Do hacked e-mails show global-warming fraud?

  • Thread starter Thread starter gilliam
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Biased towards good peer reviewed science yes. 😉 Not to mention some of what I have posted is actually from different people in the comment thread and not directly from the real climate people.
And you’re also aware of the exposed scientists attempting to influence who would peer-review their papers?

It doesn’t seem like you’re even questioning these scientists, or are even aware what these emails have revealed.
 
What do you think about the numeorus emails about how to keep disenting opinions from being published-even to the extent of rigging the peer review process to do so?

There simply is no way you can dismiss these emails as out of context and not damaging.
Well you can, but it does not give the person attempting to dismiss the emails much more credibility than Baghdad Bob.

welovetheiraqiinformationminister.com/
 
Whether global-warming fraud or not, there’s a lot of money involved. For both sides. My only argument is that if China, Korea and those in the East won’t take any measures, it does no good for the US to take measures.:confused::confused::confused:
 
George Monbiot :

It’s no use pretending this isn’t a major blow. The emails extracted by a hacker from the climatic research unit at the University of East Anglia could scarcely be more damaging. I am now convinced that they are genuine, and I’m dismayed and deeply shaken by them.

Yes, the messages were obtained illegally. Yes, all of us say things in emails that would be excruciating if made public. Yes, some of the comments have been taken out of context. But there are some messages that require no spin to make them look bad. There appears to be evidence here of attempts to prevent scientific data from being released, and even to destroy material that was subject to a freedom of information request.

Worse still, some of the emails suggest efforts to prevent the publication of work by climate sceptics, or to keep it out of a report by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. I believe that the head of the unit, Phil Jones, should now resign.
 
I have a feeling there are more shoes to drop here. And I have every expectation of enjoying it. It has been getting noticeably cooler for at least three years and anybody who spends a lot of time outdoors knows it.

Is there such a thing as “email deniers”?
 
I have a feeling there are more shoes to drop here. And I have every expectation of enjoying it. It has been getting noticeably cooler for at least three years and anybody who spends a lot of time outdoors knows it.

Is there such a thing as “email deniers”?
There is now! 🙂
 
I just came across the emails. I am glad they were found but I also see nothing revealing in them. Climate fluctuates. Humans pollute more than they should. We are current in a warming trend. Oh, and most important, climate science, as it is practiced today, is very, very poor science. Even the honest scientists and the ones that try the best can not deny that funding is driven by politics and politics by agenda. Good science can not exist under such conditions. For the situation to be remedied, research must be funded blindly and the results must be unbiased. A sceintist on a mission is not a scientist. If he were, he would recognize his on limitation to be accurate.
 
In addition to the Washington Times, the Wall Street Journal has written about this, the biggest scandal in the history of science.

online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704888404574547730924988354.html

Yet even a partial review of the emails is highly illuminating. In them, scientists appear to urge each other to present a “unified” view on the theory of man-made climate change while discussing the importance of the “common cause”; to advise each other on how to smooth over data so as not to compromise the favored hypothesis; to discuss ways to keep opposing views out of leading journals; and to give tips on how to “hide the decline” of temperature in certain inconvenient data.

Some of those mentioned in the emails have responded to our requests for comment by saying they must first chat with their lawyers. Others have offered legal threats and personal invective. Still others have said nothing at all. Those who have responded have insisted that the emails reveal nothing more than trivial data discrepancies and procedural debates.

Yet all of these nonresponses manage to underscore what may be the most revealing truth: That these scientists feel the public doesn’t have a right to know the basis for their climate-change predictions, even as their governments prepare staggeringly expensive legislation in response to them.

Consider the following note that appears to have been sent by Mr. Jones to Mr. Mann in May 2008: “Mike, Can you delete any emails you may have had with Keith re AR4? Keith will do likewise. . . . Can you also email Gene and get him to do the same?” AR4 is shorthand for the U.N.'s Intergovernmental Panel of Climate Change’s (IPCC) Fourth Assessment Report, presented in 2007 as the consensus view on how bad man-made climate change has supposedly become.

