs? The worker is only a cog in a vast impersonal machine that runs in the Newtonian universe of market forces?

You’re probably unaware, but this is directly contrary to Catholic teaching. Morality and justice, according to Catholic teaching, reside at the heart of every economic transaction, just as they do in every interaction between human beings. This most definitely includes wages.

Unfortunately, Catholic teaching has gotten lost in a society in which avarice and greed are justified as “market forces” governed by an “invisible hand” – notions which are little more than rationalizations of theft.
One Dollar per hour?

Seriously???

Are people REQUIRED to take a job paying ONE DOLLAR???

I would say, that no one would work there at all.

Can’t force someone to work for ONE DOLLAR.

Unless, of course, they include a fabulous tuition reimbursement program or a SUPER commission program.

Outstanding stock options.

There are other ways to compensate employees.
 
One Dollar per hour?

Seriously???

Are people REQUIRED to take a job paying ONE DOLLAR???

I would say, that no one would work there at all.

Can’t force someone to work for ONE DOLLAR.

Unless, of course, they include a fabulous tuition reimbursement program or a SUPER commission program.

Outstanding stock options.

There are other ways to compensate employees.
Are you saying that every worker is receiving a just wage? If an employer can pay a worker less because he can get away with it, is that always morally licit?
 
I see. So if a business decided that its balance sheet, risk profile, debt structure, analysis of demand reaction to price increases, levels of international competition, skills needs, and seasonal analysis required that its employees be paid $1 an hour, the government ought not have a say?

“Logic” demands that the government stay out and leave these decisions to market forces? The worker has no option but to accept what’s given, even if it is only subsistence crumbs? The worker is only a cog in a vast impersonal machine that runs in the Newtonian universe of market forces?

You’re probably unaware, but this is directly contrary to Catholic teaching. Morality and justice, according to Catholic teaching, reside at the heart of every economic transaction, just as they do in every interaction between human beings. This most definitely includes wages.

Unfortunately, Catholic teaching has gotten lost in a society in which avarice and greed are justified as “market forces” governed by an “invisible hand” – notions which are little more than rationalizations of theft.
Got to thinking about the ONE DOLLAR wage.

I interviewed with a company that had a terrible wage but every employee participated in the stock ownership program. Back in 1970 employees were leaving with a check for ONE MILLION DOLLARS.
 
Are you saying that every worker is receiving a just wage? If an employer can pay a worker less because he can get away with it, is that always morally licit?
Discuss all aspects with 25 words or less.
 
Got to thinking about the ONE DOLLAR wage.

I interviewed with a company that had a terrible wage but every employee participated in the stock ownership program. Back in 1970 employees were leaving with a check for ONE MILLION DOLLARS.
Which company was that?
 
This should not be particularly surprising. People who actually see what happens when the liberals get their dander up. People with real world experience understand the other side of the coin far better than the people with a lot of theory and absolutely no real world experience.
Actually, plenty of people on the right fundamentally misunderstand economics as well. Economic illiteracy is alive and well across the political spectrum. Also, it is not clear that liberals are necessarily lacking in “real world experience”, whatever that is. If you mean business owners, I know plenty of business owners who are liberals and they are no less skilled as business owners than conservatives.
 
One way or another, every 40-hour a week worker deserves to earn enough for the basic necessities of living.
In the ideal world, this is true. If a family has one member willing and able to work outside the home for 40 hours, they should get the essentials.

But is every job intended for someone to support a family on? If the local hardware store owner can hire someone to stock shelves on a Saturday morning, and there’s some teenager still living at home who’s willing to do it, wouldn’t that be better than the owner not offering the job at all?
 
One Dollar per hour?

Seriously???

Are people REQUIRED to take a job paying ONE DOLLAR???

I would say, that no one would work there at all.

Can’t force someone to work for ONE DOLLAR.
Of course you can. Look at China/Vietnam/Honduras/Bangladesh. Places where your IPhones, Nike sneakers, designer apparel, Xboxes, etc are made. These items cost hundreds of dollars and are made by people earning pennies on the dollar.

It’s what happens when market conditions are right and there is no government interference in wages. No onerous minimum wage laws to cause corporate angst in China.
Monte RCMS:
There are other ways to compensate employees.
Granted. The most consistent way is wages though.
 
