Atheists unveiling monument by Ten Commandments

  • Thread starter Thread starter GreyRabbit
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Well, your not an atheist, so the reason for that could help those on here who are Atheists.

Instead it feels as if you are trying to embrace atheism with your arguments.

Okay. I don’t see you as some kind of radical, it just feels as if your arguments are in favor of the opposition rather than your own faith.

So you think us as a society would be better off with more atheists? you’d rather more atheists? how is that loving your neighbor by guiding them away from the truth?

So the main question would be, if your more worried about religious people, than why are you yourself religious?

God Bless

Thank you for reading
Josh
I suppose I “defend” atheism for the same reason I defend anyone’s belief system, so long is it doesn’t cause harm to others. Imagine a woman who calls herself an atheist – she is a charitable, positive influence on her community. Imagine a woman who says she believes in God but doesn’t attend any church or go beyond the statement of belief, though she is like the first woman in being a charitable, positive influence. The declaration of belief in God by one doesn’t distinguish these two in any real way. This bench seems to me to be a fairly benign gesture. If it forces Catholics to be better evangelists, that’s great! Isn’t it?

I’m more concerned about religious fanaticism, yes, but I suppose it’s fair to say that I’m more concerned about fanaticism in general. Some really frightening things take place in the name of Christianity, Islam, Judaism, etc., and usually they’re carried out by fanatics. I’m sure there are crazy, fanatical atheists, but I have yet to see them fly planes into buildings.

Belief in God for me is – as Indiana Jones says – a leap of faith. But I’m not sure that knowledge is useful here.
 
I can’t think of any instances of atheists flying planes into buildings, but I can think of instances of atheists imposing starvation, gulags, labor camps, death squads, and oppression. Read “The Black Book of Communism.” It seems that atheists have caused millions more deaths in the 20th century than religions have been able to accomplish in millenia. Even that early monument to the god of Reason, the French Revolution, was ruthless with its enemies and its own people.
 
I can’t think of any instances of atheists flying planes into buildings, but I can think of instances of atheists imposing starvation, gulags, labor camps, death squads, and oppression. Read “The Black Book of Communism.” It seems that atheists have caused millions more deaths in the 20th century than religions have been able to accomplish in millenia. Even that early monument to the god of Reason, the French Revolution, was ruthless with its enemies and its own people.
So you see gulags and guillotines in our future? (That’s a serious question, not a snarky one.)
 
So you see gulags and guillotines in our future? (That’s a serious question, not a snarky one.)
What’s happened before can happen again, especially when people have forgotten what happened before. And many have.

We are seeing the beginning of the erosion of religious liberty, and the beginning of a near contempt for religion in public life. We have already seen the devolution of stable family life, and the approval of sexual anarchy across our culture. When a culture begins to decline into chaos, tyranny is a real possibility.

Carle Zimmerman wrote “Family & Civilization” long before our most recent cultural declines. Even then, his analysis was that the state of the family in western civilization was in a state of decline, which is the forerunner of civilizational decline. I don’t think he would change his analysis based on the events of the past 60 years. And he only noted two prior instance of extreme family structure decline in the preceding several millennia. He thought we were embarked on the third.
 
So you see gulags and guillotines in our future? (That’s a serious question, not a snarky one.)
I see plenty to be concerned about right now.

North Korea is an Atheistic state and so is China.

North Korea has death camps and almost the entirety of its population is suffering from extreme starvation.

The Chinese refuse to grant amnesty to any North Korean refugee who escapes through the Chinese border. The Chinese call them illegal border jumpers and promptly send them back to North Korea…never to be heard from again.

There are loads of Asian Christian missionaries working hard to navigate North Korean refugees over the border and through China, into Mongolia…where they can be given the amnesty they need.
 
I suppose I “defend” atheism for the same reason I defend anyone’s belief system, so long as it doesn’t cause harm to others.
Remember like I said, Hell is simply the absense of God and we call “Hell” the suffering of all sufferings.

