Do hacked e-mails show global-warming fraud?

  • Thread starter Thread starter gilliam
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I have followed this story since the 20th and have found not too surprisingly that there is little to no real scandal here. The so called scandal seems to mainly be a result of miss understanding what the scientists are actually saying in the emails.

But anyway realclimate has a good response not to mention there is even more answers in the massive and ever growing comment thread. realclimate.org/

And greenfyre has compiled a nice list of different replies as well. greenfyre.wordpress.com/

So sorry to stop the parade so to speak.
I dont see how either of these sites "stopped the parade"so to speak. There was no real defense of the emails in either of these sites(one of which features pictures of women in leather mini skirts and refers to anyone who is troubled by the emails as “deniers”.) The emails point out clearly that the Global Warming data is being manipulated to overstate the problem(if there is a problem at all).
 
Here’s more hype from Al Gore. What do you do when hurricanes are at a 30 year low?

prisonplanet.com/with-hurricanes-at-thirty-year-low-gore-turns-to-photoshop.html

Referring to Gore & others in this article:

“The First Global Revolution” openly admitted how they were planning to exploit the contrived hoax of global warming in order to further their agenda. “In searching for a new enemy to unite us, we came up with the idea that pollution, the threat of global warming, water shortages, famine and the like would fit the bill. All these dangers are caused by human intervention, and it is only through changed attitudes and behavior that they can be overcome. The real enemy then, is humanity itself.,”

The last sentence which I bolded is pretty scary even putting the global warming hoax aside.
 
I wonder what “context” could exppalin anemail exchnage where they were discussing the need to eliminate the midevial warming trend from their data?
 
I wonder what “context” could exppalin anemail exchnage where they were discussing the need to eliminate the midevial warming trend from their data?
And that;s the problem you are assuming that is what the email actually said.

14 Mann tells Jones that it would be nice to ‘”contain” the putative Medieval Warm Period’

This is utterly bizarre. Mann is suggesting moving the start date of a reconstruction backwards, as it will then contain (as in ‘include’) the MWP, pretty much the opposite of the accusation. Somebody needs to improve their reading comprehension.

But that is a reponse if that isn;t the email you were looking at let me know what it said. but I bet the answer would still be the same that they weren;t trying to hide or eliminate anything

But anyway I like scholars and rogues take on this as well. scholarsandrogues.com/2009/11/20/climategate-not-likely/

But really where do the emails clearly state that data is being manipulated? I mean sure if you read the emails incorrectly and assume that is what they say well then you might get that idea. But if you realize that words can have different meanings and context is important…well suddenly the controversy dissapears. For instance from the real climate article.

No doubt, instances of cherry-picked and poorly-worded “gotcha” phrases will be pulled out of context. One example is worth mentioning quickly. Phil Jones in discussing the presentation of temperature reconstructions stated that “I’ve just completed Mike’s Nature trick of adding in the real temps to each series for the last 20 years (ie from 1981 onwards) and from 1961 for Keith’s to hide the decline.” The paper in question is the Mann, Bradley and Hughes (1998) Nature paper on the original multiproxy temperature reconstruction, and the ‘trick’ is just to plot the instrumental records along with reconstruction so that the context of the recent warming is clear. Scientists often use the term “trick” to refer to a “a good way to deal with a problem”, rather than something that is “secret”, and so there is nothing problematic in this at all. As for the ‘decline’, it is well known that Keith Briffa’s maximum latewood tree ring density proxy diverges from the temperature records after 1960 (this is more commonly known as the “divergence problem”–see e.g. the recent discussion in this paper) and has been discussed in the literature since Briffa et al in Nature in 1998 (Nature, 391, 678-682). Those authors have always recommend not using the post 1960 part of their reconstruction, and so while ‘hiding’ is probably a poor choice of words (since it is ‘hidden’ in plain sight), not using the data in the plot is completely appropriate, as is further research to understand why this happens.

And once again if your really interested in finding out answers I would recommend the real climate thread. realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2009/11/the-cru-hack/ scroll down to comments
 
And that;s the problem you are assuming that is what the email actually said.