Actually, plenty of people on the right fundamentally misunderstand economics as well. Economic illiteracy is alive and well across the political spectrum. Also, it is not clear that liberals are necessarily lacking in “real world experience”, whatever that is. If you mean business owners, I know plenty of business owners who are liberals and they are no less skilled as business owners than conservatives.
No, I don’t mean liberal business owners, who are eminently capable of hiring someone for an entry level minimum wage job and paying them more - and I would be delighted to hear a list of such business owners. No clue what the starting wage for entry level is, but I would not be surprised to see Starbucks on the list for their own (as in, not franchise) stores for entry level workers.

However, the rest is non-responsive to my post. The question is not whether or not conservatives are economically illiterate. The question is, what impact will a better than 50% wage increase for minimum wage do to other wages, and what impact will it have on inflation. I await your response.
 
Of course you can. Look at China/Vietnam/Honduras/Bangladesh. Places where your IPhones, Nike sneakers, designer apparel, Xboxes, etc are made. These items cost hundreds of dollars and are made by people earning pennies on the dollar.

It’s what happens when market conditions are right and there is no government interference in wages. No onerous minimum wage laws to cause corporate angst in China.

Granted. The most consistent way is wages though.
Looking at those countries (and others) is a false dichotomy, as it presumes parity of cost of living with the US, which is not true. A far better measure is the number of hours it takes to be able to provide for basic necessities - food, clothing and shelter.
 
No, I don’t mean liberal business owners, who are eminently capable of hiring someone for an entry level minimum wage job and paying them more - and I would be delighted to hear a list of such business owners. No clue what the starting wage for entry level is, but I would not be surprised to see Starbucks on the list for their own (as in, not franchise) stores for entry level workers.

However, the rest is non-responsive to my post. The question is not whether or not conservatives are economically illiterate. The question is, what impact will a better than 50% wage increase for minimum wage do to other wages, and what impact will it have on inflation. I await your response.
The second part of your question is simple, the minimum wage has nothing to do with inflation. Inflation is related to money supply growth in the economy, when the money supply increases faster than real output, we have inflation. Now, the other part of your question is more interesting. Of all the policies that we have, the least damaging policy we have in this country is the minimum wage. I am not in favor of the minimum wage, but as a policy it has little effect on the economy. First of all, in the whole US, only about 700,000 workers earn the minimum wage. That is out of 79 million workers who earn hourly wages. So it is drop in the bucket as to the labor force. Much more damaging are occupational licensing restrictions that drive up wages of people like doctors and dentists. We pay billions of dollars extra in healthcare costs because some professions are in bed with the government to reduce competition. Which is why many so-called conservatives are economically illiterate. Do you hear many of them complaining about occupational licensing? No, the focus on the weakest policy of all, the minimum wage.
 
The second part of your question is simple, the minimum wage has nothing to do with inflation. Inflation is related to money supply growth in the economy, when the money supply increases faster than real output, we have inflation. Now, the other part of your question is more interesting. Of all the policies that we have, the least damaging policy we have in this country is the minimum wage. I am not in favor of the minimum wage, but as a policy it has little effect on the economy. First of all, in the whole US, only about 700,000 workers earn the minimum wage. That is out of 79 million workers who earn hourly wages. So it is drop in the bucket as to the labor force. Much more damaging are occupational licensing restrictions that drive up wages of people like doctors and dentists. We pay billions of dollars extra in healthcare costs because some professions are in bed with the government to reduce competition. Which is why many so-called conservatives are economically illiterate. Do you hear many of them complaining about occupational licensing? No, the focus on the weakest policy of all, the minimum wage.
Let me try it again.

Seattle has a minimum wage of $9.47 in 2016, and is on track to move to $15. And Seattle has people in 2016 making $15 for above entry level jobs. And $20 for jobs above that level.

So where are wages going to go, when Seattle hits $15/hour , for those who were making $15, and those who were making $20 an hour in 2016?

The raise on minimum is 50%+ so the previous $15/hour job is going to be $22.50 and the $20 is going to be $30?

I kind of doubt it.

And as to your definition of inflation, I take it as the rate of increase in the price of goods and services. and if the $15 and $20 jobs do increase at something approaching the rate of increase to the minimum, it is going to push the cost of goods and services up.

Maybe you don’t like that definition, but rather than argue about definitions, tell me your projections on wage increases other than the minimum - which is bound to push others.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top