Bill Nye vs. Ken Ham

  • Thread starter Thread starter Zachary
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
paragraph 1 - we agree

2 - Where do we get the origins info if we were not there?
  1. I didn’t get it that way - I got from Ham is there are two modes. The observational and the historical study. I believe the danger is modern education has conflated the two. They are extrapolating today as a key to the past. The base assumption is that everything operated the same in the past as today. That cannot be proven. It can lead to dangerous conclusions. Nye didn’t touch the word uniformatarian because we now know catastrophies (one time events) played a part in the past.
Now, we as Catholics have been given some clues through Revelation. In other words we were told. That has to count for something.

Note: I am not a Ham fan, but I see what he was getting at.

We can reliably assume the sun will shine tomorrow two ways. God told us He would provide. Or that the laws of physics tells us. But then we get back to: who is upholding those laws?
What you are saying here IS solipsism, necessarily and undeniably! We get information about the past history of the Earth and life on it from the application of the physical laws and mathematics we know and see working around us in the present. You CAN’T rationally hold that the “laws of physics” as you just said above tell us the Sun will come up tomorrow out of one side of your mouth while saying out the other side that those VERY SAME LAWS are not reliable and constant! I’ll ask again because you’ve not answered and I suspect it’s because you know that the YEC folks cannot answer it: On what basis do you believe now that the laws of nature and physics ARE constant and will be in the future, if you firmly believe that they all somehow completely were different and changed in the past?

In other words: the base assumption as you’ve so accurately said above is that everything operated the same in the past as it does today. This MUST be assumed or you must live with the consequences, to wit, a world of total irrationality and unintelligibility where nothing can be predicted or known reliably about anything at all, including the behavior of matter, the laws of chemistry, of radioactivity, of physics, or anything else. You must live actually believing that even though your combustion engine properly powers your car right at the moment, at any minute in the future it might suddenly explode as the internal chemistry might just change all of a sudden on you. I say again, no one really lives this way except for actual insane people.🤷
 
No mainstream scientist makes this distinction, and as far as I know, it’s not accepted in any scientific literature.

Seriously, where in any peer-reviewed scientific publication is this distinction accepted?

Ham - or people who share his views, at least - basically made it up as code for, “You can’t say my position has been debunked, because you weren’t there to personally observe the Earth thousands of years ago!”

But as Nye demonstrated in the debate, that assertion isn’t really true: we can know, through evidence we can observe today, what transpired in the past.

Why are some of us so resistant to evolutionary theory? It should by now be utterly uncontroversial - theologically, scientifically, and philosophically.

Only the ideology of misguided, haphazard Biblical literalism leads anyone to suggest otherwise.

His personal views aside, the position he adopts - as expressed quite clearly and repeatedly in the debate - is this: that religious beliefs, including ours, are perfectly compatible with science, including evolution.

So even according to Nye, evolution is not intrinsically a rejection of what you refer to as supernaturalism. We have nothing to fear from the findings of reputable science today.

I thought both Nye and Ham were very respectful during the debate. But people see what they want to see, I guess.

Only in the biological sense are homo sapiens 200,000 years old. The species did not achieve full behavioral modernity until around 50,000 years ago.

Hear. hear!

And evolutionary theory is empirical science.

As I said, homo sapiens reached full behavioral modernity only 50,000 years ago (roughly). So no, no “human history” or civilization for 150,000 years.

Beyond that point, we do have evidence of culture, like the 25,000-year-old Venus of Willendorf. But yes, writing came later.
Thank you, well said!👍👍
 
