Do hacked e-mails show global-warming fraud?

  • Thread starter Thread starter gilliam
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Came across this one last night. Looks into the code and data. Simple to understand:

Alarmists Hide Truth About (Lack Of) Global Warming
strata-sphere.com/blog/index.php/archives/11420
Discusses the claimed accuracy of the data.

How To Hide Global Cooling: Delete The “1940’s Blip”
strata-sphere.com/blog/index.php/archives/11466
Discusses the unpublished temp-by-country data (which does not show warming) and the “artificial” upward adjustments applied in the computer code.

Devastating if true.
 
Q: How many climate scientists does it take to change a light bulb?
A: None. There’s a consensus that it’s going to change, so they’ve decided to keep us in the dark.

JAMES TARANTO Wall Street Journal
 
MEGAN MCARDLE: The Real Problem With the Climate Science Emails. “I think most people–including me–missed the biggest part of the climate emails story. Sexing up a graph is at best a misdemeanor. But a Declan McCullough story suggests a more disturbing possibility: the CRU’s main computer model may be, to put it bluntly, complete rubbish. . . . That is a big problem. The IPCC report, which is the most widely relied upon in policy circles, uses this model to estimate the costs of global warming. If those costs are unreliable, then any cost-benefit analysis is totally worthless. Obviously, this also casts their reluctance to conform with FOI requests in a slightly different light.”

Scientist in climate change ‘cover-up’ storm told to quit… tinyurl.com/yhvxoqp
 
From an unamed poster at National Reviews “The Corner”:

I followed with interest your interchange about the recent developments
concerning global warming research. I thought John’s point that there will
always be contrarians in any scientific discipline, and that in general it
is likely that the consensus position has more validity than the
contrarian one, is a valid one. Given the recent events, though, it seems
to me that we need to develop methods that can alert us to situations
where the consensus position is faulty. In the case of climate research,
there were numerous such clues that were available five or more years ago
which should have made people look much more carefully at the consensus.
Here are some red flags in the behavior of mainstream scientists that
could be used as prompts for examining more carefully the consensus
position.

(1) Consistent use of ad hominem attacks toward those challenging their
positions.

(2) Refusal to make data public. This has been going on in this area for
some time.

(3) Refusal to engage in discussions of the actual science, on the
assumption that it is too complicated for others to understand.

(4) Challenging the credentials of those challenging the consensus position.

(5) Refusal to make computer code being used to analyze the data public.
This has been particularly egregious here, and clear statements of the
mathematics and statistics being employed would have allowed the
conclusions to be challenged at a much earlier stage.

If one believes in the science one is doing, one should be willing to go
to great lengths to engage those who challenge it or fail to understand
it, and provide various explanations at various levels of technical
detail, rather than attempt to discredit others.
 
This is rich:

Original Filename: 1136918726.txt
From: Tom Wigley
To: Keith Briffa
Subject: Re: Nature: Review of manuscript 2xxx xxxx xxxx
Date: Tue, 10 Jan 2006 13:45:xxx xxxx xxxx
There are some problems still. I note that 1032 is not cold in Yamal.
Seems odd. Is it cold in all of the three chronologies at issue?
Or did a reindeer cr*p next to one of the trees?
(scatalogical term censored)

The problem is they don’t (and can’t) know what happened. Was it a reindeer? Or did a nearby tree fall over? Or was it a particularly wet year? Or did local drainage change? Or any number of other factors. Thus the problem with semi-fossilized trees that are a thousand years old. Their use of tree-ring data as temperature proxies is so bad that they don’t see the Medieval Warming Periond (MWP) and the Little Ice Age (LIA). They knew it was a problem and began to actually claim that these two significant temperature events actually hadn’t occurred. In other words, they were trying to force the data to fit their “hypothesis” (if you can call it that).

Which graph is real:
http://tucsoncitizen.com/wryheat/files/2009/11/Battle-of-graphs1.jpg
 
[SIGN][/SIGN]

You need to step back and look at this objectively. Do your own research.

