Discussion on the Qu'ran and Hadith

  • Thread starter Thread starter Eucharisted
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
It is possible that some prophets were killed by the Jews. The reason could be that they were killed suddenly and the prophets did not have any time to pray to their God for safety, like did Jesus in the garden. John the baptist was also killed (Not by the Jews) suddenly. He did noy know what was coming. He did not get a chance to pray, like did Jesus.
**I am told by a Muslim here that Mohammad died of being poisoned. It was not a sudden death but after quite sometimes after being poisoned by a Jewish woman.

What do you think? That Mohammad did not pray to Allah in his tent to get well or Mohammad submitted to his fate that he would be the only prophet in history to die of being poisoned. Thus that how submission in Islam derived from?**
 
If Jesus had time to pray to Allah to rescue him from death, why couldn’t big Mo? Poison doesn’t kill you instantly. Big Mo still had enough time to face Mecca and pray to Allah for help. Islamic logic ain’t wrong most of the time.
 
So Jesus and his followers all said that he died and rose again. Were they lying?

John the Baptist sat in jail for who knows how long before he was killed. Why could he not pray there?
Ralph, the disciples of Jesus had all fled the scene. They were not there at the scene of crucifixion. The others who were present could not say that Jesus was still alive otherwise his bones would have been broken and he would have been killed like the other two thieves.

It was all a divine plan to save Jesus. Nothing wrong in saying that Jesus was dead. Nobody could say that he was alive. Even much later, nobody could say that Jesus did not die. Because it would be unlawful and liable for punishment. Please understand… That was all the Mercy of Allah.

John the Baptist was praying always to his God. But he did not know about the crucial moment. He did not know that death was so close at hand, like Jesus knew it. So John could not beseech Allah for safety as did Jesus in the Garden. Peace.
 
Ralph, the disciples of Jesus had all fled the scene. They were not there at the scene of crucifixion. The others who were present could not say that Jesus was still alive otherwise his bones would have been broken and he would have been killed like the other two thieves.

It was all a divine plan to save Jesus. Nothing wrong in saying that Jesus was dead. Nobody could say that he was alive. Even much later, nobody could say that Jesus did not die. Because it would be unlawful and liable for punishment. Please understand… That was all the Mercy of Allah.

John the Baptist was praying always to his God. But he did not know about the crucial moment. He did not know that death was so close at hand, like Jesus knew it. So John could not beseech Allah for safety as did Jesus in the Garden. Peace.
St. John was at Jesus’s feet with Mary, his mother when he died. And he reported the death. Furthermore, do you think the Roman soldier’s tasked with carrying out the crucifixion would have allowed him to stay alive? They knew he was dead and still pierced his heart with a lance to make sure…

The fact is Jesus claimed to be God and then proved it through his miracles and ultimately his resurrection. The Islamic view that he was only a prophet does not make sense. Either he was God or he was a charlatan and a liar. No real prophet would claim he was God himself. Only God could claim that .
 
St. John was at Jesus’s feet with Mary, his mother when he died. And he reported the death. Furthermore, do you think the Roman soldier’s tasked with carrying out the crucifixion would have allowed him to stay alive? They knew he was dead and still pierced his heart with a lance to make sure…

The fact is Jesus claimed to be God and then proved it through his miracles and ultimately his resurrection. The Islamic view that he was only a prophet does not make sense. Either he was God or he was a charlatan and a liar. No real prophet would claim he was God himself. Only God could claim that .
According to Planten, the verse and any verse of the bible refuting what Muhammad claimed were corrupted. No wonder Planten failed to read that chapter. I am pretty sure that the bible that Planten read, is much thinner than what we have. For sure, Gospel of John, The acts, Letters of Paul, all of those other letters, are missing from Planten’s bible.
 
I endorse the views of Paul C. We shouldnot be disrespectful to other religions.
 
Ralph, the disciples of Jesus had all fled the scene. They were not there at the scene of crucifixion. The others who were present could not say that Jesus was still alive otherwise his bones would have been broken and he would have been killed like the other two thieves.

It was all a divine plan to save Jesus. Nothing wrong in saying that Jesus was dead. Nobody could say that he was alive. Even much later, nobody could say that Jesus did not die. Because it would be unlawful and liable for punishment. Please understand… That was all the Mercy of Allah.

John the Baptist was praying always to his God. But he did not know about the crucial moment. He did not know that death was so close at hand, like Jesus knew it. So John could not beseech Allah for safety as did Jesus in the Garden. Peace.
As pointed out, he was stabbed by a lance that went through his pericardial sac and probablly his heart. He would have bled out. His Mother, Mary Magdaline, and JOhn were all there. Are they liers? Did his own mother not know him? Could she not tell he was dead as he lay in her arms? Was she an idiot? Were they all dumb?

So you cannot ask God for protection unless you can give him specifics? Isn’t God omniscient? Doesn’t he know when we need the help, even if we don’t? Am I supposed to ask God if he is free on Wednesday at 3:30 pm because I will need him?

