B
Blacksword
Guest
What you are saying here IS solipsism, necessarily and undeniably! We get information about the past history of the Earth and life on it from the application of the physical laws and mathematics we know and see working around us in the present. You CAN’T rationally hold that the “laws of physics” as you just said above tell us the Sun will come up tomorrow out of one side of your mouth while saying out the other side that those VERY SAME LAWS are not reliable and constant! I’ll ask again because you’ve not answered and I suspect it’s because you know that the YEC folks cannot answer it: On what basis do you believe now that the laws of nature and physics ARE constant and will be in the future, if you firmly believe that they all somehow completely were different and changed in the past?paragraph 1 - we agree
2 - Where do we get the origins info if we were not there?
Now, we as Catholics have been given some clues through Revelation. In other words we were told. That has to count for something.
- I didn’t get it that way - I got from Ham is there are two modes. The observational and the historical study. I believe the danger is modern education has conflated the two. They are extrapolating today as a key to the past. The base assumption is that everything operated the same in the past as today. That cannot be proven. It can lead to dangerous conclusions. Nye didn’t touch the word uniformatarian because we now know catastrophies (one time events) played a part in the past.
Note: I am not a Ham fan, but I see what he was getting at.
We can reliably assume the sun will shine tomorrow two ways. God told us He would provide. Or that the laws of physics tells us. But then we get back to: who is upholding those laws?
In other words: the base assumption as you’ve so accurately said above is that everything operated the same in the past as it does today. This MUST be assumed or you must live with the consequences, to wit, a world of total irrationality and unintelligibility where nothing can be predicted or known reliably about anything at all, including the behavior of matter, the laws of chemistry, of radioactivity, of physics, or anything else. You must live actually believing that even though your combustion engine properly powers your car right at the moment, at any minute in the future it might suddenly explode as the internal chemistry might just change all of a sudden on you. I say again, no one really lives this way except for actual insane people.