People did of course figure out (though non-Catholics may say ‘decided’) that the literalist interpretation was invalid long before scientific discoveries could be employed to argue against it. St. Augustine’s refutation of literalism came long before Copernicus’s. And generally speaking, people who believed the earth was flat didn’t believe that because religious texts told them so; they believed it because there wasn’t much else to believe. It took more thought and education to deduce that the Earth was round back then than most people had the time or resources to obtain. Religious traditions’ claim that the earth was flat were merely recapitulating general knowledge, not creating it; an as opinion amongst the educated clergy on that matter changed with the available evidence; indeed many of the natural philosophers of the middle ages who were proponents of the round earth theory were clergymen. Many common people continued to believe in the flatness of the earth, but that wasn’t necessarily because they were Christian, but rather because they were common people.
Pythagoras suggested a three-dimensional/spherical Earth 600 years before Jesus was supposedly born (around 600 B.C.E). 300 years later (300 B.C.E) it was regarded as scientific and mathematical fact by the Greeks and other civilizations. Thats some 600 years before Augustine, who seems to have argued more for a flat Earth than against it, was even born. It does not make sense that the flat Earth view experienced a resurgence (and it did), even among educated people, hundreds of years after the preponderance of the civilized world had accepted the Greek model unless biblical literalism is taken into account. It was Biblical literalism which reintroduced the flat Earth view as a valid belief and, yes, many of its proponents were educated Catholics with important roles in the Church and positions of influence in the courts of converted monarchs and emperors.
This does not mean, however, that are declaring all positions on the matter to be equal, but rather that it is not within its scope to make such decrees one way or the other.
It wasn’t shy about doing this in the past so why sit quietly in the wings now? Its shocking to me that Catholics often lament the existence of “Cafeteria Catholics” yet don’t believe that the Church should, in light of scientific discovery, define the meaning of or establish an official and binding position on the very text which justifies its existence. If the very word of God himself, or the inspired word of God, is subject to prudential judgement then its no wonder why there are so many different sects of Christianity.
 
This isn’t an issue of translation. The Jews believed the Earth to be flat and depicted it as such. I think they knew what was meant to be said since they wrote it. And by the way, this isn’t just about “ancient guys.” Lucius Lactantius, Christian religious advisor of Emperor Constantine, believed the Earth to be flat. St. Augustine also argued the Earth was flat and even went so far as to call it “absurd” and a “fable” that people could actually travel or even exist on another “side” of the Earth. There is a long list of examples extending all the way through the Middle Ages of Christian bishops, monks, theologians, and philosophers arguing for a flat Earth and using the Bible as evidence. If you’re only relying on the Bible, that is the only conclusion that can be reached based on what it contains. There just isn’t any way around it if you take the Bible literally.
Although it’s important to note that St. Augustine also did NOT believe in a literalistic reading of the creation account of Genesis. He would have disagreed with Ham.😃
 
But scientists themselves have stated modern science has rendered God useless.

Why?
So scientists are actually humans too who, as such, make metaphysical conclusions that may or may not be true, and may or may not actually follow from the actual facts at hand?! Shocking!😃

Seriously, plenty of scientists are Catholics, plenty believe in God and even are Christian. Just…almost NONE of them believe in the fundamentalist interpretive methods of Ham and his camp. Why be threatened by some other atheist scientists who also have metaphysical beliefs that they espouse?
 
I am a Catholic. In the broad sense all Catholics are creationists as God created it all.

Catholics always had Tradition and Scripture. Tradition came first. We have always understood Scripture as what the author intended to convey.

I would like your source for your claim otherwise.
This is rather shocking, but I agree with Buffalo here…I do not believe the Church has ever made an infallible teaching concerning the flatness or roundness of the Earth.:confused:
 
Pythagoras suggested a three-dimensional/spherical Earth 600 years before Jesus was supposedly born (around 600 B.C.E). 300 years later (300 B.C.E) it was regarded as scientific and mathematical fact by the Greeks and other civilizations. Thats some 600 years before Augustine, who seems to have argued more for a flat Earth than against it, was even born. It does not make sense that the flat Earth view experienced a resurgence (and it did), even among educated people, hundreds of years after the preponderance of the civilized world had accepted the Greek model unless biblical literalism is taken into account. It was Biblical literalism which reintroduced the flat Earth view as a valid belief and, yes, many of its proponents were educated Catholics with important roles in the Church and positions of influence in the courts of converted monarchs and emperors.

