Challenge from a Skeptic re: Miracles

  • Thread starter Thread starter PRmerger
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Your website above mentions miraculous cures that took place in Lourdes France, spiritual conversion, forgiveness-which allows God to work in our lives.
Yes, and implies that it is the result of the “placebo effect”.
Of the others, there is no mention at all that prayer was not used. Were the patients even asked? There is a great chance that along with the patient believing that the medical treatment would work, the patient was also believing that the medical treatment would work…irregardless that it wasn’t a scientific treatment…because of God’d influence on it.
Or little benovelant martians zapped their ray guns at the patients when the doctors weren’t looking. Occam’s Razor is your friend here. There is alot of maybe’s that could occur, but the various pieces of evidence points toward a naturalist explination given that your so called “miracles” happen across differing cultures, to people of faith and non-faith, and the placebo effect is well documented.
Where is the interview with the person(s) who can say that prayer was not involved?
See above
I don’t believe I am being a sceptic in asking for these answers. Also, there are no names, places, or dates attached to these supposed “spontaneous cures”.
The article references where the info is taken from
“according to a report from the investigative health journal What Doctors Don’t Tell You (WDDTY).”
By the way, that is the way doctors refer to miraculous healings…“spontaneous cures”… when prayer is involved.
And when you give a patient a placebo and something unexpected happens.
practice what you preach. Provide evidence. We have given names and places and dates. I am working on it.
I did. The article references where it got its information from, and I posted two academic books dealing with the subject.
I haven’t had time today…during this day, as I am the mother of 3 young children and cannot stay on the computer all day long.
No rush.
 
Yes, and implies that it is the result of the “placebo effect”.

Or little benovelant martians zapped their ray guns at the patients when the doctors weren’t looking. Occam’s Razor is your friend here. There is alot of maybe’s that could occur, but the various pieces of evidence points toward a naturalist explination given that your so called “miracles” happen across differing cultures, to people of faith and non-faith, and the placebo effect is well documented.

See above

The article references where the info is taken from
“according to a report from the investigative health journal What Doctors Don’t Tell You (WDDTY).”

And when you give a patient a placebo and something unexpected happens.

I did. The article references where it got its information from, and I posted two academic books dealing with the subject.

No rush.
Just out of curiosity, what is your reason for being part of this thread or this CATHOLIC ANSWERS forum? Do you often go to people of another faith and declare war against said faith? We have not done so to you, why do you do so to us?
 
I have a question for skeptics (I appologize if it has already been asked):

Do you believe that everything in the world/universe happens for a reason?

I believe that everything happens for a reason. I also think the God has something to do with it. I know you are thinking “delusional”, but thats how I feel. Can God not be a cause of things to take place, just like you or me?

I am not saying that prayer is the defining reason why someone gets healed. We can pray all we want to and it may or may not happen. I could ask you 100 times to give me $1,000,000 but that doesnt mean you will. But if I stumble upon $1,000,000 that doesn’t mean you gave it to me either. But again, you could have been the one responcible.

I have taken many scientific courses ( I am an engineer ) and know that everything does have a cause. But I also know that the tiny electrons and protons within an atom move about in a random form. This tiny allowance is plenty enough for an All-Powerful Being to manipulate the way things work. This “random movement” of particles could be God’s “safety net” to intervene whenever he wants…without being explicitly identified. How can you prove that the random movements of particles are not influenced by God? Prove to me that no outside spiritual being can be responsible for a random flowing mass. If you say “spirits can’t interact with the physical world” you just proved your skeptic view completely wrong because you don’t believe in spirits.

…Awaiting the response… 👍
 
Folks,

Is there a distinction between a miracle which uses ordinary natural forces to effect a fortuitous event, and one that uses supernatural, scientifically inexplicable forces?

I thought a miracle need not necessarily be beyond rational scientific explanation, just a fortunate coincidence of events to effect a certain fortunate outcome.

Am I wrong>
 
Folks,

Is there a distinction between a miracle which uses ordinary natural forces to effect a fortuitous event, and one that uses supernatural, scientifically inexplicable forces?

