G
Godfollower
Guest
No prob. Please stick around and keep asking questions. :tiphat:Godfollower:
Thanks for a great post. I appreciate that.![]()
No prob. Please stick around and keep asking questions. :tiphat:Godfollower:
Thanks for a great post. I appreciate that.![]()
Well, nothing about that necessarily makes for a spiritual orientation. Do you obey the law? If so, why?You are right. I do not let anyone have authority over me.
As a side not let me give you a little personal back ground into my life. I was born to a very catholic set of parents. I was always told what to do but not why I should be doing it. Back to my parents. I am the youngest of 6 children. My father was 50 years old when I was born and my mom was 44. Over the years of growing up my parents were the age of my friends grandparents. More times than not my parents were so tired of parenting that I pretty much had to survive for myself. Donât get me wrong, they really did love me but they were tired of parenting. That being said I learned that I can survive without depending on anyone. I did it myself.
I came from a farm background. I leased land and farmed on my own before I had a drivers license. Before I was out of high school I owned farm equipments and was operating of 1000 acres. From that point on I lived my own life. I took care of myself and asked no one for anything. So you might be able to see where my independent streak comes from.
Thanks for the link. That article has made more sense to me than anything that I have read, heard, or thought about Bible interpretation in many years.Lit, Iâd like to recommend the following link to you. Itâs a Catholic Answers column from âThis Rockâ about ten years ago, in which the author makes the point that the Catholic Church doesnât even have official interpretations of most passages of Scripture, precisely because a particular passageâs meaning can change from person to person and from circumstance to circumstance. You might find it helpful.
catholic.com/thisrock/2001/0101bt.asp
Some people here are rude; and some of them are absolutely determined to prove to you that their rudeness is correct, even when theyâre wrong. Donât let that deter you from inquiring about our beliefs.
Well, nothing about that necessarily makes for a spiritual orientation. Do you obey the law? If so, why? I have a tendency to not obey a lot of laws. I love to drive fast, ignore stop signs, have a beer while I drive is one of the most enjoyable things I can do. You also have to understand that my closest neighbor is 7 miles away.
And your religion, now, is what? I am not sure how to answer that other than I AM a Christian.
Does God intend there to be 40,000 different protestant sects, each with its own competing biblical interpretations?
If so, what is His purpose in wanting that? Of the 40000 different religious sects I believe that there are far greater commonalities than differences in their Biblical interpretations. If I were to venture a guess as to Godâs purpose in that many religious sects it would be that; With a large number of religions more of Godâs children have an opportunity to feel welcome in Godâs kingdom and family. The crux of all religion is the praise honor and glory of God. This way more people are giving praise, honor, and glory to Him.
Godfollower, I very respectfully disagree. The issue LT56RD is asking us to consider is authority, that is, who has the authority to correctly interpret scripture? (Which has nothing to do with the consequences of whether incorrect misinterpretation necessarily leads to damnation. I take the very Catholic position that it is between God and each individual, I gain nothing from anyoneâs damnation and pray for mercy for all as I hope for it myself). It is only natural to cite specific teachings as examples of confusion over interpretation of scripture- not debate about whether specific interpretations are correct.I would like to ask that we not address the specifics regarding the issues of the Real Presence, contraception, etc., because Litâs question is not about all of those specific issues but is about the process of understanding the Bible. Thatâs a perfectly legitimate question, one that addresses the âhowâ and âwhyâ of many other questions often addressed on these threads, and I think heâs entitled to an answer.
A wise man (G K Chesterton) once said âReformers are always right about what is wrong, but are almost always wrong about what is right.â In other words, itâs a lot easier to spot a problem than to figure out the solution. I think this applies here in spades.You are right. I do not let anyone have authority over me.
As a side not let me give you a little personal back ground into my life. I was born to a very catholic set of parents. I was always told what to do but not why I should be doing it. Back to my parents. I am the youngest of 6 children. My father was 50 years old when I was born and my mom was 44. Over the years of growing up my parents were the age of my friends grandparents. More times than not my parents were so tired of parenting that I pretty much had to survive for myself. Donât get me wrong, they really did love me but they were tired of parenting. That being said I learned that I can survive without depending on anyone. I did it myself.