Also like I said before, if life begins in nothing and life ends in nothing, that false belief ultimate renders life meaningless, therefore Atheism leads to only one logical outcome, which is desperation and despair.
Imagine a woman who calls herself an atheist – she is a charitable, positive influence on her community. Imagine a woman who says she believes in God but doesn’t attend any church or go beyond the statement of belief, though she is like the first woman in being a charitable, positive influence. The declaration of belief in God by one doesn’t distinguish these two in any real way. This bench seems to me to be a fairly benign gesture.
Because it’s much harder to live with the status quo once you acknowledge the truth. So in regards to the second woman, who “only” declares her belief in God, it would be much harder for her to live a life without God than for the Atheist. As C.S. Lewis says - A man can no more diminish God’s glory by refusing to worship Him than a lunatic can put out the sun by scribbling the word, ‘darkness’ on the walls of his cell.
If it forces Catholics to be better evangelists, that’s great! Isn’t it?
True, but how do you evangalise by defending atheism? surely you wouldn’t encourage pagans to worship their false idols would you?
I’m more concerned about religious fanaticism, yes, but I suppose it’s fair to say that I’m more concerned about fanaticism in general. Some really frightening things take place in the name of Christianity, Islam, Judaism, etc., and usually they’re carried out by fanatics. I’m sure there are crazy, fanatical atheists, but I have yet to see them fly planes into buildings.
True, fanaticism in general worries me as well.

However there is just as much, if not more fanatical atheism and if you look throughout history, fanatical atheism has been the result of far greater horrors. Didn’t you hear Richard Dawkins speech where he told people to redicule and mock us with contempt?

youtube.com/watch?v=WuXi5Qkj-J4
Belief in God for me is – as Indiana Jones says – a leap of faith. But I’m not sure that knowledge is useful here.
Okay. For me it’s many moral truths written on my heart and mind, quite simply, it makes sense and the more understanding and knowing of Christ I have, the more and more sense everything else makes, exactly like C.S. Lewis said, I don’t believe in the sun because I can see it, but because by it, I can see everything else.

God Bless

Thank you for reading
Josh
 
I suppose I “defend” atheism for the same reason I defend anyone’s belief system, so long is it doesn’t cause harm to others. Imagine a woman who calls herself an atheist – she is a charitable, positive influence on her community. Imagine a woman who says she believes in God but doesn’t attend any church or go beyond the statement of belief, though she is like the first woman in being a charitable, positive influence. The declaration of belief in God by one doesn’t distinguish these two in any real way. This bench seems to me to be a fairly benign gesture. If it forces Catholics to be better evangelists, that’s great! Isn’t it?

I’m more concerned about religious fanaticism, yes, but I suppose it’s fair to say that I’m more concerned about fanaticism in general. Some really frightening things take place in the name of Christianity, Islam, Judaism, etc., and usually they’re carried out by fanatics. I’m sure there are crazy, fanatical atheists, but I have yet to see them fly planes into buildings.

Belief in God for me is – as Indiana Jones says – a leap of faith. But I’m not sure that knowledge is useful here.
Funny that today is the feast day of St. Thomas the Apostle. You know, the apostle coined, Thomas the Doubter.

I suppose in a way Thomas had more faith than all the other apostles put together for in his disbelief, he called out to the living God to reveal Himself and God did!

Our relationship with God is a process and one that needs to be developed. So I suppose those who doubt the existence of God just have not discovered Him yet and that is why we need to let all people know what God has done for us and how great is His love.

How Great is our God by Chris Tomlin:

youtube.com/watch?v=-20GqU9Q4UE
 
This is what the Catechism says about Atheism:

Atheism

2123 “Many… of our contemporaries either do not at all perceive, or explicitly reject, this intimate and vital bond of man to God. Atheism must therefore be regarded as one of the most serious problems of our time.”58 (29)

2124 The name “atheism” covers many very different phenomena. One common form is the practical materialism which restricts its needs and aspirations to space and time. Atheistic humanism falsely considers man to be “an end to himself, and the sole maker, with supreme control, of his own history.”59 Another form of contemporary atheism looks for the liberation of man through economic and social liberation. “It holds that religion, of its very nature, thwarts such emancipation by raising man’s hopes in a future life, thus both deceiving him and discouraging him from working for a better form of life on earth.”60