I thought a miracle need not necessarily be beyond rational scientific explanation, just a fortunate coincidence of events to effect a certain fortunate outcome.

Am I wrong>
I think a “miracle” is defined as something which defies scientific or medical(scientific) explanation. Isn’t that correct? Such as the stigmata of Padre Pio.
 
Just out of curiosity, what is your reason for being part of this thread or this CATHOLIC ANSWERS forum? Do you often go to people of another faith and declare war against said faith? We have not done so to you, why do you do so to us?
Im not sure what you mean. You agreed in an earlier post that a miracle is an event/action that defies scientific explination, and has no naturalistic alternative. I’m merely pointing out that was has been presented thus far, falls short of the definition agreed upon earlier.
 
Im not sure what you mean. You agreed in an earlier post that a miracle is an event/action that defies scientific explination, and has no naturalistic alternative. I’m merely pointing out that was has been presented thus far, falls short of the definition agreed upon earlier.
The question is clear, Isambard. There is no hidden meaning. I am very curious.
 
Is why Isambard… or I… post on Catholic Forums the subject of this thread?

Doesn’t seem like it to me.
 
Is why Isambard… or I… post on Catholic Forums the subject of this thread?

Doesn’t seem like it to me.
Funny, the fact that you will not answer my question is giving reasonable certainty that you are here only to attack the faith of the Roman Catholic Church, the Bible, & Christianity. That is all you have been doing. So the question which is being argued against by you, rather than answered, can leave the assumption that I am right.
And I am not going to argue or debate with you any longer. Jesus tells us not to converse or debate with evil…and it seems that your attacks on the Faith of CAF is for the purpose of evil. So I will simply answer all of your posts with this statement. I do not have to justify my faith to infidels whose sole purpose is to destroy the Roman Catholic Faith of others.
 
Funny, the fact that you will not answer my question is giving reasonable certainty that you are here only to attack the faith of the Roman Catholic Church, the Bible, & Christianity. That is all you have been doing. So the question which is being argued against by you, rather than answered, can leave the assumption that I am right.
And I am not going to argue or debate with you any longer. Jesus tells us not to converse or debate with evil…and it seems that your attacks on the Faith of CAF is for the purpose of evil. So I will simply answer all of your posts with this statement. I do not have to justify my faith to infidels whose sole purpose is to destroy the Roman Catholic Faith of others.
Whatever floats your boat.
 
Okay…this sounds like a cop-out answer to nonbelievers, but miracles and the belief in miracles boils down to faith. Faith in God, faith in God’s power to heal, and faith in God’s wisdom to heal where He sees fit.

I can show pictures of Pio’s hands, and people would say they were doctored. You can look at his hands in person, and easily write it off as the Church’s covering up a phony with a skin graft.

There will always be “wiggle room” for skeptics. Why? Because if God shows His power in an undeniable way, He robs us all of free will. And I, as a believer in miracles, certainly don’t want that.

God uses all of His creation to work His will. Could a healing be explained by a freak of nature? Sure, but let’s not forget who is the King of Nature. Who has given us the means to heal ourselves? None other than the Lord.

We sit back in our pride and gloat about how far modern man has come, how we got where we were. Here, let me tell a story to illustrate my point.

A scientist had a talk with God. He said “thanks for everything, God, but we don’t need you anymore. With advances in modern science and medicine, we can heal ourselves, keep ourselves alive as long as we want, regrow limbs and harvest organs thanks to stem-cell research, and–of course–we can create life.”

“That is all well and good,” God replied, “but can you make a man out of the dust on the ground and give him life?”

“Why, yes we can, Lord. In fact, let me show you just how far we’ve come.” With that, the scientist stooped down and started to gather dirt from the ground to make his man.

“Wait just a minute!” God said, interrupting the man.
The man looked up at the Lord, and the Lord replied:

“Get your own dirt.”

Natural phenomena, chance occurances, miracles…call them what you will, but they are all works of God.

Of course, it requires faith. Eyes that see and ears that hear, as Jesus Christ would say.
 