But really where do the emails clearly state that data is being manipulated? I mean sure if you read the emails incorrectly and assume that is what they say well then you might get that idea. But if you realize that words can have different meanings and context is important…well suddenly the controversy dissapears. For instance from the real climate article.

ents*
So the controversy disappears only if we read the emails “correctly”. Correctly being,of course, ignoring what they say and assuming they mean something other than what they say.

Has global warming increased or decreased in the last 12 years? Can you show us a model from the mid 90s that predicted there would be a 10 year + cooling period from 1997 on? if not why should we trust any of the models presented to us, escpecially in light of the these emails showing the agenda of those pushing the global warming hysteria
 
I hope that global warming is a fake and a “con”. But i doubt it. I t hink global warming is all too real.
 
More damning excerpts:

In one e-mail, the center’s director, Phil Jones, writes Pennsylvania State University’s Michael E. Mann and questions whether the work of academics that question the link between human activities and global warming deserve to make it into the prestigious IPCC report, which represents the global consensus view on climate science.
“I can’t see either of these papers being in the next IPCC report,” Jones writes. “Kevin and I will keep them out somehow–even if we have to redefine what the peer-review literature is!”

In another, Jones and Mann discuss how they can pressure an academic journal not to accept the work of climate skeptics with whom they disagree. “Perhaps we should encourage our colleagues in the climate research community to no longer submit to, or cite papers in, this journal,” Mann writes. . . .

Mann, who directs Penn State’s Earth System Science Center, said the e-mails reflected the sort of “vigorous debate” researchers engage in before reaching scientific conclusions. “We shouldn’t expect the sort of refined statements that scientists make when they’re speaking in public,” he said.

Posted by JAMES TARANTO , Wall Street Journal
 
🍿

The emails and the spin by the only pro-“climate change” poster on the thread are great! I think the email deniers will never face up to the sham.
 
I have no doubt that the real agenda behind a lot of the global warming / climate change hype is a loathing of America and our relatively comfortable lifestyle. Its proponents want to use the power of government to tax us into what they deem a more “sustainable” (i.e. lower) quality of life.
It is a backdoor means of wealth confiscation and redistribution.Funny how this became all the rage since the collapse of upfront,and visible communism.Take a look at who exactly is supporting this:the “socialists”,former communist apologists and sympathizers.In my country its the NDP and Liberal parties.Their agenda is SO obvious.Has anyone noticed all these commercials that are flooding the airwaves with propaganda and agitprop?It’s opinion manufacturing time again folks.It happened in North America and Europe with so-called same-sex marriage suasion and look what happened.This fraud needs to be exposed as they are making it a motherhood issue,and is sucking in the young and the gullible.Ever notice that the sponsoring organizations are "identified"in tiny and almost illegible script.Thank God for this hacker.
 
🍿

The emails and the spin by the only pro-“climate change” poster on the thread are great! I think the email deniers will never face up to the sham.
Oh so pointing out that words can have more then one meaning and that context is important is spin huh? Now donlt get me wrong I can understand how people would think these emails are bad news at first. The first time I saw them I thought wow…I donlt think these can be explained…However I was suspicious too it just seemed too convient that shortly before Copenhagen suddenly CRU gets hacked and a bunch of suspicious looking emails come out. I figured I would wait for the scientifc community and what not to respond before I made my judgement. And not surprisely once they responded things began to make more sense. The fact that words have different meanings…and context is important. These emails are private they aren;t talking to the public so they might use terms and phrases and shorthand that would be confusing and even misleading to someone that doesn;t know the full context of what is being spoken about.

