E
Erikaspirit16
Guest
And here we go… No. it’s not a scientific question. You can scientifically decide that something is “alive” (although I’m not sure you’d get much agreement…are toenails “alive”?) and you can TRY scientifically to decide if a fetus / baby / whatever is viable outside the mother–but you can’t say for sure. Remove a fetus at 5 months. Will it live? Who knows? Roll the dice. Please don’t bring DNA into the process. If you do, then I’m going to have to ask you if a 4-celled zygote is a “human being.” You may well BELIEVE it is, but that’s just your personal belief. And I’d have to look it up, but there are a huge number (a majority?) of embryos that simply don’t make it–they just die naturally. And sure, some people get all weepy and hold funerals, and other people see it like cutting their toenails. It’s a matter of belief, not science.Actually, it is a scientific and philosophical question. You turning it into a “religious” question is you imposing your beliefs on the question itself.
Clearly a fetus IS a human being. It doesn’t just BECOME a human being at some indeterminable point. It is from conception when all the DNA it needs to develop is in place. Each human being develops through stages into adulthood. You were once a fetus in your life as a human being. So was I. So was EVERY human being. The fetus happens to be a being that is human. There is no dispute about that.
So when does a fetus become a human being? If you can show me a consensus opinion of biologists (not civil engineers or astronomers…) I’ll gladly change my opinion.