Okay…this sounds like a cop-out answer to nonbelievers, but miracles and the belief in miracles boils down to faith. Faith in God, faith in God’s power to heal, and faith in God’s wisdom to heal where He sees fit.

I can show pictures of Pio’s hands, and people would say they were doctored. You can look at his hands in person, and easily write it off as the Church’s covering up a phony with a skin graft.

There will always be “wiggle room” for skeptics. Why? Because if God shows His power in an undeniable way, He robs us all of free will. And I, as a believer in miracles, certainly don’t want that.

God uses all of His creation to work His will. Could a healing be explained by a freak of nature? Sure, but let’s not forget who is the King of Nature. Who has given us the means to heal ourselves? None other than the Lord.

We sit back in our pride and gloat about how far modern man has come, how we got where we were. Here, let me tell a story to illustrate my point.

A scientist had a talk with God. He said “thanks for everything, God, but we don’t need you anymore. With advances in modern science and medicine, we can heal ourselves, keep ourselves alive as long as we want, regrow limbs and harvest organs thanks to stem-cell research, and–of course–we can create life.”

“That is all well and good,” God replied, “but can you make a man out of the dust on the ground and give him life?”

“Why, yes we can, Lord. In fact, let me show you just how far we’ve come.” With that, the scientist stooped down and started to gather dirt from the ground to make his man.

“Wait just a minute!” God said, interrupting the man.
The man looked up at the Lord, and the Lord replied:

“Get your own dirt.”

Natural phenomena, chance occurances, miracles…call them what you will, but they are all works of God.

Of course, it requires faith. Eyes that see and ears that hear, as Jesus Christ would say.
that was way cool. I think I’ll use that if it is okay? that was way cool!!!
 
Do you believe that everything in the world/universe happens for a reason?
No. I believe the universe has a cause, but not a reason.
I believe that everything happens for a reason. I also think the God has something to do with it. I know you are thinking “delusional”, but thats how I feel. Can God not be a cause of things to take place, just like you or me?
It isn’t delusional. It’s obviously a fairly common belief.

I just don’t think it is the best explanation.
I am not saying that prayer is the defining reason why someone gets healed.
That’s good. 🙂
We can pray all we want to and it may or may not happen. I could ask you 100 times to give me $1,000,000 but that doesnt mean you will. But if I stumble upon $1,000,000 that doesn’t mean you gave it to me either. But again, you could have been the one responcible.
Trust me if you get a million dollars, you didn’t get it from me.😛

But more to your point, don’t you think that other theories might make a lot more sense?
I have taken many scientific courses ( I am an engineer ) and know that everything does have a cause. But I also know that the tiny electrons and protons within an atom move about in a random form. This tiny allowance is plenty enough for an All-Powerful Being to manipulate the way things work.
But it doesn’t suggest one is necessary.
This “random movement” of particles could be God’s “safety net” to intervene whenever he wants…without being explicitly identified.
What an odd idea. A god who needs a safety net. You don’t believe your god is omnipotent and omniscient?
How can you prove that the random movements of particles are not influenced by God?
I can’t. I can’t prove that the sun isn’t pulled through the heavens by an invisible chariot either. I still think the idea of invisible chariots is rather silly.
Prove to me that no outside spiritual being can be responsible for a random flowing mass. If you say “spirits can’t interact with the physical world” you just proved your skeptic view completely wrong because you don’t believe in spirits.
Why would I try and do that?
 
No. I believe the universe has a cause, but not a reason.

It isn’t delusional. It’s obviously a fairly common belief.

I just don’t think it is the best explanation.

That’s good. 🙂

Trust me if you get a million dollars, you didn’t get it from me.😛

But more to your point, don’t you think that other theories might make a lot more sense?

But it doesn’t suggest one is necessary.

What an odd idea. A god who needs a safety net. You don’t believe your god is omnipotent and omniscient?

I can’t. I can’t prove that the sun isn’t pulled through the heavens by an invisible chariot either. I still think the idea of invisible chariots is rather silly.

