[SIGN][/SIGN]
Oh and looks like this guy has gone through many of the emails that are being cited as proof of wrongdoing…
reddit.com/r/science/comments/a6zdw/summary_of_notable_emails_from_the_cru_hacking
You need to step back and look at this objectively. Do your own research.
I looked at precisely two issues that were disclaimed by the reddit poster:
1 - Phil Jones asking others to delete emails subject to FOI
The Reddit poster denies that FOI is even mentioned, but yes Jones is doing precisely that. Just look at the e-mail subject line:
Subject: Re: IPCC & FOI
Jones is asking the “hockey team” to delete emails in the context of FOI related to the IPCC’s AR4 report that CRU had managed.
eastangliaemails.com/emails.php?eid=891&filename=1212063122.txt
2 - “Hide the decline”
The “decline” is the near-term divergence between proxy trends and reality.
The reddit poster glosses over this by parroting the RealClimate line: all that is happening is that better data is being used to replace problem data. Sounds harmless, even good, right? In reality it is a problem. The entire point of these CRU studies is to build temperature proxies. The claim is that they accurately represent (proximate) reality. However, if they are wildly divergent from known reality, if the best proxies don’t match the best instrumentation, what do you have?
Scientists, real scientists, have an obligation to disclose this. CRU (Jones, specifically, and by extension, the scientists he discussed it with) did not. Instead, Jones specifically used an inappropriate technique to make their research look more consistent, upward-trending, (and alarming) than it was. Letting the graph go out mislabeled and unexplained is not good and, IMHO, fraudulent.
Furthermore, if the proxies are inaccurate in the near-term (if you can call the last 40-50 years “near-term”), what does that say for their proximation of the distant past? Their ENTIRE thesis is that we had unprecedented warming in the last decades of the 20th century. Did we? How reliable are the proxies? Apparently bad enough that Jones felt the need to cover up the problems. And since the proxies are bad for the last 40-50 years, what confidence should be placed in their ability to characterize the present, let alone their forecasting abilities? And the critiques of CRU suggest even more problems than this having to do with CRU’s proxy screening, data smoothing, and trend matching methodologies. And don’t even get me started on their data management and coding problems.
climateaudit.org/?p=7810
The reddit poster’s “rationalization” is just that, a rationalization. He’s being disingenuous.