Bart Stupak Cashes In

  • Thread starter Thread starter 1holycatholic
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
make sure you get this: no single political party that is a “Catholic Party”
But the Republican party platform (and the thinking of most of its members) is much closer to the teachings of the Catholic Church on the sanctity of life than the Democrat party. That is the reality and no amount of mental gymnastics can change that.

Ishii
 
As someone once said, the Democrats do the damage and the Republicans come in to make sure nobody can fix it. I don’t trust either party as a whole. There may be a few decent candidates here and there, but for the most part it seems that even ones that campaign on moral grounds that are very similar to what the Church teaches they pretty much forget about that entirely once in office.
👍
 
As someone once said, the Democrats do the damage and the Republicans come in to make sure nobody can fix it. I don’t trust either party as a whole. There may be a few decent candidates here and there, but for the most part it seems that even ones that campaign on moral grounds that are very similar to what the Church teaches they pretty much forget about that entirely once in office.
All the more reason to demand transparency and accountability. Politicians owe the voters - NOT the lobbyists.
 
Your characterization of the Catholic priniciple of subsidiarity as “right-wing” merely shows how ignorant you are of the subject. I would recommend reading Pope John Paul 2’s encyclical, “Centesimus Annus” for an example of the principle of subsidiarity as it relates to the modern welfare state. Here is a link with some commentary:

acton.org/pub/religion-liberty/volume-6-number-4/principle-subsidiarity

This, of course, assumes you want to go beyond the superficial name calling and actually have a serious discussion.

Ishii
Thanks for the link 🙂
 
The problem with your thinking is that it doesn’t take into account the history of the behavior of these so-called “pro-life Democrats”. When push comes to shove, they often cave in to the pro-abort leadership like Nancy Pelosi, Obama, et al. The other point to make is that to vote for a so-called “pro-life” Democrat congressman or senator, is to empower the pro-abortion rights leadership of the Democrat party. Let me give you an example: If you vote for a so-called “pro-life” Democrat senator and that gives the Democrats the majority, then the net effect is to strengthen the political hand of the pro-abortion rights lobby. That is the political reality that I think you are failing to understand when you sing the virtues of voting for these supposed “pro-life” Democrats. A vote for the “pro-life” Democrat may make some very happy and self-safisfied at not having voted for the evil Republicans, but all they’ve done is strengthen Nancy Pelosi and Barbara Boxer. Do you want the pro-infanticide rights senator Boxer to be in the minority or majority?
Prepare for the Cirque du Soleil of mental gymnastics that attempts to divorce the individual candidate from the party. 😉
Your characterization of the Catholic priniciple of subsidiarity as “right-wing” merely shows how ignorant you are of the subject. I would recommend reading Pope John Paul 2’s encyclical, “Centesimus Annus” for an example of the principle of subsidiarity as it relates to the modern welfare state. Here is a link with some commentary:

acton.org/pub/religion-liberty/volume-6-number-4/principle-subsidiarity

This, of course, assumes you want to go beyond the superficial name calling and actually have a serious discussion.

Ishii
:yup:
It’s amazing how many know that the Church has social justice teaching, and even though they don’t know its basic tenets they claim their political party’s positions are in compliance with it.
 
It is only with great regret that I vote for someone like McCain who supports abortions in cases of rape and incest but do so knowing that his opponents views were far more egregious.
I guess this is a classic case of choosing the lesser of the two evils.
 
Doesn’t really answer my question. As St,TommyMore said, we vote for candidates, not for parties. If a Democrat is truly pro-life, then what? One still cannot vote for him, because a certain plank of the party to which he belongs goes against Church teaching, even though he rejects that plank? As far as I’m concerned, pro-life is pro-life, whether one’s a D or an R, and if you think abortion it’s so central to the Democratic party platform that a real Democrat can’t be pro-life (in spite of empirical evidence), well then I guess you could say pro-life Democrats just aren’t real Democrats, but then that’s for the other Democrats to decide.

And subsidiarity? So what, now one also has to adhere to right wing positions on devolution and dimembering the federal government to be a real Catholic? Tell me, is it against Church teaching to oppose the abolition of public education too?
You are correct-we vote for the canidate not the Party. But as we saw with Stupak one must be very careful when voting for a pro-life Democrat in that history shown they will put party before life when asked to by their leadership.
 
But the Republican party platform (and the thinking of most of its members) is much closer to the teachings of the Catholic Church on the sanctity of life than the Democrat party. That is the reality and no amount of mental gymnastics can change that.