Why would I try and do that?
This person’s sole purpose for being on CAF is to attack the Catholic Faith. This is assumed because after attacking everything presented from a Catholic point of view, he/she is unwilling to give any other reason for being a part of this forum. I invite this person to please give another reason, except to try to discredit all that Catholics believe, for being part of CAF.
 
This person’s sole purpose for being on CAF is to attack the Catholic Faith. This is assumed because after attacking everything presented from a Catholic point of view, he/she is unwilling to give any other reason for being a part of this forum. I invite this person to please give another reason, except to try to discredit all that Catholics believe, for being part of CAF.
I eagerly await a response which would put this accusation to rest. I dearly hope the reasons are not which I am forced to believe, but that the person is actually just very interested in learning.
 
Us skeptics have no problem that your acception of miracals boils down to faith, its actually what we’ve been sudtly argueing all along. We do however, challenge any claims for the objective evidence for the existance of miracals.
 
To All:

I have not read any posts since my last one. Last night I spent time thinking about this thread. I am placing myself in a state of sin being on this thread any longer, because I feel that I am losing the gifts which the Holy Spirit gave me of Christian charity. I stand sincerely and strongly by every post I have sent, but there comes a time when I believe that God wants me to show Charity by just realizing that nothing that can be said or proven to people who sincerely do not want to believe will win the debate. It takes faith, and I shall pray that the skeptics will recieve the faith in Jesus, through the Holy Spirit, to know that He is God. There is no more reason for me to try to push a “skeptic” into belief.

So I will no longer take part in this thread. The Roman Catholic Faith has been proven well enough up to this point. I see no point in continnuing the debate, therefore, I say God bless you all with perseverence to continue the debate if you so choose, and the faith to believe in miraculous wonders our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ can and does perform.
 
We do however, challenge any claims for the objective evidence for the existance of miracals.
As do I…as does the Roman Catholic Church, for that matter. The RCC’s investigations into these phenomena are the most scrupulous, thorough investigations possible. I eagerly invite you to read up on the matter, but I have neither the time nor the interest to do it for you.

My statement about faith was more or less for the people who think miracles can be easily proven. There are some people of faith who tend to think nobody can rationally disagree with them. That is, of course, a fallacy.

That said, do you agree with the point I made with the story of God and the Scientist? These natural phenomena that occur to naturalistically help people get better without the benefit of modern medicine–do you accept that–if there is a God–He could control nature, and can use it phenomenally to cure people as He sees fit (I read that you’re “ignostic” (agnostic?), so bear with me)?
 
As do I…as does the Roman Catholic Church, for that matter. The RCC’s investigations into these phenomena are the most scrupulous, thorough investigations possible. I eagerly invite you to read up on the matter, but I have neither the time nor the interest to do it for you.
That’s fine, but I won’t accept any studies done outside the academic process as objective simply because of the potential for bias. Its the same reason why I largely ignore stuff put out by the Discovery Institute, Harun Yahya, or Classical Marxists writings on modern economics.

KephasAugustine;4004823My statement about faith was more or less for the people who think miracles *can [/quote said:
be easily proven. There are some people of faith who tend to think nobody can rationally disagree with them. That is, of course, a fallacy.

I agree completely

KephasAugustine;4004823That said said:
I don’t mean to be annoying, but I think a few clarifications should be made.

If we are talking about the “God” of the bible, then yes. I agree about the silliness of trying to “out-do” God if he exists.

Though, even if were discussing God the father, I still can’t see why he would be inconsistant with miracals. I mean Jesus, the early prophets, the disciples, etc. can be said to do things waaay outside the confines of a natural phenomena (assuming it went down just as stated), so God had no problem awing people before. Why should he be concerned about being ambigious now? Argueably, it would do more good to awe us now, as the pontential for “evil” is greatly enhanced through technology.

I guess my problem in the above is more of a theology question, so I’m not really sure what I answer I would accept shrug.

As per ignosticism en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ignosticism
Though to put it simply, might as well consider me an “atheist”.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top