Biblical Reference to the Rapture

  • Thread starter Thread starter PatienceAndLove
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
You fail to understand the Scriptures. These are not part of the church. They’re Jews who believe in Christ during the great Tribulation.
Rev. 12: 15-17 says nothing about Jews. It is talking about a very specific family of people, clearly identified as those who keep the commandments of God and bear testimony to Jesus. The “woman” in these verses has three meanings. Maybe more. If you claim the right to assert there is only one meaning for “woman”, then I assert my right to include yours plus two of mine.

Rev 12:15 The serpent poured water like a river out of his mouth after the woman, to sweep her away with the flood. 16 But the earth came to the help of the woman, and the earth opened its mouth and swallowed the river which the dragon had poured from his mouth. 17 Then the dragon was angry with the woman, and went off to make war ON THE REST OF HER OFFSPRING, on those who keep the commandments of God and bear testimony to Jesus. And he stood on the sand of the sea.
 
The objections to the obvious Marian interpretation of Revelation 12 are surprisingly weak. The Woman Clothed with the Sun is called the mother of the man-child who will rule all nations with a rod of iron. And since this man-child (from the reference to Psalm 2:9) is Jesus, His mother is obviously Mary.

Fundamentalists have tried to avoid this obvious scriptural teaching by abandoning their usual literalism and resorting to allegory. They have interpreted the Woman to be Nation Israel or the Christian Church - anyone but Mary. The allegorical interpretations do not work simply because
(a) you cannot consistently interpret the “son” to be an individual while preferring a collective interpretation for the mother
(b) the church does not give birth to Christ but originates from Christ and so it cannot be His mother
(c) since the Woman is the mother of all Christians it cannot be the Jewish synagogue which is considered in Revelation as hostile to all Christians
(d) in terms of usage, there is no instance in the Old Testament where Nation Israel is designated the collective mother of the Messiah; similarly, the Church is called the Spouse of Christ and the “Mother of the faithful” but never the Mother of Christ.

To be sure, in addition to signifying Mary, the Woman could, at a secondary level, also exemplify the Church. Double and triple signification is not uncommon in Scripture (take for example the healing of the paralytic in John 5:2-9 which also carries a symbolic message of Israel in the wilderness for thirty eight years, the five books of the Law and the spiritual healing of baptism).
mariology.com/book-mainmenu-28/12-1-introduction
 
The “woman” in these verses has three meanings. Maybe more. If you claim the right to assert there is only one meaning for “woman”, then I assert my right to include yours plus two of mine.
You may “assert” all you want, but you’re still wrong. The woman is national Israel and her “children” are Jewish believers during the great Tribulation period. The church Christ is presently building will have already been taken up prior to those events: “Come up here and I will show you what must take place AFTER these things.” You have no defense, only disbelief based on a faulty eschatological construct.
 
The objections to the obvious Marian interpretation of Revelation 12 are surprisingly weak. The Woman Clothed with the Sun is called the mother of the man-child who will rule all nations with a rod of iron. And since this man-child (from the reference to Psalm 2:9) is Jesus, His mother is obviously Mary.It’s not obvious at all, since the woman is not described literally but figuratively in verse one. So she represents something. Now what could that be??? :hmmm: …a crown with twelve stars…the twelve tribes of Israel. ISRAEL! Oh yearh: ISRAEL :doh2:

And it’s the male child she gives birth to that is caught up to God and to His throne. It says she gives birth to the male child, not “conceives.” A nation is often figuratively said to give birth to some famous person. Like Germany gave birth to Luther. The woman herself remains on earth, and the events that surround her and her children in that “sign” are all earthly events. Stands to reason since ISRAEL is an earthly nation. Oh my oh my. So simple you stumble over it. .
 
It’s not obvious at all, since the woman is not described literally but figuratively in verse one. So she represents something. Now what could that be??? :hmmm: …a crown with twelve stars…the twelve tribes of Israel. ISRAEL! Oh yearh: ISRAEL :doh2:

And it’s the male child she gives birth to that is caught up to God and to His throne. It says she gives birth to the male child, not “conceives.” A nation is often figuratively said to give birth to some famous person. Like Germany gave birth to Luther. The woman herself remains on earth, and the events that surround her and her children in that “sign” are all earthly events. Stands to reason since ISRAEL is an earthly nation. Oh my oh my. So simple you stumble over it. .
Your post is rather sarcastic, and yet pretentious at the same time!
Unfortunately, it is also rather weak on evidence. 😊
If she is the figure of something, then she represents a something.
Mother of Israel. Mother of all living created, and Mother of Jesus Uncreated.
 
Either, or both, depending on the context.

Jesus is the Word of God.

The Bible is the Word of God.