It wasn’t shy about doing this in the past so why sit quietly in the wings now? Its shocking to me that Catholics often lament the existence of “Cafeteria Catholics” yet don’t believe that the Church should, in light of scientific discovery, define the meaning of or establish an official and binding position on the very text which justifies its existence. If the very word of God himself, or the inspired word of God, is subject to prudential judgement then its no wonder why there are so many different sects of Christianity.
This is a little unfair, don’t you think? You’re leaving out something rather important here: the Dark Ages. The fall of the Roman Empire and Roman civilization had clearly DRASTIC effects on education, learning, opportunity, and general societal progress in the West for a long, long time. It’s really not fair to charge that somehow every Catholic priest and bishop had all of Greek and Egyptian philosophy, mathematics, and learning in their heads and yet lied to the people, as you seem to suggest here. Most of even the most educated in those days were sadly ignorant and unaware of the majority of this learning, and much of it was lost wholly in the West, despite Catholic monestaries and such trying as much as possible to preserve whatever of it they had.
 
This is rather shocking, but I agree with Buffalo here…I do not believe the Church has ever made an infallible teaching concerning the flatness or roundness of the Earth.:confused:
A rather moot point when we’re talking about the uneducated first, second, third, fourth, fifth, sixth, etc century faithful masses being told what is and is not correct by a person of authority in the Church. Especially in an era in which “The Church” was a far more nebulous concept and the Bishop of Rome less prominent.
This is a little unfair, don’t you think? You’re leaving out something rather important here: the Dark Ages. The fall of the Roman Empire and Roman civilization had clearly DRASTIC effects on education, learning, opportunity, and general societal progress in the West for a long, long time. It’s really not fair to charge that somehow every Catholic priest and bishop had all of Greek and Egyptian philosophy, mathematics, and learning in their heads and yet lied to the people, as you seem to suggest here. Most of even the most educated in those days were sadly ignorant and unaware of the majority of this learning, and much of it was lost wholly in the West, despite Catholic monestaries and such trying as much as possible to preserve whatever of it they had.
I’m not saying that anyone lied. I am merely pointing out the historical fact that educated monks, bishops, theologians, and philosophers rejected the Pythagorean model because they believed in biblical literalism. What they did is similar to what Ham did at the debate.
 
Sorry guys, according to historian James Hannam, the idea that the people in the Middle Ages believed that the Earth was flat was created in the 19th Century. “The idea that the uncouth people of the Middle Ages thought the Earth was flat is a myth that has been propagating since the nineteenth century, intended to give us a quite unfair view of this vibrant and exciting period.”

The myth that Christians in the Middle Ages thought the world was flat was given a massive boost by Andrew Dickson White’s weighty tome The Warfare of Science with Theology published in 1896. This book has become something of a running joke among historians of science and it is dutifully mentioned as a prime example of misinformation in the preface of most modern works on science and religion. The flat Earth is discussed in chapter 2 and one can almost sense White’s confusion that hardly any of the sources support his hypothesis that Christians widely believed in it. He finds himself grudgingly admitting that St Clement, Origen, St Ambrose, St Augustine, St Isodore, St Albertus Magnus and St Thomas Aquinas all accepted the Earth was a globe - in other words none of the great doctors of the church had considered the matter in doubt. Although an analysis of what White actually says suggests he was aware that the flat Earth was largely a myth, he certainly gives an impression of ignorant Christians suppressing rational knowledge of its real shape.
…
Anti-clerical history of science writers have promulgated the myth so that even today, in his book The Discoverers, Daniel Boorstin manages to produce a totally misleading account (although he eventually gets Columbus right). His bias shows badly when he castigates Christians for thinking the world was flat when they did not and then praises the erudition of Chinese geographers who actually did believe it. The myth is so prevalent that the blurb on the back cover of the UK version of Umberto Eco’s book Serendipities, the editor repeats the myth even though within the book itself, Eco devotes a good deal of attention to debunking it! The doyen of historians of medieval science, Edward Grant, covers the issue in his book, God and Reason in the Middle Ages. He finds all educated people in the Middle Ages were well aware the Earth was a sphere. Perhaps today we can at last dispense with this patronising belief about people who lived in the past.

jameshannam.com/flatearth.htm

Think about it; sailors and their families watched ships leave over and over again, and watched as the hull disappeared first followed lastly by the masts. They weren’t so dumb as to disbelieve their own eyes.

Having said that, watch out for “the God of the gaps.”
 
Sorry guys, according to historian James Hannam, the idea that the people in the Middle Ages believed that the Earth was flat was created in the 19th Century. “The idea that the uncouth people of the Middle Ages thought the Earth was flat is a myth that has been propagating since the nineteenth century, intended to give us a quite unfair view of this vibrant and exciting period.”