Based on the above the Copenhagen conference must be cancelled. No reason for it exists.
 
Three things you absolutely must know about Climategate
First, the scientists discuss manipulating data to get their preferred results. The most prominently featured scientists are paleoclimatologists, who reconstruct historical temperatures and who were responsible for a series of reconstructions that seemed to show a sharp rise in temperatures well above historical variation in recent decades…

Secondly, scientists on several occasions discussed methods of subverting the scientific peer review process to ensure that skeptical papers had no access to publication. In 2003, Tom Wigley of the University Corporation for Atmospheric Research in Boulder, Colorado, complained that paleoclimatologist Hans von Storch was responsible for “the publication of **** science ‘in order to stimulate debate’” and that they “must get rid of von Storch” (1051190249) as an editor of the journal Climate Research (he indeed subsequently resigned)…

Finally, the scientists worked to circumvent the Freedom of Information process of the United Kingdom.
 
Three things you absolutely must know about Climategate
First, the scientists discuss manipulating data to get their preferred results. The most prominently featured scientists are paleoclimatologists, who reconstruct historical temperatures and who were responsible for a series of reconstructions that seemed to show a sharp rise in temperatures well above historical variation in recent decades…

Secondly, scientists on several occasions discussed methods of subverting the scientific peer review process to ensure that skeptical papers had no access to publication. In 2003, Tom Wigley of the University Corporation for Atmospheric Research in Boulder, Colorado, complained that paleoclimatologist Hans von Storch was responsible for “the publication of **** science ‘in order to stimulate debate’” and that they “must get rid of von Storch” (1051190249) as an editor of the journal Climate Research (he indeed subsequently resigned)…

Finally, the scientists worked to circumvent the Freedom of Information process of the United Kingdom.
I think it’s ironic that the pro-GW crowd would always post “show me a peer-reviewed paper,” while at the same time doing everything they could to cut off access to the skeptics. 😦
 
Any one of their emails can be explained (or spun, if you like). Big picture, however, a pattern of malfeasance and unprofessional behavior emerges. Subversion of the peer-review process, data manipulation, financial shenanigans, perhaps even illegality with regards to UK’s FOI laws. The whole point of the scientific method is to produce testable hypotheses, repeatable results, and validated conclusions. CRU actions covered by the released information shows that they purposely subverted this process.

Categorization of key ClimateGate emails.
ecotretas.blogspot.com/2009/11/rolo-compressor-de-verdades.html
Site is non-English, but the list is, categorizing many emails by area of malfeasance.

There is documentation of leading CRU researchers hiding data and analytical code for some 10 years. This completely subverts the scientific method. If the results of a study cannot be independently verified, it should not be considered as fact. Yet the results of unverified CRU studies were in turn used to feed other like-minded AGW studies.

It has been recently shown that (CRU’s) researcher Briffa’s study using Yamal tree-rings (that produced another hockey stick projection) was highly dependent on ONE tree, the magic YAD06.
wattsupwiththat.com/2009/10/30/yamal-treering-proxy-temperature-reconstructions-dont-match-local-thermometer-records/
climateaudit.org/?p=7241

More important, to my mind, are the comments in their forecasting model code.
They show (a) their model code is a mess, (b) the manufactured proxy data is a mess, and (c) the raw (name removed by moderator)uts are a mess.
They could not document what they had done and many times the data was referred to as garbage. There is documentation of fudging data to published results. This absolutely invalidates results.
tickerforum.org/cgi-ticker/akcs-www?post=118625&page=13
(code jockey forum; starts on page 13; language can be “colorful” but it is censored)
di2.nu/blog.htm
(critique of general programming approach)

Easy to understand overviews:
The Alarmists Do “Science”: A Case Study
powerlineblog.com/archives/2009/11/024995.php

The Yamal implosion
bishophill.squarespace.com/blog/2009/9/29/the-yamal-implosion.html

Anyone who claims this is all a giant misunderstanding is engaged in wishful thinking.
 
