Bill Nye vs. Ken Ham

  • Thread starter Thread starter Zachary
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
  1. I’m not saying it can be. You’re saying it cannot. Can you support your claim or are you going to rely on the negative argument?
  2. Right there is the rub. Induction cannot prove anything. Induction can only offer evidence of. There is a whole lot of evidence for gravity, I grant you. But the theory of gravity isn’t PROVEN. Any scientist who is honest and passionate about their craft will admit that.
  3. Where does Newton write this? Is it in De Grav? The Principia? When someone drops a ball and they interprete the data, they are working with historical observations, observations of some event in that occurred in the past. The frame of history is just very, very small. Coming across a fossil, or a dead body, or burnt-out home is treated in the same way - the frame of history is just larger.
  1. Right, gravity is not proven, but its effects as we know them are reliable.
  2. Principia - “Though these bodies may, indeed, persevere in their orbits by the mere laws of gravity, yet they could by no means have, at first, derived the regular position of the orbits themselves from those laws…. [Thus] this most beautiful system of the sun, planets, and comets could only proceed from the counsel and dominion of an intelligent and powerful being.” Newton, General Scholium, Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy (1969).
So was Newton doing science?
 
Ok, mistake number one here: evolving doesn’t mean “improving” or “getting better”. It means only “changing”. Increasing complexity, decreasing complexity, whatever makes a species better suited to its environment over time.
No one would disagree with evolution as being change. It is most obvious in the adaptability of life.

:hmmm:So our devolution is better preparing us for the future?
 
No one would disagree with evolution as being change. It is most obvious in the adaptability of life.

:hmmm:So our devolution is better preparing us for the future?
Sigh, what is “devolution”? I’m saying quite obviously that this term has no scientific meaning. It is not science, but a value judgment you’re making in using that term.
 
Yes, but when you say the world is “intelligible” that means it’s able to be understood, and the only way this is possible is if the physical laws under which it operates are constant and reliable. Changing laws mean total chaos and irrationality, there would be nothing to BE understood.

Solipsism as a viewpoint entails that, since only my mind exists, the only reliable knowledge I can have would be that which I directly experience. This is the very dark heart and core of what is going on when the creationist yells “but you weren’t there!!”

I’m reiterating it again because it’s so obviously irrefutably true: the crux of Ham’s argument about “historical science” is, essentially, solipsism. Under his view I have no reason to think the Sun will rise tomorrow, the laws of the universe are NOT RELIABLE and so cannot give us any knowledge about the past or the future. It is on its face irrational thinking.
paragraph 1 - we agree

2 - Where do we get the origins info if we were not there?
  1. I didn’t get it that way - I got from Ham is there are two modes. The observational and the historical study. I believe the danger is modern education has conflated the two. They are extrapolating today as a key to the past. The base assumption is that everything operated the same in the past as today. That cannot be proven. It can lead to dangerous conclusions. Nye didn’t touch the word uniformatarian because we now know catastrophies (one time events) played a part in the past.
Now, we as Catholics have been given some clues through Revelation. In other words we were told. That has to count for something.

Note: I am not a Ham fan, but I see what he was getting at.

We can reliably assume the sun will shine tomorrow two ways. God told us He would provide. Or that the laws of physics tells us. But then we get back to: who is upholding those laws?
 
Actually, Nye’s assertion is correct. Even Creation-believing scientists do not use the existence of a supernatural entity as the basis of any of the scientific work they do. If they did, they’d never produce anything.
That’s just because narrow-minded academia members and educrats can’t have any scientific debate to burst their little bubbles and because religion and science are separate in the Dewey Decimal System for good reason.
I would encourage everyone to research their so-called predictions. They are demonstrably false.
:rotfl:

To borrow one of your quotes: “that’s a cop-out!”

They cannot be “demonstrably false” even if they are because the only way to fit that rigid criteria you’ve insinuated is to measure changes over evolutionary time, which is millions of years.