It;s like the hide the decline comment made in that one email from I think it was Jones to Mann. Now if you looked at that without knowing the context or assuming that they meant something sneaky then yes it looks real bad. But if you look at it in context suddenly it doesn;t really look bad

** One example is worth mentioning quickly. Phil Jones in discussing the presentation of temperature reconstructions stated that “I’ve just completed Mike’s Nature trick of adding in the real temps to each series for the last 20 years (ie from 1981 onwards) and from 1961 for Keith’s to hide the decline.” The paper in question is the Mann, Bradley and Hughes (1998) Nature paper on the original multiproxy temperature reconstruction, and the ‘trick’ is just to plot the instrumental records along with reconstruction so that the context of the recent warming is clear. Scientists often use the term “trick” to refer to a “a good way to deal with a problem”, rather than something that is “secret”, and so there is nothing problematic in this at all. As for the ‘decline’, it is well known that Keith Briffa’s maximum latewood tree ring density proxy diverges from the temperature records after 1960 (this is more commonly known as the “divergence problem”–see e.g. the recent discussion in this paper) and has been discussed in the literature since Briffa et al in Nature in 1998 (Nature, 391, 678-682). Those authors have always recommend not using the post 1960 part of their reconstruction, and so while ‘hiding’ is probably a poor choice of words (since it is ‘hidden’ in plain sight), not using the data in the plot is completely appropriate, as is further research to understand why this happens.**

Also it;s too long to copy and paste but one the real climate thread the really long one not the new one posted today comment 925 talks about the FOI issue. I donlt think I have seen that brought up here yet but since I bet it will thought I would nip it in the butt Not to mention points out the fact that there large gaps in the emails making seeing the context even harder.
 
Oh so pointing out that words can have more then one meaning and that context is important is spin huh? Now donlt get me wrong I can understand how people would think these emails are bad news at first. The first time I saw them I thought wow…I donlt think these can be explained…However I was suspicious too it just seemed too convient that shortly before Copenhagen suddenly CRU gets hacked and a bunch of suspicious looking emails come out. I figured I would wait for the scientifc community and what not to respond before I made my judgement. And not surprisely once they responded things began to make more sense. The fact that words have different meanings…and context is important. These emails are private they aren;t talking to the public so they might use terms and phrases and shorthand that would be confusing and even misleading to someone that doesn;t know the full context of what is being spoken about.

It;s like the hide the decline comment made in that one email from I think it was Jones to Mann. Now if you looked at that without knowing the context or assuming that they meant something sneaky then yes it looks real bad. But if you look at it in context suddenly it doesn;t really look bad

** One example is worth mentioning quickly. Phil Jones in discussing the presentation of temperature reconstructions stated that “I’ve just completed Mike’s Nature trick of adding in the real temps to each series for the last 20 years (ie from 1981 onwards) and from 1961 for Keith’s to hide the decline.” The paper in question is the Mann, Bradley and Hughes (1998) Nature paper on the original multiproxy temperature reconstruction, and the ‘trick’ is just to plot the instrumental records along with reconstruction so that the context of the recent warming is clear. Scientists often use the term “trick” to refer to a “a good way to deal with a problem”, rather than something that is “secret”, and so there is nothing problematic in this at all. As for the ‘decline’, it is well known that Keith Briffa’s maximum latewood tree ring density proxy diverges from the temperature records after 1960 (this is more commonly known as the “divergence problem”–see e.g. the recent discussion in this paper) and has been discussed in the literature since Briffa et al in Nature in 1998 (Nature, 391, 678-682). Those authors have always recommend not using the post 1960 part of their reconstruction, and so while ‘hiding’ is probably a poor choice of words (since it is ‘hidden’ in plain sight), not using the data in the plot is completely appropriate, as is further research to understand why this happens.**

Also it;s too long to copy and paste but one the real climate thread the really long one not the new one posted today comment 925 talks about the FOI issue. I donlt think I have seen that brought up here yet but since I bet it will thought I would nip it in the butt Not to mention points out the fact that there large gaps in the emails making seeing the context even harder.
😃 🍿
 
Oh so pointing out that words can have more then one meaning and that context is important is spin huh? Now donlt get me wrong I can understand how people would think these emails are bad news at first. r.
What do you think about the numeorus emails about how to keep disenting opinions from being published-even to the extent of rigging the peer review process to do so?

There simply is no way you can dismiss these emails as out of context and not damaging.
 
And some comments in the comment thread about the attempts to block skeptic papers. It seems in reality they were trying to block really horrible

From comment 828.