Again, depends on the context of how one is using that phrase.
Jesus is the living and complete Word of God (John 1). The Bible is not Jesus. However, because the Holy Spirit speaks through the words of the human authors, the Church declared the Bible to be the written Word of God; a portion or offshoot of the living Word. The Bible never calls itself the Word of God and this is important to remember when you get jumped by a fundamentalist who asserts both sola Scriptura and that the Bible is the Word of God.
 
It’s not obvious at all, since the woman is not described literally but figuratively in verse one. So she represents something. Now what could that be??? :hmmm: …a crown with twelve stars…the twelve tribes of Israel. ISRAEL! Oh yearh: ISRAEL :doh2: .
Recall that the rapturist version of the end times calls for a holocaust that will supposedly result in the death of two thirds of the Jews. Notice that the Woman escapes from the enemy untouched.
 
Recall that the rapturist version of the end times calls for a holocaust that will supposedly result in the death of two thirds of the Jews. Notice that the Woman escapes from the enemy untouched.
What you’re saying is that if the Woman in Revelation is Israel, then why do the rapturists say that there are many Jews that die? Right?
Whereas if the Woman in Revelation is Mary, who is untouched (by sin), and who gives birth to the man-child with the rod of iron (who can be interpreted to be Jesus), it makes sense.
 
What you’re saying is that if the Woman in Revelation is Israel, then why do the rapturists say that there are many Jews that die? Right?
Whereas if the Woman in Revelation is Mary, who is untouched (by sin), and who gives birth to the man-child with the rod of iron (who can be interpreted to be Jesus), it makes sense.
Affirmative. 😉
 
Recall that the rapturist version of the end times calls for a holocaust that will supposedly result in the death of two thirds of the Jews. Notice that the Woman escapes from the enemy untouched.
It’s the “remnant” that gets ushered into the Millennium and is called “ISRAEL.” It’s that “remnant” that Paul refers to in Rom. 11:26 where he says “…and thus all Israel will be saved.”

But Zech. 13:8 only states that two parts of it will be cut off and perish. And a third will be left in it and refined and tested by the Lord. It doesn’t exactly say the two thirds died in the Tribulation. But Ezekiel tells of the time of judgment that the Lord (as their King) will enter into with Israel after the Tribulation (Eze. 20:33-38). A time when the rebels and transgressors will be purged.

You don’t know O.T. prophecy, Cat. Nor can you as an Amillennialist. You must dismiss those prophecies.
 
Your post is rather sarcastic, and yet pretentious at the same time!
Unfortunately, it is also rather weak on evidence. 😊
If she is the figure of something, then she represents a something.
Mother of Israel. Mother of all living created, and Mother of Jesus Uncreated.
You get all this from Rev. 12:1? 😃
 
It’s the “remnant” that gets ushered into the Millennium and is called “ISRAEL.” It’s that “remnant” that Paul refers to in Rom. 11:26 where he says “…and thus all Israel will be saved.”
So when Paul says “all” he doesn’t really mean all.[ Interesting.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/0/0b/Imaculada_-Murillo.jpg/310px-Imaculada-_Murillo.jpg](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immaculate Conception)
You don’t know O.T. prophecy, Cat. Nor can you as an Amillennialist. You must dismiss those prophecies.
Neither. Jesus Christ has fulfilled them.
 
Yes, it is quite interesting, isn’t it?
I guess I have to spell it out: if you redefine “all” to mean “some” (“some” ethnic Israel will be saved), then “all have sinned” means “some have sinned” and you have lost your argument against the Immaculate Conception and your case for taking Mary out of Revelation 12 is sunk accordingly.
 
You may “assert” all you want, but you’re still wrong. The woman is national Israel and her “children” are Jewish believers during the great Tribulation period. The church Christ is presently building will have already been taken up prior to those events: “Come up here and I will show you what must take place AFTER these things.” You have no defense, only disbelief based on a faulty eschatological construct.
(a) you cannot consistently interpret the “son” to be an individual while preferring a collective interpretation for the mother
(b) the church does not give birth to Christ but originates from Christ and so it cannot be His mother
(c) since the Woman is the mother of all Christians it cannot be the Jewish synagogue which is considered in Revelation as hostile to all Christians
(d) in terms of usage, there is no instance in the Old Testament where Nation Israel is designated the collective mother of the Messiah; similarly, the Church is called the Spouse of Christ and the “Mother of the faithful” but never the Mother of Christ.

Moondweller, you have demonstrated an inability to support your assertion, which is clearly a faulty eschatological construct. (c) and (d) demolishes your assertion.

