Should we take this information and stand against the overwhelming majority of scientists and experts and claim that âglobal climate change is a mythâ?
I am not willing to do that and see nothing here that would lead me to do so.
The real story is not in the emails. The files released by the interloper include extensive datasets and the code used by the scientists to form their theory of AGW. The data is worthless and corrupt. Hereâs a great analysis of the situation:
devilskitchen.me.uk/2009/11/data-horribilis-harryreadmetxt-file.html
Excerpt:
With the CRU emails having been examined, it seems that some peopleâmainly techiesâare really starting to dig into the data files. These files are, as far as we can tell, temperature data, modelling results and other such useful files, i.e. these are the files produced and worked on by the CRU teams, as well as considerable amounts of information onâand code fromâthe actual computer modelling programmes themselves.
In other words, these are the guts of CRUâs actual computer modelsâthe data, the code and the applications.
And they are, by all accounts, a total bloody mess.
++++ START INSERT ++++
So, come with me on a wonderful journey as the CRU team realise that not only have they lost great chunks of data but also that their application suites and algorithms are total ****; join your humble Devil and Asimov as we dive into the
HARRY_READ_ME.txt (
thanks to The Englishman) file and follow the trials and tribulations of Ian âHarryâ Harris as he tries to recreate the published data because he has nothing else to go on!
Thrill as he
âglosses overâ anomalies; let your heart sing as he gets some results to within 0.5 degrees; rejoice as Harry points out that everything is undocumented and that, generally speaking, he hasnât got the first clue as to whatâs going on with the data!
Chuckle as one of CRUâs own admits that much of the centreâs data and applications are undocumented, bug-ridden, riddled with holes, missing, uncatalogued and, in short, utterly worthless.
And wonder as you realise that this was v2.10 and that, after this utter fiasco, CRU used the synthetic data and wonky algorithms to produce v3.0!
Youâll laugh! Youâll cry! You
wonât wonder why CRU never wanted to release the data! You
will wonder why we are even contemplating restructuring the world economy and wasting trillions of dollars on the say-so of data this bad.
This is the real story. It needs to get out to the world and people need to be made to understand what has happened here.
Because of these files, I have gone from having a basic acceptance of AGW but questioning the need to completely re-make the worldâs economy over it, to someone who now is pretty sure the whole thing really is a huge scam.