It is pointless to argue that people in the Middle Ages did not believe the Earth was flat. One word: Etymologiae.
 
It is pointless to argue that people in the Middle Ages did not believe the Earth was flat. One word: Etymologiae.
And just exactly what does that prove? I think you just might be placing just a bit too much weight on one book that has, admittedly, confusing references, don’t you? That so many others obviously state that the earth is a sphere.

Don’t belittle the middle ages, you may live to regret it some day as you learn more about it. 😉

Saw this tonight: “Isidore’s understanding of the earth as a sphere can be seen in Book III Section XXXII and Book XIV Section I. Isidore states that the sphere of the sky has earth in its center and the sky being equally distant on all sides.” That would, well, make the earth a sphere. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Etymologiae#The_shape_of_the_Earth

But again, the book has inconsistencies (gee, a book other than the Bible that has inconsistencies, who’da thunk it??)
 
And just exactly what does that prove? I think you just might be placing just a bit too much weight on one book that has, admittedly, confusing references, don’t you? That so many others obviously state that the earth is a sphere.

Don’t belittle the middle ages, you may live to regret it some day as you learn more about it. 😉

Saw this tonight: “Isidore’s understanding of the earth as a sphere can be seen in Book III Section XXXII and Book XIV Section I. Isidore states that the sphere of the sky has earth in its center and the sky being equally distant on all sides.” That would, well, make the earth a sphere. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Etymologiae#The_shape_of_the_Earth

But again, the book has inconsistencies (gee, a book other than the Bible that has inconsistencies, who’da thunk it??)
There is nothing confusing about it. The man described Earth as being in the shape of a circle, specifically a two-dimensional wheel. The reason why so much weight is placed on this book is because his wheel-like Earth was slapped on maps for centuries.The biblical literalists just would not let the two-dimensional Earth model die and, when a man regarded by some of his contemporaries as one of the sharpest minds of the age says he thinks the Earth is a two-dimensional wheel, BAM: 1,200 years of established scientific fact goes flying out the window again and we get Earth-wheel maps floating around for several hundred years.
 
There is nothing confusing about it. The man described Earth as being in the shape of a circle, specifically a two-dimensional wheel. The reason why so much weight is placed on this book is because his wheel-like Earth was slapped on maps for centuries.The biblical literalists just would not let the two-dimensional Earth model die and, when a man regarded by some of his contemporaries as one of the sharpest minds of the age says he thinks the Earth is a two-dimensional wheel, BAM: 1,200 years of established scientific fact goes flying out the window again and we get Earth-wheel maps floating around for several hundred years.
I’m sorry but your view of the Middle ages is amazingly oversimplified. First of all, it’s clear that you blame pretty much everything about that era on the Long Arm of the Church. Classical civilization (and thereby learning) did not collapse simply because Jesus. Vikings raiding from the north, semi-nomadic Slavic hordes from the East, occasionally Huns, and eventually the threat of the rising (and technologically advanced) Islamic civilization from the south all dealt repeated and severe blows to nascent ‘Western Civilization.’ Even if there were no Church (actually, especially if there were no Church) do you think the people of Europe would have had a chance at an educational renaissance in a time like that?

And what motivates you to assume that the regression was simply the result of a biblical literalism that had already been disputed by Christian theologians in the first few centuries A.D. After the Huns, or the Vandals, or the Goths, or the Vikings sacked Rome, torched the libraries and universities, and massacred the inhabitants of the major cities, how exactly were illiterate peasants (and no, they were not illiterate because of the Church; even in 4th century B.C. Greece the population was mostly illiterate) to rediscover Greek and Roman natural philosophy?

You seem to operate from the assumption that Christianity took over, then the Dark ages ensued. In fact, by the time the Church had come to wield the influence you ascribe to it beyond the city of Rome, the Dark Ages had already very much begun, that weren’t exactly throngs of educated Hellenists left around to be sent to be persecuted.

Also, your characterization of the Middle ages being an age of unmitigated stagnation in the area of science is also based more on stereotype than reality. In fact much progress was made in technology, science, etc. between the early and late middle ages. And that’s not some partisan Catholic historians’ argument; it’s the secular historians as well. The very idea of a sudden ‘Renaissance’ sprouting up in the 15th century has been challenged if not largely refuted by modern historians, and it is generally accepted that the progress was in fact far more gradual and continuous throughout the middle ages than previously believed by many.
 