The Mercy of God is shown in Jesus’s suffering, death and Ressurection. The fact that Islam denies these things shows that Islam denies the mercy of God in its truest form
 
Nonsense? God does not listen to your prayer if you fart.

Haniff: But I prayed 5 times each day!

God: Well…see…you had a big gas problem so all those prayers were useless.
 
But what if an accurate truthful description is considered disrespectful?
The issue isn’t in how the data is treated, it is the tone we use sometimes with people who disagree with us. It is not helpful to assume that people who disagree are simply idiots when they don’t see it our way. It is much more helpful to try to understand why they see things the way they do, only then can we convince them of our opinion. Cordial discussion leaves both parties respectful of each others right to believe as individuals. When someone flames out against someone else, that just sets up barriers…
 
According to Planten, the verse and any verse of the bible refuting what Muhammad claimed were corrupted. No wonder Planten failed to read that chapter. I am pretty sure that the bible that Planten read, is much thinner than what we have. For sure, Gospel of John, The acts, Letters of Paul, all of those other letters, are missing from Planten’s bible.
swariffin, you are right. I read with good interest the 4 gospels (KJV) and I enjoyed it. I did not indulge much in the works of Paul because I found him not right. (Don’t ask). Please point out that chapter again which I was to read.

The gospel of John is very much in my mind. But the other letters etc. are missing from my activity. I feel that the four gospels are enough for me. Jesus is doing very well in those gospels.
 
This thread is not for bashing Islam or Muslims, this thread is for revealing the ridiculous claims and beliefs of Islam, …
  • If you fart during prayer, your prayers won’t be answered
  • Christians believe the Trinity is Jesus, Mary, and the Holy Spirit
  • The Holy Spirit is an angel
  • Jesus is the Messiah but He never fulfilled the OT prophecies
  • Adam was created from fire …
I have one to add. This is from Will Durant’s Story of Civilization series The Age of Faith. It seem that the kaba black stone was “ejected from the bowels of heaven” Seeing as how this possible metorite has red vaining I’m wondering about the possiblity of hemaroids 😉
 
swariffin, you are right. I read with good interest the 4 gospels (KJV) and I enjoyed it. I did not indulge much in the works of Paul because I found him not right. (Don’t ask). Please point out that chapter again which I was to read.

The gospel of John is very much in my mind. But the other letters etc. are missing from my activity. I feel that the four gospels are enough for me. Jesus is doing very well in those gospels.
Good, then you see where Jesus DIED in all four Gospels, right? And you see where he said that he was God, especially in John, right?

And you see where Mary is Joseph’s wife, right?
 
The issue isn’t in how the data is treated, it is the tone we use sometimes with people who disagree with us. It is not helpful to assume that people who disagree are simply idiots when they don’t see it our way. It is much more helpful to try to understand why they see things the way they do, only then can we convince them of our opinion. Cordial discussion leaves both parties respectful of each others right to believe as individuals. When someone flames out against someone else, that just sets up barriers…
But it become dificult to remain totally respectful when people suport this twisted junk and refuse to have an honest and legitimate discussion about it. The muslim posters her just throw out red herrings and rarely adress the issues that get to the heart of the matter. As a result, I’ve just started tossing out bombs (fact filled bombs) knowing that they have probably ignored me by now anyway.
 
Actually I think I know what doesn’t seem to work here. We are trying to demonstrate the mysteries of our faith, which we can’t! But that we can’t does not mean that the mysteries themselves are not true!
I don’t know if Muslims experience the same thing when they are trying to tell us about their faith?
Anyhow, anyone who respects God and his/her neighbours, whether they are Christians, Jewish, Muslims, Hindus, Buddhists, or whatever, is worth our respect and love. If they do, they won’t tend to massacre us for any reason, even “religious” ones, will they?
 
But it become dificult to remain totally respectful when people suport this twisted junk and refuse to have an honest and legitimate discussion about it. The muslim posters her just throw out red herrings and rarely adress the issues that get to the heart of the matter. As a result, I’ve just started tossing out bombs (fact filled bombs) knowing that they have probably ignored me by now anyway.
I didn’t see this when I wrote my last post. Anyhow I don’t wish to insist on those who try to make this thread and others “interesting” and… quite offensive.
I’d rather ignore them from now on…
 
The issue isn’t in how the data is treated, it is the tone we use sometimes with people who disagree with us. It is not helpful to assume that people who disagree are simply idiots when they don’t see it our way. It is much more helpful to try to understand why they see things the way they do, only then can we convince them of our opinion. Cordial discussion leaves both parties respectful of each others right to believe as individuals. When someone flames out against someone else, that just sets up barriers…
How I agree with you here, paul c!
 
For those who wonder about my presence being rarer even in this thread, I don’t have my own computer, and the computer I used to use in the shelter where I am a volunteer went K.O. some time ago, and I have been rather busy, so that I couldn’t come here more than once or twice a week.
The times, they are a-changing…!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top