Patience is a virtue. 👍
 
Sigh, what is “devolution”? I’m saying quite obviously that this term has no scientific meaning. It is not science, but a value judgment you’re making in using that term.
de·vo·lu·tion

Full Definition of DEVOLUTION


2
: retrograde evolution : degeneration
 
  1. Right, gravity is not proven, but its effects as we know them are reliable.
  2. Principia - “Though these bodies may, indeed, persevere in their orbits by the mere laws of gravity, yet they could by no means have, at first, derived the regular position of the orbits themselves from those laws…. [Thus] this most beautiful system of the sun, planets, and comets could only proceed from the counsel and dominion of an intelligent and powerful being.” Newton, General Scholium, Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy (1969).
So was Newton doing science?
Newton was using his knowledge, abilities and sensibilities to cash out cosmogony. Today we have evidence and inferences that in fact explain how solar systems can come to be without resorting to the supernatural. Under the current paradigm, though, no that claim Newton made was unscientific. I would be hard pressed to say any paradigm should properly call it scientific.
 
If anything good can come of this debate it will be to ensure creation stays out of the science class. There is currently a campaign in the UK to get Creation banned from science classes.
Well, before the excitement and celebration get going, note the following:
  1. There’s plenty of pastors in the West who don’t want the public education system teaching Creationism in science class. :yup:
  2. Run this by Muslim communities over there and see if what happens. 🙂
 
Yes it is.

Observational is repeatable, historical is not.
No mainstream scientist makes this distinction, and as far as I know, it’s not accepted in any scientific literature.

I’m not a scientist, though; I suspect you’re not, either. Humility and good sense d
 
And that is Hams claim that “science has been hijacked by secularists”.
What? How can science demonstrate a creator? It cannot. Neither can it disprove one. How can one observe a creator? Test a creator? Potentially falsify a creator? How do we get from a faux distinction from “observational science” to “historical science” to this? One thing at a time, please.
 
That’s just because narrow-minded academia members and educrats can’t have any scientific debate to burst their little bubbles and because religion and science are separate in the Dewey Decimal System for good reason.
It is not possible to have a scientific debate about unfalsifiable philosophical/religious concepts because it isn’t science. Has nothing to do with bubble bursting.
They cannot be “demonstrably false” even if they are because the only way to fit that rigid criteria you’ve insinuated is to measure changes over evolutionary time, which is millions of years.
Um, that “rigid criteria” is called science so I’m sure where you’re going with this.
 
What? How can science demonstrate a creator? It cannot. Neither can it disprove one. How can one observe a creator? Test a creator? Potentially falsify a creator? How do we get from a faux distinction from “observational science” to “historical science” to this? One thing at a time, please.
As you correctly note under today’s paradigm a divine foot cannot be let in the door. Today’s science then, by excluding the possibility of the supernatural, has painted itself in a corner. In the past design was part and parcel of science. **Science is a discovery of truth, but yet it limits itself by its own definition to excluding truth itself. **

Reason can lead us to a creator. Philosophy can get us to God, theology gets us to who He is.

34 The world, and man, attest that they contain within themselves neither their first principle nor their final end, but rather that they participate in Being itself, which alone is without origin or end. Thus, in different ways, man can come to know that there exists a reality which is the first cause and final end of all things, a reality “that everyone calls God”.10
35 Man’s faculties make him capable of coming to a knowledge of the existence of a personal God. But for man to be able to enter into real intimacy with him, God willed both to reveal himself to man and to give him the grace of being able to welcome this revelation in faith. The proofs of God’s existence, however, can predispose one to faith and help one to see that faith is not opposed to reason

159 Faith and science: "Though faith is above reason, there can never be any real discrepancy between faith and reason. Since the same God who reveals mysteries and infuses faith has bestowed the light of reason on the human mind, God cannot deny himself, nor can truth ever contradict truth."37 "Consequently, methodical research in all branches of knowledge, provided it is carried out in a truly scientific manner and does not override moral laws, can never conflict with the faith, because the things of the world and the things of faith derive from the same God. The humble and persevering investigator of the secrets of nature is being led, as it were, by the hand of God in spite of himself, for it is God, the conserver of all things, who made them what they are."38
 
As you correctly note under today’s paradigm a divine foot cannot be let in the door. Today’s science then, by excluding the possibility of the supernatural, has painted itself in a corner. In the past design was part and parcel of science.
Sure, back when people thought the Earth was flat, the stars were dangling from a dome which rested on the edges, and it was all held in place by God(s). The fact is that science has not only disproved such mythological whimsy, but gradually provided natural explanations for things which were once thought to be caused or controlled by the supernatural.
 