I’m sorry but your view of the Middle ages is amazingly oversimplified. First of all, it’s clear that you blame pretty much everything about that era on the Long Arm of the Church. Classical civilization (and thereby learning) did not collapse simply because Jesus. Vikings raiding from the north, semi-nomadic Slavic hordes from the East, occasionally Huns, and eventually the threat of the rising (and technologically advanced) Islamic civilization from the south all dealt repeated and severe blows to nascent ‘Western Civilization.’ Even if there were no Church (actually, especially if there were no Church) do you think the people of Europe would have had a chance at an educational renaissance in a time like that?

And what motivates you to assume that the regression was simply the result of a biblical literalism that had already been disputed by Christian theologians in the first few centuries A.D. After the Huns, or the Vandals, or the Goths, or the Vikings sacked Rome, torched the libraries and universities, and massacred the inhabitants of the major cities, how exactly were illiterate peasants (and no, they were not illiterate because of the Church; even in 4th century B.C. Greece the population was mostly illiterate) to rediscover Greek and Roman natural philosophy?

You seem to operate from the assumption that Christianity took over, then the Dark ages ensued. In fact, by the time the Church had come to wield the influence you ascribe to it beyond the city of Rome, the Dark Ages had already very much begun, that weren’t exactly throngs of educated Hellenists left around to be sent to be persecuted.

Also, your characterization of the Middle ages being an age of unmitigated stagnation in the area of science is also based more on stereotype than reality. In fact much progress was made in technology, science, etc. between the early and late middle ages. And that’s not some partisan Catholic historians’ argument; it’s the secular historians as well. The very idea of a sudden ‘Renaissance’ sprouting up in the 15th century has been challenged if not largely refuted by modern historians, and it is generally accepted that the progress was in fact far more gradual and continuous throughout the middle ages than previously believed by many.
You are overreacting to what I said. The body of knowledge in terms of the three-dimensional/spherical Earth model developed by Pythagorus was not lost. The flat-Earth model, after being reintroduced by the biblical literalists, gradually faded away again and was only espoused by an almost invisible biblical literalist minority until the the late 6th/early 7th century C.E. Isidore of Seville was aware of the Pythagorean model. He had to have been because it was prevalent in his time. The issue here is that people like Isidore simply disagreed with it because of their literalist views and for the next 700 years the Earth was often depicted as a two-dimensional wheel. I am not implying that there was some nefarious plot on the part of Isidore to undermine scientific progress but, yes, there was plenty of unmitigated stagnation because religious people were willing to disregard established scientific fact for no other reason than a widely respected religious figure disagreed with it. There were other factors, but that is a big one.

The point is that Its fine if some religious people want to spend another 1,900 years trying to reconcile the empirical realities of the world and universe we live in with their beliefs. My problem is with people like Ken Ham who want to force the rest of us come along for the ride and try to muddy the waters with pseudoscience along the way.
 
It is pointless to argue that people in the Middle Ages did not believe the Earth was flat. One word: Etymologiae.
You have a very interesting definition of the word ‘people.’ Also, if I took a poll in ancient Greece on the matter, do you honestly think even a significant percentage of the people there would say that the earth is a sphere? A handful of scholars in two or three city-states believed it, and you only know that because some monks preserved their writings during the Dark Ages.
It wasn’t shy about doing this in the past so why sit quietly in the wings now? Its shocking to me that Catholics often lament the existence of “Cafeteria Catholics” yet don’t believe that the Church should, in light of scientific discovery, define the meaning of or establish an official and binding position on the very text which justifies its existence. If the very word of God himself, or the inspired word of God, is subject to prudential judgement then its no wonder why there are so many different sects of Christianity.
I suppose you’d also say I’m not a good enough Catholic because I don’t think the Church should declare whether M&Ms are objectively better or worse than skittles. And the possible *implications *of a theory beyond the realm of science are not the same thing as the theory itself. The fact that the Church does not opposes evolution is in itself a decision based in part on an evaluation of the possible implications of it. Evidently it was concluded that evolution does not imply the nonexistence of God or imply the invalidation of Church teaching. Why say more than needs to be said?