I looked at precisely two issues that were disclaimed by the reddit poster:

1 - Phil Jones asking others to delete emails subject to FOI

The Reddit poster denies that FOI is even mentioned, but yes Jones is doing precisely that. Just look at the e-mail subject line:
Subject: Re: IPCC & FOI
Jones is asking the “hockey team” to delete emails in the context of FOI related to the IPCC’s AR4 report that CRU had managed.
eastangliaemails.com/emails.php?eid=891&filename=1212063122.txt

2 - “Hide the decline”

The “decline” is the near-term divergence between proxy trends and reality.
The reddit poster glosses over this by parroting the RealClimate line: all that is happening is that better data is being used to replace problem data. Sounds harmless, even good, right? In reality it is a problem. The entire point of these CRU studies is to build temperature proxies. The claim is that they accurately represent (proximate) reality. However, if they are wildly divergent from known reality, if the best proxies don’t match the best instrumentation, what do you have?

Scientists, real scientists, have an obligation to disclose this. CRU (Jones, specifically, and by extension, the scientists he discussed it with) did not. Instead, Jones specifically used an inappropriate technique to make their research look more consistent, upward-trending, (and alarming) than it was. Letting the graph go out mislabeled and unexplained is not good and, IMHO, fraudulent.

Furthermore, if the proxies are inaccurate in the near-term (if you can call the last 40-50 years “near-term”), what does that say for their proximation of the distant past? Their ENTIRE thesis is that we had unprecedented warming in the last decades of the 20th century. Did we? How reliable are the proxies? Apparently bad enough that Jones felt the need to cover up the problems. And since the proxies are bad for the last 40-50 years, what confidence should be placed in their ability to characterize the present, let alone their forecasting abilities? And the critiques of CRU suggest even more problems than this having to do with CRU’s proxy screening, data smoothing, and trend matching methodologies. And don’t even get me started on their data management and coding problems.
climateaudit.org/?p=7810

The reddit poster’s “rationalization” is just that, a rationalization. He’s being disingenuous.
As I understand though nothing was actually deleted. He may have sent that email and haste and one could argue he shouldn;t have said that. But as I understand it nothing was deleted. But as I understand it in many cases they CAN:T give people the the raw data because they do not own it. Then there is the fact that much of the data is already available. But the reddit guy and yes me I guess should have read that email clearer.

Also on the decline and proxy thing…it is important to note that tree rings aren;t the only way to do a temperature proxy.ncdc.noaa.gov/paleo/recons.html But of course research needs to be done as to why we see that decline after 1960 happenswith tree rings. Though according to this is sounds like it may not be a problem with all tree ring records…or our data got better well read for yourself. realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2008/09/progress-in-millennial-reconstructions/

And are you talking about the Harryreadme file? If so that was addressed in the updated realclimate post

**HARRY_read_me.txt. This is a 4 year-long work log of Ian (Harry) Harris who was working to upgrade the documentation, metadata and databases associated with the legacy CRU TS 2.1 product, which is not the same as the HadCRUT data (see Mitchell and Jones, 2003 for details). The CSU TS 3.0 is available now (via ClimateExplorer for instance), and so presumably the database problems got fixed. Anyone who has ever worked on constructing a database from dozens of individual, sometimes contradictory and inconsistently formatted datasets will share his evident frustration with how tedious that can be. **
source of quote : realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2009/11/the-cru-hack-context/
So that seems to explain why that data looked like such a mess or so at least that I think is what I have been hearing people saying as I haven;t looked at the file myself. I donlt know enough about climate science at this point that I would trust myself to just look at raw data and know whether it was good or bad
More stuff in the link as well.

Of course we could throw out all the data from these guys and still have more then enough evidence for a solid theory of MMGW. As this university and the scientists involved in these emails certainly arenlt the only ones doing climate research.
 
