Do hacked e-mails show global-warming fraud?

  • Thread starter Thread starter gilliam
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Ben Stein’s film Expelled documents the scientific community’s systematic discrimination of those who subscribe to the theory of intelligent design. If there is any truth to the thesis in that film, why would it be so far-fetched that it could happen with regard to other areas as well?
 
Should we take this information and stand against the overwhelming majority of scientists and experts and claim that ‘global climate change is a myth’?

I am not willing to do that and see nothing here that would lead me to do so.
If you want to read more than one article about it, here you go:

Hackers steal electronic data from top climate research center
washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/11/20/AR2009112004093.html

Hackers leak e-mails, stoke climate debate
news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20091121/ap_on_sc/eu_climate_hacked_e_mails

Climate scientists accused of ‘manipulating global warming data’
telegraph.co.uk/earth/environment/climatechange/6619796/Climate-scientists-accused-of-manipulating-global-warming-data.html

Senator Inhofe Says He Will Call for Investigation on “Climategate” on Washington Times Americas Morning Show
epw.senate.gov/public/index.cfm?FuseAction=Minority.Blogs&ContentRecord_id=2188feb3-802a-23ad-4de4-3fbc0a92e126&Issue_id

Hiding evidence of global coolingRate this story: Junk science exposed among climate-change believers
washingtontimes.com/news/2009/nov/24/hiding-evidence-of-global-cooling/

Climategate: the final nail in the coffin of ‘Anthropogenic Global Warming’?
blogs.telegraph.co.uk/news/jamesdelingpole/100017393/climategate-the-final-nail-in-the-coffin-of-anthropogenic-global-warming/

The fact of the matter is that the “overwhelming majority” is a result of many, many other scientists being silenced and discredited simply because they did not agree with “the consensus” (which is always the rule of science: the majority is correct; disregard other, contradictory facts, e.g. the precession of Mercury, even though Newton was absolutely correct; photons acting like a wave, when they are obviously particles, etc.).

Yet, these are the same people that villainize the Catholic Church for “silencing” Galileo.
 
Along with these emails, there are a lot of computer program files which contain comments to explain what the program does. Now, emails only discuss data, but comments explain how the data is actually used by the sicneists.

It seems that there is a lot of manipulation of data, where data is tampered with in order to produce desired results.

From one file in particular:
; Apply a VERY ARTIFICAL correction for decline!!
;
yrloc=[1400,findgen(19)*5.+1904]
valadj=[0.,0.,0.,0.,0.,-0.1,-0.25,-0.3,0.,-0.1,0.3,0.8,1.2,1.7,2.5,2.6,2.6,$
2.6,2.6,2.6]*0.75 ; fudge factor
Look at the last line, the “fudge factor”. Notice that the values are not affected, then they drop, then they steadily rise. The temperature data is combined in this list of numbers in a way that makes later temperatures seem higher than they actually area.

And in another file, pl_decline.pro, we have:
;
; Now apply a completely artificial adjustment for the decline
; (only where coefficient is positive!)
;
In recon1.pro
;
; Specify period over which to compute the regressions (stop in 1940 to avoid
; the decline
;
When treating data, there should be no excuse to use ANY artificial means to hide or avoid ANY types of declines. If it’s artificial, then it’s not ACTUAL.

More can be found here:
bishophill.squarespace.com/blog/2009/11/23/the-code.html
 
One thing I stumbled on was their use of “teleconnection” trees. The studies use trees that are not affected by local temperatures, but are (they claim) driven by the the “Global Temperature Field,” that is, trees that are tele-kinetically in touch with global (not local) temperatures. Bizarre, bizarre stuff. Needless to say, this is not proven science.
 
Any one of their emails can be explained (or spun, if you like). Big picture, however, a pattern of malfeasance and unprofessional behavior emerges. Subversion of the peer-review process, data manipulation, financial shenanigans, perhaps even illegality with regards to UK’s FOI laws. The whole point of the scientific method is to produce testable hypotheses, repeatable results, and independently-validated conclusions. CRU actions covered by the released information shows that they purposely subverted this process.

Categorization of key ClimateGate emails.
ecotretas.blogspot.com/2009/11/rolo-compressor-de-verdades.html
Site is non-English, but the list is, categorizing many emails by area of malfeasance.

There is documentation of leading CRU researchers hiding data and analytical code for some 10 years. This completely subverts the scientific method. If the results of a study cannot be independently verified, it should not be considered as fact. Yet the results of unverified CRU studies were in turn used to feed other like-minded AGW studies.