You pretty much hit the nail on the head there. I see all church leaders as men called by God to serve. (And I am greatful that there are people who respond to Godâs call to minister to the rest of us) But whether pastor, priest, bishop, or pope they are still men and, in my mind they are no better and no less than I am. We all have a different job and I respect them for the job that they do but their jobs are no more righteous or important than mine or yours.LITs struggle is the very basic question- Did Christ establish a Church and grant it His authority to act on His behalf, teach the faith and settle disputes which arise etc? With his assurance He would guide it in all truth? LIT states he has an issue with allowing other men over him, and as he sees the Church as men, not the representatives of God, then his word is as good as theirs. He sees himself, and LIT please forgive me if Iâm putting words in your mouth, submitting to the perhaps capricious whims of men as opposed to humbly submitting to the guidance of Godâs Church . A very natural and understandable train of thought.
I thank you for your insight, understanding, and care that you show in this post. I greatly appreciate it. Yes I have asked difficult questions. Many of which many not have a simple answer. And some of the answers I may not agree with. Faith is a complicated topic. It is so personal that it effects us to our vary core. When someone challenges us that our âfaithâ is not what it should be, you could just as well tell us that we are a bad person and that our life is worth nothing, for we have the âwrong faith attitudeâ.LIT, you have raised a very basic question about faith and following the Church. I think it as a question far too few Catholics raise, or are even aware exists. Many cradle Catholics come to a point in their life where they realize that they are Catholic by birth but have never really examined if they personally believe the faith or have simply followed it by habit. I do sincerely wish you all the best in your faith journey and hope you donât allow comments by individuals to dissuade you from any particular faith. All religions are practised by fallible men on earth, I would agree with you that it is far more important to God how we live our lives, He said we would be judged by how we treat others as a sign of how we accepted Him.
I am glad that this is as clear to you as it is to us.You are right. I do not let anyone have authority over me.
This is indeed a shortcoming of many parents. When children are young, they need to be given guidance before they are able to understand the the âwhyâ. As they get older, they need to be taught the âwhyâ - understand the reasoning and motivation behind the expectations. If this is not done, children never learn how to morally reason.Code:As a side not let me give you a little personal back ground into my life. I was born to a very catholic set of parents. I was always told what to do but not why I should be doing it.
It is good that you were cooperating with Godâs grace in your life to get your needs met. It is really difficult for people who think they can do everything in their life on their own to depend on God, and even depend upon others the way He intends for us to do. Perhaps this ability will grow in you as you continue to grow spiritually.I came from a farm background. I leased land and farmed on my own before I had a drivers license. Before I was out of high school I owned farm equipments and was operating of 1000 acres. From that point on I lived my own life. I took care of myself and asked no one for anything. So you might be able to see where my independent streak comes from.Code:Back to my parents. I am the youngest of 6 children. My father was 50 years old when I was born and my mom was 44. Over the years of growing up my parents were the age of my friends grandparents. More times than not my parents were so tired of parenting that I pretty much had to survive for myself. Don't get me wrong, they really did love me but they were tired of parenting. That being said I learned that I can survive without depending on anyone. I did it myself.
No, that is not what I mean. I mean that the Catholic Church is not a âbible churchâ in the sense that our doctrines are extrapolated from the pages of the book.I am not really sure what you are trying to say here. Am I to understand that there is nothing in the bible that deals with the teachings that I am opposed to.
Exactly!It all depends on how the Bible is interpreted whether there are contradiction to the Churchâs teachings.
This is not surprising in a person who has problems with authority. This is the fruit that grows from the tree.Code:I have a tendency to not obey a lot of laws. I love to drive fast, ignore stop signs, have a beer while I drive is one of the most enjoyable things I can do. You also have to understand that my closest neighbor is 7 miles away.
How can you tell?Code:I am not sure how to answer that other than I AM a Christian.
I agree that the goal is the honor and praise of God, but God is to be worshipped as He proscribes, not ours.Code:Of the 40000 different religious sects I believe that there are far greater commonalities than differences in their Biblical interpretations. If I were to venture a guess as to God's purpose in that many religious sects it would be that; With a large number of religions more of God's children have an opportunity to feel welcome in God's kingdom and family. The crux of all religion is the praise honor and glory of God. This way more people are giving praise, honor, and glory to Him.