Of course we could throw out all the data from these guys and still have more then enough evidence for a solid theory of MMGW. As this university and the scientists involved in these emails certainly arenlt the only ones doing climate research.
You mean we should listen to the ones who haven’t been caught yet?
 
This is rich:

Original Filename: 1136918726.txt

(scatalogical term censored)

The problem is they don’t (and can’t) know what happened. Was it a reindeer? Or did a nearby tree fall over? Or was it a particularly wet year? Or did local drainage change? Or any number of other factors. Thus the problem with semi-fossilized trees that are a thousand years old. Their use of tree-ring data as temperature proxies is so bad that they don’t see the Medieval Warming Periond (MWP) and the Little Ice Age (LIA). They knew it was a problem and began to actually claim that these two significant temperature events actually hadn’t occurred. In other words, they were trying to force the data to fit their “hypothesis” (if you can call it that).

Which graph is real:
Tucson Citizen - The Voice of Tucson
I actually haven;t seen any climate scientist claims that the mediveil warming period and the mini ice age didn;t exist. They are just not the big hump dip in more recent constructions as they were in old one(s).

And that bottom graph seems to only be about Europe are both the graphes only about European temperatures? But as I understand it that bottom graph is an old graph that mainly used data from northern europe a lot of it from central England. youtube.com/user/greenman3610#p/u/17/vrKfz8NjEzU
 
As I understand though nothing was actually deleted. He may have sent that email and haste and one could argue he shouldn;t have said that. But as I understand it nothing was deleted. But as I understand it in many cases they CAN:T give people the the raw data because they do not own it. Then there is the fact that much of the data is already available. But the reddit guy and yes me I guess should have read that email clearer.
You need to read more for yourself and stop listening to the spin. In another e-mail, Jones brags about how much of his e-mail he has deleted (or at least tried to… another indication he doesn’t have a clue about computers).

eastangliaemails.com/emails.php?eid=940&filename=1228330629.txt
Phil Jones, Dec 3, 2008:
About 2 months ago I deleted loads of emails, so have very little – if anything at all.
And this is AFTER the FOI requests came in. That they are saying “nothing was deleted” is a parsed legal statement that says nothing about their intent or their actions.
 
Not just ONE or TWO emails.

THOUSANDS of emails.

Read them.

Deliberate conspiracy by scientists, politicians, academia and news media.

What would now be appropriate are two things:
  1. a RICO investigation and prosecution.
  2. absolute distrust in these groups of people. We cannot believe anything they say.
Consider that for YEARS they refused to share their data, even though it was paid for by the taxpayers.

These guys (and gals) attempted to cover their tracks for YEARS.

And now the whole sordid mess is blown for the whole world to see.

We now need to go back and take a look at the Ozone Hole hoax, as well.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racketeer_Influenced_and_Corrupt_Organizations_Act

Read this and also do more research about bringing these “people” before Federal Grand Juries.

ricoact.com/
There is no strong evidence heck not even weak evidence that they tried to cover up anything. About the worse thing in those emails are a couple apparently hastely sent emails talking about deleting stuff related to FOI requests. And as I understand it nothing was ever deleted. Also it is important to understand some data LEGALLY they CANNOT give up as they do not own it and our under agreement not to release it. So the pressure shouldn;t be on them but on the metrological community to be more open with the data.

From real climate

**This comment from Halldór Björnsson of the Icelandic Met. Service goes right to the heart of the accessibility issue:

Re: CRU data accessibility.

National Meteorological Services (NMSs) have different rules on data exchange. The World Meteorological Organization (WMO) organizes the exchange of “basic data”, i.e. data that are needed for weather forecasts. For details on these see WMO resolution number 40 (see bit.ly/8jOjX1).

This document acknowledges that WMO member states can place restrictions on the dissemination of data to third parties “for reasons such as national laws or costs of production”. These restrictions are only supposed to apply to commercial use, the research and education community is supposed to have free access to all the data.

Now, for researchers this sounds open and fine. In practice it hasn’t proved to be so.

