Free will and foreknowledge revisited

  • Thread starter Thread starter Confessor01
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I also have another question, Confessor. David committed the sins of adultery and murder. So you don’t believe David freely chose to sin?

God Bless,
Michael
I deny that he had free will, not that he freely chose to sin.
So let me get this straight. God creates all of us, therefor he is responsible for how we interpret things. He creates someone who doesnt interpret the evidence of his existence to be enough proof. Then he gives them the most painful punishment you can imagine for all eternity because of this.
It is not true that “God creates all of us, therefor he is responsible for how we interpret things.” This is to ask the same thing asked in Romans 9:19.

Otherwise, it would be better to take what the Bible says on its own authority; therefore when the Bible says that “11 For this reason God sends them a powerful delusion so that they will believe the lie 12 and so that all will be condemned who have not believed the truth but have delighted in wickedness,” (2 Thess. 2:11-12), you better not say God is doing something wrong.
 
:hmmm: I never liked Physics. That’s why I majored in History! 😛

Now how does this relate to God “containing” evil within Himself? I’m trying to make the connection.

God Bless,
Michael
Since causes must contain their effects in some way, it follows that God, being the creator of the entire world ex nihilo, must contain evil in Himself in some sense.

Of course, I outright repudiate the concept that God has any evil in His nature; hence it is the “problem” of evil. It’s an oddity. But my entire point is that this is not somehow only a Calvinistic problem. It’s a paradox that exists in Roman Catholicism as well.
 
What’s the differebce between freely chosing and free will?

Thanks and God Bless,
Michael
Discussions involving Calvinism always have a nasty penchant to reduce to discussions over the nature of freedom, so I have already written about this several times. Please tell me whatever questions you may have after seeing the following posts:

forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=5447596&postcount=19

forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=5421921&postcount=25

forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=5431034&postcount=41
 
From the other thread:
Confessor01 said:
There is a sense in which we choose our desires, but ultimately speaking, we do not – that is, if we do end up choosing some specific desire or inclination, it is only because our decision was caused by some pre-existing desire or inclination.
 
I deny that he had free will, not that he freely chose to sin.

It is not true that “God creates all of us, therefor he is responsible for how we interpret things.” This is to ask the same thing asked in Romans 9:19.

Otherwise, it would be better to take what the Bible says on its own authority; therefore when the Bible says that “11 For this reason God sends them a powerful delusion so that they will believe the lie 12 and so that all will be condemned who have not believed the truth but have delighted in wickedness,” (2 Thess. 2:11-12), you better not say God is doing something wrong.
All I got out of this is God makes people believe a lie with delusion and then condemns them to hell.

and

you better not say God is doing something wrong.

I dont see how this means anything. If you take the time and build a human being from head to toe, designing everything in our brain that controls the thought process, then you are responsible for the thought process of your creation.
 
Since causes must contain their effects in some way, it follows that God, being the creator of the entire world ex nihilo, must contain evil in Himself in some sense.

Of course, I outright repudiate the concept that God has any evil in His nature; hence it is the “problem” of evil. It’s an oddity. But my entire point is that this is not somehow only a Calvinistic problem. It’s a paradox that exists in Roman Catholicism as well.
What is the nature of evil? Do you believe evil is the absence of good?

God Bless,
Michael
 
Discussions involving Calvinism always have a nasty penchant to reduce to discussions over the nature of freedom, so I have already written about this several times. Please tell me whatever questions you may have after seeing the following posts:

forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=5447596&postcount=19

forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=5421921&postcount=25

forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=5431034&postcount=41
Thank you for the posts. Perhaps you can explain something to me. We act on our desires. A Christian, for example, can have conflicting desires (i.e. the desire to obey God and the desire to commit a sin/ temptation). A Christian can and does act on the desire to sin. Are you saying that a Christian who sins could not do otherwise but sin?

God Bless,
Michael
 
All I got out of this is God makes people believe a lie with delusion and then condemns them to hell.

and

you better not say God is doing something wrong.

I dont see how this means anything. If you take the time and build a human being from head to toe, designing everything in our brain that controls the thought process, then you are responsible for the thought process of your creation.
If you have a problem with what the Bible says, then I can’t really do anything about that. (Are you Catholic?)

If you think I’m somehow misinterpreting 2 Thessalonians 2:11-12, then please say so.
 
If you have a problem with what the Bible says, then I can’t really do anything about that. (Are you Catholic?)

If you think I’m somehow misinterpreting 2 Thessalonians 2:11-12, then please say so.
I am an atheist. That was just the way I interpreted. I dont know which way you interpreted it.
 
Thank you for the posts. Perhaps you can explain something to me. We act on our desires. A Christian, for example, can have conflicting desires (i.e. the desire to obey God and the desire to commit a sin/ temptation). A Christian can and does act on the desire to sin. Are you saying that a Christian who sins could not do otherwise but sin?

God Bless,
Michael
A Christian who sins could do otherwise only in a counterfactual sense, i.e., if his desires were different.

Ultimately, the problem with the “free will” position is that it refuses to allow one’s unchosen desires to sway the person’s choice, but in that case the choice must have a pure “liberty of indifference” – in which case all his acts are perforce arbitrary, and morality is destroyed. (This is about as brief an argument against free will as I can state it.)
 
A Christian who sins could do otherwise only in a counterfactual sense, i.e., if his desires were different.