2125 Since it rejects or denies the existence of God, atheism is a sin against the virtue of religion.61 The imputability of this offense can be significantly diminished in virtue of the intentions and the circumstances. “Believers can have more than a little to do with the rise of atheism. To the extent that they are careless about their instruction in the faith, or present its teaching falsely, or even fail in their religious, moral, or social life, they must be said to conceal rather than to reveal the true nature of God and of religion.”62 (1735)

2126 Atheism is often based on a false conception of human autonomy, exaggerated to the point of refusing any dependence on God.63 Yet, “to acknowledge God is in no way to oppose the dignity of man, since such dignity is grounded and brought to perfection in God…”64 “For the Church knows full well that her message is in harmony with the most secret desires of the human heart.”65 (396, 154)
 
I suppose I “defend” atheism for the same reason I defend anyone’s belief system, so long is it doesn’t cause harm to others. Imagine a woman who calls herself an atheist – she is a charitable, positive influence on her community. Imagine a woman who says she believes in God but doesn’t attend any church or go beyond the statement of belief, though she is like the first woman in being a charitable, positive influence. The declaration of belief in God by one doesn’t distinguish these two in any real way. This bench seems to me to be a fairly benign gesture. If it forces Catholics to be better evangelists, that’s great! Isn’t it?

I’m more concerned about religious fanaticism, yes, but I suppose it’s fair to say that I’m more concerned about fanaticism in general. Some really frightening things take place in the name of Christianity, Islam, Judaism, etc., and usually they’re carried out by fanatics. I’m sure there are crazy, fanatical atheists, but I have yet to see them fly planes into buildings.

Belief in God for me is – as Indiana Jones says – a leap of faith. But I’m not sure that knowledge is useful here.
Surely you don’t confuse beliefs with the people who believe them. We should respect and love all people, whether they are atheists, Christians, Jews, Muslims, or of any other persuasion. But I defend only the Christian belief; why would I defend what I believe to be false? But I do respect a person’s right to believe it.

And, yes, belief systems do cause harm to others. I would say that loss of one’s immortal soul is harm enough?
 
Our faith should not rise, or fall, or even be impacted, by any monument of any kind.

We are called to be apart from the world in our faith in Christ…when the world conducts such silliness, we should pray for them. Let them have their monuments…if we help the Lord convert the country back to Him, then over time those monuments will appear more and more pathetic.
 
Also like I said before, if life begins in nothing and life ends in nothing, that false belief ultimate renders life meaningless, therefore Atheism leads to only one logical outcome, which is desperation and despair.
Life is not meaningless to atheists. Atheism and nihilism are two different doctrines.
True, but how do you evangalise by defending atheism? surely you wouldn’t encourage pagans to worship their false idols would you?
Surely you don’t confuse beliefs with the people who believe them. We should respect and love all people, whether they are atheists, Christians, Jews, Muslims, or of any other persuasion. But I defend only the Christian belief; why would I defend what I believe to be false? But I do respect a person’s right to believe it.
If I don’t defend an atheist’s right to publicly share his views, why should I expect him to make room for mine in the public square?
 
If I don’t defend an atheist’s right to publicly share his views, why should I expect him to make room for mine in the public square?
True, I agree with that.

God Bless

Thank you for reading
Josh
 
If I don’t defend an atheist’s right to publicly share his views, why should I expect him to make room for mine in the public square?
You wrote:
I suppose I “defend” atheism for the same reason I defend anyone’s belief system…
Now you write:
If I don’t defend an atheist’s right to publicly share his views…
I hope you can see the difference between these two remarks. I agree with the latter, but I totally disagree with the former.

I defend a person’s right to share his views, but I don’t defend his views-- there’s a big difference.

Apparently, you did not mean the first statement. The written word is unforgiving, but I think I know what you mean now. Peace.
 