Most NMSs also can distribute all sorts of data that are classified as “additional data and products”. Restrictions can be placed on these. These special data and products (which can range from regular weather data from a specific station to maps of rain intensity based on satellite and radar data). Many nations do place restrictions on such data (see link for additional data on above WMO-40 webpage for details).

The reasons for restricting access is often commercial, NMSs are often required by law to have substantial income from commercial sources, in other cases it can be for national security reasons, but in many cases (in my experience) the reasons simply seem to be “because we can”.

What has this got to do with CRU? The data that CRU needs for their data base comes from entities that restrict access to much of their data. And even better, since the UK has submitted an exception for additional data, some nations that otherwise would provide data without question will not provide data to the UK. I know this from experience, since my nation (Iceland) did send in such conditions and for years I had problem getting certain data from the US.

The ideal, that all data should be free and open is unfortunately not adhered to by a large portion of the meteorological community. Probably only a small portion of the CRU data is “locked” but the end effect is that all their data becomes closed. It is not their fault, and I am sure that they dislike them as much as any other researcher who has tried to get access to all data from stations in region X in country Y.

These restrictions end up by wasting resources and hurting everyone. The research community (CRU included) and the public are the victims. If you don’t like it, write to you NMSs and urge them to open all their data. **

Now I do think there should be an investigation. Not because anything bad was done but because it will likely be necessary now to clear up their names.
 
Also on the decline and proxy thing…it is important to note that tree rings aren;t the only way to do a temperature proxy. ncdc.noaa.gov/paleo/recons.html But of course research needs to be done as to why we see that decline after 1960 happens with tree rings.
Do you understand that the ONLY reason that the proxies match the temperature records is that CRU made them match? Proxies are proxies only if they match a physical phenomenom reliably, predictably. If I have to throw out proxy chronologies for no other reason than they do not match a physical phenomenom, they they are not good proxies. I can get the same result with random data (no relation to the physical phenomenom). I just throw out any series that don’t match a pattern and voila, “proxy” series that match, except it has no relationship to the physical phenomenom and has no predictive capability. It just happens to closely mimic the measurement data for a particular length of time.

They can make it sound like they were replacing poor data with better data, but they were effectively hiding the poor qualiy of their proxies.

I have to run. I’ll adddress your other points later.
 
You need to read more for yourself and stop listening to the spin. In another e-mail, Jones brags about how much of his e-mail he has deleted (or at least tried to… another indication he doesn’t have a clue about computers).

eastangliaemails.com/emails.php?eid=940&filename=1228330629.txt

And this is AFTER the FOI requests came in. That they are saying “nothing was deleted” is a parsed legal statement that says nothing about their intent or their actions.
Yes but those emails could have been anything. Finicial records silly jokes sent to him by colleages blah blah blah you name it not just climate data and what not . I read that email over and over again and saw nothing to indicate that he is saying well I deleted all those emails related to this FOI request 2 monthes ago! It simply sounds like he is saying he deleted some emails. But I guess I should be more specific from what it sounds like and I admit I don;t know for sure No info specifically related to FOI requests and the like was purposely deleted . But really that email(s) you linked too is rather vague and doesn;t really say what he deleted. But of course one could argue that even talking about deleting such emails isn;t smart. But talking of it certainly isn;t proof that any such deletions took place. But of course things like this is likely why an investigation will have to take place to clear names.
 
Do you understand that the ONLY reason that the proxies match the temperature records is that CRU made them match? Proxies are proxies only if they match a physical phenomenom reliably, predictably. If I have to throw out proxy chronologies for no other reason than they do not match a physical phenomenom, they they are not good proxies. I can get the same result with random data (no relation to the physical phenomenom). I just throw out any series that don’t match a pattern and voila, “proxy” series that match, except it has no relationship to the physical phenomenom and has no predictive capability. It just happens to closely mimic the measurement data for a particular length of time.