And what do you mean by the meaning of it? You must be aware that historically, people trying to draw ‘meaning’ from evolution beyond the science itself, such as into morality an social hierarchy, has had pretty disastrous results.
 
You are overreacting to what I said. The body of knowledge in terms of the three-dimensional/spherical Earth model developed by Pythagorus was not lost. The flat-Earth model, after being reintroduced by the biblical literalists, gradually faded away again and was only espoused by an almost invisible biblical literalist minority until the the late 6th/early 7th century C.E. Isidore of Seville was aware of the Pythagorean model. He had to have been because it was prevalent in his time. The issue here is that people like Isidore simply disagreed with it because of their literalist views and for the next 700 years the Earth was often depicted as a two-dimensional wheel. I am not implying that there was some nefarious plot on the part of Isidore to undermine scientific progress but, yes, there was plenty of unmitigated stagnation because religious people were willing to disregard established scientific fact for no other reason than a widely respected religious figure disagreed with it. There were other factors, but that is a big one.
Do you seriously think that there is some sort of ratcheting effect when it comes to knowledge? Without prior knowledge, why do you think people would automatically default to believing in a round earth? Once knowledge is list it is lost forever or until someone recreates it. What I am saying is that the tendency to believe in a flat earth versus a round earth was intuitive. It did not require the intervention of the Church; without the Church, no other sources on the matter, most people would just assume that the earth was flat. And generally, excluding usually just a few copies of the works of a few scholars stored away somewhere was not sufficient to ‘rekindle’ knowledge of the roundness of earth. You are still attributing to the Church a belief that most people would default to anyway after knowledge is lost. And just because a few or even one copy of a piece of writing survive to be rediscovered centuries later, does not mean it is not effectively lost for the people of that time. If you read a few books on the history of mathematics you’d be amazed at how many things had to be discovered multiple times because of how easily it could be effectively ‘lost.’

And again, if you would bother to read anything of an opposing point of view (even including numerous secular, academic historians) you’d realize that the Church contributed a great deal of resources and manpower to science. It may have often exercised strict and even stifling power in Europe, as did the secular regimes. But that was all but necessitated by the circumstances; Vikings, Eastern nomads, Moors, and unheard of famines resulting from reurbanization to name a few. There was a siege mentality, and often quite justifiably so. But hey, I’m sure an individualistic liberal democracy spawned ot would’ve still fared just fine. :rolleyes:

Had there been no Catholic Church, would things have been any less stagnant? My answer is not; probably more stagnant in fact. You just seem intent on viewing it as though it existed in a vacuum.
The point is that Its fine if some religious people want to spend another 1,900 years trying to reconcile the empirical realities of the world and universe we live in with their beliefs. My problem is with people like Ken Ham who want to force the rest of us come along for the ride and try to muddy the waters with pseudoscience along the way.
First of all, I’m not defending or siding with Ham.

An secondly, make no mistake, your going to have to ‘reconcile’ your secular beliefs with the the world every bit as much as any religious person. Do you honestly think you have any more reason to believe in the existence of human rights than to believe in the soul? Perhaps they’re both located in the pineal gland (a Descartes reference I just had to throw in)? Do you think kin selection theory of human moral behavior will provide a solid rational basis for you to demand that people behave morally? Or merely call into question whether such a thing as right an wrong really exists? I assure you, your worldview is laden with axioms and articles of faith and beliefs inconsistent with a certain interpretation of many scientific discoveries, and are not merely some default position. Just because those axioms aren’t the ones being called into question right not doesn’t mean they’re tenable, and it also doesn’t mean their time won’t come.
 
There is nothing confusing about it. The man described Earth as being in the shape of a circle, specifically a two-dimensional wheel. The reason why so much weight is placed on this book is because his wheel-like Earth was slapped on maps for centuries.The biblical literalists just would not let the two-dimensional Earth model die and, when a man regarded by some of his contemporaries as one of the sharpest minds of the age says he thinks the Earth is a two-dimensional wheel, BAM: 1,200 years of established scientific fact goes flying out the window again and we get Earth-wheel maps floating around for several hundred years.
As I stated before: “Isidore’s understanding of the earth as a sphere can be seen in Book III Section XXXII and Book XIV Section I. Isidore states that the sphere of the sky has earth in its center and the sky being equally distant on all sides.”