Ultimately, the problem with the “free will” position is that it refuses to allow one’s unchosen desires to sway the person’s choice, but in that case the choice must have a pure “liberty of indifference” – in which case all his acts are perforce arbitrary, and morality is destroyed. (This is about as brief an argument against free will as I can state it.)
Are you sure you are only 19?
 
I am an atheist. That was just the way I interpreted. I dont know which way you interpreted it.
Oh, my bad. I thought you were Catholic.

Anyway, there’s no problem with this if you understand morality and determinism, and namely how the former implies the latter – that is, not only how morality does not need free will, but also how morality precludes free will. If you analyze your experience briefly, you will realize that you always perform actions because you want to do them. If you also realize that you do not choose what you want, then you can see how both (1) you are responsible for your actions, and (2) you couldn’t do otherwise.

As a result, even if God is in sovereign control of people’s hearts, such that their desires can be altered at His fiat, it follows that people are still responsible for their actions. Even if He’s sovereign over an influence that leads to the people’s delusions, they are still responsible.

Sounds odd? Sure. But it doesn’t contradict experience, while the free-willist model does.
 
A Christian who sins could do otherwise only in a counterfactual sense, i.e., if his desires were different.

Ultimately, the problem with the “free will” position is that it refuses to allow one’s unchosen desires to sway the person’s choice, but in that case the choice must have a pure “liberty of indifference” – in which case all his acts are perforce arbitrary, and morality is destroyed. (This is about as brief an argument against free will as I can state it.)
But I think that prior to sinning, a Christian often experiences conflicting desires and has the ability to resist temptation. Why does one Christian resist temptation and another one falls into temptation and sins? And how do you explain the following passage:

1 Corinthians 10:13

13No temptation has overtaken you but such as is common to man; and God is faithful, who will not allow you to be tempted beyond what you are able, but with the temptation will provide the way of escape also, so that you will be able to endure it.

Aren’t Christians given sufficient grace to resist temptation? Our desires may be unchosen, but acting upon those desires is a choice.

God Bless,
Michael
 
Oh, my bad. I thought you were Catholic.

Anyway, there’s no problem with this if you understand morality and determinism, and namely how the former implies the latter – that is, not only how morality does not need free will, but also how morality precludes free will. If you analyze your experience briefly, you will realize that you always perform actions because you want to do them. If you also realize that you do not choose what you want, then you can see how both (1) you are responsible for your actions, and (2) you couldn’t do otherwise.

As a result, even if God is in sovereign control of people’s hearts, such that their desires can be altered at His fiat, it follows that people are still responsible for their actions. Even if He’s sovereign over an influence that leads to the people’s delusions, they are still responsible.

Sounds odd? Sure. But it doesn’t contradict experience, while the free-willist model does.
I think you are implying that just because God made me want to cheat on my wife it doesnt mean its not my fault that I do it?

But you have to understand that God also made our ability to reason. If he didnt give us the ability to reason that cheating on your wife is not worth it then its still his fault.

Basically, because our brain controls everything we do, whatever created our brain and programmed how it functions is responsible for what it does.
 
But I think that prior to sinning, a Christian often experiences conflicting desires and has the ability to resist temptation. Why does one Christian resist temptation and another one falls into temptation and sins? And how do you explain the following passage:

1 Corinthians 10:13

13No temptation has overtaken you but such as is common to man; and God is faithful, who will not allow you to be tempted beyond what you are able, but with the temptation will provide the way of escape also, so that you will be able to endure it.

Aren’t Christians given sufficient grace to resist temptation? Our desires may be unchosen, but acting upon those desires is a choice.

God Bless,
Michael
That passage would show that in all instances there is some type of ability to do otherwise, and again I declare that it is counterfactual. There is no situation in which we have no counterfactual ability to do otherwise.

If we think that our desires and motives are restrictive rather than conducive of our free choices, then we must posit that choice is the result of some “liberty of indifference” – that is, something totally unaffected by desires and motives. But if that is the ground of morality, then all choices are arbitrary.
 
I think you are implying that just because God made me want to cheat on my wife it doesnt mean its not my fault that I do it?

But you have to understand that God also made our ability to reason. If he didnt give us the ability to reason that cheating on your wife is not worth it then its still his fault.
I’m not sure what point you’re trying to make involving “reason.” I believe that reason plays a big part in making choices, but I don’t see how this makes any room for free will.
Basically, because our brain controls everything we do, whatever created our brain and programmed how it functions is responsible for what it does.
This begs the question. If it is the case that morality implies determinism, then you can’t state these things as if they’re fact.

Please do a little analysis of the kind I mentioned above, or better yet, look to my brief critiques of free will in my responses to Michael.
 
But I think that prior to sinning, a Christian often experiences conflicting desires and has the ability to resist temptation. Why does one Christian resist temptation and another one falls into temptation and sins? And how do you explain the following passage:

1 Corinthians 10:13

13No temptation has overtaken you but such as is common to man; and God is faithful, who will not allow you to be tempted beyond what you are able, but with the temptation will provide the way of escape also, so that you will be able to endure it.

Aren’t Christians given sufficient grace to resist temptation? Our desires may be unchosen, but acting upon those desires is a choice.

God Bless,
Michael
same thing I said to confessor. What we decide to do is a direct result of our brain which God made. Yes our brain decides what we do, but God programmed what kind of decisions our brain likes to make. Because if God didnt make our brain then who did? And what are brain decides is a result of how it is made.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top