It has been recently shown that (CRU’s) researcher Briffa’s study using Yamal tree-rings (that produced another hockey stick projection) was highly dependent on ONE tree, the magic YAD06.
wattsupwiththat.com/2009/10/30/yamal-treering-proxy-temperature-reconstructions-dont-match-local-thermometer-records/
climateaudit.org/?p=7241

More important, to my mind, are the comments in their forecasting model code.
They show (a) their model code is a mess, (b) the manufactured proxy data is a mess, and (c) the raw (name removed by moderator)uts are a mess.
They could not document what they had done and many times the data was referred to as garbage. There is documentation of fudging data to match published results. This absolutely invalidates results.

Professional critiques of CRU model code:
tickerforum.org/cgi-ticker/akcs-www?post=118625&page=13
(code jockey forum; starts on page 13; language can be “colorful” but it is censored)
di2.nu/blog.htm
(critique of general programming approach)

Easy to understand overviews:
The Alarmists Do “Science”: A Case Study
powerlineblog.com/archives/2009/11/024995.php

The Yamal implosion
bishophill.squarespace.com/blog/2009/9/29/the-yamal-implosion.html

Anyone who claims this is all a giant misunderstanding is engaged in wishful thinking.
 
The file briffa_sep98_d.pro says: “Apply a VERY ARTIFICAL correction for decline!!” and “APPLY ARTIFICIAL CORRECTION.”
In banking, this is known as “plugging the numbers” and can get you five years minimum in the federal pen. It matters, because it could be used to hide unsoundness or insolvency and cause a bank failure. Bank failures are bad for consumers and the economy.

So, these guys are “plugging the numbers”, the ultimate purpose of which is to cost consumers billions of dollars, and the ultimate effect is almost certainly loss of jobs.

Seems worse to me than plugging in some country bank somewhere.
 
What overwhelming majority do you speak of?

I am speaking of the overwhelming majority of scientists and climate experts

sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/01/090119210532.htm

ucsusa.org/global_warming/science_and_impacts/science/

cnn.com/2009/WORLD/americas/01/19/eco.globalwarmingsurvey/
How do I know that the other Global Warming “experts” didn’t either base their conclusions off the flawed research of others and/or use the same flawed research methods themselves? I’m sure the researchers that worked so hard to hoodwink the public also hoodwinked other scientists. 🤷
 
How do I know that the other Global Warming “experts” didn’t either base their conclusions off the flawed research of others and/or use the same flawed research methods themselves? I’m sure the researchers that worked so hard to hoodwink the public also hoodwinked other scientists. 🤷
This is apparently exactly what happened. Hadley CRU was known to have the largest datasets relating to world temperatures. Turns out much or most of this data is bad, wrong and worthless. In one of the leaked files, a CRU programmer is actually trying to reconstruct data that was lost, and he does it by converting latitude and longitude measurements into temperatures: in other words, he just made the numbers up.

The bad, fudged data used at Hadley CRU was also used by NASA and the UN’s IPCC.

This is a major, major, giant scandal; probably the biggest scandal ever in the history of science. Bigger than Galileo, bigger than Darwin.
 
Those who still believe in MMGW should volunteer to pay the government $3,000 apiece every year from now on, (the average annual cost to families if “cap and trade” becomes law) and leave the rest of us the heck alone! But I have no particular expectation that they will do either one.
 
Should we take this information and stand against the overwhelming majority of scientists and experts and claim that ‘global climate change is a myth’?

I am not willing to do that and see nothing here that would lead me to do so.
There is no “overwhelming majority,” the emails show there was ACTIVE MEASURES taken by Mann and company to block from the debate (vis-a-vis peer review, etc) those who doubt either global warming or man made global warming.

I doubted from the beginning because I’m old enough to remember the 1970s and the scare science raised about global cooling.
 
A very strongly-worded piece from Real Clear Politics:

realclearpolitics.com/articl … 99280.html

Quote:
This is an enormous case of organized scientific fraud, but it is not just scientific fraud. It is also a criminal act. Suborned by billions of taxpayer dollars devoted to climate research, dozens of prominent scientists have established a criminal racket in which they seek government money-Phil Jones has raked in a total of £13.7 million in grants from the British government-which they then use to falsify data and defraud the taxpayers. It’s the most insidious kind of fraud: a fraud in which the culprits are lauded as public heroes. Judging from this cache of e-mails, they even manage to tell themselves that their manipulation of the data is intended to protect a bigger truth and prevent it from being “confused” by inconvenient facts and uncontrolled criticism.
The damage here goes far beyond the loss of a few billions of taxpayer dollars on bogus scientific research. The real cost of this fraud is the trillions of dollars of wealth that will be destroyed if a fraudulent theory is used to justify legislation that starves the global economy of its cheapest and most abundant sources of energy.
This is the scandal of the century. It needs to be thoroughly investigated-and the culprits need to be brought to justice.
This story is really getting legs. People are starting to get very angry as it all sinks in.