It is dangerous to base a view of the Middle Ages on one interpretation of one, as I mentioned, ambiguous work, essentially by one man. Objectively speaking, that is hardly fair.

This argument is falling into the same trap I mentioned before of hinging an entire argument on one knowledge gap. And what happens when that knowledge gap closes? The argument fails. History is different? Well no, history doesn’t change; only the way we see history changes. We need to realize the “dark ages” were only considered “dark” because historians didn’t know what went on then. This gave a lot of anti-clerical people with axes to grind opportunities to paint their own history of the Middle Ages. We are now finding that these invented histories, in many instances, were wrong.

So don’t pass judgment on the Middle Ages so quickly. We are only just now finding out what the real truth is about those times, and in many areas it wasn’t as much a scientific backwater as some would like to portray.
 
What you are saying here IS solipsism, necessarily and undeniably! We get information about the past history of the Earth and life on it from the application of the physical laws and mathematics we know and see working around us in the present. You CAN’T rationally hold that the “laws of physics” as you just said above tell us the Sun will come up tomorrow out of one side of your mouth while saying out the other side that those VERY SAME LAWS are not reliable and constant! I’ll ask again because you’ve not answered and I suspect it’s because you know that the YEC folks cannot answer it: On what basis do you believe now that the laws of nature and physics ARE constant and will be in the future, if you firmly believe that they all somehow completely were different and changed in the past?

In other words: the base assumption as you’ve so accurately said above is that everything operated the same in the past as it does today. This MUST be assumed or you must live with the consequences, to wit, a world of total irrationality and unintelligibility where nothing can be predicted or known reliably about anything at all, including the behavior of matter, the laws of chemistry, of radioactivity, of physics, or anything else. You must live actually believing that even though your combustion engine properly powers your car right at the moment, at any minute in the future it might suddenly explode as the internal chemistry might just change all of a sudden on you. I say again, no one really lives this way except for actual insane people.🤷
We already know decay rates vary. The molecular clock varies. These were assumed to be constants.

I did not say all laws.

God can act through supernatural means as well as natural means. He has no restrictions. One time events are studied to come up with the best explanation. We also know catastrophies have shaped the earth. Looking at the past based on the current brings uncertain conclusions.
 
Pythagoras suggested a three-dimensional/spherical Earth 600 years before Jesus was supposedly born (around 600 B.C.E). 300 years later (300 B.C.E) it was regarded as scientific and mathematical fact by the Greeks and other civilizations. Thats some 600 years before Augustine, who seems to have argued more for a flat Earth than against it, was even born. It does not make sense that the flat Earth view experienced a resurgence (and it did), even among educated people, hundreds of years after the preponderance of the civilized world had accepted the Greek model unless biblical literalism is taken into account. It was Biblical literalism which reintroduced the flat Earth view as a valid belief and, yes, many of its proponents were educated Catholics with important roles in the Church and positions of influence in the courts of converted monarchs and emperors.

It wasn’t shy about doing this in the past so why sit quietly in the wings now? Its shocking to me that Catholics often lament the existence of “Cafeteria Catholics” yet don’t believe that the Church should, in light of scientific discovery, define the meaning of or establish an official and binding position on the very text which justifies its existence. If the very word of God himself, or the inspired word of God, is subject to prudential judgement then its no wonder why there are so many different sects of Christianity.
It was made up in the 1800’s.
 
This is a little unfair, don’t you think? You’re leaving out something rather important here: the Dark Ages. The fall of the Roman Empire and Roman civilization had clearly DRASTIC effects on education, learning, opportunity, and general societal progress in the West for a long, long time. It’s really not fair to charge that somehow every Catholic priest and bishop had all of Greek and Egyptian philosophy, mathematics, and learning in their heads and yet lied to the people, as you seem to suggest here. Most of even the most educated in those days were sadly ignorant and unaware of the majority of this learning, and much of it was lost wholly in the West, despite Catholic monestaries and such trying as much as possible to preserve whatever of it they had.
The Not So “Dark” Ages
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top