Yes it is.
Observational is repeatable, historical is not.
No mainstream scientist makes this distinction, and as far as I know, it’s not accepted in any scientific literature.
Seriously, where in any peer-reviewed scientific publication is this distinction accepted?
Ham - or people who share his views, at least - basically made it up as code for, “You can’t say my position has been debunked, because you weren’t there to personally observe the Earth thousands of years ago!”
But as Nye demonstrated in the debate, that assertion isn’t really true: we
can know, through evidence we can observe today, what transpired in the past.
Why are some of us so resistant to evolutionary theory? It should by now be utterly uncontroversial - theologically, scientifically, and philosophically.
Only the ideology of misguided, haphazard Biblical literalism leads anyone to suggest otherwise.
Nye rejects Supernaturalism, rejects God, and rejects the Bible no matter the interpretation, he says some of this outright in the debate, and has said it prior to the debate.
His personal views aside, the position he adopts - as expressed quite clearly and repeatedly in the debate - is this: that religious beliefs, including ours, are perfectly compatible with science, including evolution.
So even according to Nye, evolution is not intrinsically a rejection of what you refer to as supernaturalism. We have nothing to fear from the findings of reputable science today.
It’s one thing to say it, another to actually offer that respect. He didn’t appear to me to be very respectful of Kentucky, or Kentuckians in general during the debate, YMMV.
I thought both Nye and Ham were very respectful during the debate. But people see what they want to see, I guess.
If Homo Sapiens have been around for 200,000 years, why does written human history disappear post 5000 years? That means it took Homo Sapiens 195,000 to learn to write anything down?
Only in the biological sense are homo sapiens 200,000 years old. The species did not achieve full behavioral modernity until around 50,000 years ago.
I submit only empirical science in the science classroom. Students should take a mandatory philosophy class. Agree?
Hear. hear!
And evolutionary theory
is empirical science.
If they were around for 200,000 years and it took them 195,000 years to write anything down about their life, their ancestors, their conquests etc. then they were not humans like we are humans or they were not around that long. Humans, as a whole, are informational. Nothing happened in 195,000 years that was not worth remembering and passing down to future generations?
As I said, homo sapiens reached full behavioral modernity only 50,000 years ago (roughly). So no, no “human history” or civilization for 150,000 years.
Beyond that point, we
do have evidence of culture, like the 25,000-year-old Venus of Willendorf. But yes, writing came later.