It’s fascinating watching this unfold in real time.
 
A very strongly-worded piece from Real Clear Politics:

realclearpolitics.com/articl … 99280.html

Quote:
This is an enormous case of organized scientific fraud, but it is not just scientific fraud. It is also a criminal act. Suborned by billions of taxpayer dollars devoted to climate research, dozens of prominent scientists have established a criminal racket in which they seek government money-Phil Jones has raked in a total of £13.7 million in grants from the British government-which they then use to falsify data and defraud the taxpayers. It’s the most insidious kind of fraud: a fraud in which the culprits are lauded as public heroes. Judging from this cache of e-mails, they even manage to tell themselves that their manipulation of the data is intended to protect a bigger truth and prevent it from being “confused” by inconvenient facts and uncontrolled criticism.
The damage here goes far beyond the loss of a few billions of taxpayer dollars on bogus scientific research. The real cost of this fraud is the trillions of dollars of wealth that will be destroyed if a fraudulent theory is used to justify legislation that starves the global economy of its cheapest and most abundant sources of energy.
This is the scandal of the century. It needs to be thoroughly investigated-and the culprits need to be brought to justice.
This story is really getting legs. People are starting to get very angry as it all sinks in.

It’s fascinating watching this unfold in real time.
 
Amazing that these “unassailable institutions of higher learning and research” were so willing to call energy companies “corrupt” because they make money from producing energy. Meanwhile, they were corrupt all along, because - surprise! - they made money (through federal funding, speaking engagements, and the Oscar-winning fiction movie “An Inconvenient Truth”) from producing falsified studies so they could get more money to write more falsified studies, etc., etc… Not only that, they ruined the careers of people who dared pose other theories (e.g., climate change due to solar cycles; the “mini-Ice Age” of the Middle Ages; even refined computer model, ocean temperature, and core sample readings that show much lower “changes” to the point of statistical insignificance).

I believe in being a good steward of the planet God gave us (Genesis 2:15), but we are also called to seek the truth, and not settle for half-truths. “The whole truth is generally the ally of virtue; a half-truth is always the ally of some vice.” (G.K. Chesterton)

How’s that “hope and [climate] change” working for ya?
The point about scientists being swayed by financial interests is a strong one.

This could be a very crippling blow to the stature of scientists in general. As it becomes more and more apparent to everybody that the apocalyptic prophecies of science are a farce, science itself will no longer be in a position of arbiter of truth.
 
I can only hope that the hopelessly disorganised Opposition here in Australia gets on board with this soon. Proposed ETS legislation is currently being debated in Parliament. The latest news story indicates that the scheme will add $1,100 to the average family’s annual bills.

To have these kinds of increases to combat a non-existant crisis is criminal.

Yes, we should invest in alternate energy sources. Oil and gas will run out or become increasingly difficult to extract. Yes, we should encourage people to invest in their own power production. We had such a scheme here in Australia in which the government was offering $8,000 rebate on installing a solar power generator on your roof. Then, the unions got involved and put a means test on it, essentially killing it in its tracks. Those whose incomes fell under the cut-off did not have enough money to install the things in the first place and $8K was only about half the price. We’d’ve been in it in a flash, had we qualified for the rebate. There was even a provision for selling our excess power back to the grid. Then, they wondered why very few people took up the offer.

Yes, we should take care of the environment. Recycle, Re-use. Man has always done this except for the last 60 years or so when we became a ‘disposable’ civilisation. Everything is made to wear out and be replaced. Nothing is being made to last.

We should not waste our resources, but the ETS or Cap and Trade is all smoke and mirrors.
 
Not more of this … seriously cherry picking emails then screaming conspiracy and ignoring context doesn;t prove or even provide half way decent evidence of some vast conspiracy. I mean these aren;t even all the emails and likely not all the documents either. So we are most definately not getting the whole picture not by a long shot.

Anyway Phil Jones makes a response in this piece. guardian.co.uk/environment/2009/nov/24/climate-professor-leaked-emails-uea And as he points out the CRU isn;t the only source of climate data.

And another response from the university of East Anglia uea.ac.uk/mac/comm/media/press/2009/nov/homepagenews/CRUupdate

Oh and looks like this guy has gone through many of the emails that are being cited as proof of wrongdoing…reddit.com/r/science/comments/a6zdw/summary_of_notable_emails_from_the_cru_hacking
 
Not more of this… seriously cherry picking emails then screaming conspiracy and ignoring context doesn;t prove or even provide half way decent evidence of some vast conspiracy. I mean these aren;t even all the emails and likely not all the documents either. So we are most definately not getting the whole picture not by a long shot.