Life is not meaningless to atheists. Atheism and nihilism are two different doctrines.
True, they are two different doctrines. Both of them render life meaningless. I know this from experience. I’ve heard atheists say that they do the right thing just because it is the right thing, Says who? If in the end it doesn’t matter, why would it matter in the present moment? If human life is no more precious than a stone’s life, why cherish it? Instinct?

The mere fact of existence does not equate to love if it is simply happenstance. One can see this in the person who exists in pain and suffering, where neither love nor justice could be imagined for that person in a world devoid of God.

What does it matter if a person dies now so that I may have his money and a better life, or from old age, since his fate is the same, that is, in the end he ceases to exist? Justice and love are false concepts if there is no God, since the existence of man without the concept of God is neither just nor loving.

If you say, “So that we can create a moment of love and justice in the present moment,” my answer is, “Why?” In the end it is meaningless.

I have experienced this void and absence of meaning first hand when I tried to live as an atheist in my youth. I can tell you this, I would not trust anyone who embraces this doctrine. The fact is, I find it next to impossible to believe that anyone can really believe there is no God. Even if they are not so bright, I still find it incomprehensible that they do not at the very least “feel” the absurdity of their position. I’m guessing its an ego thing, perhaps an attention getter, or to feed some sense of their own superiority.
 
If I don’t defend an atheist’s right to publicly share his views, why should I expect him to make room for mine in the public square?
That is really the whole point… How many atheist do you know that do this? And do you think they are going to change because you are now supportive of their choice to reject God?
 
If I don’t defend an atheist’s right to publicly share his views, why should I expect him to make room for mine in the public square?
I suppose I “defend” atheism for the same reason I defend anyone’s belief system, so long is it doesn’t cause harm to others.
I hope you can see the difference between these two remarks.
Nope – sorry. In both statements, I’m stating that I defend an atheist’s right to be an atheist, just as I defend a Muslim’s right to be a Muslim or a Jew to be a Jew or, or, or…
True, they are two different doctrines. Both of them render life meaningless. I know this from experience. I’ve heard atheists say that they do the right thing just because it is the right thing, Says who? If in the end it doesn’t matter, why would it matter in the present moment? If human life is no more precious than a stone’s life, why cherish it? Instinct?
Your anecdotal experiences aside, there are different definitions for atheism and nihilism for a reason. Atheists don’t see human life as “no more precious than a stone’s life.”
That is really the whole point… How many atheist do you know that do this? And do you think they are going to change because you are now supportive of their choice to reject God?
Plenty! The atheists I know are reasoned, rational people – they’re not the boogeyman that I often read about here.
 
Plenty! The atheists I know are reasoned, rational people – they’re not the boogeyman that I often read about here.
Well then they will probably be easier to convert to the Love of God compared to the ones that I know. They don’t want me to even mention His name or acknowledge His goodness and how he has revealed Himself to us first in creation. I won’t go any further than that because acknowledging God as “creator” of the universe is a hard enough concept for unbelievers to accept and bringing Jesus into the conversation and how God revealed Himself in Jesus completely and fully is too much for their minds and hearts to comprehend. Understanding of God is a process - I guess just pray that they come to know Him in this lifetime! Amen. Peace.
 
Atheists don’t see human life as “no more precious than a stone’s life.”

.
Precious in the sense of a rose, in that they don’t last long. If in the end our lives come to the same end as a rock, I see little difference, nor can I see how any rational person could.

I have one atheist friend who at least accords humans with the status of animals. I guess that’s something, and I imagine all atheists do the same. But since atheists deny the spiritual realm, they can’t accord human beings anything more.
 
Your anecdotal experiences aside, there are different definitions for atheism and nihilism for a reason. Atheists don’t see human life as “no more precious than a stone’s life.”
Why?

God Bless

Thank you for reading
Josh
 
I’m actually okay with the OP’s story. As a redoubtable thinker once said, “the answer to free speech that you don’t happen to like is … MORE SPEECH.” It’s certainly an improvement over the proscription of religious expression.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top