Ishii
The Republican Party is closer on ONE ISSUE. If it would so happen that the Abortion issues would be resolved, the Republic Party would be a pretty hard sell as to being “More in line with Catholic teaching”
 
I have a hard time believing anyone who uses the “prudential judgment” argument has ever worked in a homeless shelter before. All those people are poor, starving, and freezing to death without clothes because they forsook “prudential judgment?”
Which is totally irrelevant to a discussion about whether a Catholic can vote for pro-abortion politicians. It is not those of us in the pro-life ministry who advanced the Prudential judgment argument. It was the Church . We are required to care for the poor and both political parties believe it should be done. The problem is is when those who profess to be pro-life but support pro-abortion politicians claim that not only is the Democrat approach to serving the poor superior to that of the Republicans but that it is so superior it allows them to support abortion. The church categorically rejects that
That seems to be how some people think. Doesn’t matter what the GOP does, as long as they’re not as bad as those baby-killing Democrats. By that logic, we should throw parades for Josef Stalin and celebrate all the massacres and forced famines he ordered, merely because the guy he was fighting against happened to be worse.
It would seem to be a no-brainer to realize that all right rights flow from the right to life. Peace and prosperity for all do little for those who were killed in the womb. I will have to admit that in my 35 years of working in the pro-life ministry this is the first time I’ve been compared to Joseph Stalin but then when dealing with those trying to defend the indefensible one runs into all sorts of strange analogies
 
The Republican Party is closer on ONE ISSUE. If it would so happen that the Abortion issues would be resolved, the Republic Party would be a pretty hard sell as to being “More in line with Catholic teaching”
Well hopefully someday the Democrats will embrace life and we can find out whether your theory is correct . Meanwhile those of us committed to the pro-life ministry and those of us committed to following the teachings of the church will have to stick with the party that has been the forefront of helping us achieve our goals.

I always get a little amused at the way these threads digress. We quickly move into the Republicans are evil personified and other than the fact they support the slaughter of 1.2 million children a year the Democrats sit at the right hand of God. The truth is both parties have tenable ideas and offer varying solutions to the country’s problems. However the Democrats embracing of abortion and homosexuality(for example) make supporting them untenable for Catholics. It is true that the occasional Democrat comes along who is pro-life and support the Churchs view on homosexuality and of course a Catholic could vote for them but given his parties allegiance to the culture of death he will have little influence.
 
The Republican Party is closer on ONE ISSUE. If it would so happen that the Abortion issues would be resolved, the Republic Party would be a pretty hard sell as to being “More in line with Catholic teaching”
That one issue trumps everything else. No other issue is proportionate to abortion.


Abortion Is the Black Hole of Moral IssuesExplaining Ratzinger’s “Proportionate Reasons”


Most Democratic party positions are in direct conflict with Church teaching:

  1. *]Abortion - Democratic FAIL
    *]Euthanasia - Democratic FAIL
    *]Fetal Stem Cell Research - Democratic FAIL
    *]Human Cloning - Democratic FAIL
    *]Homosexual “Marriage” - Democratic FAIL

    The Democratic party is permeated with a blatant disregard for the Catholic principle of subsidiarity in every aspect of every position they hold.
 
:yup:
It’s amazing how many know that the Church has social justice teaching, and even though they don’t know its basic tenets they claim their political party’s positions are in compliance with it.
I know. When you mentioned the word subsidiarity to them they had no idea what you’re talking about.
 
The Republican Party is closer on ONE ISSUE. If it would so happen that the Abortion issues would be resolved, the Republic Party would be a pretty hard sell as to being “More in line with Catholic teaching”
Which is why I don’t believe the Republican party has a vested interest in actually ending abortion. They’ll nibble at the edges so people can throw that in our faces and say, “see, the Republicans REALLY are pro-life.”

Um…yeah. :rolleyes:

I still don’t see how it is advantageous to the Republican Party to actually end abortion. Without the abortion issue to flog, there’s little to no reason for a Christian to ever vote Republican unless they are wealthy or have been bitten the lottery mentality bug (one day I’ll be rich).

Then, of course, people will come along and engage in a bit of slander by saying, "you disagree with the :bowdown2: One, True, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Party :bowdown2:? How DARE YOU!? You must, therefore, be voting for “pro-abortion democrat candidates.”