Anyway Phil Jones makes a response in this piece. guardian.co.uk/environment/2009/nov/24/climate-professor-leaked-emails-uea And as he points out the CRU isn;t the only source of climate data.

And another response from the university of East Anglia uea.ac.uk/mac/comm/media/press/2009/nov/homepagenews/CRUupdate

Oh and looks like this guy has gone through many of the emails that are being cited as proof of wrongdoing…reddit.com/r/science/comments/a6zdw/summary_of_notable_emails_from_the_cru_hacking
I agree. I’m sure we are not getting the whole picture. There’s probably much more that these “scientists” have been faking. I certainly don’t trust their responses to be truthful.
 
[SIGN][/SIGN]
Oh and looks like this guy has gone through many of the emails that are being cited as proof of wrongdoing…reddit.com/r/science/comments/a6zdw/summary_of_notable_emails_from_the_cru_hacking
You need to step back and look at this objectively. Do your own research.

I looked at precisely two issues that were disclaimed by the reddit poster:

1 - Phil Jones asking others to delete emails subject to FOI

The Reddit poster denies that FOI is even mentioned, but yes Jones is doing precisely that. Just look at the e-mail subject line:
Subject: Re: IPCC & FOI
Jones is asking the “hockey team” to delete emails in the context of FOI related to the IPCC’s AR4 report that CRU had managed.
eastangliaemails.com/emails.php?eid=891&filename=1212063122.txt

2 - “Hide the decline”

The “decline” is the near-term divergence between proxy trends and reality.
The reddit poster glosses over this by parroting the RealClimate line: all that is happening is that better data is being used to replace problem data. Sounds harmless, even good, right? In reality it is a problem. The entire point of these CRU studies is to build temperature proxies. The claim is that they accurately represent (proximate) reality. However, if they are wildly divergent from known reality, if the best proxies don’t match the best instrumentation, what do you have?

Scientists, real scientists, have an obligation to disclose this. CRU (Jones, specifically, and by extension, the scientists he discussed it with) did not. Instead, Jones specifically used an inappropriate technique to make their research look more consistent, upward-trending, (and alarming) than it was. Letting the graph go out mislabeled and unexplained is not good and, IMHO, fraudulent.

Furthermore, if the proxies are inaccurate in the near-term (if you can call the last 40-50 years “near-term”), what does that say for their proximation of the distant past? Their ENTIRE thesis is that we had unprecedented warming in the last decades of the 20th century. Did we? How reliable are the proxies? Apparently bad enough that Jones felt the need to cover up the problems. And since the proxies are bad for the last 40-50 years, what confidence should be placed in their ability to characterize the present, let alone their forecasting abilities? And the critiques of CRU suggest even more problems than this having to do with CRU’s proxy screening, data smoothing, and trend matching methodologies. And don’t even get me started on their data management and coding problems.
climateaudit.org/?p=7810

The reddit poster’s “rationalization” is just that, a rationalization. He’s being disingenuous.
 
Not just ONE or TWO emails.

THOUSANDS of emails.

Read them.

Deliberate conspiracy by scientists, politicians, academia and news media.

What would now be appropriate are two things:
  1. a RICO investigation and prosecution.
  2. absolute distrust in these groups of people. We cannot believe anything they say.
Consider that for YEARS they refused to share their data, even though it was paid for by the taxpayers.

These guys (and gals) attempted to cover their tracks for YEARS.

And now the whole sordid mess is blown for the whole world to see.

We now need to go back and take a look at the Ozone Hole hoax, as well.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racketeer_Influenced_and_Corrupt_Organizations_Act

Read this and also do more research about bringing these “people” before Federal Grand Juries.

ricoact.com/
 
Not more of this …, seriously cherry picking emails then screaming conspiracy and ignoring context doesn;t prove or even provide half way decent evidence of some vast conspiracy.
Myself and other programmers have looked at the actual program files used by the scientists.

Take a look at the top post here. It shows how one program uses 20 numbers to manipulate temperatures over 100 years, in 5-year periods.

bishophill.squarespace.com/blog/2009/11/23/the-code.html?currentPage=3#comments

This is just one of dozens of examples. Other programmers have noted that these programs often IGNORE data that produces errors, when a good program would STOP and admit there’s an error, instead of acting as if it doesn’t exist.

When programs ignore data that causes errors, it completely undermines the scientific method, because when decent scientists verify the results with their own programs, they will NEVER get the same results because their programs never IGNORED any data.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top