Amazing that these “unassailable institutions of higher learning and research” were so willing to call energy companies “corrupt” because they make money from producing energy. Meanwhile, they were corrupt all along, because - surprise! - they made money (through federal funding, speaking engagements, and the Oscar-winning fiction movie “An Inconvenient Truth”) from producing falsified studies so they could get more moeny to write more falsified studies, etc., etc… Not only that, they ruined the careers of people who dared pose other theories (e.g., climate change due to solar cycles; the “mini-Ice Age” of the Middle Ages; even refined computer model, ocean temperature, and core sample readings that show much lower “changes” to the point of statistical insignificance).

I believe in being a good steward of the planet God gave us (Genesis 2:15), but we are also called to seek the truth, and not settle for half-truths. “The whole truth is generally the ally of virtue; a half-truth is always the ally of some vice.” (G.K. Chesterton)

How’s that “hope and [climate] change” working for ya?
 
Oh so pointing out that words can have more then one meaning and that context is important is spin huh? Now donlt get me wrong I can understand how people would think these emails are bad news at first. The first time I saw them I thought wow…I donlt think these can be explained…However I was suspicious too it just seemed too convient that shortly before Copenhagen suddenly CRU gets hacked and a bunch of suspicious looking emails come out. I figured I would wait for the scientifc community and what not to respond before I made my judgement. And not surprisely once they responded things began to make more sense. The fact that words have different meanings…and context is important. These emails are private they aren;t talking to the public so they might use terms and phrases and shorthand that would be confusing and even misleading to someone that doesn;t know the full context of what is being spoken about.

It;s like the hide the decline comment made in that one email from I think it was Jones to Mann. Now if you looked at that without knowing the context or assuming that they meant something sneaky then yes it looks real bad. But if you look at it in context suddenly it doesn;t really look bad

** One example is worth mentioning quickly. Phil Jones in discussing the presentation of temperature reconstructions stated that “I’ve just completed Mike’s Nature trick of adding in the real temps to each series for the last 20 years (ie from 1981 onwards) and from 1961 for Keith’s to hide the decline.” The paper in question is the Mann, Bradley and Hughes (1998) Nature paper on the original multiproxy temperature reconstruction, and the ‘trick’ is just to plot the instrumental records along with reconstruction so that the context of the recent warming is clear. Scientists often use the term “trick” to refer to a “a good way to deal with a problem”, rather than something that is “secret”, and so there is nothing problematic in this at all. As for the ‘decline’, it is well known that Keith Briffa’s maximum latewood tree ring density proxy diverges from the temperature records after 1960 (this is more commonly known as the “divergence problem”–see e.g. the recent discussion in this paper) and has been discussed in the literature since Briffa et al in Nature in 1998 (Nature, 391, 678-682). Those authors have always recommend not using the post 1960 part of their reconstruction, and so while ‘hiding’ is probably a poor choice of words (since it is ‘hidden’ in plain sight), not using the data in the plot is completely appropriate, as is further research to understand why this happens.**

Also it;s too long to copy and paste but one the real climate thread the really long one not the new one posted today comment 925 talks about the FOI issue. I donlt think I have seen that brought up here yet but since I bet it will thought I would nip it in the butt Not to mention points out the fact that there large gaps in the emails making seeing the context even harder.
Bwahahahahahahahah:D
 
Should we take this information and stand against the overwhelming majority of scientists and experts and claim that ‘global climate change is a myth’?

I am not willing to do that and see nothing here that would lead me to do so.
 