Um…no. :rolleyes:

I can’t vote for EITHER. The evil of the pro-choice-on-abortion plank precludes me from voting Democratic AND the evils in the positions of the Republican party precludes me from voting Republican. As a result, I have been leaving a lot of blank spaces on my ballot and concentrate on the Props. Truth is, I’m politically homeless. 🤷
 
That one issue trumps everything else. No other issue is proportionate to abortion.

Explaining Ratzinger’s “Proportionate Reasons”
Abortion Is the Black Hole of Moral Issues

Most Democratic party positions are in direct conflict with Church teaching:

  1. *]Abortion - Democratic FAIL
    *]Euthanasia - Democratic FAIL
    *]Fetal Stem Cell Research - Democratic FAIL
    *]Human Cloning - Democratic FAIL
    *]Homosexual “Marriage” - Democratic FAIL

    The Democratic party is permeated with a blatant disregard for the Catholic principle of subsidiarity in every aspect of every position they hold.

  1. Four of the five are life issues. I think I have already addressed that. The fifth is something that has no bearing on elections, because the electorate is opposed, and SCOTUS is loathe to decide against the electorate. What about war? Republicans tend to like wars. It is a right of workers to organize into unions Something else the Republicans are opposed to, You cannot serve God and mammon. A democrat who is truly pro-life is a superior candidate to a pro-life Republican. YOu need to get beyond party labels. Vote for the person.
 
Well hopefully someday the Democrats will embrace life and we can find out whether your theory is correct . Meanwhile those of us committed to the pro-life ministry and those of us committed to following the teachings of the church will have to stick with the party that has been the forefront of helping us achieve our goals.

I always get a little amused at the way these threads digress. We quickly move into the Republicans are evil personified and other than the fact they support the slaughter of 1.2 million children a year the Democrats sit at the right hand of God. The truth is both parties have tenable ideas and offer varying solutions to the country’s problems. However the Democrats embracing of abortion and homosexuality(for example) make supporting them untenable for Catholics. It is true that the occasional Democrat comes along who is pro-life and support the Churchs view on homosexuality and of course a Catholic could vote for them but given his parties allegiance to the culture of death he will have little influence.
Before Roe v. Wade, the Democratic Paty was the home of the majority of Catholics because of the moral bankruptcy of the Republican party, which has historically been motivated by promoting big business.

“The business of America is business”–Herbert Hoover (Republican)
 
Four of the five are life issues. I think I have already addressed that. The fifth is something that has no bearing on elections, because the electorate is opposed, and SCOTUS is loathe to decide against the electorate. What about war? Republicans tend to like wars. It is a right of workers to organize into unions Something else the Republicans are opposed to, You cannot serve God and mammon. A democrat who is truly pro-life is a superior candidate to a pro-life Republican. YOu need to get beyond party labels. Vote for the person.
What about war? Let’s let the Pope address that:

While the Church exhorts civil authorities to seek peace, not war, and to exercise discretion and mercy in imposing punishment on criminals, it may still be permissible to take up arms to repel an aggressor or to have recourse to capital punishment. There may be a legitimate diversity of opinion even among Catholics about waging war and applying the death penalty, but not however with regard to abortion and euthanasia.

Having disposed of that can you show us where the Republican Party opposes the right of workers to form unions? I believe you will find that not only does the Republican Party support the right of workers enjoy the union they also support the right of workers not to join a union -something the Democrat party refuses to do .

Whether a pro-life Democrat is superior pro-life Republican is debatable however it is a theory very hard to test as there are so few of them

…
 
Before Roe v. Wade, the Democratic Paty was the home of the majority of Catholics because of the moral bankruptcy of the Republican party, which has historically been motivated by promoting big business.

“The business of America is business”–Herbert Hoover (Republican)
In your opinion. But there is absolutely nothing in church teaching that supports that. In fact for the hundred years prior to the civil rights movement it was the Democrat party that enforced brutal segregation upon blacks. And lest you try to contend that they have made up for by their treatment of blacks now keep in mind that their policies aid abette the killing of 400,000 black children year and their only regret about this is that the taxpayers are not forced to pay for it.

So let’s review. From 1865 through 1965 the Democrats enforced segregation of blacks, hardly the actions of that party that is in line with Catholic teaching. From 1973 to today they have embraced Roe V Wade and the culture of death-again hardly in line with Catholic teaching. So are you trying to make the case that for a grand total of eight years the Democratic Party was more in line with Catholic teaching than anyone else? Appears you are damning them with faint praise even if your supposition is correct
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top