I am glad that this is as clear to you as it is to us.You are right. I do not let anyone have authority over me.
This is indeed a shortcoming of many parents. When children are young, they need to be given guidance before they are able to understand the the âwhyâ. As they get older, they need to be taught the âwhyâ - understand the reasoning and motivation behind the expectations. If this is not done, children never learn how to morally reason.Code:As a side not let me give you a little personal back ground into my life. I was born to a very catholic set of parents. I was always told what to do but not why I should be doing it.
It is good that you were cooperating with Godâs grace in your life to get your needs met. It is really difficult for people who think they can do everything in their life on their own to depend on God, and even depend upon others the way He intends for us to do. Perhaps this ability will grow in you as you continue to grow spiritually.I came from a farm background. I leased land and farmed on my own before I had a drivers license. Before I was out of high school I owned farm equipments and was operating of 1000 acres. From that point on I lived my own life. I took care of myself and asked no one for anything. So you might be able to see where my independent streak comes from.Code:Back to my parents. I am the youngest of 6 children. My father was 50 years old when I was born and my mom was 44. Over the years of growing up my parents were the age of my friends grandparents. More times than not my parents were so tired of parenting that I pretty much had to survive for myself. Don't get me wrong, they really did love me but they were tired of parenting. That being said I learned that I can survive without depending on anyone. I did it myself.
No, that is not what I mean. I mean that the Catholic Church is not a âbible churchâ in the sense that our doctrines are extrapolated from the pages of the book.I am not really sure what you are trying to say here. Am I to understand that there is nothing in the bible that deals with the teachings that I am opposed to.
Exactly!It all depends on how the Bible is interpreted whether there are contradiction to the Churchâs teachings.
This is not surprising in a person who has problems with authority. This is the fruit that grows from the tree.Code:I have a tendency to not obey a lot of laws. I love to drive fast, ignore stop signs, have a beer while I drive is one of the most enjoyable things I can do. You also have to understand that my closest neighbor is 7 miles away.
How can you tell?Code:I am not sure how to answer that other than I AM a Christian.
I agree that the goal is the honor and praise of God, but God is to be worshipped as He proscribes, not ours.Code:Of the 40000 different religious sects I believe that there are far greater commonalities than differences in their Biblical interpretations. If I were to venture a guess as to God's purpose in that many religious sects it would be that; With a large number of religions more of God's children have an opportunity to feel welcome in God's kingdom and family. The crux of all religion is the praise honor and glory of God. This way more people are giving praise, honor, and glory to Him.
He sees himself submitting to the perhaps capricious whims of men as opposed to humbly submitting to the guidance of Godâs Church
I dontâ see how one equates to the other, Lit. Of course the shepherds are not âbetter or more righteous or more importantâ than others. They have a certain call. I donât understand how that equates to âsubmitting to capricious whimsâ. And how is it that you dontâ see the guidance of the authorities appointed by Christ as an expression of Godâs love for you?You pretty much hit the nail on the head there. I see all church leaders as men called by God to serve. (And I am greatful that there are people who respond to Godâs call to minister to the rest of us) But whether pastor, priest, bishop, or pope they are still men and, in my mind they are no better and no less than I am. We all have a different job and I respect them for the job that they do but their jobs are no more righteous or important than mine or yours.
I agree with you about faith being a core subject. But, if we have the wrong faith attitude, is it not better that we hear about it, so that we really dontâ end up as a bad person having a life that is worth nothingCode:Faith is a complicated topic. It is so personal that it effects us to our vary core. When someone challenges us that our "faith" is not what it should be, you could just as well tell us that we are a bad person and that our life is worth nothing, for we have the "wrong faith attitude".
Given the chip you were wearing on your shoulder when you started this thread, somehow I donât think that is the problem.Code:Maybe I am too non combative for I will listen and try to understand anyones take on faith and beliefs. I may not agree with them for my life but I will not tell them that they are wrong for there beliefs.