CBS News:

As the leaked messages, and especially the HARRY_READ_ME.txt file, found their way around technical circles, two things happened: first, programmers unaffiliated with East Anglia started taking a close look at the quality of the CRU’s code, and second, they began to feel sympathetic for anyone who had to spend three years (including working weekends) trying to make sense of code that appeared to be undocumented and buggy, while representing the core of CRU’s climate model.

One programmer highlighted the error of relying on computer code that, if it generates an error message, continues as if nothing untoward ever occurred. Another debugged the code by pointing out why the output of a calculation that should always generate a positive number was incorrectly generating a negative one. A third concluded: “I feel for this guy. He’s obviously spent years trying to get data from undocumented and completely messy sources.”

Programmer-written comments inserted into CRU’s Fortran code have drawn fire as well. The file briffa_sep98_d.pro says: “Apply a VERY ARTIFICAL correction for decline!!” and “APPLY ARTIFICIAL CORRECTION.” Another, quantify_tsdcal.pro, says: “Low pass filtering at century and longer time scales never gets rid of the trend – so eventually I start to scale down the 120-yr low pass time series to mimic the effect of removing/adding longer time scales!”

cbsnews.com/blogs/2009/11/24/taking_liberties/entry5761180.shtml
 
Should we take this information and stand against the overwhelming majority of scientists and experts and claim that ‘global climate change is a myth’?

I am not willing to do that and see nothing here that would lead me to do so.
I’m one of those who is “on the fence” regarding the “climate crisis.” I don’t understand how you can’t take the new information and not have it influence your thinking. The emails were from climate “scientists and experts.” Why would I trust them now that their underhandedness has come to light? :confused:

Conclusions based on falsified data are false conclusions. It erodes my trust in scientists as a whole unfortunately.
 
Should we take this information and stand against the overwhelming majority of scientists and experts and claim that ‘global climate change is a myth’?

I am not willing to do that and see nothing here that would lead me to do so.
The real story is not in the emails. The files released by the interloper include extensive datasets and the code used by the scientists to form their theory of AGW. The data is worthless and corrupt. Here’s a great analysis of the situation:

devilskitchen.me.uk/2009/11/data-horribilis-harryreadmetxt-file.html

Excerpt:

With the CRU emails having been examined, it seems that some people—mainly techies—are really starting to dig into the data files. These files are, as far as we can tell, temperature data, modelling results and other such useful files, i.e. these are the files produced and worked on by the CRU teams, as well as considerable amounts of information on—and code from—the actual computer modelling programmes themselves.

In other words, these are the guts of CRU’s actual computer models—the data, the code and the applications.

And they are, by all accounts, a total bloody mess.

++++ START INSERT ++++

So, come with me on a wonderful journey as the CRU team realise that not only have they lost great chunks of data but also that their application suites and algorithms are total ****; join your humble Devil and Asimov as we dive into the HARRY_READ_ME.txt (thanks to The Englishman) file and follow the trials and tribulations of Ian “Harry” Harris as he tries to recreate the published data because he has nothing else to go on!

Thrill as he “glosses over” anomalies; let your heart sing as he gets some results to within 0.5 degrees; rejoice as Harry points out that everything is undocumented and that, generally speaking, he hasn’t got the first clue as to what’s going on with the data!

Chuckle as one of CRU’s own admits that much of the centre’s data and applications are undocumented, bug-ridden, riddled with holes, missing, uncatalogued and, in short, utterly worthless.

And wonder as you realise that this was v2.10 and that, after this utter fiasco, CRU used the synthetic data and wonky algorithms to produce v3.0!

You’ll laugh! You’ll cry! You won’t wonder why CRU never wanted to release the data! You will wonder why we are even contemplating restructuring the world economy and wasting trillions of dollars on the say-so of data this bad.

This is the real story. It needs to get out to the world and people need to be made to understand what has happened here.

Because of these files, I have gone from having a basic acceptance of AGW but questioning the need to completely re-make the world’s economy over it, to someone who now is pretty sure the whole thing really is a huge scam.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top