Sure, back when people thought the Earth was flat, the stars were dangling from a dome which rested on the edges, and it was all held in place by God(s). The fact is that science has not only disproved such mythological whimsy, but gradually provided natural explanations for things which were once thought to be caused or controlled by the supernatural.

The Myth of the Flat Earth


You are correct, science has disproved the pagan gods.
 
Yes it is.

Observational is repeatable, historical is not.
No mainstream scientist makes this distinction, and as far as I know, it’s not accepted in any scientific literature.

Seriously, where in any peer-reviewed scientific publication is this distinction accepted?

Ham - or people who share his views, at least - basically made it up as code for, “You can’t say my position has been debunked, because you weren’t there to personally observe the Earth thousands of years ago!”

But as Nye demonstrated in the debate, that assertion isn’t really true: we can know, through evidence we can observe today, what transpired in the past.

Why are some of us so resistant to evolutionary theory? It should by now be utterly uncontroversial - theologically, scientifically, and philosophically.

Only the ideology of misguided, haphazard Biblical literalism leads anyone to suggest otherwise.
Nye rejects Supernaturalism, rejects God, and rejects the Bible no matter the interpretation, he says some of this outright in the debate, and has said it prior to the debate.
His personal views aside, the position he adopts - as expressed quite clearly and repeatedly in the debate - is this: that religious beliefs, including ours, are perfectly compatible with science, including evolution.

So even according to Nye, evolution is not intrinsically a rejection of what you refer to as supernaturalism. We have nothing to fear from the findings of reputable science today.
It’s one thing to say it, another to actually offer that respect. He didn’t appear to me to be very respectful of Kentucky, or Kentuckians in general during the debate, YMMV.
I thought both Nye and Ham were very respectful during the debate. But people see what they want to see, I guess.
If Homo Sapiens have been around for 200,000 years, why does written human history disappear post 5000 years? That means it took Homo Sapiens 195,000 to learn to write anything down?
Only in the biological sense are homo sapiens 200,000 years old. The species did not achieve full behavioral modernity until around 50,000 years ago.
I submit only empirical science in the science classroom. Students should take a mandatory philosophy class. Agree?
Hear. hear!

And evolutionary theory is empirical science.
If they were around for 200,000 years and it took them 195,000 years to write anything down about their life, their ancestors, their conquests etc. then they were not humans like we are humans or they were not around that long. Humans, as a whole, are informational. Nothing happened in 195,000 years that was not worth remembering and passing down to future generations?
As I said, homo sapiens reached full behavioral modernity only 50,000 years ago (roughly). So no, no “human history” or civilization for 150,000 years.

Beyond that point, we do have evidence of culture, like the 25,000-year-old Venus of Willendorf. But yes, writing came later.
 
**Operation Science **and Historical Science****
Code:
        Yes, historical science **can** produce        reliable conclusions.
    Earlier, I say that scientific        methods "vary from one area of science to          another."  Some variations in methods are due to differences        between operation science (to study the        current operation of nature, what is happening now) and historical          science (to study the previous history of nature, what happened        in the past).  Both types of science are similar in most important        ways, especially in their use of scientific logic, but there are minor        differences.   /   Although some young-earth creationists try to contrast *historical* origins          science with *experimental* empirical            science (i.e., science based on observations), this is wrong because** historical              origins science ***is based on observations* so it   *is empirical.*
    **Although repeatable controlled     experiments can be done in operation science, this is not possible        for historical events.  **Sometimes, the limitations of historical data        provide a reason for caution about conclusions.  But this challenge        has inspired scientists to develop methods that reduce the practical impact        of data limitations, and historical sciences — in fields such as        astronomy, radiometric physics, and geology — are authentically scientific.
    In historical science, one        way to "reduce the practical impact" is to use repeatable uncontrolled          experiments to gather data.  For example, other pages explain        how observations of many Cepheid stars from many parts of the universe        have shown that all Cepheids have similar properties, allowing them (and        supernovas, which have their own consistencies) to be useful for measuring        astronomical distances.  These consistencies let scientists develop        reliable descriptive theories, which can become explanatory          theories that usually are related to (and are consistent with) explanatory        theories in operation science.
 
Why did you send me a link which falsely states that belief in a flat Earth is a myth and goes on about what people thought in the Middle Ages?
There are OT bible verses about a round earth. Anyone who looked can see the horizon is not flat, then and now.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top