There is no battle between Scripture and Marian doctrine. The battle is between competing interpretations of Scripture as it relates to Mary. On the one side we have the 20th century Protestant Fundamentalists who have dispensed with many essential elements of the historic Christian Faith and who have themselves split into over twenty thousand sects that differ on fundamental interpretations of Scripture on various issues.

On the other side we have the consistent interpretation of Scripture held for 20 centuries from the time of the New Testament Church. This interpretation, the early Church Fathers taught, was the interpretation of the divinely inspired New Testament writers themselves and this was the interpretation that was ratified by Church Councils and Creeds and accepted even by the Protestant Reformers. (rejected by you)

“This is the Faith of the Fathers that has been held from the beginning and that continues to be affirmed today by Christians of many different denominations. The one century-old Fundamentalist interpretations of Scripture deny Marian doctrine and devotion - and in many cases even Christological and Trinitarian doctrine. Twenty centuries of the historic Christian Faith, however, affirm the fundamental Marian doctrines as essential and true. If a Fundamentalist were to read the writings of the ancient Church Fathers, both East and West, he will be shocked to see that every one of them writes of Mary with the highest reverence, showering her with affectionate praise. These are the men who helped establish the canon of Scripture and gave us the great doctrines of Christendom.”
mariology.com/book-mainmenu-28/13-2-misconceptions-about-mary

The Church Fathers can never be trumped by your assertions based on opinions that are less than 100 years old.
 
40.png
kepha1:
Moondweller, you have demonstrated an inability to support your assertion, which is clearly a faulty eschatological construct. (c) and (d) demolishes your assertion.
Oh but I did adequately support my interpretation without making any “assertions.” Just because you disagree doesn’t mean I didn’t support it. The text and context back me up.
(a) you cannot consistently interpret the “son” to be an individual while preferring a collective interpretation for the mother
Sure you can, when the “woman” is already presented figuratively in verse one.
(b) the church does not give birth to Christ but originates from Christ and so it cannot be His mother
I didn’t say the woman was the church.
(c) since the Woman is the mother of all Christians it cannot be the Jewish synagogue which is considered in Revelation as hostile to all Christians
I never said the woman is a Jewish synagogue. Not all “Christians” (i.e., believers in Christ) are part of the church Christ is presently building.
(d) in terms of usage, there is no instance in the Old Testament where Nation Israel is designated the collective mother of the Messiah; similarly, the Church is called the Spouse of Christ and the “Mother of the faithful” but never the Mother of Christ.
“Collective mother?” Strange terminology. However, Christ Himself stated: “…salvation is from the Jews,” and Israel was a Jewish nation at the time of Christ’s first advent, and will still be a Jewish nation at His second. Even though Satan is determined to destroy her in order to prevent Christ’s return as “King of kings and Lord of lords” (Rev. 19:11-16). When He will bind him for 1000 years and reign over the house of Jacob (“Israel,” Lk. 1:32-33) as well as this entire earth (Zech. 14; esp. v. 9). At that time Jesus will ascend His father David’s throne in Jerusalem, just as the angel Gabriel told Mary at the Annunciation. It will happen. Though Satan, and even many Christians, will it not to happen.

Rev. 12 is about Satan’s attempt to destroy that people and nation in the latter days to prevent Christ from reigning as rightful King over His promised Kingdom. It’s not at all about Mary or the church. Mary will have been resurrected and raptured (caught up) with the church prior to the Tribulation events prophesied in that chapter.
The Church Fathers can never be trumped by your assertions based on opinions that are less than 100 years old.
Scripture always trumps the opinions and writings of men. Historically, the church was predominately Pre-mill. for the first 400 years. In fact, those who were not were considered heretics. That means the predominate view was that Christ would return to set up a literal, political, kingdom on earth. Your Amillennialism is a later development - based not on the prophetic Scriptures but instead ignoring them, even by spiritualizing them.
 
Cat Herder:
I guess I have to spell it out: if you redefine “all” to mean “some” (“some” ethnic Israel will be saved), then “all have sinned” means “some have sinned”
When Paul said that “all Israel will be saved.” he meant that nationally. He didn’t say all Jews will be saved. The Jewish nation that will be ushered into the earthly, Millennial reign of Christ will be a “saved,” Jewish nation. All Jews who make up that nation will be “saved.” Hence, ALL Israel will be “saved.”
and you have lost your argument against the Immaculate Conception and your case for taking Mary out of Revelation 12 is sunk accordingly.
See my above post to kepha1.
 
Historically, the church was predominately Pre-mill. for the first 400 years. In fact, those who were not were considered heretics. That means the predominate view was that Christ would return to set up a literal, political, kingdom on earth. Your Amillennialism is a later development - based not on the prophetic Scriptures but instead ignoring them, even by spiritualizing them.
As you are making claims that are not based anywhere within scripture, please provide documentation to back this claim.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top