Clearly you are a man after Godâs own heart. I hope you will find what you are seeking.Thanks for listeningCode:And as a final note the highlighted words in the above quote really means a lot to me. That is the way I have really tried to live my life. *Love one another as God loves you and how you would like to be loved.*:thumbsup:
LIT56RD
Maybe my inability to submit to authority of the church has to deal in part with the belief of infallibility. My mind just can not grasp the idea that a human (other than Christ) or group of humans could never ever make a mistake. If that is the case than they are just as âgood or perfectâ as Christ was.When the Scriptures are removed from their context (the Catholic Church), it is easy to misinterpret them. The Sacred Tradition (Teaching of the Apostles) is preserved infallibly in the CC. When the reader departs from the point of view of the authors, sometimes the meaning of the writing is no longer clear. The Catholic way of reading the Scripture is to understand it according to the perspective of the authors.
I believe that God sent his only son Jesus to be our redeemer and savior. And by Jesusâ suffering and death we can be freed of sin and entering to the kingdom of heaven.Originally Posted by LIT56RD View Post
I am not sure how to answer that other than I AM a Christian.
How can you tell?
I have been so independent all my life. I tend to rely on no one. Even after 34 years of marriage I just now starting to depend on my wonderful wife. Guess I believe in one of two things.It is good that you were cooperating with Godâs grace in your life to get your needs met. It is really difficult for people who think they can do everything in their life on their own to depend on God, and even depend upon others the way He intends for us to do. Perhaps this ability will grow in you as you continue to grow spiritually.
It seems that you may misunderstand what infallibility is. Briefly infallibility is Freedom from error in teaching the universal Church in **matters of faith or morals. ** It isnât because the human cannot make mistakes they have but that the Holy Spirit protects His Church from error.Maybe my inability to submit to authority of the church has to deal in part with the belief of infallibility. My mind just can not grasp the idea that a human (other than Christ) or group of humans could never ever make a mistake. If that is the case than they are just as âgood or perfectâ as Christ wasâŚ
None of us can wrap our puny minds around the gifts and mysteries of God. However, the gift of infallibility does not mean a person , or group of persons âcould never make a mistakeâ.Code:Maybe my inability to submit to authority of the church has to deal in part with the belief of infallibility. My mind just can not grasp the idea that a human (other than Christ) or group of humans could never ever make a mistake. If that is the case than they are just as "good or perfect" as Christ was.
Well, the Scriptures say that the demons believe this also. do you think they are saved?I believe that God sent his only son Jesus to be our redeemer and savior. And by Jesusâ suffering and death we can be freed of sin and entering to the kingdom of heaven.
I have been so independent all my life. I tend to rely on no one. Even after 34 years of marriage I just now starting to depend on my wonderful wife. Guess I believe in one of two things.
*]If I canât do it myself than I a must be a failure at it and not do it at all.
*]What give me the right to infringe on someone else to help me. They have more important things to do than to help me.
I am having a real hard time of making sense of all of this. So you are saying is that even popes are human and have all human frailties they never make a mistake.LIT have you investigated the difference between âimpeccableâ and âinfallible?â I find this is a common misunderstanding.
From the very first pope (Peter), popes have been prone to human weakness, temptation, cowardice and misjudgement in their own behavior. This doesnât affect their infallibility.
To steal anotherâs example, whatâs the minimum score you could get on a math test if you were infallible at math? Answer: zero. You could turn in a blank test. Being infallible doesnât guarantee youâll come up with the right answer (thatâs impeccable). Being infallible is when the answer you DO write down is never wrong. More than one pope died shortly before reportedly making a major decision (and some before ever making really ANY decisions). Could simply be blank tests, IMO.
Originally Posted by LIT56RD View Post
I believe that God sent his only son Jesus to be our redeemer and savior. And by Jesusâ suffering and death we can be freed of sin and entering to the kingdom of heaven.
I accept that Christ is MY savior.Well, the Scriptures say that the demons believe this also. do you think they are saved
No he is not saying that they never make a mistake.I am having a real hard time of making sense of all of this. So you are saying is that even popes are human and have all human frailties they never make a mistake.
If I may expand on the math problem: If the math test asks what is 4 times 4? The pope declares that it is 17, than 17 will be what it is for now and for ever.![]()