They can make it sound like they were replacing poor data with better data, but they were effectively hiding the poor qualiy of their proxies.

I have to run. I’ll adddress your other points later.
As I understand it the CRU involved in this email hack didn;t do all those reconstructions. Also since I made my last post I found this post.desmogblog.com/michael-mann-his-own-words-stolen-cru-emails

The “decline” refers to a well-known decline in the response of only a certain type of tree-ring data (high-latitude tree-ring density measurements collected by Briffa and colleagues) to temperatures after about 1960.

So it really does sound like it is only specific tree ring data. But the point of showing you the link of reconstructions is to show that not all of it relies on tree ring data.

But really I guess without reading more on the subject I cannot say why for instance they feel that the tree ring data with the divergence problem is ok to use before 1960 but not after. But I guess that is one reason why it is good to have more then one source of reconstruction data. So we test them against each other and what not.

But I found this comment and it sounds like it brings up much of the concerns you are about the reliablity of constructions Gavins response doesn;t say much but you might want to read it. realclimate.org/?comments_popup=2019#comment-144869
 
Yes but those emails could have been anything. Finicial records silly jokes sent to him by colleages blah blah blah you name it not just climate data and what not . I read that email over and over again and saw nothing to indicate that he is saying well I deleted all those emails related to this FOI request 2 monthes ago! It simply sounds like he is saying he deleted some emails. But I guess I should be more specific from what it sounds like and I admit I don;t know for sure No info specifically related to FOI requests and the like was purposely deleted . But really that email(s) you linked too is rather vague and doesn;t really say what he deleted. But of course one could argue that even talking about deleting such emails isn;t smart. But talking of it certainly isn;t proof that any such deletions took place. But of course things like this is likely why an investigation will have to take place to clear names.
That is funny, funny stuff. I urge all readers of this thread to click the link to read the Phil Jones e-mail for themselves. It is a relatively long e-mail entirely devoted to strategies for avoiding compliance with requests for information (in particular, e-mails) under UK’s “Freedom of Information” (FOI) act, UK’s “Environmental Information Regulations” (EIR) statutes, and UK’s “Data Protection Act” and the headaches the “team” was experiencing from the many requests. Right in the middle of it Jones makes his statement about having “deleted loads of emails” in reference to a particular information request.

Jones said he deleted them. I take him at his word.

If they weren’t deleted, apparently it wasn’t for lack of his trying.
 
As I understand it the CRU involved in this email hack didn;t do all those reconstructions. Also since I made my last post I found this post.desmogblog.com/michael-mann-his-own-words-stolen-cru-emails

The “decline” refers to a well-known decline in the response of only a certain type of tree-ring data (high-latitude tree-ring density measurements collected by Briffa and colleagues) to temperatures after about 1960.

So it really does sound like it is only specific tree ring data. But the point of showing you the link of reconstructions is to show that not all of it relies on tree ring data.

But really I guess without reading more on the subject I cannot say why for instance they feel that the tree ring data with the divergence problem is ok to use before 1960 but not after. But I guess that is one reason why it is good to have more then one source of reconstruction data. So we test them against each other and what not.

But I found this comment and it sounds like it brings up much of the concerns you are about the reliablity of constructions Gavins response doesn;t say much but you might want to read it. realclimate.org/?comments_popup=2019#comment-144869
Read my post again. They are blowing smoke at you. They had to hide the decline. Their proxies are little better than noise. Their “calibration” period (really just curve matching) ended in 1960 and the proxies immediately diverged from measured reality, just the same same as noise would. If they did not hide the decline, the fact that the proxies are non-predictive would be obvious. And it would immediately call into question their historical backcast as well. The notion that the 90s were the hottest ever relies heavily on these reconstructions that are now known to be meaningless.

And in the second link note that Gavin says he “could argue” the point but doesn’t. Instead he says they have new series that are newly calibrated. It doesn’t matter. The proxies are non-predictive and will begin to diverge immediately past the calibration period.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top