**2 Michael Mann discusses how to destroy a journal that has published sceptic papers.

Overstated. The journal in question was ‘Climate Research’ in the wake of publication of a sceptic paper [Sally Baliunas and Willie Soon] so poor it provoked the resignation of half the board.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sallie_Baliunas#Controversy_over_the_2003_Climate_Research_paper
sgr.org.uk/climate/StormyTimes_NL28.htm

and Mann’s opinions were: There have been several papers by Pat Michaels, as well as the Soon & Baliunas paper, that couldn’t get published in a reputable journal. This was the danger of always criticising the skeptics for not publishing in the “peer-reviewed literature”. Obviously, they found a solution to that–take over a journal! So what do we do about this? I think we have to stop considering “Climate Research” as a legitimate peer-reviewed journal. Perhaps we should encourage our colleagues in the climate research community to no longer submit to, or cite papers in, this journal. We would also need to consider what we tell or request of our more reasonable colleagues who currently sit on the editorial board…What do others think?

‘Perhaps encourage’, ‘request of our colleagues’ Hardly the language of someone hellbent on destruction. Mann’s statements are consistent with ensuring the academic literature effectively screens out substandard papers, a proper concern for a senior scientist.**

same comment…
**12 Tom Wigley says that von Storch is partly to blame for sceptic papers getting published at Climate Research. Says he encourages the publication of **** science. Says they should tell publisher that the journal is being used for misinformation. Says that whether this is true or not doesn’t matter. Says they need to get editorial board to resign. Says they need to get rid of von Storch too.

This is really the same discussion as (2) – What to do about a journal letting substandard papers into the literature? The quote is ‘Hans von Storch is partly to blame — he encourages the
publication of **** science ‘in order to stimulate debate’. One approach is to go direct to the publishers and point out the fact that their journal is perceived as being a medium for disseminating misinformation
under the guise of refereed work. I use the word ‘perceived’ here, since whether it is true or not is not what the publishers care about — it is how the journal is seen by the community that counts.**

I thought this post was interesting too. timpanogos.wordpress.com/2009/11/22/smoking-guns-in-the-clr-stolen-e-mails-a-real-tale-of-real-ethics-in-science/

As for the so called lack of warming read this realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2009/10/a-warming-pause/ And I thought this was good too. skepticalscience.com/How-do-we-know-global-warming-is-still-happening.html skepticalscience.com/How-we-know-global-warming-is-happening-Part-2.html

initforthegold.blogspot.com/ his most recent posting is good too.

And real climates most recent post on this realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2009/11/the-cru-hack-context/ hopefully they will keep updating with more answers
 
As for the so called lack of warming read this realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2009/10/a-warming-pause/ And I thought this was good too. skepticalscience.com/How-do-we-know-global-warming-is-still-happening.html skepticalscience.com/How-we-know-global-warming-is-happening-Part-2.html

initforthegold.blogspot.com/ his most recent posting is good too.

And real climates most recent post on this realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2009/11/the-cru-hack-context/ hopefully they will keep updating with more answers
Are you aware that the people exposed in the hacked emails are the same ones who founded realclimate.org? It’s probably not a good idea to use them as so many as your sources in this thread. The site it a little…biased? :rolleyes:
One of the emails:
In order to be a little bit more pro-active, a group of us (see below)
have recently got together to build a new ‘climate blog’ website:
RealClimate.org which will be launched over the next few days at:

realclimate.org

The idea is that we working climate scientists should have a place where
we can mount a rapid response to supposedly ‘bombshell’ papers that are
doing the rounds and give more context to climate related stories or
events.
 
Are you aware that the people exposed in the hacked emails are the same ones who founded realclimate.org? It’s probably not a good idea to use them as so many as your sources in this thread. The site it a little…biased? :rolleyes:
Biased towards good peer reviewed science yes. 😉 Not to mention some of what I have posted is actually from different people in the comment thread and not directly from the real climate people.

Anyway the guardianuk has had a couple good articles on this as well…

guardian.co.uk/environment/2009/nov/20/climate-sceptics-hackers-leaked-emails

guardian.co.uk/environment/2009/nov/20/climate-sceptics-email-hacking
 
Calliso,
How do you defend the scientists’ stated intent of deleting files rather than submit to FOIA requests?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top